Gypsie Eyes

166 posts1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7 ... 12
User avatar
Gender Female
Points 5890
Reviews 440
Chapter 5

“Miss Morn.” Karenna stopped and turned around, holding her hands behind her to hide the napkin-wrapped leftovers she had pinched from lunch. Headmaster Tavrinal approached her across the courtyard, walking with the sedate grace she had noticed before. He paused when he was a few feet away, waiting for the other students to file out of the mess hall and out of earshot before speaking. “Miss Morn,” he said again.

“Headmaster?” she replied.

“I am not one to avoid the obvious, so let me just say that your behavior last night impressed me, as did certain…reports concerning your journey here. I should like to have you officially classified as a Possible Wizard Class 3.”

Karenna felt the panic rise within her. She dropped her eyes, trying to act indifferent. “Why ask me first, then?”

“Because of your eyes,” he said bluntly.

She started, and raised her head to stare at him.

His gaze was steady. “I know it can’t have been easy for you, growing up with eyes like yours. I want you to know right now that I don’t much care how you came by them. But we both know it would be difficult for you to avoid unpleasantness if you were officially classified and began taking classes in advanced magic. I have no desire to see you suffer, Miss Morn.”

She meant to say thank you. What came out was, “Why do you care?”

He blinked. For a moment, she saw his expression waver between a smile and a frown. It remained neutral. “Despite what you may think, Miss Morn, not all men like me, not all wizards or—dare I say—humans have a desire to see every person with Gypsie eyes beheaded, hung, or enslaved.”

“I’m not a Gypsie,” she hissed, not meeting his gaze.

“I’ve already said I don’t care,” he replied coolly. “But may I take your reaction as a ‘no’ to my proposal?”

Karenna forced herself to be calm. “You may.”

“Very well, then.” With that, he turned and left. She watched him go for a long time, then shoved him from her mind and continued to where she was headed.

* * *

Boom sat happily munching leaves at the edge of the Gypsies’ Forest. Karenna hadn’t come all day, and now it was well into the afternoon. He hadn’t moved from the spot she had led him to, but the day hadn’t been boring. Boom had a very hard time getting bored. He could watch the shadows move and lengthen; he could listen to the rustle of the wind in the leaves and the distant sounds of Gypsie movement; he could smell the sweet, vibrant scent of the carpets of leaf litter that covered the ground; he could feel the activity of the tiny insect communities moving below and around him. Boom knew what the word “dull” meant, but he had never had occasion to use it.

Just as he reached for another fresh twig, there was Karenna. She looked tired and faintly annoyed, but she smiled at him all the same. “Hello, Boom.”

“Hello, Miss Morn.” He extended the leafy twig towards her. “Would you like some?”

Karenna looked at the twig. “You eat leaves?”

Boom smiled. “And bark, but leaves are better. Sometimes in winter I’ll eat the wood as well, but leaves are the best.”

"Um, why do you eat leaves at all?”

“The spell did more to me that make me grow,” he said, smiling. “I don’t eat or sleep like normal people, and I can see magic as a kind of glow.” He cocked his head, “Like the glow coming from your wand.”

She had tucked her wand in her belt beneath her tunic, and now she grabbed for it. Boom raised a massive hand dismissively. “No worries, Miss Morn.” The comfortable, un-threatening magic he pulsed with calmed her. “So, do you want some?”

Karenna gave him a weary smile and sat down next to him, setting the leaves carefully to one side. “No, thank you, Boom. I brought some leftovers, though, if you like.”

He eyed the slightly squashed contents of the napkin she held out to him. It wouldn’t have even registered in his digestive system. “That’s all right.” She shrugged and tucked the napkin away before leaning back against a nearby tree.

“I’m sorry I couldn’t get here sooner,” she said. The fading sunlight and dancing leaves above sent vibrant shadows swirling across her face. She closed her eyes and exhaled a long, frustration-laden breath. “It’s been very… tiring.”

Boom had noticed her tendency to pause before select words. He wasn’t sure if this was to draw attention to them or make sure that they were the right ones. “Tiring?”

Karenna shook her head. “It’s nothing you need to worry about, Boom. I’m just glad to have the chance to rest.”

The giant glanced in the direction of the Academe. “Won’t they wonder where you are?”

“It’s our ‘free time’ now.”

“Oh.”

They sat in silence for a long time. Not an uncomfortable silence, but the silence that comes when two people have said all that is necessary for the moment. Boom listened to the trees grow for awhile and then said, “Do you know yet?”

Karenna’s eyes were still closed and she was breathing slowly. “Know what, Boom?”

“If you’re a Gypsie or not?”

The two different-colored eyes opened very deliberately. “What?”

“I said, ‘Do you know if you’re a Gypsie yet?” Boom repeated patiently.

She stared at him for a few long moments, until Boom began to worry that he had said the wrong thing. Finally, she said, “No, Boom.”

“Oh.”

A very different sort of silence filled the space between them this time. A third voice, cheerful and from high above, broke it, “Well, you two are certainly some of the most sparkling conversationalists I’ve ever encountered.” Tannar dropped languidly into the small clearing, grinning like a cat.

