Gypsie Eyes

166 posts1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 ... 12
User avatar
Gender Female
Points 5890
Reviews 440
The bloody speech is not, in fact, over, but I couldn't wait anymore! Myth and Aero, your catches have been integrated (though I left some of the things you mentioned b/c of style/stubbornness ;-))
So, here goes, Chapter 4 at last!
"In a sort of ghastly simplicity we remove the organ and demand the function...We laugh at honour and are shocked to find traitors in our midst. We castrate and bid the geldings be fruitful." ~C.S. Lewis




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 5890
Reviews 440
Chapter 4

Headmaster Tavrinal sat bent over a few sheets of parchment, his quill pen scratching as he wrote. The candle set beside him dripped wax onto the oak desktop and the flame spluttered lower and lower. Finally he returned the pen to the inkwell and set aside the pile of papers. Massaging his neck, he glanced into the mirror that perched on the corner of his desk. There was only a hint of gray leaking into his long brown hair, and the wrinkles around his eyes were mostly shallow. Not too bad for a younger wizard.

Ashter Tavrinal had managed to become headmaster by one simple technique: he knew exactly when not to use magic. Too much spell-muttering tended to make those who administered the school a little nervous. While not a training center for mages, it was traditional that the Academe should always have a wizard as headmaster. And so the Normals, who really ran things, had been glad to find one without too many wrinkles who also had a tendency to keep his powers to himself. Ashter was, of course, proud of his wrinkles; they were a badge of honor, the price that magic demanded of those wizards who used it. But still, it was nice that he looked like he belonged to the same generation he was born in. He knew forty-year-olds who could pass for eighty.

As he brought the candle to his lips to blow it out, he felt a slight shiver run down his spine. He had learned to trust that shiver. Hastily turning the breath that would have ended the flame into a short spell to hide its light from all but he, Ashter Tavrinal rose and left his study.

The spring night was warm and comfortable, and the moon overhead cast a wan light that painted the Academe in silken shadows. The campus was huge, even after years as its headmaster, Tavrinal was still constantly amazed by its size. The buildings were all at least two stories high, taller in some places, made from blocks of reddish sandstone. The three buildings in the middle of the property were the tallest, five stories, and housed the main classrooms. In the grassy fields closest to the Gypsies' Forest the students practiced archery and horsemanship, in the main courtyard outside the mess hall they gathered to hear the speeches and exchange a few brief moments as simply children. Ashter had been to the palace, and he knew that his institution rivaled even it in size and sheer impressiveness. He glanced up at the full moon overhead, then around him for the origin of his telling shiver.

All mages could see better by moonlight than Normals, and so Ashter had no trouble spotting the source of his magical premonition. A huge, human-shaped form was lurking at the edge of the Academe’s borders. At least, it was trying to lurk, and not doing a very good job of it due to the fact that it was hopping nervously from foot to foot, sending little tremors through the ground.

Ashter approached it warily. As the candle illuminated its face, he saw that it was a boy, not much older than eleven. He stood no shorter than twelve feet tall with shoulders broader than a normal man’s arm-span, but there was no mistaking the child-like quality of that large, round face. His bright, innocent blue eyes were red-rimmed, as if he had been crying. Despite the headmaster’s spell, the boy could apparently see the light clearly. Tavrinal barely needed to suppress the desire to run—all of his instincts told him this child was no threat.

“I’m sca-sca-scared of the dark,” whispered the child. His voice was a boy’s voice, true, but so deep that you felt it could rattle stone.

The headmaster took a hesitant step forward. “What’s your name son?”

“I don’t gotta name. They call me Boom cause they say my voice is like thunder.”

To Ashter’s unease the boy started to cry softly. This was well outside his area of experience. He patted the child awkwardly on one huge forearm. “There, there,” was the best he could manage. In spite of his massiveness, the boy seemed harmless and not a little silly.

Boom brought one head-sized fist into the light and opened it. Two broken halves of an arrow lay there. “I just wan-wanted to give this back,” he said, wiping his nose and managing to stop weeping.

