E - Everyone

A Chicken on Trial: Chapter Three, The Fowl Witch

They entered Claude’s ramshackle estate, it’s ceiling sunken, and the swamp-smell all the more profuse. It was one room, Claude’s bed was pressed against the far corner, and a small fire huffed and puffed in the confines of a crumbling chimney. Henrietta would call it cozy.

Claude sat her on the table, then rummaged through the uneven cupboards for chickenfeed. Bernadette paced the rooms perimeter, shrewd eyes picking up details and swallowing them whole. Henrietta, at last, felt content enough to preen herself, a small aura of dust clouding her as she shed anxiety from her feathers.

“Would you like tea?” called Claude, once Henrietta was provided for.

“I’d love some,” Bernadette replied.

Shortly, the two humans were sat at the table with steaming cups of tea in their hands, a sated Henrietta between them.

“I have to ask,” Claude said, uneasy, “why take Henrietta’s case? When I can’t even pay you.”

Bernadette smiled through paper-thin lips. “The challenge, of course. And the renown, for winning. Which I will. Win, that is.” She raised the tea in cheers, then took a long swig. “I’m the best lawyer I know,” she said, setting it back down on the wooden table with a clank, “it’s only the matter of proving it. Next week, Henrietta will be put before the council and tried for witchcraft. The prosecution will argue that she has cavorted with the devil and invited an untold amount of evil into the community.”

“So, what do we do?” asked Claude, exasperated.

“We cannot deny that Henrietta was roosting a basilisk. We might be able to deny her malicious intent, but that ground is shaky. However, chickens, specifically hens, are inclined to care for eggs. So, if a snake did find her way into the coop, and Henrietta obeyed her natural intuition, it would not be her fault, but Mr. Huber’s, who failed to protect his chickens.”

Claude recoiled, face flushing a vibrant fuchsia. “My uncle hadn’t been out to the coop in months. The chickens were my responsibility, not his. It’s all my fault.”

“Incompetency is not a crime; you won’t be burned for it.” said Bernadette. Claude crumpled like tea leaves in hot water.

“Bok bok!” Henrietta cried, mortified. Of course, neither paid her any heed.

“My uncle fired me this morning,” Claude confided, “a death sentence like any other.”

Bernadette sucked in a breath and stared into the basin of her mug. It seemed, at last, she didn’t have anything to say. This was a relief to Henrietta. Now that her belly was full, she felt the pull of a fuzzy slumber. She fluffed up her feathers, then laid her head on her cloud-like bosom, and dozed.

-

She woke to weeping.

Bernadette was gone, and the fire burned low. The sun outside had just set, and the world was cast in a hazy, purple glow, like a dream. Henrietta stretched, extending her neck and wings as far as they could go, then swiveled her head around to trace the sound. Claude was knelt to the floor before the fireplace, hands clasped above her head, body wracked with sobs.

There was a pang in Henrietta’s tiny chicken heart, and though her tiny chicken brain could not understand why Claude despaired, (the two of them were together again, after all, and they were safe!) she knew the girl was in desperate need of comfort.

Henrietta leapt from the perch with a cats grace, and waddled beside Claude, clucking to her comfortingly. A jolt ran through Claude, like she was struck by lightning, and she shot upward. Her hazel eyes, like quiet creeks, were bloodshot, and tears carved rivers into her cheeks. But when she saw Henrietta, she laughed and smiled. “Your hungry again, aren’t you? I’ll betcha the constable fed you next to nothing. Let me get you something to eat.”

She rose to her feet and moved toward the kitchen, where she leafed through the cupboards. A steady stream of cursing stemmed from her, as she realized there was no more chickenfeed to be had.

Henrietta was left puzzled before the fireplace. She cocked her head at it, curious about the heat that brushed against her feathers. It reminded her of that gap between the paneling, a portal to another space. She shuffled closer, letting the warmth envelop her a little more. And when that wasn’t enough, she moved closer still. If she ate the embers, would the warmth transfer to her belly? Henrietta was about to find out; her head was almost in the chimney.

“No, Henrietta!” yelled Claude, scooping her from the ground, soiling Henrietta’s fun. “Naughty chicken. You’ve got a real knack for almost killing yourself, you know? And a real knack for hurting my heart.” She brought Henrietta to the table, setting her next to the empty bag of chickenfeed, and then replaced the fireplace’s grate. She was more frazzled than before, which had not been Henrietta’s intent.

