Published August 10, 2026
Warning: This work has been rated 18+ for language and violence.
I made a book trailer! Click here to watch it: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A4-72TLaRdE
(A/N: this is a rewrite since I obviously went back and wrote in Greer's chapters into part one.)
16. The Warehouse
They scuttled around below him like little black beetles, darting in and out of the shadows. Slivers of scalps underneath unwashed hair shone in the dim LED lights. They dragged in boxes of supplies and crates of food and bags of bedding and arranged their sleeping bags on the floor in rows, one by one, like soldiers. They did what Clem told them to do.
Greer stood on the mezzanine floor, alone, his palms gripping the paint-chipped metal railings. Sweat ran in small beads across his forehead, but he didn’t wipe it away. He didn’t wipe away the tears that were welling in the ducts of his eyes, either. He just stood there and watched. There were ten of them. Ten. That was about a third of the Shadow’s troops, discounting the girls and the babies. They all wore black, ill-fitting faux-leather jackets and dirty joggers, trying to achieve a uniform look. They looked like they had all just swamped into the depths of a Primark sale and fought for the ugliest pieces they could find.
Clem, the cleanest of them all, was bossing around a group of boys, telling them exactly where to stack each can of soup on the shelves of the makeshift kitchen. Some of the younger Shadows were shaking their heads in disapproval from where they lounged on their sleeping mats. A card game was happening, but no one had made a move in five minutes, all focused on these strangers taking over their home.
And there was nothing Greer could do about it.
They had driven back in solemn silence. Clem’s people had forced their way inside, and Henry and Mikey had been unable to keep the gates closed without attracting crawlers with the noise, ultimately having to let them in. Without weapons, what could they have done? When Greer and the others had pulled up, there was a mob waiting to accost them, which Clem avoided by taking the stupid transceiver to the location Cry wanted. Maybe if she had taken Bethy and Cal with her, they might have been able to hold fort and force the few others out. But Bethy and Cal, though timid as they were, had remained at the warehouse, and Clem had forced Donnie to come with her.
He could have refused. But he didn’t.
‘No! Labels have to be facing outwards,’ Clem said sharply, her shrill voice striking Greer’s ears. He winced a little. ‘And only stack ones that are of the same product, down to the brand. Can you put all the red ones together, and then all the yellow ones? It looks better that way, and it's easier to find what you need. No, don’t open that! That’s my personal suitcase!’
Greer scanned his eyes across the floor again, picking out the new prey like a hawk. There were two boys he did not like the look of. One was huge, nearly six feet tall; a skinhead with acne scars hooked deep into his square face and overgrown peach fuzz growing from his lip like mould on a stone fruit. The other was shorter and leaner, with a shaggy nineties-style haircut and tinted sunglasses that hid most of his face from view, save for his very thin lips. They were mooching about the place, hands deep in their pockets, looking in every corner, spying in kids’ tents and bags and then making rude faces at each other. He hoped that Donnie and the others would hurry up and come back inside.
There was a loud smash, followed by a series of tinny clatters as one of Clem’s kids dropped a crate and the contents spilt out onto the floor. Cans of fruit rolled away, escaping between people's legs and under tables as the brine from a jar of pickled onions began to stink out the room. The smell made Greer’s stomach lurch, and he was about to turn away and go into the office when he spotted a small figure dash in through the doors and duck beneath a table, gathering up as many cans as he could, using the front of his T-shirt as a makeshift bag. Greer recognised the greasy brown mop of hair that hung around the kid's neck and sighed. He quickly trotted down the stairs, ignoring the ruckus to his right and heading straight for the kid, who was slowly sliding out from under the table with his loot. He looked around, reminding Greer of a mouse’s nose twitching in the air, then made a break for the door.
Greer grabbed the kid by the back of his T-shirt. ‘Busted.’
‘Hey! You made me drop stuff!’ Jasper wriggled out of Greer’s grip, half of the cans thudding to the ground as Greer bundled him out of the door. ‘Get off me!’
‘What the hell are you doing?’ Greer asked, looking down at Jasper’s dirty face, sticky with jam. ‘You know you’re not supposed to come over here. Donnie got a room for you over there, with the other kids!’
‘They’re babies!’ Jasper exclaimed, sticking out his tongue. ‘All they do is cry and smell. And the big girls make me do dumb kiddie things like paint rainbows and sing songs!’ he said, crossing his arms so hard his elbows nearly disappeared into his ribs. I’m not a baby! I have a gun!’
‘You do not have a gun.’
‘I used to have one!’
It was kinda sad, really, Greer had to admit. Too young for the Shadows, too old for the babies. No proper place for him now that the other little ones had mostly been shuttled off once the Ident found their siblings or cousins. ‘I’m sorry, it’s not fair, I know.’
‘So let me join!’ he said, jumping upwards, a glint in his blue eyes. ‘I’ll fight, and maybe I can earn my gun back if I do good enough. I’ve already killed like seventeen hundred crawlers with that thing, or maybe even more.’
‘Maybe another day,’ Greer sighed. ‘There’s a bunch of new kids in there who have taken over, in case you couldn’t tell.’
‘Did you let them in?’ Jasper said, tilting his head to the side.
‘Sort of. It’s complicated.’
‘Well, why don’t you just kick them out if you don’t want them here?’ he asked with a confused look. ‘Just shoot them with my gun if I can’t have it back.’
