z
  • Home

Young Writers Society



The Exchange student, Chapter 3

by NadyaStatham


Levi runs to his room and comes back with his charger and a surge protector. "Sorry," he says. "I can't even imagine how you feel. This is so annoying." "No, no. Don't do that. You are the one helping me in the middle of the freaking night. Morning, actually." Levi nods, plugging in his charger as his phone slowly starts to reboot and everything. "How did you know the police would help? I mean, the first aid was completely brushed off and sent to my sister." I remark while yawning.

"I'll explain later," he says, immediately calling the policeman back. "Bonjour, c'est encore moi. Hello, it is me again." Thank God, the policeman recognises his voice and immediately picks up where they left off. This time, without wasting any more time, he says Mia's name. As soon as he said it, the policeman doesn't hesitate anymore and says he'll send an ambulance right away.

If only I had known that from the beginning, Mia would be fine now. Who would have thought that the police knew Mia. She really is the best nurse in France. My mind wants to say was, but I force it to say no. She is not dead, I know it.

After about an hour and a half of waiting, we got a call back on Levi's phone. The same policeman who had spoken to Levi was now talking to him. "Hello, sir. Can you hear me?" This time he asked Levi in English rather than French. Levi nudges me to listen as he puts the phone on speaker again. "Yes, I can hear you." "I have someone who wants to talk to you about Mrs Walters." the police officer says while clearing his throat. Levi looks at me in a "who could that be" and I curl my lips into a "I don't know". "Dope..." he says very slowly.

"Cheers, Gustin," I hear faintly before a heavy British accent takes over. "Hey, this is Sergeant Mark Walters from..." "Mark!" I shout through the phone, Levi hands me his phone, signalling that he is going to make himself some coffee. "Palma," he asks, a bit confused. "Yes, is Mia all right?" Mark sighs and says, "I don't know. They just took her to the hospital and said I can't go in. She has something in her blood and is completely unconscious. She was having a seizure when the ambulance arrived."

"Oh God, do you have any idea what could have happened to her? It's not like Mia to pass out like that." I say, rubbing my eyes. "I know. I told Gustin that too." "Who is Gustin?" I ask curiously. Mark says, "The policeman that the American had on the phone. He is a good friend of mine and Mia." "Was she sick?" I ask Mark. "No. She wasn't sick. Thank God that the American called the police. The doctor said it could have been worse, but she had been like this for a long time, they think. When I went out to go to the store she seemed fine. Who is that American anyway?" "The eldest son of my new exchange family." I explain.

"What are you not going to study at Oxford?" Mark asks, puzzled. "No, Dad said it could be a new opportunity." I sigh. Now that I know Mia is safe in the hospital, being looked after, my tiredness takes over. Mark has a word with Levi and thanks him for his help. As Levi puts the phone down he says, "You guys really are all "cheers, mate." British and all." "I take that as a personal insult." I say as I finish a glass of water. "No, no. That's not what I mean. It's just that I went to an international elementary school with a lot of British folks. I have some friends there too, but none of them like Mark. He just goes Cheers like every other second." "I know what you mean." I chuckle.

"Palma, you need to get some sleep. Your school starts tomorrow." I know that Levi is right, but I am not sure if I can let it go that easily. I really want to know the cause of what happened to Mia. I want to wait for the doctor to give me some kind of confirmation that Mia is going to be okay.

I lie in bed for the second time with my heart on high alert. Hoping Mark will text me to say she is fine. I finally manage to fall asleep.

The next morning, the first thing I do when I wake up is text Mark about Mia. He just texts me back, "call me when you are ready to talk." I have no idea what that means, but I decide to take a shower and then call him back. As I get out of the shower and change into a simple pair of jeans and a t-shirt. If I go into the kitchen now, I will probably be talking to the Winters. So I decide to call Mark first.

"Hey Mark. How are you doing?" I ask with a bit of excitement in my voice wishing everything is alright with Mia. "I am trying." He says a little abruptly, "Listen, I need to tell you something first…" "How is Mia holding up," I ask, cutting him off. Mark clears his throat and says, "You see, Palma. Half an hour after you went to bed. The doctor told me she was suffering from..." "A stroke," I say quickly. "Yes, how did you know?" Mark asks rather confusedly. "Mia told me, so I tried to contact the first aid as quickly as possible." I answer.

"Well, the doctor said that there was a blood clot in one of her veins, which made it impossible for the heart to pump blood to her brain, and because she fell out of bed, she hit her head pretty hard on the bedside table, which made it even more life-threatening. If she had only got to the hospital half an hour earlier, she could have been saved. What I'm trying to say is…" Mark explains. "No, no, no. Mark please." I plead, I know what he's going to say. I just don't want to believe it.

"I am sorry, Palma, but Mia is dead." Mark sniffs.

~ 6 years later ~

"That is why my sister, Mia Walters, has been dead now for six years, three months and two weeks. If only she had arrived half an hour earlier, she could have been saved. You see, my sister was a field nurse. She knew what was happening to her, she knew she was having a stroke. She knew she was going to die if she did not get help soon. The entire reason she told me to get first aid immediately.

