Okay with such a diffrent piece I am going to take a diffrent approach than how I normally review. Lets get craking.
Paragraph 1
Great start. You had me intruiged right away. Perhaps you could change the repeatition of the word place because as of now it makes it seem a little bit off. You want to have repeatition usage with meaning.
Paragraph 2
Great job at giving more insight to both the boy and his surroundings. Love the picked up his tools however there is something I would like to address. "stank of death" because you have "death" as a character this phrase looses it's meaning. Perhaps be more descriptive of what the smell is, you could even associate it with sight or another sense. When you use the word Death in this poem you need it to mean the person or else it looses its meaning.
Paragraph 3
I like this paragraph. It is good at setting the scene for what is about to come. The ryhme is really good as well. Not a lot to say about it but that is okay.
Paragraph 4
Great work here. Death's short speech was good. I don't know how much I like the boy's words. I would have rather seen quick speech and another visual of what is happening then the boy talking about wanting to go home. That is just me though.
Paragraph 5
I like how you change the image of the place bringing it back to the idea that wherever this boy is isn't heaven or hell. You give a mixture of both with bringing in the white and talking of the beauty amongst the "muck". However I think you need to add a comma to "turning white they were changing back" after white.
Paragraph 6
Intresting paragraph. While I think the rhymes were a bit forced you brought more of a human esque appearence to Death.
Paragraph 7
Again another very intresting paragraph. You continue to make Death more human which is good and bad. While you want to be able to relate to the Angel of Death you are also making him loose some of his power.
Paragraph 8
Great rhyme here. Not at all forced and the words you chose were well chosen. With that being said you talk about the boy putting his arm around Death and looking him in the eyes, giving the idea that this boy who you had stated was seven, is taller and older than he is. I would advise you to take another look at this boy and perhaps change is age which may help with the believability in him The boy being so worldly and knowlegeable doesn't leave me with the impression he is as young as you say. The only thing supporting that is the letter he wrote to his mother.
Paragraph 9
I like the ending. I don't love it but its very good. I am glad you wrapped it up but I feel you could have been more discriptive in what had happened. You left me wanting more at the end.
Overall:
This is a really good solid piece. I myself like to try and potray Death as a human, and one that is very human at that. I try though to keep him/her still the powerful idea and being that he/she is. In your case it is a man, which is fine, but he is almost too human that you loose some of the idea in there. Your message while very clear doesn't really match the complexity of your poem. I think it is a good message it just wasn't the right one for me. I did however enjoy the originality and diffrence you have created. Rhyming paragraphs is really cool. While it may turn some people off I have fallen in love with it. In all I would give it a 8/10. Great job and keep writing!!!
Points: 249
Reviews: 122
Donate