Greer let out a laugh and stared up into the sky, lacing his fingers together and cupping the back of his head. It wasn’t a stupid question, not really. Why didn’t they? ‘We can’t,’ he squeaked, his voice cracking. ‘They just want to help find kids too, as we found you.’
‘I want to help!’
There were still a few tins on the floor, and Greer kicked a Fruit Cocktail over to Jasper. ‘Take that, go back to the girls, and I won’t get you in any trouble with them, alright?’
Jasper sighed heavily, the air lifting his fringe upwards. ‘Fine,’ he said, picking up the tin. ‘I just wanted food for myself. Them girls make me eat baby food. All mashed up and yucky.’
‘I’m sorry,’ Greer said. ‘I’ll talk to them about it, okay?’
Jasper spun on his heels and sulked away. Greer watched until he became a small figure and disappeared inside. He bent down and picked up the remaining tins, collecting them in his arms. When he turned around to take them back inside, there was someone blocking the door.
They towered above him, and when he looked upwards, their face was obscured by the thick cloud of cigarette smoke curling upwards out of their mouth. As it slowly cleared away, the pockmarked face of the large boy he had disliked the look of came into focus.
‘Alright,’ the boy said, his voice deep and gruff, like an ogre’s. He pulled the cigarette from his mouth and handed it out to Greer. ‘You want?’
Greer shook his head feebly, then coughed and wafted his hand to clear away the smoke. ‘Sorry,’ he choked. ‘I don’t smoke.’
‘Bad habit,’ the kid said, shrugging. His lip twitched as he raised the cigarette to it again. ‘Be lucky to find any around here anymore. All gone.’
‘Yeah,’ Greer nodded, awkwardly swinging his left foot around.
‘Your mate was the one who got killed, right?’ he asked, taking a deep inhale. ‘You saved Clem?’
‘Uh, yeah, that was me,’ he said, nearly dropping a tin of beans. ‘I’m Greer.’
‘Bronson,’ the kid said with a wink. A few dotted scars prickled across his eyelid, like tiny stars. ‘Sorry about your mate. It happens.’
‘I know.’ The words got caught in Greer’s throat, as though his gag reflex had detected them as a threat. They scratched at his tongue as they climbed up. ‘He wasn’t really my friend.’
‘That kid who legged it, that your brother?’
He shook his head. ‘No, no. Just a kid. He stole these,’ he said, holding up the cans.
‘But you’ve got a brother, somewhere. Right?’
‘How do you–’
Bronson tapped his nose. ‘Ask the right questions, get the right answers.’
What the fuck did that mean? Something about Bronson made Greer want to drop the tins, sprint over to the other warehouse and scoop Gage up into a hug. Made him want to push past and hide in the crowd inside. Bronson hadn’t even done anything wrong; it was just something rolling off him, like the stink of smoke mixed with something more sour. ‘Right,’ he managed to say eventually.
‘You got that look.’ Bronson took another drag, letting the smoke curl out slowly through his nose. ‘The looking-after-someone look. My cousin had that look.’
'Right,' Greer said again, because it seemed safer than asking what happened to the cousin. Bronson kept looking at him, like he expected more. ‘Gage. My brother. He's nearly eighteen months.’
'Where's he at then, little Gage?' Bronson nodded vaguely towards the smaller warehouse, like he already half-knew the answer and just wanted to hear Greer say it out loud. 'That the baby place? With the girls?'
‘Why do you care?’ Greer asked, suddenly snapping back to himself. There was no reason for this giant to give two shits about the babies or the girls. He answered to Clem, and Clem hadn’t given it a second thought. Hadn’t she? She knew about it, of course, but it hadn’t seemed to interest her, because you can’t weaponise babies into troops to rally for some disembodied voice on the radio, right?
‘I don’t,’ Bronson said on an exhale, rolling his shoulders back in a slow, sluggish motion. He flicked grey ash onto the concrete. ‘Just good to know things.’ His eyes slid back to Greer's face. They looked almost colourless in the flat evening light, and there was something unhurried and assessing in the look, like he was weighing Greer up on a scale that only made sense to him. 'Who’s who, what’s what; useful information, that.’
‘Useful for what?’
Bronson laughed. ‘Dunno,’ he said, chucking the end of the cigarette onto the floor. He crushed it under a heavy boot, twisting his sole back and forth, smearing the end dregs into the concrete. He gave an impish grin. ‘Ask me again later.’
Bronson turned and slowly pulled the door open, sinking inside the warehouse until all that was left was the stink of tobacco and the ash sprinkled over the ground. Greer let out a breath he hadn’t realised he’d been holding in, his head swimming with little fish, each one surfacing just long enough to gulp at him before vanishing back under. The image of Bronson’s huge hands throttling Gage’s neck, flinging him about like a rag doll, crashed down at him, squeezing his lungs. He gasped for air. Why did that boy make him feel so dirty, so creeped out? It was worse than being covered in crawler juice.
‘Oi, Greery-boy,’ came a voice from across the car park. He turned to see Lester, whose green eyes were twinkling mischievously in the setting sun. He had one hand in his pocket; the other rubbing at the back of his head compulsively. His nose was swollen, blooming in tones of blue and purple. ‘Holy moly, man. You look like shit.’
‘No more than you do,’ Greer replied, shaking his head to clear it. ‘I’m just, I don’t know, I’m just thinking.’
‘Well, don’t,’ Lester said with a sniff. ‘It gives you wrinkles.’
‘Is it done?’
