#13 (The List)

9 posts
User avatar
Gender Female
Points 2188
Reviews 74
Number 13 of The List. They do not need to be read in order.


---

She’s standing at edge of the road, and the streetlight is shining down on the top of her head. I can see her perfectly from where I’m sitting, inside a dingy diner on the corner of south street.

She’s waiting for the bus, I can tell, a bag at her feet and her arms wrapped around herself. She’s wearing a sweatshirt, but it’s too cold for just that.

I slip out of the restaurant. My boots sound on the pavement and I know that she can hear me coming but she doesn’t make a move to turn around.

When I’m standing next to her it’s just now that I can see how truly small she is. The top of her head barely comes up to my chest.

“The next bus doesn’t come for another half hour, you know,” I say, conversationally.

The girl’s only reply is the fog of her breath on the night air.

“It might be better for you to wait inside the diner over there.”

Once again, she says nothing.

“Come on, it’ll be my treat.”

She turns and looks up at me.

“I killed a boy,” she says flat out.

There isn’t anything I can do to keep the shock off of my face, I'm sure it’s clearly visible. “You… You did what?”

“I killed him,” she says, turning her face back to gaze down the street. “I reached into his chest and I tore out his heart. And then I ate it.”

I have no idea what to say to this. I don’t think there is any response.

After a moment of silence, I say hesitantly, “I’m going to assume that you’re speaking…. Figuratively?”

She shrugs her shoulder. “Killing someone is killing someone, whether or not they die.”

“That doesn’t make any sense.”

She glances at me again. “It makes perfect sense.”

I let the subject drop.

A car drives by, bathing us in the light of its headlights.

“It’s too cold to be waiting out here,” I say finally.

“I can’t feel anymore anyway, so it doesn’t matter.”

I sigh. “Be that as it may, I’m sure, it would still make me feel a lot better if you at least came inside and had something warm to drink.”

The silence stretches on for so long that I begin to think that she’s going to keep ignoring me, but she suddenly swoops down and picks up her bag, then marches off in direction of the diner. I run to catch up with her.

By the time I am caught up with her she’s already slid into a booth in the diner. I slide into the seat opposite her.

She’s pushed down the hood on her sweatshirt, and I can see that her hair is short, bangs falling across her forehead in short spikes. Her skin looks as though it would be pale under normal light, and the light coming from the overhead lights makes her look positively dead.

The waitress comes over and asks if we want coffee. I nod my head for the both of us, and she fills two mugs with the steaming liquid and, after asking if we need anything else, walks away.

She gazes down into the cup for what seems to be the longest time before picking it up gingerly and taking a sip.

“Where are you going?” I ask, in an attempt to make conversation.

“Everywhere and anywhere,” she says promptly, running a long, slim finger around the edge of her coffee cup.

“And what state is that town in?” I ask, feeling a small smile come over my lips.

“Nowhere.”

Silence .

“And what’s your name, girl who is going Everywhere and Anywhere which is located in the state of Nowhere?”

“I gave up my name when I killed that boy. It no longer exists.”

“I’m sure you didn’t kill him.”

“The look in his eyes after I ate his heart told me otherwise.”

I stay silent for a moment, unsure of what to say.

"Well, my name is Evan."

She doesn't say anything, but finishes off her coffee, and then reaches across the table and takes mine. I don’t protest. She takes a long drink from it, and then sets it down on the table.

I glance outside, and see that there’s a bus waiting at the bus stop. It doesn't look like the bus that usually comes. I nod my head toward it. “your ride is here.”

She looks in the direction I gesture to, and nods. “It is.” She reaches down and picks up her bag, sliding out from the booth. I follow, after hastily throwing a few dollar bills on the table.

The cold air hits me like a bag of cement after the warm interior of the diner. She’s walking quickly down the sidewalk towards the idling bus, which doesn’t seem in a hurry to be on its way.

When she’s almost reached it, I step in front of her. “What are you really running away from?”

She stares up at me, her eyes deep and fathomless. “From everything and anything. And nothing.”

“That isn’t a real answer,” I say, fighting the urge to grind my teeth as she sidesteps around me and continues toward the bus. The doors slide open just as she reaches them.
Before she disappears in the interior of the bus, she turns and looks at me again. To my surprise, she smiles, and in her smile is the answer.