* * *

Karenna rose instantly, a little unsteady on her feet. For a moment she allowed herself the luxury of a small, inward curse. She knew better than to use magic that long when she’d never tried the spell before. But she quickly turned what energy she had on the intruder. “What are you doing here?” she demanded.

To his credit, Tannar sobered quickly. “I know you snuck off last night,” he said. “I didn’t follow you because…well, I really don’t know why not. But I had the feeling you’d do the same thing today. So here I am.” With that, he sat down cross-legged on the carpet of leaves and looked up at her expectantly.

Her anger slipped away. She didn’t let it go, it wriggled out of her grasp and slid away before she could catch it again. She snorted, just for show, and then sat down heavily on the leaf litter. “What do you want with me, Tannar?” she asked, almost pleading. “Why don’t you just go find someone else to bother?”

He didn’t say anything for a long time, just looked at her in that penetrating way he had. That treacherous part of her began to purr again. Finally he broke eye contact and scratched at his bronze bands. “No reason,” he whispered.

“It’s because you’re an Elementar,” said Boom, addressing Tannar with something akin to awe.

Tannar stood quickly and backed away; Karenna stared at him. “What are you talking about?” he said, trying to sound scornful and failing.

“You’re glowing,” said Boom, still fascinated. “I can see the magic just…just pouring off you, even more than it pours from Miss Morn’s wand. And I can see your real form, too, at first I thought it was just a trick of the light.”

Now Karenna stood as well and drew her wand. She saw Tannar flinch slightly at the sight of it. That’s right, Elementars had always been afraid of a wizard with a wand; only magicians, with their power to capture and control the immortal spirits, could hurt them like a wand could. Karenna was still weary from her extended eavesdropping and knew she couldn’t put much energy behind a spell. Even if she could have she knew few attack spells. But that was all right. The virtue of a wand was that you didn’t have to say the words aloud.

She pointed the sixteen inches of magic-charged wood at him and he froze. “Is it true?” she demanded, surprised at her own calmness.

He put his hands out, palms up. “Look, Karenna, I…”

“Is it true!”

He swallowed, lowered his hands. “Yes,” he said softly. “Yes, it’s true.”

Panic gripped her, and she seemed to hear Obern and Shanna’s conversation again in her mind, she seemed to hear Shanna talking about what a threat an Elementar—or, more specifically, their magician—could be to a Gypsie in hiding. And Tavrinal, he had protested he didn’t care whether she was a Gypsie or not. What wizard wouldn’t care? “Who is your master?” Karenna’s wand hand was shaking now, but she didn’t notice. She knew what happened to solitary Gypsies the government found on their territory. “Some politician in the capitol, some bloody magician to the king, who!”

Tannar scoffed. “Yes, right, some big nob at the palace sent a member of the most powerful race in the world to track down a single, Gypsie-looking student.”

“Who!” Fear found one of the spells in Karenna’s head and shot it out the tip of the wand. A bolt of blue light hit Tannar in the chest, knocking him to the ground. Smoke rose where the blast had burned a hole through his clothes, but the skin beneath it was undamaged. He half lifted himself and looked at her. “Karenna, listen…”

“Who!” Another blast connected, even weaker than the first. The use of magic and the fear drained her like no amount of physical labor could, but she knew that even in this state two attack spells like that should have had a normal human groaning in pain. “Who sent you!” Another blast, charged with all the energy left in her and the terror of discovery connected, and this time Tannar let out a soft cry.

Tears were blurring Karenna’s vision and her hand was shaking violently. This wasn’t like with the Werewolves; she had never before used her magic to hurt anyone, only defend herself and others.

“This isn’t you,” said a voice. It took her a moment to realize it was Tannar’s. “This isn’t who you are, Karenna, this is the human-bred fear they’ve forced on you.” His eyes, dark and depthless, were looking up at her, almost pleadingly. Gently, he took the hand not holding the wand and drew her towards him. She went down on her knees by his side, still crying quietly.

Almost tenderly, he placed her hand over one of the smoldering holes in his shirt and pressed it to the skin beyond.

There was a flash of darkness, of the nearby rumbling of thunder and the pounding rhythm of a thousand raindrops. “This is my birth,” said Tannar, a mere voice in her ear now. The storm was building around her, dark, cold, and windy. She was inside the thunderhead. “This is who I am.” The clouds grew darker, the sky beyond them black and starless. Below her, far below, she could see mountains rising from the swirling sable mists.

Then suddenly there was a pain as if she were being ripped apart, and just as abruptly it stopped. She floated, motionless, only a few feet above the craggy mountainside. Rain poured down around her, soaking her through. Somewhere in the distance, she heard someone crying.

“You asked me about my master,” Tannar’s voice was barely audible over the thundering rain. The crying, more a sound of fear than sorrow, came closer, and Karenna could faintly see a shape in the gloom. The figure came closer, stumbling over every loose rock and falling with every other step. His hands gyrated wildly as if he were trying to keep his balance. Karenna could see him clearly now; he was only about twelve years old with long, streaming black hair and pale skin that almost glowed in the dark. The breath left her body. Avarn! She tried to cry out to him but no sound emerged. Avarn!

And suddenly she was back, in the Gypsies’ Forest, in her own body, in the present time. Tannar lay on his side below her, his dark eyes serious. She was breathing hard, her exhaustion forgotten in a rush of adrenaline. “What happened!” she screamed. “That was Avarn, that was my friend, what happened!”

