Warning: This work has been rated 16+ for language.
Taken Down for edits
Points:
Time spent:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Hey! I totally understand that you want to take this down for edits
Again, I wanted to get this out of the green room for you while you edit!
I'm going to write a super quick review for you just so we can get this out of the green room!
Unfortunately without any of the work to go off of, I can't comment on any of your actual prose, but I can offer some general editing tips in case you see this and in case that is helpful to you!
Especially if this is a first draft, when you go to edit try to think big picture. Make sure all of your main characters have clear wants and clear things standing in the way of those wants and it's clear why it matters. Make sure each scene is driving that plot forward and make sure the characters are happening to the plot and the plot not happening to the characters. (The characters should have agency and they should be the ones moving things forward not endless things happening to them). Make sure there's an overall arc for the story. I personally like to use beat sheets when I edit (I'm a pantser at heart for first drafts so they're not helpful to me then :p) to make sure I'm hitting all of the major points of the story.
Once you hit all the big picture things, then look at what I think of as medium level things. Are you describing and showing and do the words jump off the page? Then from there move into the small sentence level things like am I using strong verbs? Am I using active voice rather than passive voice? Have I taken out filter verbs and filler words? Stuff like that.
Happy to talk more about editing if that's helpful to you! I hope this isn't too redundant of information for you
Yay, another chapter! I also love the name of this chapter
Ooh, another perspective! I think you did a nice job with this chapter; it wasn't too fast paced or too slow paced. I like how we got to learn about Eva - you characterized her nicely in this chapter. I also like how we got to meet her friend, and your scenes all felt relatable and like they could actually happen. Nice job! I really liked this chapter. I'm going to point out some grammar things, if you don't mind. I apologize if I'm being too nitpicky; I only want to help! <33
This opening sentence though xD quite interesting
This is a pretty small thing, but if you're going to do the ".." thing, it's usually three dots! (an ellipsis)
Another small thing, you're missing a space between "okay," and "right"
You switch to past tense here when the rest of this is in present tense.
Book names should be italicized
Very small thing, you're missing a space between "afternoon," and "so"
You don't really need a dash here.
Couple of small things, the period should be attached to "first" and the comma to "Jenkins"
Small thing, "I' m" should be "I'm"
I really like this comparison! It's quite unique. I kind of feel like they should be in the same paragraph. A lot of your paragraphs consist of only one or two sentences, so I think a lot of them could be combined. But if that's your style, then feel free to ignore this! <3
Oof. Small thing, you're missing a space between the sentences
Small thing, the comma should be attached to "promise"
Another small thing, the quotation should be attached to "And"
Same thing with this period. Sorry if I'm being too nitpicky; I just really want to help you out
I think "Where?" would work better than "Where."
This quote should end with a double, not single, quotation.
You don't need the second period.
SAME DUDE SAME
Overall, I think this was a great chapter!
Thank you so much!! <3 No, I love that you point out my missteps, it helps me a lot!!
I'm also planning on including something about playing the piano, so I'll probably need you again, I hope you won't mind %uD83C%uDF39%uD83C%uDF39
I%u2019m glad to hear <33
I won%u2019t mind at all; I%u2019m be happy to help!
Oof that really messed up, hopefully you can still read it xD I%u2019ll rewrite it just in case

I am glad to hear <33
I do not mind at all; I will be happy to help!
Oof that really messed up, hopefully you can still read it xD I%u2019ll rewrite it just in case

I am glad to hear <33
I do not mind at all; I will be happy to help!
Oof that really messed up, hopefully you can still read it xD I%u2019ll rewrite it just in case

I am glad to hear <33
I do not mind at all; I will be happy to help!
Oof that really messed up, hopefully you can still read it xD I%u2019ll rewrite it just in case

I am glad to hear <33
I do not mind at all; I will be happy to help!
Omg that replied so many times I%u2019m so sorry ahhh xD
Don't worry, I keep messing stuff with the site All Day, I can't stop
Thank you!!