I’m running away from myself.
"Funniest Member -- Sachiko. Secretly the devil. Do not engage. I repeat, do not engage." -- Iggy

"Behold ye babes of grammar: the goddess Sachiko. She does what she wants." -- Lauren2010




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 2816
Reviews 252
Youuu again. Aren't you prolific. :P I am going to get straight into it, because I can, and this is apparently how it works with us.

When I’m standing next to her it’s just now that I can see how truly small she is. The top of her head barely comes up to my chest.

Adverbs. Adverbs. Do you know many falsely small people? xD That one, at least, can die?

Also, more adverbs. A lot of adverbs that are evil. They're full of cholesterol, you know. Put too many in and they clog up your story's arteries.

Also, I love your female characters. They have the best dialogue. xD

“I can’t feel anymore anyway, so it doesn’t matter.”

Anymore anyway. Guh. xD Try to make it sound less repetitious?

“your ride is here.”

Capital. *nods*
And... that was brilliant. Essentially, I can't fault it. It's exactly the sort of thing I would write, a simple character exchange. It's to the point, and it's maddeningly vague, and I really like it. Evan seems... not quite a character, perhaps, but maybe he's just there to reflect against the other character. Regardless, I enjoyed the back and forth of the dialogue. It's the sort of thing I love to read Good job. ;)

Also, I'm sorry. this review is even more useless than the one before it.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1330
Reviews 900
This is going to be the most useless critique I give today, Imouto-chan.

I loved it. It ran beautifully, your flow was excellent and the narrative progressed perfectly. I loved the descriptions and Matty is right about the dialogue, your female is ferocious and wonderful, I love her character.

I've just thought of something that may be of use. Your last lines, the final explanation. Thinking on it now, it's underwhelming. It was surprising, I didn't see it coming - honestly, I thought she was dead and he'd killed her in the way she described killing the boy. The delivery was a little anti-climatic for me, but that may be a personal thing. I'm not even sure how you'd fix it, to be honest, I only noticed it as something that didn't quite gel with how I saw all the rest of it.

All in all, very nice work!

*Hearts* Le Penguin.
I like you as an enemy, but I love you as a friend.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 13816
Reviews 563
Hey Sachi!

This is really very lovely. :D You have a simplistic but beautiful style and it works magic in this story. Despite the reliance on dialogue, you have a wealth of detail whenever you do take the time to describe something. Beautifully done. The nameless girl especially benefits from this ambiguity and mysterious characterization. And the ending--the ending is what really hooked me. That was extremely well done. I'm just going to make a few comments, all right? You really have it nearly polished up. ^_^

She’s waiting for the bus, I can tell, a bag at her feet and her arms wrapped around herself. She’s wearing a sweatshirt, but it’s too cold for just that.


So, before I start making suggestions, I just want to come out and tell you that my style is world's different from yours. So take the suggestions I give for what they are--your style is enchanting and I love it, but my suggestions come from someone who is the opposite of a minimalist. :P But, moving on, I love the simplicity here, but the line 'it's too cold for that' stuck out to me. I think it would be nicer if we had a short, vivid image of what makes it so cold outside here.


I slip out of the restaurant. My boots sound on the pavement and I know that she can hear me coming but she doesn’t make a move to turn around.


I think a stronger word for 'sound' would work well here.

“The next bus doesn’t come for another half hour, you know,” I say, conversationally.


Is conversationally really necessary?

There isn’t anything I can do to keep the shock off of my face, I'm sure it’s clearly visible. “You… You did what?”


I think a reference to a specific facial change would be nice here. This part just strikes me as odd.

She shrugs her shoulder. “Killing someone is killing someone, whether or not they die.”


Love that

And your ending--fabulous. That smile was an extremely nice touch. :) All in all, I really enjoyed this. One thing I would urge you to look into is your usage of static and dynamic description. There are times when I feel you are aiming to create a static moment, like little freeze frames. The narrator commenting that the girl looks a certain way and describing things so matter-of-factly aids with this. But then again, there are times when movements seem fluid and dynamic, mostly when you describe using clearly active voice. This is not necessarily bad, but the largely static description with interjections of dynamic description threw me off slightly. At first, I thought you were aiming for a static setting, but when the dynamic parts came in, I got a little confused. Just something to think about as you are revising. :wink:

Nice work! I really enjoyed this. Gold star for you. :wink: Keep writing and PM me if you have any questions!
~ WD
If you desire a review from WD, post here

"All I know, all I'm saying, is that a story finds a storyteller. Not the other way around." ~Neverwas




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1030
Reviews 1260
Wow, Sachiko. This is a beautiful piece of work.