When my sister died because of it, I decided that she would be the last one to die. This is why I believe that Mrs. Hinder is guilty of not sending an ambulance to save Mia when she was a first-aid attorney. My sister had to die in order for justice to be served. I hope that I have made a clear statement.

The judge looks at the dispatcher, whose name is Mrs. Hinder, and without a second thought, she lifts her hammer and bangs it down twice. Mark looks at the judge, sweat dripping from his brow, while I hold my breath for the moment of truth. "Mrs. Hinder, you are guilty and will serve your sentence in prison."

Mark comes up to me and hugs me, "Palma, thank you so much." He sighs with relief. I return the hug and say, "Stay strong, Mark. Be there for Shawn." I take my papers and my bag and walk out of the courthouse.

I walk up to my husband's car, "That smile on your face tells me all I need to know. Once again, sorry I could not be there. You won!" he says. I smile as I give him a kiss on the cheek. "I had to do something for Mia." "Of course you do. When I saw the look in your eyes that morning while you were on the phone, I knew you would never let it go until you found justice for what happened. That's just what makes you you." My smile fades as I think of Mia. She doesn't even know that I got married to Levi, and that my exchange family is now my in-law family and that her son is now a teenager riding around on a skateboard.

"Do you want to grab something on the way home?" he asks. I nod. "Dope, let's go to Dushi Donuts." As we drive through the city, looking around and still can't believe I've actually settled here, in New York. Now Mia can finally rest in peace, and I can move on with my life. I have dedicated the last six years of my life to this.

Who would have thought my life would take such a turn, me going to the US to study as an exchange student, on the same night that my sister dies of a stroke in France. After quitting both marketing and algebra to get justice for what happened with the first aid dispatcher, I ended up becoming a lawyer. After that, I later married my now best friend, the eldest son of my exchange family, Levi. Six years later, I finally got justice for Mia.

Well, certainly not me.