Instantly, Ashter’s fiercely retentive memory came to his aid. Unit Thirty-two had been out on the shooting range this afternoon. He quickly brought up a mental register of names and faces…and smiled. “Just wait here,” he said, patting the boy again. “Don’t move.”

“Can I keep the candle?”

The headmaster placed the remains of the candle carefully on the open hand and dashed away with as much dignity as a dashing wizard could manage.

He knocked softly on the door to her dormitory, praying she would be awake. She opened the door for him, and he saw that she was already dressed. So she had felt something.

She stiffened when she saw him. “What is it, headmaster?”

“I need your help, Miss Morn,” he said. “Please come with me.”

Karenna came. She didn’t ask questions and didn’t hesitate. She started when she saw Boom standing in the moon-lit shadows, but Ashter saw her calm as he had, the magic inside her connecting with the calm, steady, undamaging magic that pulsed ever-so-gently from the child-giant.

“Boom,” he said softly, “this is Karenna Morn. Miss Morn, this is Boom.”

The child-giant waved one hand sheepishly. The candle had burned down in his other hand, leaving a small pool of molten wax. “Who are you?” she asked, approaching Boom cautiously. “I thought giants were just a fairy tale.”

“They are,” Boom rumbled gently. “When I was little, I accidentally stepped between two wizards who were fighting. The spells made me grow, my clothes too, and now no one wants me.” Ashter had heard of accidents like this before, but never in his memory had the consequences been so extreme.

Karenna took his wax-free hand in both her slim ones. She was taller than Ashter; her head came to about the middle of Boom’s torso. “How old are you?” she asked.

“I was eleven when I grew,” he said. “That was…” he lapsed into silence as he thought, “twenty-four years ago.”

“You’re thirty-five years old?”

Boom shrugged. “A doctor, a Normal doctor, not a Healer, said my brain and my body won’t grow anymore. He said I’m stuck at eleven, but I know more things than most kids do. I know about…” he paused again, and Karenna could have sworn he blushed, “about where babies come from, and I know about Gypsies and Werebeasts, and about Werenna and Scharon. I know how to live on my own and take care of myself.” He hung his head sheepishly. “I’m not stupid.”

Karenna stepped closer to him and examined the waxy hand. She began to chip the hardened puddle away, being careful not to scratch him. “No,” she said quietly. “No, you’re not stupid, Boom. You’re just very different, and sometimes humans have trouble dealing with people who aren’t like them. They can be…very cruel.”

Ashter Tavrinal nodded quietly to himself. Every mage, however powerful or accepted, experienced that kind of prejudice at one point or another. And he didn’t even want to imagine what Karenna had had to live with because of her eyes.

Boom sniffed. “You’re not cruel.”

Karenna smiled. “Thank you, Boom.”

The headmaster stepped forward and laid a hand on her shoulder. “Can you handle this?” he asked, knowing the answer.

She nodded, and he left silently.

* * *

Karenna watched Headmaster Tavrinal go. She wondered, for a moment, why he had chosen her. Because he knows, said a traitorous little voice inside her. He knows what you won’t even admit to yourself.

“Are you alright?” asked Boom.

“I’m fine,” she said automatically.

“Can I pick you up?”

“What?”

He scooped her up gently in one massive hand. She managed not to cry out as her feet left the ground and her legs dangled over the edge of his palm. Boom lifted her until they could see each other face to face. “All right,” she said breathlessly.

Boom smiled. “You’re pretty. You have nice eyes.”

“Not many people think so.”

“Are you a Gypsie?”

Karenna shifted her position on the wide hand. Finally she said, “I don’t know.” It was probably the most honest answer she had ever given that question.

Boom cocked his head to one side. “You look like a Gypsie, tall and coppery-skinned. How come you don’t know?”

“Because I don’t,” she snapped.

Boom winced and put her down quickly. Karenna took a deep breath. “I’m sorry, Boom; I’m not mad at you.”