I really enjoyed your simple writing style, and the fact that you used little dialogue tags.The present-tense is quite artful, and your cliffhanger was great. It definitely a chilling tale.

However, it was a little confused. The story seems as though it's paced to quickly. Certain pivotal events are not explained (like the murder of the boy and the last line). I'm also wondering why the MC would allow a girl who just killed someone to come in with her. The ending was confusing, as I didn't see any clues that could lead up to it. I was thinking that this would be a ghost story.

Anyway, great job, and keep writing.
You can probably talk to me in chat if you have any questions.

All our dreams can come true — if we have the courage to pursue them.

-- Walt Disney




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 15394
Reviews 1464
STOP! It's Chiko time!


She’s waiting for the bus, I can tell, a bag at her feet and her arms wrapped around herself. She’s wearing a sweatshirt, but it’s too cold for just that.


This bit really stuck out to me. :P I really don't know if I like the first part of it-- the part about her waiting for the bus can be stuck in the first paragraph. The 'I can tell' seems otherwise unnecessary! I'm with Domi -- the last part of the sentence sounds like it's awkwardly tacked on for detail, and I think it can go kapish. ;)


As Mat verbalized, you're rather good with short pieces of just character interaction. It's a very admirable talent. Here, I think you did a good job. The girl's placidity was well placed, well versed, but I think the main character was empty. He needs to voice a little bit of emotion or whatever else he can so that we're feeling how he feels -- otherwise, we're wondering why he even cares about talking to her.

Nonetheless, I enjoyed reading this. I'd love very much if you continued writing a posting. ;)

Keep it up! Gold star for you. :)

June
"I'd steal somebody's purse if I could google it and then download it." -- Firestarter




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 33318
Reviews 382
Hi Sachiko,

How this thing managed to receive so many gold stars, I will never know. As it stands, it's a poor piece, something that sounds as if you took all of ten minutes to write it and tried to inject it with a theme at the eleventh hour.

Sachiko wrote:Number 13 of The List. They do not need to be read in order.


If this is a part of the story itself (and it probably is not), then it's a good beginning, one that's original and manages to introduce some sort of emotion - or emotion deriving from lack of such - and should definitely be kept. Unfortunately, this is one of the only good parts of this entire piece.

She’s standing at edge of the road, and the streetlight is shining down on the top of her head. I can see her perfectly from where I’m sitting, inside a dingy diner on the corner of south street.


The narrator is contrived and nowhere like a real person. "I can see her perfectly", "dingy diner on the corner of south street". These are info-dumps. You tried to hide it carefully but it shows like an open wound, a clumsy attempt to introduce a background without doing any real work.

She’s waiting for the bus, I can tell, a bag at her feet and her arms wrapped around herself. She’s wearing a sweatshirt, but it’s too cold for just that.


Too engulfed in weasel words and phrases to make any sort of impression. "I can tell" - of course you can tell. Are you just trying to up your word count?

"It's too cold for just that" - same thing. Get rid of it.

I slip out of the restaurant. My boots sound on the pavement and I know that she can hear me coming but she doesn’t make a move to turn around.


There has to be some reason you know this. Show, don't tell. I shouldn't even have to say this to someone with a literary portfolio as extensive as yours.

When I’m standing next to her it’s just now that I can see how truly small she is. The top of her head barely comes up to my chest.

“The next bus doesn’t come for another half hour, you know,” I say, conversationally.

The girl’s only reply is the fog of her breath on the night air.

“It might be better for you to wait inside the diner over there.”

Once again, she says nothing.

“Come on, it’ll be my treat.”


The narrator is coming on too powerfully for an initial meeting with a stranger who he doesn't even know standing out by herself on a sidewalk. Three seconds and he's already inviting her in for dinner, his treat? There is a wholly unrealistic and unsatisfying vibe about this whole plotline right now. Either expand on the attempted conversation and then get to the punch, or just don't get to the punch. Simply have him attempt small talk. Buying someone dinner isn't small talk.

She turns and looks up at me.

“I killed a boy,” she says flat out.