The End!

~~~

Please note

When you leave a review, constructive criticism mainly on the content and writing style is highly appreciated. Other things are also welcome, but mainly criticism.


Is this a review?


  

Comments



User avatar
204 Reviews

Points: 23671
Reviews: 204

Donate
Wed Apr 10, 2024 4:39 am
View Likes
Moonlily wrote a review...



Hello Hello I hope You dont mind me coming in with a little review. I do want to start I haven't read the first two chapters so there are things I am bound to miss. the three main issues I see are with the pacing the dialogue and certain things about the setting.

Now I won't harp on the formatting as many have done that before so instead I want to point out something that confused me. After the time skip we cut to the MC in a courtroom I want to say speaking? The reason I am unsure as it is formatted like narration but should have quotation marks if she's speaking. I would recommend clearing it up in future drafts.

My feedback for the pacing is mostly having to do with the second part. As I said haven't read the other parts so maybe I am missing set up here. It just feels way too fast and if this going to be a big moment I am guessing it is there should be time to soak it in. This could be a good chance for both emotional tension and suspense as you have the judge unsure who to trust. The jury could also be dragging it out making the reader and the MC feel hopeless and nervous, give the MC/reader challenges but let those challenges breathe. Think about it from a reader's point of view if I am confusing. You got to the good part of the book the cast is overcoming big things and they win very quickly with nothing to keep you on the edge of your seat, that would come off as disappointing in my mind. if this is dealt with in other chapters forgive me, it is just the placement of the flashback makes it feel like this is a new grand moment rather than continuing with an ongoing thing.

A second thing with the pacing is the MC is just smiling she just won I feel there should be a bit more time to show her feelings. Does she not realize she won at first and is just on autopilot as she ends her case? Does she tear up after then fully realize it and express her glee or just break down overwhelmed? this might come off as nitpicky but slowing things down and having these personal moments not only helps your character feel real but makes the bond between them and the reader deeper. Plus it shows the weight of this moment and sells it as a whole.

Lastly, this one might come off as odd but I don't feel the cast interacts with the setting enough. To me they feel like there floating in a void, please tell us what are the sounds and smells of the room. What furniture is there what does it look like? What are the others doing and most importantly what is the mc doing? Is she pacing the courtroom floor with a folder for all the gasping public to see or shakingly easing onto her tiptoes as she sorts through cracking well-loved mugs? Forgive me if this sounds rude but to make the story feel real the setting has to feel real as well. Giving the reader little details not only builds that setting but also shows how the cast interacts or feels in that setting it makes the world easier to buy into. even if it isn't fancy, what I am trying to say is you never want the characters to feel disconnected from the setting ( Unless that's the point.)
Sorry for the long somewhat unformatted review If you have questions please ask. Regardless Keep it up, and drink water!




NadyaStatham says...


Thanks a lot!



User avatar
679 Reviews

Points: 14544
Reviews: 679

Donate
Tue Apr 09, 2024 6:43 pm
View Likes
Messenger wrote a review...



Hi there! You asked me a while back for a review and I'm here at least. I really do apologize about the delay, but I think there's a lot to discuss about this short story. So let's jump in.

Icy has pointed out a lot of the thoughts I had on the overall story and technical aspects of the story. Separating speaking lines from characters with dialogue tags is important to help the reader know who is talking. She gave a good example of how to break it up, but I would stress that it's the most necessary change to make.
A second point is your tense: you are writing in the first-person present tense, which is totally fine. It's less common but I think it works well for stories like this, where you have mystery and thriller and drama mixed together. There were a few times in your three parts where you went into past tense at the wrong time, so just keep an eye out for that in the future. Past tense can still be used in a present-tense story, but only when its discussing something that has already occurred.

Now, onto the plot of the story. I like the setup of being stuck on the phone. It adds so much stress and drama because we know how helpless Palma is. We've probably all struggled with a similar situation, although hopefully not one as life-threatening.
Some things to work on: the idea of her being an exchange student doesn't seem relevant to the story. She could be in England at home and the same difficulties would've occurred I would think. I also did not understand why the first-aid lady, Mrs. Hinder, was so crazy? I thought there was going to be a setup where Palma was being studied in a controlled environment, or she was maybe going crazy and half of what she was seeing and hearing weren't real. As is though, it felt forced that she was sentenced with some sort of manslaughter or murder charge.
The ending also felt quite rushed. I'm not sure that it was necessary to know that she quit algebra or married Levi etc. I think this story has the bone structure to be really gripping and intense if you shrink the scale down to just the night of the phone call.

I hope this helps!
~Messy




NadyaStatham says...


Hey Messy,

This review was quite helpful, I'll take a look at your advice again when I rewrite this novella. I appreciate the hoenst crticism, it's what I need. XD

Thanks a lot,
Amaya



User avatar
1589 Reviews

Points: 173529
Reviews: 1589

Donate
Thu Dec 07, 2023 11:20 am
View Likes
IcyFlame wrote a review...



Hey there Amaya!

It's been a little while since I read chapter two, but I'm going to do my best to remember what happened so that I can review then end of this story. I think if you ever wanted to go back and make it longer you've definitely set up the premise and the characters to do so. As we mentioned before you could even make it dual POV and explore Palma and Liam's different experiences as they go off to their respective exchange schools.

I think that setting it up as an exchange program doesn't necessarily fit with the main theme of the plot - I expected to see her going to this new school, making new friends and having new experiences. As is, I think you could simplify it down. She could be going to stay with a friend who's moved - which would also explain how she kind of recognises the brother at the airport.

Another tip (which I've probably mentioned before) is to make sure you start a new paragraph when a different character is speaking. So for example, your first paragraph could look like this:

Levi runs to his room and comes back with his charger and a surge protector. "Sorry," he says. "I can't even imagine how you feel. This is so annoying."

"No, no. Don't do that. You are the one helping me in the middle of the freaking night. Morning, actually."

Levi nods, plugging in his charger as his phone slowly starts to reboot and everything.

"How did you know the police would help? I mean, the first aid was completely brushed off and sent to my sister." I remark while yawning.


See how it's much clearer then to see who's speaking? It'll also make it much easier to follow the story which will make it more enjoyable for your reader.

The shock factor in this worked really well though! I wasn't expecting that to happen to Mia, and it's an interesting commentary on the barriers we have with different countries - if they'd understood what was happening earlier things might have been different.

I did feel like the end was a bit more rushed vs the other chapters. I think because you had so much to fit in across such a short piece of text. Perhaps if you go back to edit this the six years later could be a separate, more explored chapter?

I thought this was a good attempt, and I think your strongest element is definitely your characters - I was totally rooting for her to get together with Levi!

Hope this was helpful.

Icy




User avatar
1456 Reviews

Points: 321
Reviews: 1456

Donate
Sun Nov 05, 2023 6:21 pm
View Likes
vampricone6783 wrote a review...



Hello there, person on the other side of the screen! I'm reviewing using the YWS S'more Method today!

Let the reviewing commence!

Top Graham Cracker -Palma gets help for Mia, but before anything can be done, Mia dies. And it’s all thanks to Mrs. Hinder, who kept asking Palma questions that had nothing to do with Mia whatsoever.

Slightly Burnt Marshmallow -It’s just something I thought of, but you don’t have to listen if you don’t want to. When Mark wants Palma to call him when she’s ready, it could in italics/quotation marks (or one of them) to show that he was talking to her. Again, it was just a thought I had.

Chocolate Bar - I like how you wrote that Palma is still thinking about Mia. She doesn’t forget her even as her life gets better and still has that sadness in her from Mia dying. It’s how a real person would feel.

Closing Graham Cracker - This was a bittersweet, but real, ending to “The Exchange Student”. It’s great that Palma has this life for herself and that Mrs. Hinder went to jail, but Mia still died. An appropriate final chapter to the story.

Goodbye for now, human being! :>




NadyaStatham says...


Hey there, Circus girl on the other side of the screen!

Thank you for this review! You made my day, I will definitly keep your suggestion in mind. I am glad you liked the ending.

Thank you for your support during this novel! I seem to struggle with finishing and sticking to big projects like novels, so this was a small big step for me, for finishing one project.

Amazingly yours,
Rinisha



vampricone6783 says...


Ofc! :>




Who knows anything about anyone, let alone themselves.
— Hank Green