Tannar was quiet for a moment, and when he spoke, he didn’t fully answer her question. “I…I pitied him,” he said quietly. “He had just been blinded, painfully, and I had compassion. I…joined to him. Willingly.”

Karenna stared, her panic forgotten. Never in the history of their world had an Elementar willingly submitted to a human. Magicians had to train for years until they could control even the weakest of Tannar’s race, and even then many died in their first attempt. “You’re the gull,” she whispered.

“What?” Tannar looked annoyed. “Just because I’m a being of air and water doesn’t mean you can go around name-calling.”

She smiled faintly and shook her head. “No, it’s nothing. By the three flowers, it’s been so long since I saw him…” her voice trailed off for a moment. Abruptly, she demanded, “What happened to him?”

“You remember when his mother came for him, to train him as a magician. You remember she was married, to a man not Avarn’s father.”

Karenna nodded.

“It turned out the husband was just about totally insane, with plenty of arrogance to complement it. He tried to take control of an Elementar more powerful than he anticipated. It killed him and blinded Avarn before his mother could take control. He fled, and…well, you saw.”

She closed her eyes, fighting back tears. “I should have been there,” she said despairingly.

“No offense, but what could you have done?”

Karenna glared at him sharply.

He sighed. “Look, I’m sorry, all right. But even if I’d been there I probably couldn’t have stopped it, we’re talking about a serious magical power-house of a being.”

For a moment, her face lost its accusatory look as she calculated in her head. “But, if I last saw him eight years ago and you found him when he was twelve, then you’d be only—”

“Six years old, yes, I know,” said Tannar, levering himself to a sitting position.

“Six years,” she said softly. “Why did he wait so long to send you to me?”

Tannar stared at her. “How do you know he wanted to send me?”

Again, she smiled her own, private little smile. “Something he said to me just before he left.”

The Elementar looked a little suspicious. “Well, to answer your question, he waited because if I’d left him too soon, he might have died. My joining to him gave him the strength to survive his burns and his fear, and because of the way we were joined I could act as his eyes as well. He probably could have sent me a couple of years afterwards, but I convinced him to wait until your training at the Academe was done.”

“Then why are you here now? My training isn’t done. And why wait in the first place?”

Deliberately, Tannar closed his mouth and looked at her. “That’s for him to tell you, not me.”

Tired, overwhelmed, crashing from her adrenaline rush, Karenna sank back to a cross-legged position, her hands pressed to the ground behind her for balance. It was all too much, all at once. She glanced at Tannar. “So you’re only six years old?”

“It’s not that strange,” said Boom. Karenna started—she had forgotten he was there. “Look at me,” the giant continued. “I’m thirty-five and I look like I’m eleven.”

Tannar laughed and fell back again. “I like him,” he declared, fighting his way upright once more. “He’s almost as strange as me.”

Boom chuckled, a deep, rumbling sound that shook the earth. With one hand he reached out and picked up the Elementar, bringing him close to his face. “Friends?” said the giant.

“Friends,” said Tannar, dangling between the solid fingers.

Boom grinned, revealing large white baby teeth that could probably bite through bone. He put Tannar down carefully and turned to Karenna. “Friends?” he asked, holding out one huge hand palm up. She dragged herself into a sitting position on it and he brought her to his shoulder, where she perched like a skinny, wingless parrot.

“Friends,” she whispered in his ear.

Tannar stood on the ground with his fists on his hips and looked up at her. “And is all forgiven?” he inquired.

She waved a hand in assent. “But not forgotten. I still have questions.”

He smiled a little. “But later.”

“Later.”
Last edited by gyrfalcon on Fri Oct 27, 2006 6:07 am, edited 2 times in total.
"In a sort of ghastly simplicity we remove the organ and demand the function...We laugh at honour and are shocked to find traitors in our midst. We castrate and bid the geldings be fruitful." ~C.S. Lewis




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 6517
Reviews 798
I have a bit to say on this. I'll come back and deliver the crit, when I have time.
Mah name is jiggleh. And I like to jiggle.

"Indecision and terror, thy name is novel." - Chiko




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 790
Reviews 2
Cool chapter. Again, I like Tavrinal, even though he really can't deal with other people. He's still smart.

Of course Tannar and Boom had to meet. I was waiting for that encounter.

Now we know what Tannar is, which is something of a relief.

More importantly, Karenna knows who and what Tannar is--an ally.So life is good.

You might try and toss another ball in the air here--everything seems very resovled.Your best when nobody has any idea what the heck is going on.

More posts later.
"Me fail English? That's unpossible!"
-??




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 820
Green = Comment/Correction
Indigo = Quote
Black = Review

*

“I am not one to avoid the obvious, so let me just say that your behavior last night impressed me, as did certain…reports concerning your journey here. I should like to have you officially classified as a Possible Wizard class 3.” The highest level any possible mage could be acknowledged as.


Capitalise ‘class’. For a moment I thought the last sentence was part of the speech. It seems a little out of place there.

Karenna felt the risings of panic.


I’m not sure whether it should be ‘rising’ or ‘risings’. I think ‘rising’ would fit better.