There isn’t anything I can do to keep the shock off of my face, I'm sure it’s clearly visible. “You… You did what?”


You may be sure but the reader isn't. Stop going on and on about images that you don't even describe. All you do is say "shock" and then write almost a full line about it, without even offering the reader a means to turn it into some sort of vision. Rectify that before anything else.

“I killed him,” she says, turning her face back to gaze down the street. “I reached into his chest and I tore out his heart. And then I ate it.”

I have no idea what to say to this. I don’t think there is any response.


Again, the stand-alone sentence above is completely unnecessary. There are things that a reader needs to figure out on his own, and you're not allowing it for some reason.

After a moment of silence, I say hesitantly, “I’m going to assume that you’re speaking…. Figuratively?”


This has all the tact and intelligence of a 15-year-old schoolgirl giggling about a naughty joke her friend has made. It has no place in such a distant, and surreal story that you're trying to create. "I'm going to assume that thisorthat". It's pathetic and out of place.

At this point, the girl starts turning into a wise mystic delivering answers shrouded in secrecy, and it's not cute or funny or deep. Look:

She shrugs her shoulder. “Killing someone is killing someone, whether or not they die.”

...

She glances at me again. “It makes perfect sense.”

...

“I can’t feel anymore anyway, so it doesn’t matter.”


These quotes above are annoying and do nothing to help the reader feel any sort of connection to the girl.

I sigh. “Be that as it may, I’m sure, it would still make me feel a lot better if you at least came inside and had something warm to drink.”

The silence stretches on for so long that I begin to think that she’s going to keep ignoring me, but she suddenly swoops down and picks up her bag, then marches off in direction of the diner. I run to catch up with her.

By the time I am caught up with her she’s already slid into a booth in the diner. I slide into the seat opposite her.

She’s pushed down the hood on her sweatshirt, and I can see that her hair is short, bangs falling across her forehead in short spikes. Her skin looks as though it would be pale under normal light, and the light coming from the overhead lights makes her look positively dead.

The waitress comes over and asks if we want coffee. I nod my head for the both of us, and she fills two mugs with the steaming liquid and, after asking if we need anything else, walks away.

She gazes down into the cup for what seems to be the longest time before picking it up gingerly and taking a sip.


This part could have been good had you not assumed that the reader is a complete idiot and can't understand symbols and gestures without being held like a child. "to think that she's going to keep ignoring me" is an example, as is "and the light coming from the overhead lights makes her look positively dead". That dead quote is especially bad because it just tells the reader that something about the light makes her look this way, but doesn't do anything other than that. You can't be either very vague or very specific about the most pointless things. There is a balance you need to find; go through this section and purge anything that sounds too much on either end.

“Everywhere and anywhere,” she says promptly, running a long, slim finger around the edge of her coffee cup.

...

“Nowhere.”

...

“I gave up my name when I killed that boy. It no longer exists.”

...

“The look in his eyes after I ate his heart told me otherwise.”


Again, her sudden transition to someone who talks in riddles and symbols is becoming very frustrating and unrealistic. If there's something supernatural about this girl and she has to talk like this, can you at least not make her sound so mind-numbingly arrogant and preachy? This is easily one of the worst sections in this already terrible story.

I'm not going to finish a line-by-line on this because it simply has too many of the same mistakes repeated over and over again. Use the advice given above and apply it to the full story. However, I will make mention of the fact that this:

She stares up at me, her eyes deep and fathomless. “From everything and anything. And nothing.”


And now her eyes are deep and fathomless without any sort of real description or reason why, and she ends on the familiar cryptic note. This without a doubt completely batters to death any credibility or semblance of relatability that this piece could have ever possessed.

I'm not sure why this is so bad; perhaps it is a piece just designed to get the author back in the mood of writing. I don't know. What I do know is that it serves no purpose and holds no weight and needs to be put into the recycle bin as soon as possible. Use it as a stepping stone to more decent works. Save the beginning, though - the only salvageable section of the piece.

Hope that helped,
Galerius




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 9692
Reviews 3900
Hey Sachi!

So yeah... you have a nice, clean style which is always a pleasure to read! However, a couple of rather major things irked me about this piece, so I figure I'll touch on that really briefly.

#1: The lack of Evan

And probably most everybody will disagree with me, but I really really didn't like it how Evan wasn't really in the picture at all. That probably doesn't make sense... um... okay! So you center on the girl (which is good) and you have Evan describe her and how she looks. And then he goes out to meet her.