“I like Gypsies,” he said, almost as an apology. “They think I’m kinda funny and harmless and let their kids play with me ‘cause their magic doesn’t hurt me. No playing anymore, though. Not since I dropped one.”

“You dropped one of their children!” asked Karenna, surprised at her concern for this Gypsie child she had never met.

“I didn’t mean to,” exclaimed Boom, looking ashamed and guilty. “He bit my hand really hard. I didn’t mean to.”

“Was he hurt?” she said, trying not to smile. He just looked so very comical, standing there, huge and unthreatening, nearly crying like the little boy he was.

Boom hiccupped. “No, only bruised a bit.”

Karenna sighed a little in relief, but she was becoming rapidly aware that someone was going to hear him. She took the still wax-marked hand and tugged him towards the deeper darkness of the Gypsies' Forest. “Come on, Boom,” she whispered frantically, “we can’t have anyone finding you here.”

Boom came obediently, like an elephant following a fox. She closed her eyes when they first entered among the forbidding trees, praying silently that the Gypsies either wouldn’t see them or wouldn’t care. They went a few yards into the Forest and then Karenna stopped. She looked around nervously at the unfathomable shadows around her. “Will you be all right in here for tonight?”

He nodded. “I live in here. Will you come and visit me tomorrow?”

“I’ll try.” She smiled at him and turned to leave.

Boom put one hand on her shoulder. “Thank you,” he said, and for a moment there was a hint of more than eleven-year-old maturity in his voice and manner.

She pressed her cheek to the hand. “Goodnight, Boom.” And as she stole away back to her own bunk, the forest didn’t seem quite so frightening.

* * *

Tannar heard her open and shut the door quietly as she snuck back into the dormitories. He had wanted to follow her, had known he should, but he hadn’t. He would follow her tomorrow, he decided.

He sighed and rolled over, pressing his face to his pillow. Oddly enough, the thing he was glad about was not that she had returned safely from whatever errand she had been on—it was the knowledge that Obern had not gone on that errand with her. Still puzzling about why this made him happy, he closed his eyes and rolled over, bracing himself for another long, boring, sleepless night.

* * *

Vishna turned her head at the sound of footsteps. Avarn entered her study, walking slowly with his hands held out so as not to collide with the haphazard piles of books. “What is it?” she snapped. “I’m busy.”

“You’re always busy, mother,” said Avarn, that infuriating little smile on his lips.
Vishna scowled, but only because she knew he couldn’t see her. “Where’s your little pet? Off playing with the clouds again?”

Avarn’s smile vanished. “Tannar is…running an errand for me,” he said, his blank blue eyes glaring at her.

Against her will, she squirmed in his stare. She hadn’t been able to look him in the eye once in the past six years. “Why you allow him such freedom I’ll never know,” she said. “Their kind need to be kept on a short lead, you of all people should know that.” She didn’t regret the words, exactly, but as Avarn’s long, thin fingers lightly caressed the old burn scars that formed a mast-like pattern on his face, she felt a pang of guilt. Vishna knew the scars still pained him; she herself had dozens all over her body. “I’m sorry…” she said, for once truly meaning it.

Avarn exhaled softly. “Meensha sent me to say dinner’s ready.” He turned away from her and began to navigate his way back to the door.

Vishna reached out a hand to grab his arm, and stopped. “Avarn,” she said, but he was gone.

* * *

Karenna watched from the other end of the mess hall as Obern and Shanna talked together animatedly. The twins sat next to her, discussing their classes. She did not touch the bland meat and bread in front of her, nor did she hear the conversation of the two young boys next to her. Her variegated eyes were fixed upon her unit-mates, and they flashed as Shanna laughed at something the handsome young man said and laid a hand casually on his shoulder.

Before her better judgment could stop her, she closed her eyes and whispered a few short words in Elemental. It was a spell she hadn’t tried before, but it worked as it should. Every word of Shanna and Obern’s conversation became clear and almost sharp in her ears, while the ambient noise around her faded away.

“..and with those eyes,” Shanna was saying, almost playfully.