Claude continued rambling to herself. “That Bernadette lass is a real piece of work, eh? You think if I socked her in the face she’d learn not to talk so much? I’ll show her incompetency.”

“Bok,” tsked Henrietta, who wished to remind Claude to behave more ladylike.

She dropped to the floor and pried at a loose floorboard, pulling it away to reveal a rectangular abyss. From it, she drew a book. More of a tome, really, as tall and wide as Henrietta was. Golden letters gleamed in the dim firelight, written in a strange and jagged alphabet. It creaked as it opened.

“Alright, Claude,” said Claude, to herself. Her breath came in short bursts, and her fraying braid was coming apart, hair falling across her face as she fixated on the books pages. “You’ve got this.”

She closed her eyes. It was almost completely dark, the light from the fire caressing one side of Claude as her hands rose into the air. She spoke in a voice Henrietta did not know, thrusting a spike of fear into the hen, rippling from her wings to her talons, as though an ice-hand strung her nerves like a lute. She shrank backward, clucking quietly in fright.

Then, the bag of chickenfeed swelled. The smell of grain crashed over Henrietta, sudden and disorienting. The seams of the burlap sack strained, then snapped, and it’s inside guts spilled across the table and onto the floor, the sound a hailstorm of corn.

When Claude’s eyes opened, they were not their usual hue, but pools of ink that stared, unseeing. She scrunched her face up in annoyance and swiped at them with her hands, picking out the darkness like one would an eye boogie. She blinked a few times for good measure, then smiled, sly, at the full bag of chickenfeed. Then, as though nothing happened, she fetched a broom and swept the spillage into a pan, humming a jolly old tune. She paused, only a moment, as a wave of nausea seemed to crash over her. She leaned against the broom, wavering like a mirage. But it passed quickly, and she returned to the task at hand.

Once she’d put the broom away, she returned to Henrietta, and cooed softly, “I’m sorry, old girl. I hadn’t meant to scare you.” Claude extended a hand toward her. Henrietta hesitated only a moment, before allowing her to scratch her head.

“I’m going to tell you a secret,” Claude said, voice barely above a whisper. She grinned, teeth jagged in the darkness, “You and I are going to survive. I’m going to make sure of it.” 

Comments & reviews · 4
Note: You are not logged in, but you can still leave a comment or review. Before it shows up, a moderator will need to approve your comment (this is only a safeguard against spambots). Leave your email if you would like to be notified when your message is approved.

User avatar
Tikaya
Review
Tikaya wrote a review · Wed Jan 21, 2026 12:44 pm

I’m a little late with reviewing today so let’s head straight in ^^
Last time Henrietta got herself a legal defender who already achieved her release back to her home! What’s going to happen this time around?

I love Bernadette’s confidence 😊 Her motivations are also valid, in this case I think. Everyone would love to be the lawyer who managed to have “successfully defended non-verbal chicken” on their resumé=D (That said “lost case defending hen” might look bad on the resumé and raise a few eyebrows on why she’d even taken the job in the first place…)
I like how she phrases this: “ invited an untold amount of evil into the community.“

Oh and I like that after the going theory, Bernadette also gets to the truth. I wonder if she can call the snake as a witness, provided it escaped and can be found?
I am way to invested in this court case now.

Wellll if the uncle has already fired her, even more reason to just claim incompetence? It wont cost her that much anymore. It doesn’t sound like she’d get employment in this position again anyway…

I do wish we would get more of Henrietta’s perspective. Just… what she’s doing while the boring humans talk about boring, uninteresting human stuff.

Kinda stuff like this: “It reminded her of that gap between the paneling,“ This is neat!
And I love that thought, dangerous as it might be: “If she ate the embers, would the warmth transfer to her belly?”

YWS overextended your italics formatting here:

“Bok,” tsked Henrietta
might want to fix it.

Oh my. Well that is an unexpected twist. No wonder Claude thinks this is her fault. And I wonder where the snake came from now. And did the snake egg maybe really turn into a basilisk egg now? EVERYTHING IS POSSIBLE!! And I love it!
Love this description: “picking out the darkness like one would an eye boogie”

I suddenly think that maybe Claude can get employment everywhere after all if she’s careful ^^
So maybe it isn’t just the trial that I’m looking forward to now!

