Harry Potter fanfic (from epilogue)

25 posts1, 2
User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 29
JK Rowling was definitely writing that epilogue so people would write fanfics!!! So now I'm just responding to that...it's really bad because I wrote it during class when I was bored but anyway...critiques are welcome and invited...enjoy!

Rosie watched as her parents disappeared from view in the leftover smoke of the Hogwarts Express. Although she felt rather lonely in the emptiness of her compartment and scared of being so far from her home, Rosie was excited for the magic and adventures awaiting her at Hogwarts.
“May I join you?”
Rosie jumped, having been lost in thought, her focus on the landscapes emerging out the window. She turned to see a pale boy her age, tall and thin, his fine light-brown hair almost covering his intense blue eyes.
“If you wish,” Rosie said casually, though inside her heart pounded wildly; she had always been strange and shy and had never found friends in her Muggle school who could accept her for her unique magical abilities. The boy sat down across from her and took his wand out from its hidden place within his newly-made robes, twirling it in his fingers. When he noticed Rosie watching him, he hastily shoved the stick back into his robes, blushed slightly, and looked away.
“What? Do I have somethin’ on my face?” the boy asked, rubbing around his face gingerly. Rosie rolled her eyes and looked away.
“Who are you anyway?” the boy asked, furrowing his brows.
“Rosie,” Rosie said, still not looking at him. “You’re the Malfoy boy, right? Smith or something?” the boy nodded, his eyes still on her face. “I’m not supposed to talk to you, so if you would please…”
“Why not?” the boy asked defensively, “I won’t hurt you! How can you know you don’t like me when you don’t even know my name?!” The boy ran his fingers through his hair, which quickly took its original neat form on top of his head after contact. “It’s Scorpio; does no one know my name?! I’m not my father, you now,” he added quickly, hoping to reassure her.
“Please, I shouldn’t be—”
“But you are, aren’t you?” Scorpio interjected quickly. “Come now, your dad may not like me because I’m a Malfoy, but your mum isn’t like that, is she? And besides, our dads aren’t here now, are they?”
“I guess not…”
“Good,” Scorpio said quickly, “Have you thought about which house you’ll be in? I’m guessing you want to be in Gryffindor like your mum and dad—”
“Cousin! There you are!” Albus exclaimed entering the cabin, happy at having discovered a friendly face, though freezing at the sight of Scorpio. “Who’re you?”
Scorpio looked up serenely at him, relief expressed in his eyes at not having been called “Draco Malfoy’s son” or “the Malfoy boy” as he usually was at the cost of his father’s celebrity at having been Harry Potter’s enemy in their Hogwarts years.
“Al, this is Scorpio Malfo, Draco’s son,” Rosie said before Scorpio could get a word in. Scorpio blushed furiously, looking out the window so as to hide his flushed face from Albus.
“Oh. Alright,” Albus said casually, sitting down beside Rosie. Rosie’s eyes widened at Albus in disbelief of her cousin’s ignorance that Scorpio was his father’s enemy, grandson of the hated Death Eater Lucius Malfoy. Scorpio composed himself and smiled over at Albus.
“D’you reckon we’ll be in the same House, erm…what’s your name?” Scorpio asked, his face still lightly blotched with color.
“Albus Severus Potter,” Albus said with a grin, “Dunno ‘bout you, mate, but I want to be in Gryffindor.” Scorpio just stared for a moment; Potter’s son, son of “The Boy Who Lived”, who defeated the Dark Lord Voldemort. He forced his eyes off this boy who so resembled his hero father except for, of course, the lightning-shaped scar Albus’ father Harry bore as a symbol of the loss he had experienced soon after his first birthday from Lord Voldemort as well as a symbol of he who had saved the wizarding world from the evil of Voldemort and his famous Death Eaters. Awkward silence passed through the compartment. Scorpio pulled out the new September edition of Quiddich Today and pretended to be reading.
'"Many years ago, when I was young, I saw a fire, and what looked like death-- and beyond that, in the dark places, something...or some One, who knew me. Shall I at last find my way back to that wonderworld of Night?"'




User avatar
Gender None specified
Points 8413
Reviews 816
First and foremost, this story could greatly benefit from spacing between paragraphs. This makes it easier and more pleasant to read.

Although she felt rather lonely in the emptiness of her compartment and scared of being so far from her home, Rosie was excited for the magic and adventures awaiting her at Hogwarts.


This is unnecessary. Are you a fan of anime? I know that this kind of stream of consciousness occurs often in that genre, but it should probably remain there [I'm not bashing anime; I'm just noticing something]. Same here:

she had always been strange and shy and had never found friends in her Muggle school who could accept her for her unique magical abilities.


And why does she show her magic to muggles?