“I don’t know,” said Obern. “I don’t think they’d let her in if she really was a Gypsie; Tavrinal’s not some idiot Class 1 wizard to be fooled by a kid.”

I’m older than you are, she thought angrily, but kept her irritation in check. In truth she was seventeen, a year older than the required age. Her parents had lied to try to keep her away from this place, from all these people who would judge her as these two were doing.

“Tavrinal may be powerful,” Shanna said, as if she doubted the fact, “but you just have to look at his face to see that he’s barely touched a spell-book since he was appointed headmaster—he gets by on reputation. And if she really is a Gypsie, kid or not, she should be strong enough to pull the wool over the eyes of a lazy old wizard like that.”

Again, Karenna had to restrain the desire to let her anger loose. But she was glad she’d decided to eavesdrop; this conversation could affect her safety.

“Well, if Tavrinal couldn’t see through her, what could? An Elementar?” Obern’s tone was a half disapproving, half mocking. “Anyway, she hasn’t even shown enough magical potential to rate even a Possible Wizard Class 1, and you’re a Class 2 yourself.”

If Shanna was pleased by the roundabout compliment she didn’t show it; she almost seemed not to have heard him. “You weren’t there when those Werewolves attacked our caravan. She’s a mage all right, but whether a decent human wizard or one of those Gypsie soothsayers I don’t know. And you should have seen the weather that sprang up; it was almost like those stories about the air-water Elementars and the storms they could conjure on cue.”

“So now we’re back on Elementars,” sighed Obern, and while Karenna couldn’t see them in her auditory-enhanced state, she knew he had flung an arm around Shanna’s narrow shoulders and embraced her carelessly. “Make up your mind, Shan, either she’s a Gypsie-born soothsayer out to infiltrate the Dirantyr military or she’s an abnormally powerful magician with weird eyes who’s managed to gain control of an Elementar before she’s even of age.”

“I never said she was a magician,” Shanna retorted.

Before Karenna could hear more of their conversation, Tannar’s voice broke her out of the spell, “This seat taken?”

She started and stared up at him, the world around her seeming all-too loud after her focused eavesdropping. He grinned that not-quite-human grin of his, balancing his lunch tray effortlessly on one hand. She moved over to make room for him, her senses slowly coming back into clarity. But she continued to glare at the table across the mess hall from hers, and she felt her body’s weariness as the price of her magic.
Last edited by gyrfalcon on Wed Oct 25, 2006 9:48 pm, edited 4 times in total.
"In a sort of ghastly simplicity we remove the organ and demand the function...We laugh at honour and are shocked to find traitors in our midst. We castrate and bid the geldings be fruitful." ~C.S. Lewis




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 890
Reviews 85
Hey Gyr!

Well I've really been looking forward to this chapter, I liked it a lot! But anyways here is my critique!

Blue Italics= comments on quotes

Red= thoughts while I'm reading

Chapter 4 Critique

First of all I liked the whole 'knowing when not to use magic' for Tavrinal. That was unique and something original.

Something I think would be cool would be if you described Tavrinal's office more. I mean he is the headmaster, it must be unique in some way.


Ashter was, of course, proud of his wrinkles; they were a badge of honor, the price that magic demanded of those wizards who used it. / she felt her body’s weariness as the price of her magic.


Interesting...how magic in your world causes stuff to happen to their bodies.

The spring night was warm and comfortable, and the moon overhead cast a wan light that painted the Academe in silken shadows.


Okay, well I've noticed that you haven't mentioned a whole lot of description of the outer lying grounds of the acadame. At first I figured you would be giving more info later, but now that we're in chapter 4 I think you should do a little more describing. That way we have a better picture of the environment we're in. All I know at the moment is that the acadame is a bunch of terracotta buildings with a courtyard and a gypsie forest. I know the Gypsie Forest is mysterious, but other than that I really don't have a good image of things. I find myself actually substituting in environments from Harry Potter and this is very bad because your story needs to be very original, but in order for people to separate the world from similar stories (Not that your story isn't original, but there are a lot of stories about wizards, magic, etc...) you need to describe the world more. The environment of your story is vital to the reader's vision.