Something flickered in Lester’s eyes, there and then gone in a second. ‘Yeah, yeah, he’s all buried,’ he sighed. He had changed into a plain black T-shirt and joggers, but they were still as stained and dirty as their army gear had become. Greer could see the rounded shapes of his biceps moving under the thin fabric as Lester rubbed at his head again. ‘Round the back, under some shrubbery. Man, Donnie won’t stop praying. He’s got the beads out. The whatsit. The Rosemary.’
‘Rosary,’ Greer corrected quietly. ‘I’m sorry I wasn’t there.’
‘It’s okay.’ Lester rested a hand on his shoulder and squeezed it. ‘We didn’t really know him, did we?’
Neither of them answered that.
They stood in silence for a few moments as Lester leaned in, his eyes scanning across Greer’s face like they could read his thoughts. Before he could speak, the doors swung open, and Cal strolled out, carrying a black binbag of rubbish. Bethy trailed behind him. Words were tumbling out of her mouth with such speed, like they were hot on her tongue and she had to spit them out.
‘What did Clem say about the points system? Did she like it? I think it could work, maybe.’ She gave a quick nod of acknowledgement as she passed, a near smile pulling at the corner of her mouth. ‘Like, we compete against each other with the training and recruitment and earn weapons and privileges. Like house points, back in school? That way we can feed back to Cry in proper data sets, like he wanted from us.’
Lester caught Greer’s eye and mouthed fuck that.
Cal stopped and rolled his eyes. ‘She’s gonna figure it all out tomorrow,’ he said, looking over at Greer and Lester. ‘Where should we dump these?’
‘We just throw everything in that big skip over there,’ Lester said, pointing across to the far end of the carpark. Cal thanked them, and the pair moved on.
‘Oh, I forgot,’ Lester said with a grin, his face brightening too fast. ‘I got you something. Saw it in one of their boxes and nicked it for you. I think they’re planning on doing some sort of rationing system, because they were labelling all the food with initials.’
‘What?’
‘I know, stupid, right? It should be–’
‘No, what did you get me?’
Lester pulled a purple packet from his pockets and dangled it in front of Greer’s face. Pickled Onion Monster Munch. ‘Your favourite, right?’
His stomach lurched, a vinegary acid rising in his throat. He could see Danny grinning with his mouth full, saying this is the best thing I have eaten in so long. Now that mouthful st undigested in his stomach, six feet underground. Greer pushed Lester’s hand away.
'Greer?' Lester's smile started to slip, confusion creeping in where he'd expected thanks. ‘I thought these were–’
‘I’m going to bed.’
‘Wait!’ Lester shouted, jogging to keep up with him, but Greer waved him off and ran as fast as he could to the cabin and threw himself onto the top bunk.
The night drifted by in a haze. At some point, Lester had stumbled in, fallen asleep on the bottom bunk and was snoring loudly. Much later, Davey and Paul had joined him in a chorus of heavy, steady breathing. Donnie never went to bed. Greer lay half awake, his toes curled upwards against the duvet, thrashing every time the fingers of a dream clasped at him. Gage crying. Danny dying. Bronson smiling.
***
‘Our Father, who art in heaven, hallowed be thy name,’ Donnie murmured over the freshly dug lump of earth. His hands were pressed tightly together, tilted to the gently warming sky, the rosary clasped between them. God was the only constant presence in his life, the only thread between the old world and the new. If he didn’t make time to pray early every morning, before the others woke up, nothing would keep him grounded; in which case, he might as well float up into the sky and drift away from the troubles he had to solve. His thumb found the crucifix first, then moved to the large bead just beyond it, pausing there as the words left his lips: ‘Thy kingdom come, thy will be done, on earth as it is in heaven.’ He let his fingers drift to the next bead, one of the three small ones marking the space before the first decade. 'Hail Mary, full of grace, the Lord is with thee.'
He rolled the smooth, worn beads between his fingertips, feeling the prayers of generations before him surge through his bones. The rosary had belonged to his Grandmother, a stout Irish Catholic woman who he remembered little of, only her rough hands on his as she taught him how to pray. It had been her grandmother – his great-great-grandmother – who had strung the beads herself, knotting each one by hand into sturdy cord, until the wooden decades wound their way down to a small tin crucifix forged for her by her husband. He had never seen that side of the family much, his mother's side, only at Christmas and the occasional Easter. His father was never invited. This rosary was the only gift he had ever received from them, sent over in a little jade green envelope with his full name inked on the front: Donald Seamus O’Connor. Grandmother had left it to him in her will.
‘Forgive me,’ he said, looking up to a sky stained pink and raw, the clouds ahead already dulling to grey. His mother used to say, 'Red sky in the morning, shepherd’s warning.’ A storm was coming. ‘Forgive me, Father, for I have sinned, and I am always sinning. Forgive me, Father, for my unholy thoughts, for my lust, for my failings,’ he began, his heart hammering against his chest, sweat forming on his brow as he squeezed his eyes shut, expelling every sinful thought he’d ever had back out into the air. He had to say it out loud; he had to, but he couldn’t. He couldn’t admit it. Not to God, not to himself, certainly not to the others. Not now. ‘Guide me,’ he said, his voice cracking into a sob. ‘Guide me, Father, show me the right path to dispel my lust, my feelings, my–’
'Donnie?'
He froze. A girl’s voice broke through the air and pulled him from his prayers. The rosary went slack in his hands as he turned his head around to see her standing there. Clem, close enough that she must have heard at least the last few words. Her leather jacket hung loose and undone over her shoulders, swamping her small frame. She had on a crisp white blouse, like the girls had worn at Catholic school, and a tight black skirt over her pale thighs. Hugged against her chest was a clipboard, cradled like a baby. He looked her in the eyes and felt pathetic.