“I’m not a Gypsie,” she hissed, not meeting his gaze.


I’m always so keen to know why Karenna won’t accept that she is a Gypsie (am I right?) so there is another mystery to solve. You’re keeping me hanging off my chair!

She closed her eyes and exhaled a long, frustration-laden breath. “It’s been very…tiring.”


Use a space after using ellipses.

Boom had noticed her tendency to pause before select words. He wasn’t sure if this was to draw attention to them or make sure that they were the right ones. “Tiring?”
Karenna shook her head. “It’s nothing you need to worry about, Boom. I’m just glad to have the chance to rest.”


Separate the dialogue spoken by the two characters with spaced paragraphs.

“I said, ‘Do you know if you’re a Gypsie yet?;” Boom repeated patiently.


Take out the semi-colon there.

She stared at him for a few slightly too-long moments, until Boom began to worry that he had said the wrong thing. Finally, she said, “No, Boom.”


I’m not sure I understand what ‘too-long moments’ means.

A third voice, cheerful and from high above, broke it, “Well, you two are certainly some of the most sparkling conversationalists I’ve ever encountered.” Tannar dropped languidly into the small clearing, grinning like a cat.


You can probably imagine me grinning like mad right now. XD

“What do you want with me Tannar?” she asked, almost pleading.


I don’t know if I’m right here or not but shouldn’t there be a comma after ‘me’?

“You’re glowing,” said Boom, still fascinated. “I can see the magic just…just pouring off you, even more than it pours from Miss Morn’s wand. And I can see your real form, too, at first I thought it was just a trick of the light.”

Now Karenna stood as well and drew her wand. She saw Tannar flinch slightly at the sight of it. That’s right, Elementars had always been afraid of a wizard with a wand; only magicians, with their power to capture and control the immortal spirits, could hurt them like a wand could. Karenna was still weary from her extended eavesdropping and knew she couldn’t put much energy behind a spell. Even if she could have she knew few attack spells. But that was all right. The virtue of a wand was that you didn’t have to say the words aloud.


Wow! Now I know why you began Tannar’s introduction with: As he continued to watch her, scratching instinctively at the bronze bands around his wrists, he decided he didn’t really want to hurt her. He just wanted her to never have been born.

She knew what happened to solitary Gypsies the government found on their territory. “Some politician in the capitol, some bloody magician to the king, who!”


This should end with a question mark.

What can I say? As you progress with each chapter I’m pulled further into this world you have created.

You and I seem to have similar ideas and I love how you’ve portrayed Elementars (in my case I have the pera) and how Tannar was willing to give himself to Avarn. This shows he cares, even if he doesn’t appear to most of the time. I still think he is my favourite character, I’m drawn to creatures rather than humans and I had a feeling he wasn’t really what he was supposed to be.

I absolutely loved it when Karenna visualised the thoughts/vision inside Tannar.

There is nothing bad I can say. Like you said, I have ‘eagle eyes’ and usually spot a lot of things, in this chapter you’ve done extremely well to bring out the real Tannar.

One more thing, I beat Aero to critiquing first! XD

-- Myth
.: ₪ :.

'...'




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 5890
Reviews 440
:-) hehe...I'm so glad you guys like it! Myth, you're vonderful, dahling. Your eagle-eyed catches shall be integrated forthwith.
:-)

>added later< *sings* the catches have been integrated, the catches have been integrated! :-)
"In a sort of ghastly simplicity we remove the organ and demand the function...We laugh at honour and are shocked to find traitors in our midst. We castrate and bid the geldings be fruitful." ~C.S. Lewis




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 32885
Reviews 2058
Chapter 2:

Karenna smiled rather more warmly as the twins came and clustered around her like kittens around a mother cat.
'rather more warmly' doesn't really work. if you're going to say 'Karenna smiled more warmly' you would also have to say 'more warmly at the twins than she had at the others' or something. I think you should take out 'rather' either way.

Karenna had to fight back a mounting claustrophobia. It wasn’t right, being surrounded by all this heavy, oppressive stone; it wasn’t natural. She was enclosed, she couldn't move. Trapped, confined, she was cramped, cornered—she was trapped.
Alright, we get it! She's trapped, and has claustrophobia! I'd suggest finding a better way to give the reader the same feeling :-D Explain if it makes her shake, makes her breath quickly (or deeper than normal), is she flushed, or has chills?

I like your story, I want to know whats with the girls eyes. And Tanner seems a little strange.

But I keep getting the feeling that your story is taking a long time to start up, like this is just filler until we get to the real plot, your just explaining things. But I may be wrong, this is just what I'm getting so far.
“It's necessary to have wished for death in order to know how good it is to live.”
― Alexandre Dumas, The Count of Monte Cristo




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 8231
Reviews 214
gyrfalcon wrote:Prologue

The little gang of kids was not, as any casual observer would think, watching the storyteller.

write it this way: The small group of children...
use group, cluster or a similarly good adjective.


But all the kids, even those who had never seen, knew what the brown curtain hid.

change kids to children. It's too informal.

All the kids knew the real story; Avarn had told them often enough, and he would tell them again tonight.

change kids to children again
There were gulls there, hundreds of them, calling and screaming and fighting over a scrap of fish or a half-rotten skeleton.

change gulls to seagulls. It describes better.