I see parallels to the first generation. In a way, it reminds me of Wuthering Heights ^_^

In general, I think you could have done more with Rosie's thoughts. Not by telling them straight out, necessarily, but by showing where she hesitates, where she looks nervous. So far, all body language like this is coming from Scorpio.




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 890
Reviews 11
Is this the first part?

For it seems really unfinished. It also doesn't seem to have much of a plot, to be perfectly frank.
My upcoming novel/short story...

"Regrets" (Working title)

A man who keeps one eye on the past may learn from his mistakes, but a man who keeps both eyes directed to the past is blind.




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 3762
Reviews 201
This is definitely a great start to something. It's good to space out your paragraphs, though.

I agree with Amelia with the body language. To me, Scorpio seemed really twitchy, with the constant turning to face the window and stuff. Having Rosie doing something so that you can show her actions would be good. However you want to go about it, do it.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 29
Yeah...this is just what I wrote during a class, so it's not even a whole chapter...

I'm really hating how I depict Rosie though...I'll post another draft pretty soon (or at least ASAP) which will be the whole of the chapter...

Thanks for the criticism! Always happy for more!

~Deoris
'"Many years ago, when I was young, I saw a fire, and what looked like death-- and beyond that, in the dark places, something...or some One, who knew me. Shall I at last find my way back to that wonderworld of Night?"'




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 48
This is okay.

The one thing that really annoyed me is that it's Scorpius, not Scorpio. Also, I don't think Albus would have called Rosie 'cousin' if he took after his parents at all.

Other than that, this was great. I look forward to reading more.
:wink:
All the world's a stage,
And all the men and women merely players.

~William Shakespeare




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 31
This is ok. It's a great start to something. But, there's some un-needed information and then some stuff that seems to be missing. In short, it doesn't seem like a whole, it feels like there should be more. So maybe you sshould elaboreate a little, and expand the story.

I, also, don't think that Albus would've called Rosir 'Cousin'. It just doesn't seem Natural. I'm also not sure that when it talk about Albus's appearance, it should be "Albus' ". instead it shoulld be Alubus's.

Other than that it's a great start!

xoxo
-Caitlin
Boys are definitely NOT worth your time.

Well, this boy wasn't.




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 890
Reviews 22
Having just finished The Deathly Hallows myself, I really liked this fanfic. I realize you'r making a circle: Didn't the trio of the HP books met in the same way, in Hogwarts Express? I'm not saying these three will be friends too, but the narrative has a nostalgic feeling to it.
Keep up the good work!
"They are like scarecrows form a watermellon plantation. Do not fear them, for they can't do you any harm, and no good either".




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 1057
Reviews 26
This looks great! It deserves at least 4 stars.
"Speak softly and carry a big stick."

Theodore Roosevelt


"It is better to be present with ten men than absent with ten thousand."

Timur the Lame (Tamerlane)


"I know that I know nothing at all."

Aristotle




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 6040
Reviews 210
His name isn't Scorpio. It's Scorpius.

Anyway, why would Rosie be told not to talk to Scorpius? I got the impression that, while Harry and Ron would never be friends with Draco, they'd at least no longer be enemies. I think Harry especially would try to break the chain of taking-things-out-on-your-enemies'-children.

I'm curious to see where you go with this. We don't have lots of information about the next generation, so it's fun to see where people take it.
✖ I'm sick, you're tired. Let's dance.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 29
The thing is, Ron told Rosie to beat Scorpius (sorry!) in every test and such, so I figured he would basically hint that she shouldn't be friends with him...

Anyways, thanks for the comments, guys! I wrote another version of this-- it's called Ch.1: On the Hogwarts Express. Can't wait to hear more from y'all :-)

~Deoris
'"Many years ago, when I was young, I saw a fire, and what looked like death-- and beyond that, in the dark places, something...or some One, who knew me. Shall I at last find my way back to that wonderworld of Night?"'




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 6040
Reviews 210
Ah. I interpreted that as more of a "you are Hermione's daughter" than "that is Draco Malfoy's son" sort of thing, if you know what I mean. I guess that works, though.
✖ I'm sick, you're tired. Let's dance.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 690
Reviews 1
I think you guys are being a bit critical, I thought it was pretty good. Although I suppose reviews are supposed to critical so....
"The moral of Snow White is never eat apples."




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 27
Well It's pretty good. Maybe if you made more of a finish.Good for standing up for yourself. I can't weight for more!
Pajamas are the best kind of clothing.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 67
I like it. Everyone already said the things that needed doing. I would definatly keep up the good work. I think that if you just do some more work it would be awsome!
Goth-Hippie?!



Sea and Sky- both blue. Once, in proposal, Sea turned red. Sky's father- Sun forbade so she wept as rain, uniting the lovers in defiance.
— AlexWrites