‘I couldn’t help but overhear,’ she said with a smile, showing her perfectly straight teeth. He licked his tongue over his crooked ones, averting his gaze back to Danny’s grave. ‘I never took you for one to be struggling with lust,’ she continued, moving closer. ‘But I guess Catholic families did always have a dozen or so kids, right? What were you, one of eight, nine?’
‘Ten,’ he admitted, pocketing the rosary, hiding it away from her prying eyes. ‘Oldest of ten.’
‘Ouch,’ Clem winced, and it sounded sincere. ‘I’m sorry. I was an only child. A lonely childhood made for minimal loss.’
‘I could have guessed,’ he said, his eyes still down and focused on the grave. He pictured Danny underneath it, bloodied and pale and torn up, and hoped he was whole again in Heaven.
Clem made a tutting sound. ‘I am sorry about him, you know,’ she said. ‘I didn’t mean for it all to go so wrong. It was the fun of it, I suppose. The race. I truly didn’t know Cry hadn’t told you.’
‘We didn’t even know you existed,’ Donnie growled, in a low, accusatory tone.
‘Well, that’s not our fault, is it?’ Clem said, mock-offended.
Donnie splayed his right hand out on top of Danny’s grave, pushing the dirt through his fingers. He took a deep breath in. ‘You said all this yesterday, when we dropped the transceiver off. Don’t make me listen to it all again. Not in front of Danny. You got a problem with me? We set up that office upstairs and make it official.’
‘Oh, now you want to make it official? Yesterday you were this close.’ She raised her hands and used her forefinger and thumb to show the space of an inch or two. ‘This close to throttling me in that jeep. Not very Christian of you.’
‘I’m Catholic,’ he said, unmoving.
‘Whatever, same thing. So, what type of lust are you praying about? I’m guessing it’s not about the girls, is it?’ she said, her lips curling into a wicked smile. He said nothing, and her face brightened with the cruel, childish delight of someone who had just figured out a weakness they could use to get their own way. ‘I don’t even need to say it, do I?’
‘I don’t know what you mean,’ he said, looking up at her. He slowly rose to his feet until he towered above her, and clenched his trembling hands into tight fists. ‘Whatever you’re insinuating, you’re wrong. My prayers are between me and my God, not you.’
Clem smiled down at her clipboard and then wrote something with a theatrical flair. ‘Donnie, your secrets are safe with me,’ she said sweetly. ‘Anyway, I came to find you because you’ve got a mission from Cry, if you want it.’
‘Why would I trust him?’ he seethed. ‘After yesterday? I can’t just go straight back out there on his word.’
‘But people might be in trouble,’ she said with a pout. ‘Apparently, he intercepted a radio broadcast from the hospital. Some kids inside sounded like they were in need of help. Isn’t that what being a Shadow is all about?’
***
By the time Greer awoke, he was heavy with sweat, his curly hair plastered to his forehead in thick clumps. The cabin smelt like stale farts and morning breath, with just a hint of Lynx Africa wafting through, which meant Lester had already gotten up. Greer slipped down the ladder and pulled off his sodden T-shirt, swapping it for his semi-clean vest and camo jacket, then pulled off his boxers and flung them into a far corner to worry about later and pulled on a fresh pair. His last fresh pair. He wriggled into his camo trousers and boots and then sat for a moment on Lester’s bunk, watching the steady rise and fall of Paul’s chest in the bottom bunk beside him. A wet patch marked the pillow where Paul had drooled in the night.
Outside, the air was crisp, and the gentle, nostalgic coo of pigeons nesting in the trees behind the cabin filled the air. He took a left and went around the back of the warehouse to where they had buried Danny. A fresh lump of earth marked with a small wooden cross was resting beneath a dying oak. He gulped and turned around instantly.
Inside the warehouse, a large group of kids were stifling yawns as they queued up for breakfast, each holding a plate that had been marked with their initials. The whiteboard that had been collecting dust in the office upstairs had been moved down, and upon it there were four vertical lines, separating the names of everyone there into four groups. Next to each name was a space for a tally. Several kids already had several marks next to their names, including Bronson. Barely any of the Shadows had one. Jesus, Greer thought, scratching his head. Clem had been busy in the few hours that had already passed in the morning. He looked around, peering over everyone’s greasy heads, trying to spot Donnie or Lester, but he couldn’t see either of them. Davey was stuffing his face with a bowl of cornflakes smothered in UHT milk, sitting on one of the fold-out tables acting as counter space.
‘Davey,’ he called, pushing through the kids. ‘The fuck is going on?’
He wolfed down another mouthful. ‘Uhm, breakfast?’
‘Where is everyone?’ Greer let out an annoyed sigh.
‘In the garage,’ he said, shrugging. ‘I don’t care. I wasn’t invited, so…’ He raised another spoonful to his lips and slurped up the milk. ‘I’m just helping myself. Clem came down this morning and said all this crap about a points system.’ He pointed at the board, wiping his lips with the back of his hand.
‘I saw,’ Greer said, irritated. ‘So, what are they doing in the garage?’
‘No idea. Seemed real important, though. Is Paul awake yet?’
Greer shook his head. ‘No, he was drooling and snoring when I left.’
Davey put the bowl down. The spoon clinked against the china. He hopped off the table and stretched his arms up with a yawn. ‘Ugh, I’ll go get him up.’