This gull flew badly, for he had broken his wing only last week, and Avarn and Karenna had barely been able to set it properly.

write it like this: This gull flew badly, he had broken his wing only last week. Avarn and Karenna had...

Avarn shook his head. “No. She said she didn’t know who my father was but she was lying.”

Avar shook his head, "No. She...

She would probably be the only one in the village who wouldn't; even his adopted caretakers were slightly wary of him.

get rid of the semi colon. Make it a period.

“Yes. And she says that’s why I can talk to gulls and things, because I have an afin…an affin-i-ty for them, for water and air things.

remove water. It doesn't really fit.

“Well then,” he said, “I’ll send a gull to come and get you and bring you to me, so you can free me from her and we can stop whatever evils she’s doing together.”

put a comma after doing and before together.


That's all I have done right now. I'll crit chapter 1 today or tomorrow and get back to you as soon as possible. Nice story so far. I'm lovin it.
"wub wub wub wub. Now Zoidberg is the popular one."

"Computer... Captain's musk"




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 55
Hey, Gyr!
I haven't had time to read much so far, but I do see where you've improved it a lot. Great job!
The only thing I have to take issue with you at the moment is the first paragraph. Good idea, but when I read it, I am overwhelmed with a flood of commas!
gyrfalcon wrote: The little gang of kids was not, as any casual observer would think, watching the storyteller. Instead their eyes were focused on the thin, frail boy who sat nearest her, who would make little sounds of annoyance whenever she lied. The kids trusted him more than any adult, for he knew everything and could talk to the gulls by the river-port. His name was Avarn. He had slick black hair and vaguely effeminate features, which made the bigger boys pick on him, and disconcertingly pale blue eyes, which made them stop. No one, adult or child, strong or cowardly, could look Avarn in the eyes without feeling that to disobey him would be to disobey a king. And he was their king.

See what I mean? It was just a little... comma overload. ;)
Also, a little of the dialogue in the prologue seemed... not contrived, but as if it's there solely for the reader's benefit. Karenna (sp?) already knows that Avarn doesn't know his real parents and vice versa. It just didn't seem right. You know what I mean?
Sorry, I'm a bit foggy-headed today. Two hours of drama class will do that, I suppose...
Cheers! ~Shafter
Got YWS?

Over 18? Join The Writers Society today!
http://www.thewriterssociety.com




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 890
Reviews 85
Chapter 5 Critique

Blue Italics = Comments on Quotes
Red = Thoughts While Reading

He paused when he was a few feet away and waited for the other students to file out of the mess hall and out of earshot before speaking.


I'm not a fan of the double and :wink:

“Headmaster,” she replied.


I think this should be a question instead of a statement because he waits to speak, so the other children can file out. As well as Karenna is trying to hide the food she took. So I think she would be questioning more.

She dropped her eyes, tried to affect indifference.


I don't like the second clause of this sentence; the second part, really doesn't flow well at all. :) Perhaps write it...'She dropped her eyes, acting indifferent... (or something similar)

She meant to say thank you. What came out was, “Why do you care?”


I like this line :D

“Despite what you may think, Miss Morn, not all men like me, not all wizards or, dare I say, humans have a desire to see every person with Gypsie eyes beheaded, hung, or enslaved.”


This sentence feels comma overloaded for me. Think about changing it.

I like how the scene doesn't go how I thought it would go. I personally thought she would be oh thats so cool, at first; and then when she was kind of wary about it I figured she would agree in the end. But then she didn't! Interesting... Obviously she doesn't want to be noticed.

She hadn’t come all day


You never state who 'she' is in this paragraph. I know the reader knows who it is, but it might be just nice for you to say Karenna hadn't come all day...first. It just seems like the right thing to do.

“Hello, Miss Morn.” He extended the leafy twig towards her. “Would you like some?”


Why does he call her Miss Morn? I'm unsure if he does it like a child trying to sound proper or whether its a mistake in character. If its the first, then you need to communicate that to the reader. If its the second, then just have him call her Karenna.

Boom smiled. “And bark, but leaves are better. Sometimes in winter I’ll eat the wood as well, but leaves are the best.”


I'm curious as to why he eats leaves and bark and wood? Last I checked the guy was a human who just had a bad run-in with magic. Wouldn't he want to eat the same stuff that humans do, unless the magic changed his taste buds. Or is this just a weird quirk he developed?

I personally am thinking its a weird quirk that just makes him 'Boom'. If it is this, you need to establish how he developed this quirk possibly and why. Otherwise it seems kind of random, at least to me. Most readers probably wouldn't analyze this, but I tend to go into analyze overdrive when I critique.


Her anger slipped away. She didn’t let it go, it wriggled out of her grasp and slid away before she could catch it again.


Over imagery here. I had to read it three times before I understood that she was talking about her anger. It might just be the mood I'm in, but I don't think you need this here. It just might make the reader a bit confused. At first I was like what was she holding? A butterfly? A bug? A what? And then I realized it was her anger. Anyways just something to think about.

“It’s because you’re an Elementar,” said Boom, addressing Tannar with something akin to awe.

Tannar stood quickly and backed away; Karenna stared at him. “What are you talking about?” he said, trying to sound scornful and failing.

