Fanmade Hamilton Song

by CapybarasAndCoffee

Published August 6, 2025

E - Everyone

In Songs

PreviousNext

(this takes place after phillips die prob before its quiet uptown)

Eliza: I look around

Look around and think

If only you were alive right now

Phillip.

Its quiet uptown

Cause your not here

I wish

I would've hugged one last time

Before you walked out the door

I won't get to hear your wonderful poems anymore

Your name was Phillip

You were a poet

Sometimes you were scared but you never showed it

You were a ladies man like your father

And sometimes even a bother.

We took a break

While your father broke our hearts

You were there with Angelica to comfort me

When our world fell apart

Still so blinded by your fathers pride

Then you went off and died

For him

For him

For him you did so much

All you longed for was acceptance

But all he gave you was expectations

To follow in his stead

How could have i expected you to do better

When he was the lead of the house

And in the front of your mind.

Alexander: Eliza,

Im sorry that I knew

And told him to do it

Im sorry that I knew

Is there anything I can do

Eliza: Angelica was right you'll never be satisfied

Not with your life not with mine

When I first met you I felt helpless

But now when I see you I feel hopeless

I gave you a son

I thought that would be enough

I gave you a daughter

I thought that would satisfy

I give you support in everything you ever do

But you never did anything for me

You ask if there's something you can do?!

You had one job Alexander!

Be true

And you blew it

Phillip never got to see the day where he could blow us all away.

So obsessed with your legacy

You forget your family

And you forget that a legacy

Starts with a family!

Don't you know what I went through when I told the kids about Maria

Still Phillip loved you

And you sent him out to die

YOU TOLD HIM TO POINT THE GUN AT THE SKY!

If you would've just taught him mercy.

Alexander: Eliza please-

Eliza: That will be enough-

Comments & reviews · 4
User avatar
Tikaya
Review
Tikaya wrote a review Review · Nov 25, 2025

Alright, I know very little about Hamilton but here goes.
First thing first, there’s a typo here “(this takes place after phillips die prob”, it’s “dies” right?

From what I can imagine, I feel like this would work as a song. It has the pauses and the dramatic potential. Ohhh and I remember there’s a Hamilton song where characters keep asking “what’s your name” so this:

Your name was Phillip
feels like it echoes it and works really well!

I’m not sure abt the grammar in this one: “When he was the lead of the house” leader?

In Alexander’s lines, I like the repletion of “I’m sorry that I knew”

Oh and this is so powerful:
When I first met you I felt helpless
But now when I see you I feel hopeless


And I love that drop here:
You had one job Alexander!
Be true

I can imagine the music so well!

Great song, I like it a lot!

User avatar
HildegardHope
Review
HildegardHope wrote a review Review · Sep 12, 2025

Hello! So this is really good
I could def hear the voices of the actors when i was reading it, the biggest issue was it was kind of hard to tell exactly when someone stopped singing or when someone else started singing.

I would suggest maybe bolding the names?

It starts off really strong, but I do think after

Eliza: Angelica was right you'll never be satisfied

this line, it does start to get a little weaker, and feel slightly less in character. I'm not sure how exactly to describe it, but that's just my gut feeling, maybe it would be easier to tell with music in the background, since i can only guess based on the Hamilton soundtrack how this is supposed to sound.

this isn't exactly the best example and is kind of personalized but-

Don't you know what I went through when I told the kids about Maria

I read this line to the tune of that song from the sound of music that is sung by the nuns yk the one thats like 'what do you about a problem like Maria' and but mean I think that's just part of the problem of posting lyrics without music it happens to everyone.

User avatar
EmersonK Comment
EmersonK commented Comment · Aug 24, 2025

This is really good. I am a very big fan of Hamilton, and this really resonates with me. I am also a songwriter and find lyrics to be challenging to write. I am very impressed with the lyrics and emotional pull of this.

User avatar
EmersonK Comment
EmersonK commented Comment · Aug 24, 2025

This is really good. I am a very big fan of Hamilton, and this really resonates with me. I am also a songwriter and find lyrics to be challenging to write. I am very impressed with the lyrics and emotional pull of this.



There’s always a story. It’s all stories, really. The sun coming up every day is a story. Everything’s got a story in it. Change the story, change the world.
— Terry Pratchett