Greer moved back through the crowd, not caring to queue up and get himself breakfast. He turned and headed for the garage, where Lester and a very tense-looking Donnie were getting their gear together. A jeep sat with all four doors open, ready to be loaded with weapons and provisions, and Cal was cleaning the windscreen with a rag and a bucket of soapy water.
‘Ah, Greery-boy,’ Lester’s eye lit up when he saw Greer, and he sauntered over, pulling him into a brotherly hug. ‘You’ve missed out. We’re going on a top-secret deadly suicide mission,’ he said in a sarcastic tone. He leaned in closer, his nose still swollen and purple, and whispered, ‘Vector wants us to steal the pyramid!’
Greer pictured Clem with her sharp black bob with the straight fringe and knew exactly what Lester meant. He let out a laugh. ‘Ah, a secret mission?’
‘Not really secret,’ Lester replied, fiddling with his jacket buttons. ‘But it seemed urgent. Some kid at the hospital radioed in for help, apparently. Was that what she said, Donnie?’
Donnie was cleaning one of Jasper’s uncle’s rifles. His jaw was clenched, teeth grinding back and forth in a way that made his jaw stick out, Habsburg-like. He didn’t look up but said solemnly, ‘Cry intercepted a radio channel, probably from some walkie-talkie, and he reckons it’s from the hospital. So Clem wanted us to check it out.’
‘And we’re doing what Clem says because...??’ Greer narrowed his eyes, sure that Donnie would offer more resistance. ‘Like, Cry is not reliable, as we found out yesterday. How do we know this isn’t just some other stupid set-up?’
‘That’s exactly what I said.’ Lester threw his hands in the air. ‘But oh, no! Donnie here actually thinks it’s a good idea!’
Donnie looked up from his gun. His eyes were red and bloodshot, like he hadn’t slept at all. His hair was fuzzy and sticking up all over the place. ‘If there are kids in danger, we go and save them. That’s our motto.’
‘Yeah, but-’ Lester began.
‘End of!’ Donnie said. ‘We save kids and kill those damn crawlers. End of.’
Greer looked at Lester in shock. Lester’s face was scrunched in confusion. He leant in closely to Greer and whispered, ‘I think Donnie might be a robot, and Clem has rewired him somehow.’
It wasn’t funny. Lester went back to cleaning his own gun, and soon after Paul stumbled in, still half asleep. There was toothpaste smeared across his chin and remnants of milk and cereal splattered down his shirt. He shrugged on a jacket and glanced at the rest of them, eyebrows raised.
‘Alright?’ he said, yawning and turning to Greer. ‘What’s this all about then? You and Davey on the naughty list or something?’
Greer exhaled loudly. ‘Something like that.’
He leant against the door frame with his arms crossed and watched as the four of them got ready. Donnie didn’t speak a word as he opened up the garage door and then climbed into the front of the jeep. Lester climbed in beside him, and Paul and Cal got in the back. The slam of the doors shutting echoed around him as the engine started up, and as they drove off, he gave a sad wave to Lester, who had pressed his nose up against the glass so that he looked like a pug. He closed the garage door behind them, the metal groaning shut with a hollow clang that seemed to swallow the last of the engine noise.
He pulled it back under control – in through the nose, out through the mouth – and turned, unsure what he was even supposed to do with himself now that Clem was running everything.
Suddenly, a child's scream tore through the warehouse, bouncing off the garage doors and right into his ears. It was followed quickly by a surging chorus of shouting and cheering.
Greer was moving before he'd finished thinking the word Jasper.
Points:
Time spent:
IP address:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Some questions you could answer after reading, if you wanted!:
1. Clem and Greer have different ideas on how this new world should be run. Clem wants rules and structure, whilst Greer wants instinct and action. Which approach do you think is more likely to keep people alive?
2. Greer admires the Exterminators for going out and killing crawlers rather than waiting for orders, but Clem points out that this led to one of them being kidnapped. Whose interpretation of events do you find more convincing, and why?
3. Greer thinks of Clem as a 'stupid bitch' for assigning him newbies, and assumes she's trying to sabotage him. Do you think this is a true reading of her motives, or could there be another explanation for her choice?
4. Why do you think Greer took Jasper along, even if he thought he was too young?
5. Paul's death is relayed through the walkie-talkie. The reader doesn't get a description of what happened. What do the narrative and emotionality of the piece gain by keeping the reader (and Greer) at a distance from the violence, compared to the visceral, close-up violence shown in earlier chapters (such as Katie's death)?
6. The chapter ends with the detail that Jasper's rabbit "only had one eye." Why might the author (meee!! hello) choose to end the chapter on this image rather than on the crawler attack?
This chapter has a lot of dramatic events packed into it! The young characters in this chapter seem to act their age at least sometimes despite the nightmarish state of their world. I like how you write dramatic scenes. I think you describe what is going on very clearly without making the blocks of writing excessively long. Your closing sentence mentions that Jasper's rabbit has only one eye, which makes me think the rabbit's might play an important role in future chapters, or perhaps it might be a red herring, if that is what you choose to use the rabbit for. You are a good writer!
Hello hello! I am coming to this without any context but here goes! Excited to dive in - I love the premise of this story. Overall: I loved this chapter, too. It's punchy, excellently paced, packed full of memorable characters, and leaves me wanting more.
Incredible opening. This is something I've noticed throughout: these people are such believable teenagers and I love it. The focus on the granular everyday is working so well, too. Just because the apocalypse happens doesn't mean people stop craving a particular snack!