“You’re glowing,” said Boom, still fascinated. “I can see the magic just…just pouring off you, even more than it pours from Miss Morn’s wand. And I can see your real form, too, at first I thought it was just a trick of the light.”


Yeah...uh huh...this seemed totally fake to me when I read it. Want to know why? Again, last time I checked...Boom is human. Unless he developed some quirky things when that magic affected him. How does Boom see it and nobody else does?

She went down on her knees by his side, still crying quietly. She was so tired…


I realize that you're trying to tell us that she's tired, but basically the reader already knows that she is when you told us she used all of her energy. Having the...'She was so tired...'...ruins the emotional scene that is taking place at the moment. It takes the reader out of that realm where he is literally sucked into the book. I would get rid of it.

dark and cold and windy.


The 'and' problem again.

By the three flowers, it’s been so long since I saw him…”


I like how you have your own little saying that they say in their world.

“You’re the gull,” she whispered.


Cool, I never expected that.

He probably could have sent me a couple of years afterwards, but I convinced him to wait until your training at the Academe was done


But her training at the academe isn't done. So obviously he didn't wait. This contradicts.

I loved it! Absolutely wonderful. I could really feel their emotions and I liked the cheerful ending to this chapter. It was uplifting :D

Amazing job, once again! Hopefully my critique will help you bud!

~Aero
They haven't invented the missile that can kill an ideal.




User avatar
Gender None specified
Points 890
Reviews 145
Darling, you were supposed to let me know when you updated! Now I have about a bazillion chapters to crit! I just finished reading them all, and I must say that I'm quite impressed. I'll get down to the nitty-gritty when I have time again, but I promise you a critique soon.

Keep writing! :)
"A poet in love is best encouraged in both capacities or neither." ~ Jane Austen, Emma.




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 32885
Reviews 2058
Chapter 3: (Hopefully more to go into the master copy!)

With Tannar, at least she could have commiserated, albeit silently, about the tediousness, but the Vocilias listened with rapt faces and Menee was practically mouthing the words with the teacher.
With tanner she could as least have commiserated (could you find an easier word to use? No point in using big words if you can use smaller ones) , albeit silently, about the....

(the above is from the first part...I have to go do some things, I'll finish up when I get the chance.)
“It's necessary to have wished for death in order to know how good it is to live.”
― Alexandre Dumas, The Count of Monte Cristo




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 5890
Reviews 440
Claudette: your suggestions for Karenna's claustrophobia attack were wonderful!!! I went back and changed it--hope it's better, that scene's been bugging me for awhile
Aero: darling, what would I do without you? ;-) Thanks so much.

Thanks again to everyone! I am actually in the process of finishing up chapter six (I've written several, SEVERAL chapters beyond chapter six, but I needed to interject a new chapter so six will be mostly first draft stuff)

Shafter, darling, you are so right about the prologue. I shall give it a more thourough look-through soon.

*gives cake to everyone!*
"In a sort of ghastly simplicity we remove the organ and demand the function...We laugh at honour and are shocked to find traitors in our midst. We castrate and bid the geldings be fruitful." ~C.S. Lewis




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 8231
Reviews 214
Here's my crit for chapter 1:

For a moment, he considered the hailstone again. "Tanner."

should be a comma after again.

same here:
She averted her gaze."I know...

comma after gaze

Other than the stuff mentioned, it was wonderful. You, Gyr, are probably one of the best writers I've ever seen. Next, I'll do chapter 2.
"wub wub wub wub. Now Zoidberg is the popular one."

"Computer... Captain's musk"




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 5890
Reviews 440
oy! Pros, you and Shafter keep giving me conflicting advice on the "comma before a quotation mark" thing! ;) Oh well, I'm sure it'll work out. Thanks so much, darling, I'm blushing! Chapter Six to come soon.
"In a sort of ghastly simplicity we remove the organ and demand the function...We laugh at honour and are shocked to find traitors in our midst. We castrate and bid the geldings be fruitful." ~C.S. Lewis




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 5890
Reviews 440
Chapter 6

The next day, near the end of their class with Jataal, the battle mage asked Tannar to stay after the hour was up. The Elemental waited suspiciously while his fellows left the armory, talking amongst themselves. Karenna shot him a look, half of caution, half of pity. He grinned wryly at her, pretending a confidence he didn’t fully feel. She was the last to leave the classroom, and Tannar turned to face the teacher once they were alone. “Well,” he said bluntly, “what do you want?”

Jataal tossed Tannar the broadsword he had used the other day; he caught it instinctively. “On guard,” said the battle mage, and tugged a similar weapon free from its display sheath.

Tannar didn’t move, holding the sword to his side. “What do you want?” he repeated, shifting his weight.

Jataal didn’t answer; he attacked, bringing his sword around in a simple thrust. Tannar blocked it without thinking. “Good form,” commented the teacher. “Excellent reaction time. Where did you learn to fight like this?”

“What business is it of yours?” Tannar demanded, frowning slightly. He shoved Jataal’s blade away with his own and attacked in a graceful swipe that should have caught the old man lightly on the shoulder. The battle mage laughed and moved his body fractionally so that the sword split the air mere inches from his skin.

“But not perfect, for all your style,” said Jataal, still jovial. His next attack was no beginner’s move; Tannar had to scramble to counter it.