I know infodumps are usually bad in stories, but you haven't given enough description throughout for me to really get a good picture of the outerlying grounds. Maybe give some more description here since its a good opportunity.


Okay, as I'm reading the portion where the headmaster comes upon 'Boom' you give me little insights to how he feels about the giant boy, with the words...hesitant, and he approached warily...but i'm still not really quite sure how he feels about the situation. I'm getting mixed emotions that he is calm/apprehensive and I'm not sure what to think... This may just be because I'm tired at the moment, but anyways, I think his dialogue is giving me the calm image and your description is trying to bring forth nervousness.

he was supposed to get children who were old enough to have passed this stage.


I understand the image you're trying to give us here, but I don't think this sentence fits in because Boom is not one of the students.

He quickly brought up a mental register of names and faces…and smiled. “Just wait here,” he said, patting the boy again. “Don’t move.”


Two things about this quote! First I like the mental register, that is very cool and original :) Second, I don't like how he immediately goes and gets Karenna, its very sudden and kind of caught me offguard completely. I was like what? I understood more as I read on, but I dunno maybe look it over see if you can make it seem not so sudden. Maybe he ponders or something? Anyways, there is nothing really wrong with it, I just felt it was sudden.

She was already awake when he opened the door to her dormitory room. Awake and dressed. He smiled again.


Yeah, okay, is this guy a pervert or something? He's just opening the girls' dormitory door?

“I need your help, Miss Morn,” he said. “And I know that you’ve felt something, too. Come with me.”


I don't like this dialogue at all, it seemed very choppy and awkward to me. Reword it somehow. Also I don't like how he just reveals that he knows that she has felt something. Maybe have Karenna reveal that she felt something when she actually starts talking to Boom. How you reveal it here feels totally random and doesn't fit the context for me.

Karenna came. She didn’t ask questions and didn’t hesitate. She would make a good wizard someday. She did start a bit when she saw Boom looming at the edge of the Academe, but he could forgive her for that.
'

Okay, the thing I have a problem with here is that you start three sentences in a row with the same word...She! Reword them so that doesn't happen.

“Who are you?” she asked, approaching Boom without flinching. “I thought giants were just a fairy tale.”


In these two sentences you tell us two things. You tell us that Karenna is very brave in the face of danger and also that giants are complete fairy tales. They seem to contradict each other, if giants are only things of fairy tales, why isn't she a little scared? a little nervous? Do you seem my point? I don't care if you're some guy that has seen a billion things. If something totally out of the ordinary, alien, appears wouldn't you be a little nervous? Heck if I saw a giant, I wouldn't say "I thought giants were only things of fairy tales." I would be more like..."Uhhhh..."

Now I understand if its her personality, but I think she should at least be a little nervous? You need to play a little along the lines of natural human tendencies or it seems completely fake.


Karenna stepped closer to him and examined the waxy hand. She began to chip the hardened puddle away, being careful not to scratch him. “No,” she said quietly. “No, you’re not stupid, Boom. You’re just very different, and sometimes humans have trouble dealing with people who aren’t like them. They can be…very cruel.”


I like this paragraph, it reveals a lot about karenna :o

“You dropped one of their children!” asked Karenna, with a horror that surprised her.


Umm yeah, with a horror that surprised her? lol, that sounds funny. I would just say asked Karenna in horror.

“I didn’t mean to,” sobbed Boom, and he was sobbing now, long, deep rolls of sorrow.


First, you say sob twice here. Second, I don't like the whole sobbed Boom, and he was sobbing now (sounds funny). Third long, deep, rolls of sorrow? Rolls of sorrow? Yeah I don't thinkt hat works, sorrow is an emotion, not something that rolls. You're putting a visual description with an emotion and it sounds awkward (for me anyways).

“Was he hurt?” she demanded.


You're using demanded here, and it doesn't fit what just happened. You just said she asked horrified and now you're saying she demanded. I would think she would barely dare to ask not demanded, especially if she's horrified.