...Case in point. I can see this so clearly in my mind. I've seen so many teenage boys act this way.
If you're looking for stuff to cut, this reads a touch awkwardly and feels redundant to me! I already have a strong sense of Clem's clothing and it feels odd to back that up with something that Greer can't even see.
Same as above, I think you're successfully conveying that this is Greer's opinion of Clem elsewhere in the passage.
Impeccable. I smiled so hard at this - and bringing the Monster Munch back through makes it feel less like set dressing and more like a fact of life, as well as making for a great punchline. In general, the back-and-forth in this scene is so good.
Delightfully grotesque image!!! I don't really have a good sense of what the Crawlers look like, but that one's probably on me for jumping in at chapter 13!
OHHHHH I ADORE THAT THIS IS THE FINAL LINE. Throwing a striking image at the reader is one of my favourite ways to end a piece and this is SUCHHH a good example of it.
Questions
1. Clem and Greer have different ideas on how this new world should be run. Clem wants rules and structure, whilst Greer wants instinct and action. Which approach do you think is more likely to keep people alive?
Honestly, I think they're both being a bit stupid but in opposite directions (and in ways that stem from very legible & understandable worldviews, which is a real strength of this chapter). The thing about this entire set-up is that there are no good options and they're having to make the best of a terrible situation. This possibly speaks to my own approach to narrative, but: these kids were doomed from the start. Greer is correct that a bunch of traumatised and in-over-their-heads teenagers aren't going to respect a system just because they've been told to. Clem is correct that doing whatever feels right in the moment is a loser's game. I feel like success lies in whether they can each figure out the correct times to make concessions to the other.
2. Greer admires the Exterminators for going out and killing crawlers rather than waiting for orders, but Clem points out that this led to one of them being kidnapped. Whose interpretation of events do you find more convincing, and why?
HMM. SO. I think this bit of exposition might be the weakest part of the chapter - in that I reached it and went 'ah, exposition', so received it as pure information rather than as differing interpretations. Again, this might be a casualty of me jumping in at chapter 13 - I assume if this has already happened on the page, it would read differently. To answer the actual question: I don't think Greer is wrong per se but I get the sense that he is heavily projecting his own situation onto it. Clem definitely seems to be more clear-eyed about what happened.
3. Greer thinks of Clem as a 'stupid bitch' for assigning him newbies, and assumes she's trying to sabotage him. Do you think this is a true reading of her motives, or could there be another explanation for her choice?
Nah, I read this as Greer reacting out of pure anger (with a dash of unexamined misogyny). My sense is that Clem is trying to mix in the younger/less experienced kids with the older/more experienced ones, possibly because she read somewhere that this was an effective workplace training strategy and didn't quite think through that this is the apocalypse and not a management seminar.
4. Why do you think Greer took Jasper along, even if he thought he was too young?
I get the feeling that, for all his bluster, Greer does fear Clem a little - or, at the very least, respects her authority enough not to go against her too blatantly. I think there's also a bit of 'ah, screw it, I give up on you lot' in his attitude towards the kids more broadly - which leads to a rather hands-off, 'you are responsible for your own choices no matter how old you are' approach. So when Jasper says he wants to go, Greer's more inclined to just let it slide.
5. Paul's death is relayed through the walkie-talkie. The reader doesn't get a description of what happened. What do the narrative and emotionality of the piece gain by keeping the reader (and Greer) at a distance from the violence, compared to the visceral, close-up violence shown in earlier chapters (such as Katie's death)?
Hmmmmm. This is a really good question. I think the biggest gain is contributing to Greer's wider sense of being detached from things, and not having access to the action. You also get a little of that classic theatre tragedy effect where having something relayed lets the reader imagine the worst possible version - but to be totally honest, I'm not sure how much it's doing here. Maybe my tolerance for body horror is too high but getting swallowed whole is not a particularly gnarly image to me. The Crawler's distended body totally is, though, which is another bonus of this choice!
6. The chapter ends with the detail that Jasper's rabbit "only had one eye." Why might the author (meee!! hello) choose to end the chapter on this image rather than on the crawler attack?
The missing eye evokes the gore and violence that the rest of the piece is drenched in - and by collapsing that image into that of a child's stuffed animal, you get the discomfort and horror of the situation without actually showing it yet, so you get the bonus of building anticipation as well. I see what you're doing and it's very clever!!!
Thank you so much for the review! I do need to cut some exposition so your feedback was really helpful <3
(Also, bc I feel I didn't make it clear enough: I am a massive fan of unlikable characters and I am GNAWING on these guys)
You would probably love Ravi from my previous chapters XD I love unlikeable characters too
Oooh, I'm sure I would!! Hype to read them
*side eyes this A/N*
Really raises the immersion :3 Ofc Greer would not go out of his way to explain this!This one is more acceptable. I still don’t like it but it’s not actively harmful.
Hey hey Greer, noodles are definitely real food.
Oha he is an Enforcer? That sounds ominous.
I like how you mention this without context:
Uhhh I am less willing to let the quota thing slide. WHAT kind of quotas need to be met in the APOCALYPSE? O.O
I find it weird how you introduce the wrestling thing and then go into a description of Bronson like this. It doesn’t feel like you adequately explain why Greer went there and he has 0 reaction to this. We are still stuck with his gripes abt the food so the transition into this… was not v elegant.