“Won’t someone complain if you slice up the students?” Tannar said, grinning in spite of himself.

“So don’t let me slice you up.” Again, the sword moved faster than Tannar had expected; he was just barely able to block it. He smiled and, knowing it was stupid, abandoned the human-leveled pretense. If his opponent was going to fight on a higher level than most mortals, well then so was he.

The next few moments were pure joy. Tannar had been born with the strength, speed, and instincts to defeat any Normal opponent, but he had never truly been trained, instead learning what he could from the books in the vast libraries that filled Avarn’s home. Jataal, for all his mortality, was better than he, and the thrill of a challenge overcame all concepts of common sense.

Suddenly, Jataal stopped and leaned against the wall, breathing hard and putting a hand up. Tannar halted his attack mid-swing. “What’s wrong?”

Jataal smiled. “Fifty-three years, that’s what’s wrong. Not as young as I used to be. By Werenna you’re a talented thing.”

And the common sense Tannar had abandoned came crashing in too late to do him any good. “Not as talented as you,” he tried anyway, knowing how hopeless it was.

The battle mage laughed, wheezing slightly with fatigue. “Not as educated, yes. Not as talented, well, I don’t know about that.” He straightened and looked Tannar in the eyes. “I want to start training you, kid. Personally. You’re better than any Possible Battle Mage here, and the first student to come along in years who’s worth my time.”

For a moment Tannar ached to accept. “I can’t,” he said.

“Why not? The government would love someone like you; they’d pay you whatever you’d ask—”

“I just can’t,” snapped Tannar. “It’s…complicated.”

“Ah…” said Jataal. He replaced his sword and took a seat on one of the few wooden chairs scattered about. “It’s complicated, is it? So complicated you’d throw away a job many people would kill for?”

“A job that many people would get killed for,” returned Tannar.

Jataal smiled, and this time the expression was knowing. “It’s not the violence you have a problem with, my boy.”

“Well then,” said Tannar, annoyed again. “Pray tell what it is then.”

“There, there now. I’m no Gypsie fate, I can’t tell the future or what’s in a man’s heart. I’m a battle mage. I tell what’s in a man’s attack stance, his strategy, his tactics. And your tactics are all evasive.”

Tannar snorted. “I’ve heard enough. I said no and that’s that.” He turned his back and started to leave.

“It doesn’t have to be official.”

Slowly, Tannar revolved until he faced Jataal again, a barely controlled eagerness burning in his eyes. “How’s that?”

“If it’s complicated, then maybe it’s complicated,” Jataal said. “Then maybe I don’t get the credit for training one of the best natural-born warriors to come along in fifty years. But maybe I get the satisfaction of seeing him get better, maybe I get the satisfaction of being the only one who can say ‘I beat him once.’ And maybe that’s good enough for me.”

“Maybe I don’t want to risk it.”

Jataal shrugged. “It’s up to you. The offer stands, however long it takes.”

For a moment, far too long of a moment, Tannar hesitated. And when he finally spoke it wasn’t “Forget it” or “I’ve had enough.” It was, “I’ll think about it.”

“You do that.”

* * *

Karenna walked the twins to the door of their first healing-magic class and waited with them while they worked up the courage to go inside. “It’s not like they’ll make you actually use any of the spells today, not for months as I understand it,” she said as they all but cowered behind her.

“We know,” replied one of them, probably Menee.

“Then what’s the problem?”

“Um,” said the other, Laroo. “The teacher knows our father.”

“So?”

They gulped in unison. “Well, you see,” Laroo explained hesitantly. “The fact that we didn’t turn out as battle mages was…frankly a disappointment to our father. But our mother’s a healer, and she convinced him that healers can do just as much important stuff as battle mages.”

“So now,” Menee picked up the account, “he’s rather…convinced that we’re going to be fantastic healers. The words ‘Class 1’ don’t register with him.”

“And he’s told this teacher to give him regular reports on what he calls ‘our progress.’”

“Which we will consider very good if we manage not to kill the first animal we try the spells out on,” finished Menee.

Karenna sighed. “I see. Well, I have class, too, boys, I’m afraid I can’t hold your hands all the way.”

“We know,” said Menee.

“Thanks anyway,” said Laroo.

She shoved each of them gently into the class room and waved before continuing on to her own class. They stood there for a moment, then moved tentatively to two seats in the far back corner. The door at the front of the room opened violently and a tall, sallow, red-haired man strode in, his dark teacher’s robes fluttering. Again, the twins gulped.

“I am Professor Nebonava,” he announced, glaring around with large, washed-out brown eyes. “And I understand that I have two members of the famous Vocilia family in my class.”

This time, the twins groaned.

* * *

Shanna’s hand shot up for perhaps the hundredth time that period, and Karenna sighed as the teacher beamed and called on her. Not as though Karenna herself wanted the attention, she was still jittery and tired from the magical exhaustion of the day before. But she knew the answers as well as the young aristocrat did, and not being able to show her up rankled. “There are five types of human mages,” said Shanna primly. “Wizards—general magic uses, magicians—who bind Elementals, fordges—makers of magic items, battle mages—the warriors, and healers, who are also called menders.”