BUT WHY?

And that's what really bugs me. Evan does things, but the first person doesn't give us any feeling of intimacy for his character. We aren't allowed to know why he does things, why he takes action, why he says the things he does. It seems like he's mostly there to let the girl vent... it doesn't matter what he thinks the way he thinks or does the things he does. As long as he talks with the girl, then it's okay... except I really miss the intimacy of the first person atmosphere and interior reflection that this piece is almost completely lacking.

#2: Inspector Clouseau dialogue

Image

So, what do I mean? A line from "A Shot in the Dark" goes like this:

Clouseau: "I believe everything and I believe nothing. I suspect everyone and I suspect no one."

Now, this line is awesome. But it's awesome because it is so confusing and ambiguous that it ends up being so ridiculous that it's funny. This isn't supposed to be a funny piece!

#3: The girl is annoying

And probably everybody is going to disagree with me here, but I didn't like the girl at all. She was annoying. If I were to meet her in real life, I would probably be like, "Okay, I'm walking away from you now. Have fun!" That's not to say that she is a bad character, or that her being annoying to me is a bad thing as well. Annoying characters can be quite good! In this case, she annoys me because she's vague, doesn't seem to think things through, and is completely lost. This is not bad. But I want to know more about Evan to see why he's so interested in this girl. Many people would just ignore her. I would.

Hope that helps! :D
Ubi caritas est vera, Deus ibi est.

"The mark of your ignorance is the depth of your belief in injustice and tragedy. What the caterpillar calls the end of the world, the Master calls the butterfly." ~ Richard Bach

Moth and Myth <- My comic! :D




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 6517
Reviews 798
Hey-o, Miss Sachik-o! =D

So, although it wasn't part of any deal, I thought I'd pop on over and return the favour you gave me.

She’s standing at edge of the road, and the streetlight is shining down on the top of her head. I can see her perfectly from where I’m sitting, inside a dingy diner on the corner of south street.


'She's standing at the edge of the road.' Incidentally, I find it hilarious that this quote was pointed out a few times without anyone mentioning this.

When I’m standing next to her it’s just now that I can see how truly small she is.


Icky. Cut for flow.

It’s too cold to be waiting out here,” I say finally.

“I can’t feel anymore anyway, so it doesn’t matter.”

I sigh. “Be that as it may, I’m sure, it would still make me feel a lot better if you at least came inside and had something warm to drink.”


Urgh, emo-ness. This particular dialogue is flat, and pointedly unsubtle to the point of absurdity. It feels off. Destroy it.

The silence stretches on for so long that I begin to think that she’s going to keep ignoring me, but she suddenly swoops down and picks up her bag, then marches off in the direction of the diner.


Watch them conjunctions, girl.

Okay, so basically, you have a nice clean style here and it's easy to follow. Now, personally, I love ambiguity - I'm a huge fan of little snapshots such as this, little mysteries -- the problem with this is that it's trying too hard to be mysterious and what's worse, it's too self-conscious about it. Which is why, as Snoink pointed out, the dialogue is contrived and a little absurd. The dialogue all toward the end needs some major revision.

I think you'll find that the most normal of answers, in surreal situations, come off much better than deliberately nonsensical cryptic remarks.

Another problem is motive. Am I the only one who found Evan to be incredibly creepy? I mean, when he wasn't being all beige and unremarkable. He went over to a random girl, at night, at a bus stop and makes strong overtures to her like 'You'll be better off in the diner' -- cue wierd-o leer. See, even that would be fine though, because at least we'd understand why he bothered. But, we don't and so in the end we are left with an enigma wrapped in a mystery wrapped in ludicrous (the rapper), wrapped in tomato sauce and left in an oven.

In any case, my dear lovely Chiko, this is a tad overwrought. We need a little more info - not on the girl, but on Evan, he's the instigator of all this. More from him, less from the girl. More relevance, less what-you-think-sounds-cool-for-all-of-ten-seconds. Um. So, yeah. Did I mention I love you? *NOMS*

XD Hope that helped, dear. Good luck with it! :P
Mah name is jiggleh. And I like to jiggle.

"Indecision and terror, thy name is novel." - Chiko



This looks like a really bad episode of Green Acres.
— David Letterman