Srsly with the long descriptions, it feels like forever until Greer has any thought of thought abt why this is happening and if it is ok or normal or bad :/
Very good description: I already have a certain expectation of her now!
Oh I hate her alright XD
…how do they know all this…
I don’t think you have adequately explained why Clem is in charge. Yes she do be liking rules but how did she get the position? It sounds like she’s new etc and this isn’t a normal office job so I don’t see how she could ever establish any sort of authority over the other kids. It seems implausible atm.
Ohhh these are the kids near the hospital! I like that we are continuing where the other chapter left off!
I do like how Clem immediately hands over the keys once Greer asks for them.
(Incidentally, Clem is a professional starcraft player and I cannot detach the name so easily from him XD)
I don’t understand why Greer listens to this girl. Why doesn’t he just take the kids he WANTS to take? You really did not explain that part which makes me not like any of these characters even if the writing continues to be good.
even more reason to take only those you think are actually capable of saving them? Or does he have no idea who is currently available that is capable enough? That is also a poor reflection on Greer! This sounds like a disaster waiting to happen and I do not care about that. All of these are behaving stupidly and deserve what’s coming -.-
Ugh and ofc it’s bully and victim. Rev, I do not like how you set this up and I hate Clem and I want to move back to characters who make sense thank you. If I wanted corporations being idiotic and sending the worst ppl to do the most important jobs, I would watch the news.
Yep, like a mismanaged corporation where your own goals precede ACTUAL survival. Ugh.
How old is Jasper? At least he has a ranged weapon so he might be surprisingly useful.
Oh okay, at least Greer asks for his age.
Srlsy WHY are you taking this kid?! Don’t you have your own head to think????
THEN WHY ARE YOU LISTENING TO CLEM???!!
I am five seconds away from abandoning this chapter.
That said .. they were talking abt Cry from the Broadcast, earlier! I …didn’t realise oops.
Ofc -.-
Is this Ravi’s Dad? oô
You were definitely worried about the wrong chapter.
1
I am unhappy with both approaches and I don’t understand how Clem got to be in charge when things worked differently before her arrival. It sounded like Greer’s stuff worked and now we have Clem in charge and it is not working any longer and I hate either approach.
2
They both didn’t convince me. I don’t like either approach. Community based solutions would work best here and they are both not able to figure this out and I am very angry atm.
3
I don’t like Greer from his petty narration and I don’t like how you never set up why they were listening to Clem. I suppose with Jasper’s slingshot skills she didn’t send those 4 with him for NO reason but the whole narration was so irritating and Greer such a negative nancy that I dont care if Clem made the most brilliant decision ever. I don’t like the character archetypes you set up here and I feel like I know exactly how things are gonna go and even if you subvert my expectations, it will not feel satisfying. At least this is what I currently think. Maybe you can really turn things around but for now, I remain highly skeptical.
4
I wish I knew. I complained enough about this. It sounds like there is a punishment for not going on missions that Clem assigns you? Also Jasper said he did want to come so what was he gonna do?
5
I feel more for Paul than any of the others you introduced this chapter. Lester too.
I think we get the slow dread from trying to get to them in time, from knowing that they are THE BEST OF THE BEST and from knowing the situation they were in (last chapter). I think it works very well and we do not need to be emotionally invested in them to feel anxiety over their rescue.
That said, the whole thing with picking up the random boys took too long for me to really care. (yes I will harp on this point. Nothing hurts as much as feeling betrayed by something that is written so well XD)
I also assume we will get the fallout from Paul’s death once the characters have time to process. But the “it ate paul” is very visceral in on itself.
6
Sounds to me like Mr Jasper killed the rabbit with a slingshot to the eye (or rather that this is what the stuffed rabbit is supposed to represent), the most skillful and best way to hunt game. I think it is a hint that he is rly good with the slingshot
Silly time: it is ofc a reference to Ravi and hints at Jasper’s inner darkness!
ah yee i was taking a risk with this chapter. I think it will be set up better when I add a chapter or two to Part One. There are reasons they are listening to clem and i should have mentioned. She has sent most of group a and b (the og, trained and strong shadows) out on missions (which would be to find more kids and bring them back, because she is building something) so that's why he takes the kids he doesn't want.
I think because i know the story I lowkey forget that my readers dont--- oop.
i definitely should have explained somewhere that clem had punishments for shadows who rebelled against her regime. aaaaaaaaaaaa i hate this chap now lol
If she has punishments she also needs ways to enforce them and I don't see how she could
OKAY I HAD AN IDEA:
So if I establish in part one not only Greer's backstory of the shadows being set up and rescuing kids, but that Clem actually ran her own outfit too, before this merger. Cry was sort of in charge of both, as they needed him to send the broadcasts. The shadows were more successful at this.
When her group and the Shadows crossed paths, Clem realised her group had a worse setup, and so convinced Greer and his friends to let her group move in with them at the warehouse and join forces.
This is where they started to clash over leadership, but Cry backed Clem and refused to even meet Greer - the main reason for this will become apparent later on, so I don't want to spoil Cry's intro, but the reason that Cry gave was that Clem's dad had been a radio engineer, so knew about the radio stations, etc. Or she went to a fancy school that had it's own radio station or something like that.
So Clem has some leverage there because she has closer ties to the people they need to actually do their jobs. She also now becomes the only one that can actually get in touch with Cry aside from when they listen to the broadcasts. Since Cry is in a high tower with a good radio signal, he can see where the crawlers are headed, etc and dictate the best times to go into the city. Clem controls this info and puts her original group in charge of the food supplies and training.