“Very good,” said the teacher, a thin woman with straight black hair. “Now, would anyone care to name more of the specific talents of each mage?”

The blonde girl’s hand rose again, but she didn’t wait for permission before she spoke, “Miss Illitta, why are we bothering with this? All of us know the answers already.”

Several heads nodded surreptitiously, and there were various murmurs of agreement.

Illitta flashed a look at Shanna. “Not everyone has your privileged upbringing, Miss Liam, or your magical talent.” Her gaze flicked around the room quickly before coming to rest on Karenna. “Miss Morn, for instance,” she said, “can you tell us the specific talents of a type of human mage?”

Karenna felt her cheeks flush, and this time there were suppressed chuckles from around the room. She knew the information, but she had been foolish with her knowledge before and the ordeal of Tannar’s revelations yesterday had made her wary. But because Avarn was on her mind, and she didn’t want to appear stupid whatever the consequences, she said, “Magicians control Elementars, right? The two are bound together, and whatever one feels, so does the other.”

“Very good,” said Illitta, a thin-lipped smile twisting her mouth. “Can anyone tell me how many Elementars one magician can control at a time?”

“The most recorded is four,” said Shanna without bothering to even raise her hand. “But that has only happened in rare cases. Most average magicians can only manage one or two, perhaps three if they’re very talented. Of course, most die trying to gain control of their first. And even if they don’t, they feel whatever pain their slave goes through in the process.”

“Shouldn’t they?” said Karenna quietly. “The magicians do steal their freedom.”

Shanna scoffed. “It’s not as if they’re human that you have to worry so.”

Karenna bit back a retort. She lowered her head and said demurely, but with a trace of venom, “Whatever you say, of course.”

She heard Shanna open her mouth for an angry comeback, but the teacher interrupted. “Girls, girls,” she said, waving her hands for peace, “debate is not the object of this class.”

“But truth is,” said Karenna softly. “Or it should be.”

“What was that, Miss Morn?” snapped Illitta.

“Nothing, ma’am.”

Miss Illitta went back to her lecture. Shanna, who sat in the front row, waited until the teacher’s attention was elsewhere then twisted in her seat to throw a glance back at Karenna. She smiled sweetly, and didn’t meet the aristocrat’s eyes.

* * *

Tannar sat amongst the constant bustle and noise of the mess hall, picking at the food before him and thinking. “And he made us stand up in front of the whole class and introduce ourselves,” Laroo wailed.

“And he said, ‘I only hope the rest of you can measure up to the natural talent of these Vocilias,’” Menee added, pitching his voice to imitate the offending teacher.

The late afternoon sun that filtered through the high slitted windows darkened with the gathering storm-clouds. Still the twins talked, babbling about their simple anxieties and temporary problems. A peal of thunder ripped through the noise of the dinner chaos, and for a moment there was silence.

Karenna glanced from the ever-thickening clouds outside to Tannar. He didn’t look at her. Another thunderclap, louder than the first, resounded, again silencing the hundred conversations that buzzed through the large room. “Tannar,” said Karenna softly.

“Frustration,” he muttered. “Let me get it out in a thunderstorm or it’ll come out in a hurricane.”

There was the noise of a million raindrops slamming into stone. Several of the students jumped, and those sitting near the windows shuffled away from the pervasive rain that clawed its way through the glass-less slits. “Tannar,” said Karenna again.

But Tannar wasn’t listening. Jataal’s offer tore at him; he wanted so badly to accept. To learn from a real warrior, to train under a master battle mage such as he: it was a dream he had never dared have. Then why don’t you?

Tannar started, another thunderclap manifesting his surprise. Avarn?

Why not let him train you, my friend? The magician’s voice was faint and very distant, but achingly familiar. If this will make you happy, I trust you. For a few perfect seconds Avarn’s heartbeat filled his mind, soothing the ever-present pain of the distance that separated them. Then it faded to silence and with it the clamor of the storm died and the constant pounding of rain-drops became the pitter-patter of isolated showers.

Karenna put a hand on his arm and he started again. “What’s wrong?” she said.

He realized that he was breathing hard, and for an instant he felt his eyes glow blue. Then he was back in control. “Nothing,” he said, standing and carrying his tray of untouched food to the waste bins. He strode out into the fading afternoon light and stopped. The buildings around him were drenched, every slab of stone dark with moisture. Tannar inhaled the clear, alive scent of after-rain air. He glanced up at the dissipating storm-clouds, smiled, and saluted them before swaggering off.

* * *

Jataal was sitting alone in the corner of the armor, watching the quickly-dissipating storm-clouds, when the door behind him slammed open. He turned and caught the hilt of the broadsword that Tannar flung at him. The boy held the same sword Jataal had tossed to him that morning.

Tannar grinned impishly. “On guard.”
Last edited by gyrfalcon on Thu Nov 16, 2006 7:19 am, edited 3 times in total.
"In a sort of ghastly simplicity we remove the organ and demand the function...We laugh at honour and are shocked to find traitors in our midst. We castrate and bid the geldings be fruitful." ~C.S. Lewis



/I think, today,/ he thought back, /the important fact is that I don't/ need /to be better than him. He can just be a person. And I... I can just be one too./
— Adolin (Wind and Truth by Brandon Sanderson)