Hi again, Hatt! Sorry for the delay, but I wanted to get this review to your before your revisions were due ^^
I'm actually a bit surprised at the direction you ended up taking this piece. There was a little bit less emphasis on that moment watching the stars and more on the dynamic of your friends, which I actually think speaks more to the point you're trying to make. It's actually a really nice contrast between the first part of the whimsical, picturesque moment under the stars, and then the descend back to reality (literally), which showed the dynamic between you and your friends.
Although, I do agree with Que's point about the song in the beginning. There's a lot of set up for getting to the top of the mountain, watching the sky, and having this music playing in the background. It's even in the title! But what exactly is the purpose of the song? While I'm sure that most people are familiar with the song and its general idea, maybe incorporating it a little bit more, like maybe some meaningful lyrics, some emotions it provoked, would be helpful to emphasize its importance? Like Que said, it's in the title after all! But I did like the moment of hearing someone else calling out over the mountains, because it was a nice comedic moment, but also helps you transition into the actual focus of your essay, the people.
I think Que also covered most of the flow/editing comments, because most of what I would've said, she also covered. I did want to reiterate that I think the flow of this piece is still great, since it's clearly written in your voice. It comes across conversational and personal, which does well to get us to understand why this feels like "home". It's comfortable and casual ^^
“Man, you guys are no fun,” Rithy said, waving a hand exasperatedly. “It is getting pretty dark, though,” he added after looking around.
A quick suggestion, though, is that this feels like a kind of fast transition. I did enjoy the fast pace back and forth of the dialogue before this, since it emphasizes your later point that you all mesh well together, but it felt like it moved on a little too fast? My suggestion might be to frame this like a snippet, something that happens in the middle of the stargazing, like there are the two contrasting worlds of nature and your friends and they blend well together, if that makes sense. And then after another second or two, then you all collectively decide to walk back? Rather than just an abrupt, "well, my suggestion didn't work, let's go back" type of feeling? I don't know if this makes sense, so feel free to ask for clarification haha.
If you're still looking for another piece to add too, it feels like the second half (outside of the concluding paragraph), focuses a lot on the group and its dynamic. This is totally valid since it's the center of the piece, but it also feels like you, as the narrator, fade to the background a bit. I think the piece might also benefit from adding a little bit more emotion, or emotional language during the action instead of retrospectively. Like, do you chime in with your own "nightmare scenario", spurred on by the energy of others? Do you laugh a little bit louder at the tarantula than you normally would have? Do your limbs feel heavy from sleep, but you're carried on by the footsteps of your friends in front of you? Maybe just a few more personal details to keep us connected to you, so that when you introspect at the end, it transitions a bit smoother.
Sorry if this was a bit all over the place, haha. But do let me know if you have questions or would like clarification!
Happy writing ^^
~ Wolfe
Points: 26330
Reviews: 767
Donate