I found it today. I found the Box.
It sat there underneath the secret earth, gleaming with mysterious, untold secrets. It looked at me—dared me—to open it and unleash everything I’ve ever questioned.
I remember her words well. I’m sorry, she said. I’ve hidden the Box, she said. Please find it, she said.
I thought she was speaking in riddles. I thought she was losing her sanity. In that brief last moment I ever had of her, I lost every speck of hope I ever had to begin with.
But here the Box sat, closed for many years like an ancient artifact waiting to be discovered. The dirty gems around the Box gleamed under the smothering, screaming sun, almost as if it was threatening me to bury it back under the quiet, peaceful earth where it would rest forever in purity, untouched by my soiled human hands.
The wind blew against my skin, making my skin prickle with goose bumps. Go away, it cried. Go away.
I slowly dug out the box. Many years ago, she and I would play pirate. I’ll make a map, she said, and you get to find my treasure.
Needless to say, I never found it.
I looked everywhere, and I could never find it. Even when she disappeared, I couldn’t find it. Even when the years came by and the weeds grew out and her existence faded away in a hushed whisper, I couldn’t find it.
And now, when her existence was practically nonexistent, I found it.
But because I found it, it meant that she wasn’t nonexistent. She still existed; she was still in my mind. I remembered a ghostly trace of her smile, her long dark hair, her chocolate eyes, her dimples when she smiled, every freckle she had on her face. I remembered her even when the world didn’t. She still, in fact, existed.
I stared at the Box. It was the one we both bought together—maroon embroidery gems on the side with a bird flying out of its cage painted on the front. To be frank, it was ugly, but she insisted in buying it. Don’t you see the beauty in it? she asked me. It represents freedom.
The irony of it all was so very disgusting.
I ripped open the Box.
I didn’t know what to expect.
Maybe I was expecting a lot; she did, after all, told me that she would only put her dearest and precious things in the Box.
But there was almost nothing in it.
Almost nothing.
There, hidden in the shadows of the encasing Box, was a thin photograph.
I slowly reached in and stared at it.
Scrawled in her curly cursive and calligraphic handwriting was the word “HOPE.” Right below it was a frozen moment in time, beautifully captured in an elegant, dainty way.
I saw her. I saw me. I saw a pigeon flying out of our hands.
I closed my eyes.
The memory replayed in my mind like a broken record. We were so young, so innocent, and she caught my attention with her smile even when she was holding a wild pigeon. I walked up to her and asked what she was doing.
I caught it, she said.
But why would you want to catch a pigeon?
I’m not going to keep it, she said. I’m going to release it.
That doesn’t make any sense. Why would you catch it only to release it?
Because I want to watch it fly out of my hands, she said. Don’t you wish you could fly like them?
I don’t know. I don’t think about these things.
Here, take it, she said. Take it and let go.
I opened my eyes. Her map was wrong. It didn’t lead to this place. It led nowhere, but even if the Box was seemingly put in this place very randomly, it connected to that very specific, rather stupid memory of our old childish days.
We released our first bird together in this exact spot.
I stared at the Box. A bird, flying out of its cage. Freedom. Don’t you wish you could fly like them?
I thumbed her face on the photograph, purposely scratched out so it was unidentifiable.
“HOPE”? What hope was there?
There was no hope.
There was never any hope to begin with.
I’m sorry, she said. I’ve hidden the Box, she said. Please find it, she said. Please forget me, she said. Please don’t think of me anymore, she said. Thank you, she said. Goodbye, she said.
Why? Why did it have to be this way?
I’m forgetting her voice. I’m forgetting her laugh. I’m starting to forget her face.
She is a ghost in my life, a mystery I cannot solve.
They said she wasn’t right in the head. I said she was normal. They said she was crazy. I said she was beautiful. They said she was wicked. I said she was gifted.
I felt something wet and salty fall down my cheek.
What happened? What happened to her? What happened to me? Everything used to be so perfect. She used to be so happy. I used to be so happy.
Look at this photograph. Look how young we were. Look at the bird flying out of our hands. Look at what we wore. Look at what we did.
I miss it. I miss it so, so much.
I miss you.
But it can’t be the same.
It can never be the same.
It’s too late.
Things changed.
You’re gone.
You’ll never come back.
And soon enough, I will forget you.
You won’t exist in this world anymore.
All traces of you will disappear.
And the only thing I will have of you is this ugly Box.
Points:
Time spent:
IP address:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
This is great. I have nothing to comment on in terms of content because it is all very good.

Just a couple of picky things.
You use "she said" very very often. It wouldn't hurt to cut back on them a bit. For example.
"I remember her words well. I’m sorry, she said. I’ve hidden the Box, she said. Please find it."
You could end that line there. The final she said is unnecessary.
Also,
"And now, when her existence was practically nonexistent, I found it.
But because I found it, it meant that she wasn’t nonexistent. She still existed; she was still in my mind. "
That bit seems a little muddy with the word existent. I would say in the second line maybe change a few words around. Its quite a tongue twister if you read it allowed. Maybe you could find a way to write it using less words but still have the same impact.
Sorry for the short review, but it means a good thing. It means you did well and there isn't much for me to say. I would tell you the good things but then i would pretty much be copying the whole story here.
Oh wow! I havent been on YWS in a little while and this was a brilliant piece to come back to- the reason I love YWS!
I liked how you trailed off at the end, like when your thinking of a memory and it trails out of thought, but then you ended it with a defient sentence. Good job!
I also like how we're in your head as youre reasoning out how nothing can be the same
I think that one or two of your descriptions could be a little more.. original maybe? For example- "her long dark hair, her chocolate eyes, her dimples when she smiled, every freckle she had on her face"- it could be anyone- so describe the someone youre thinking of, what makes them unique!
But I do think that it's a brilliant piece! Hope you keep it up!
To say the least, this was amazing.
The title caught my attention and dragged me into the story—"The Box" is a rather mysterious title, calling on my curiosity—from where I proceeded forget that I was the reader and not actually the character in this story. The emotion and flow was heart-wrenching and wonderful, and your grammar was near perfect. I felt for the character and made its distress my own, as if I was in the story myself. I had expected this mystic box to have something extraordinary inside it, so your adding only a photograph was a great twist. Fantastic job! I loved it.
Oh my goodness. This short story was beautifully written. The grammar was amazing, everything was amazing.
"The irony of it all was so very disgusting.
I ripped open the Box.
I didn’t know what to expect.
Maybe I was expecting a lot; she did, after all, told me that she would only put her dearest and precious things in the Box.
But there was almost nothing in it.
Almost nothing.
There, hidden in the shadows of the encasing Box, was a thin photograph.
I slowly reached in and stared at it."
This was my favorite part. FAVORITE part. It was so beautiful! You did a really great job on writing this story. This is now my favorite short story. Keep writing!
GrapeNerd
...that was amazing. One of the best short stories I have read in a while. your grammar was amazing, and your story flowed well. I could feel the narrators feelings, like they were my own, and this story sent shivers down my back. What an amazing piece. I also liked how even though it was a short story, it felt like a long poem. And though, it dint rhyme, it was put together so nicely, it just flowed, like a river along soft stones. I really hope you continue to write, I will be watching you. -Andy