Then with the photo in greer's pocket, the idea was that it was his younger brother, (a toddler) and Clem separated the smaller kids for 'safety' and took away access when Greer didn't do what she said, but it felt like a repeat of the Lottie/Jack storyline, so I didn't elaborate as I didn't know what to replace it with. But I'm thinking now perhaps Greer is gay, and he doesn't want the other boys to know, and the photo is of his boyfriend, who he has been unable to find since a mission went wrong, and Clem has threatened him with exposing his sexuality. She claims she has people out looking for him.
So when Clems sends the strongest fighters out on missions, it's because those are her priority cases from Cry's personal network, and it leaves Greer stuck running the base with whoever's left over, which is also why he gets stuck with a "B-team" like Bronson's group instead of picking his own, and he has to take them or she will 'expose him'
DOES THAT MAKE ANY SENSE AAAA
Depends on how Cry ended up backing Clem. What he saw in her.
I think it would also work if Greer had a bit of... idk fear of Clem? Like more than just getting removed from office. Like he were treating her like more of authority figure with actual power than a convenient person to complain abt in narration? If she had power over HIM too or if we saw other ppl not named Cry also backing her, or saying that she's doing this much better than him? We can have both, him saying the point system is stupid and that she takes too long decide on stuff but ALSO shows of her effective leadership. I think even if you wanted to keep that a secret, that she is actually competent, it really hurts this chapter if you do. We need to see her being effective so we can have a better understanding of both Greer and her.
"She also now becomes the only one that can actually get in touch with Cry" that is really good and we also had this in THIS chapter. It just wasnt really working because you didnt establish why Greer would care abt Cry that much. There's some context missing (that even if you had this in the previous story or even a previous CHAPTER), you need to re-establish here
" Clem separated the smaller kids for 'safety' and took away access when Greer didn't do what she said" Ahh and her own group, her loyalists, are in charge of 'safety' Ohh that is good. If you had THIS in the chapter, I would have loved it. I think you were a bit to keen on showing that Greer is capable and didn't show enough of him being vulnerable :) I also see what you mean about the Lottie-Jack thing. But I wouldn't have minded a Jack-an-adult-crawler even tho we already had Ravi's Dad. And you could draw parallels between Ravi and Clem, how they approach it and how Lottie/Greer react to a similar situation. It could also help forge a bond between Lottie and Greer if they were to meet. Also would get Lottie invested in freeing the kids from Clem's control etc There are avenues worth exploring if you allow the parallels and not sweep them under the rug.
Otherwise, I'm not sure how Clem can really control someone as independent as Greer even if she has her own ppl.
(Yes even in review responses I answer as I read instead of reading everything in one go)
So the gay thing. Hm. I guess homophobia always works for this in a pinch. I do like the idea that his bf is missing and that he was known to the other boys. That said... I kinda like the little kid thing more even if it is a repeat. I think you can make the bf work tho, you are a good writer :3
I guess Clem also keeps Greer close bc she doesnt like him, huh? XD Maybe she's a homophobe XD
You always have such amazing insight and I'm really grateful!! I'm glad the little brother idea works for you. Perhaps he is also gay, and he is dating a boy in clem's group, which is one of the reasons he decided to go ahead and merge groups, but he doesn't want this to be known still, and clem uses it against him (perhaps always sending his bf on the most dangerous missions). I was thinking she would be a more traditional private school girl, and perhaps isn't a HUGE homophobe but definitely isn't comfortable with it.
And you are so right that I've been too keen on making Greer look competent and not vulnerable enough, and that we need to actually SEE Clem being effective instead of just Greer complaining about her, or else it doesn't make sense she's about to remain in charge. I'll definitely work this into my rewrite of the chapter, and having other people vouch for her is a good idea.
Also maybe Greer breaks up the fight between Bronson and jasper, and jasper then sticks to greer like a shadow and maybe stows away in the jeep instead of being chosen to go, because he wants to help his new 'big brother?'
WAIT AND IT WOULD BE SO CUTE TO HAVE LOTTIE AND GREER BOND OVER HAVING BABY BROTHERS YOU'RE SO RIGHT. And that is one of the things that spurs him to finally rebel against Clem (alongside other spoilers i wont say)
okay i need a rewriting session today... katie's burial can wait xD
TYSM AGAIN TIKAA
Hmm if the bf is in Clem's group we need a REALLY good reason for how they started dating.... because it sounded like tensions were pretty high from the beginning xd
Remember I am just one person. The number of times I wrote a review where I went like "oops I was a bit too negative" and then looked at the GUSHINGLY POSITIVE responses of every other reviewer... You wouldnt believe it xd
"Also maybe Greer breaks up the fight between Bronson and jasper, and jasper then sticks to greer like a shadow and maybe stows away in the jeep instead of being chosen to go, because he wants to help his new 'big brother?'" AWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWW <3
(I need to see it in action but it can look very cute~ Especially if Greer immediately feels responsible, against his inner narration, for this poor kiddo) (I also like him breaking up the fight more actively and maybe showing some concern for Jasper so we see some of his caring side, contrasted with Clem's coldness?)
tbh it didnt feel as if Greer had ever been IN CHARGE in charge in this version of the chapter, more a lieutenant to a higher up XD
Have fun rewriting :3
Thought some more and here's what I came up with: Cry is an adult that's not inflected
I'M SAYING NOTHING (BUT YOU SHOULD BE A DETECTIVE)