User avatar
Valkyria
Review

This took a sinister turn. I love it!

This chapter turns the plot on its head in a fun direction, and I love the supernatural direction it's taking. And it doesn't feel out of place at all. It makes sense, considering that the humans were actually going to try a chicken in court. I also love that we're seeing more of Claude's characterization. She's sympathetic, but I would like to have seen more of her personality and interactions with her uncle in the earlier chapters because her turn to magic feels jarring in this chapter. If it is either foreshadowed or if she's fleshed out earlier, it is just as much as a surprise when she uses magic but also makes us understand why she's doing this. I also think that the implications of the basilisk egg can be fleshed out more too. Why is it (or the creature in general) associated with negative things?

Overall, I really enjoyed this chapter! It became very compelling. I look forward to reading more!

User avatar
Helvetia
Review

The plot thickens! Well, maybe it chickens.

I think this is a new frontier for these characters. This chapter takes Henrietta and Claude’s story into darker, more mysterious territory. It really blends the absurdly endearing qualities with this new quietly sinister atmosphere. Claude is sketchy. She truly comes into her own here. Her emotional turmoil is tangible, and her self-recriminations are painfully relatable. The juxtaposition of her vulnerability with the sly confidence she shows afterwards adds layers to her character.

But, you have to consider what the magic adds to the storyline outside of the obvious. The spellcasting scene, for example, is compelling. However, its suddenness feels too jarring to me. Some foreshadowing of Claude’s knowledge of magic earlier in the story could make this shift feel more organic.

Henrietta’s fear during the spell is well-conveyed, but her reaction afterward feels rushed. I imagine with her usual characterization, she would somehow try to be more empathetic to the new turn of events. How does she reconcile the warmth and safety she associates with Claude with the newfound strangeness? This introduces compelling stakes that leave me eager to see how far she’ll go, and what price she’ll pay, for survival. I wonder if Henrietta wonders that too.

Very hopeful, yet very foreboding. This is absurd, but it knows it’s absurd, and that self-awareness makes it special for me.

All the best!

Thank you for the review!!

User avatar
Snoink
Review
Snoink wrote a review · Tue Dec 31, 2024 11:48 pm

DUN DUN DUNNNNNNN. Little did Henrietta know but her alliance with the chicken lady would align her with witchy forces! Though, I'm not sure this is going to make her case particularly strong... I mean, Bernadette is set on proving Henrietta's innocence from witchcraft, but that's what Claude is going to do! Will this backfire on them both??? Maybe?????? If I were Bernadette, I would be ready to pull out my hair by now, hahaha.

Though like... it sounds like Bernadette kind of gave up? Like, I'm not sure what exactly is going on, but Bernadette seems like she's given up? Or maybe I'm confused? I'm also not quite sure why Claude is at fault here? Or why Bernadette would think Claude would be okay with blaming Claude's uncle? Like, all these things make me slightly weirded out.

Speaking of Claude... that... is not a traditionally feminine name? It's usually considered masculine (the feminine name is "Claudia" or "Claudette." It was quite a shock to see that name describe a woman! (Also, a long time ago, I once had a nasty character named Claude, so I was slightly bothered by it... omg, he was such a nasty character, haha.)

Though like... the truth is trickling out and honestly I am becoming even more horrified by this world. The snake was not just a snake but a BASILISK???? AW HECK NO, KILL IT WITH FIRE. Though, this means that I think my original advice (i.e., to describe the egg) is even more important. Also, since this is a BASILISK, I think it would be important to describe how the snake curled around the next. Like. This thing is probably huge, so all of this is important information!

Anyway. I'm not sure if I trust Claude? This could go the Pinnochio route where the fox and the cat lead Pinnochio astray and cause him to fall into ruin. After all, it seems like witchcraft is hated and persecuted around here, so maybe there's a good reason for that. Claude's brief foray into the dark arts hardly made me sympathetic toward her... this could end up pretty badly. Hmmmmmmm.

Okay! Enough babbling! I have another chapter to read, apparently!



I hope everyone's safe and sound and has some potatoes in the pantry.
— Arcticus