Boom hiccupped loudly before continuing his drawn-out blubbering. “No, only bruised a bit.”


Maybe have Karenna sigh in relief instead of just jumping into how she knew someone was going to hear him if they stayed there, right after you say this.

like an elephant following a fox


Interesting image...

She pressed her cheek to the hand, solid as a fortress wall. “Goodnight, Boom.” And as she stole away back to her own bunk, the forest didn’t seem quite so frightening.


I don't think 'solid as a fortress wall' fits here because I'm getting more of an emotional setting and then you add in this imagery that ruins the tender emotion in my opinion.

Also another thing, you mention how the forest didn't seem quiet so frightening. But before now you have barely mentioned that she is frightened of the forest. If you're going to add in that little end piece, you need to convey that she is frightened of the forest a lot better!

Still puzzling about why this made him happy, he closed his eyes and pretended to be asleep.


Why did he pretend to be asleep? She goes into the girls' dormitory and he's in the boys' dormitory. He doesn't need to pretend to be asleep.

Their kind need to be kept on a short lead


I think you should change lead to leash.

Instantly, she regretted the words.


Why did she regret her words? Because he was touching his scars? Does Tannar have to do with the scars? Sorry, the reason I ask a lot of questions in my critiques is because I want to make sure you're asking yourself these questions when you add in something to the story. I'm not sure why she regretted her words so I wasn't sure if you really knew. But yeah just make sure you always ask yourself these questions as long as you know, then I'm happy wondering...for now.

I don't like how Meeshna and Vishna both end in the 'shna', I would change one of the names so they don't seem so similar.

The twins sat next to her, discussing their first drill practice


Whats a drill practice? You don't tell the reader what this is so you leave us at a blank of what to imagine.

I liked the conversation she eavesdropped on. That was a cool effect and brought some more knowledge of what people are thinking about her.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Overall it was very good, and I liked it a lot! I love to read your writing, its all very imaginative and makes me want to read more. As usual you portrayed your characters beautifully. Hopefully this critique helps you. Keep up the amazing work!

~Aero
They haven't invented the missile that can kill an ideal.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 93
I've only read the first chapter, because I don't have time to read the rest (but I do want to, and will get to it! Don't worry!) and so far, so good! It's slightly boring at the beginning but then again, what great books aren't? It got better though, and I was quite sad when I had to unglue my eyes from the computer screen to clean the dishes =[. I hope you keep writing this and have fun doing it! You'll be sure to see me back here! ...if I can find this thread again, that is >.>;
"Admitting that you don't like reading is admitting that you don't have an imagination." -- Broken Wings




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 36
*impish Duranni grin*
Boom knows where babies come from...!

Thank you, thank you, THANK YOU for telling us what happened to the child he dropped! But why should Karenna be surprised to be horrified?
And I agree with Aero, about the fortress wall bit...yeah, it's a wall, all right, one that we come up against rather sharply in the middle of this soft little scene...yes, and have Master T. at least knock. That's all I have for today. *curls up on kitty blanket*
True friends stab you in the FRONT. (Oscar Wilde)




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 5890
Reviews 440
sorry, Karenna's surprised that she's horrified because the child was a Gypsie, and according to human standards she's not "supposed to care" what happens to Gyspie kids. will change, though, not worth the confusion. shall also change the "fortress wall" part and...yes, in my head Tavrinal does knock, I think I forgot to add it somewhere in there, though...HE IS NOT A PERV!!!
enjoy your kitty blanked, Sage, and call me whenever you get a chance!
"In a sort of ghastly simplicity we remove the organ and demand the function...We laugh at honour and are shocked to find traitors in our midst. We castrate and bid the geldings be fruitful." ~C.S. Lewis




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 32885
Reviews 2058
Well, I've only read the prologue but I'm swooning with excitement! You brought the two main characters in a lovely way, I think the only sentence I'd be picky with is where you describe the boys physical features and use the word "disconcertingly" but that's because I have a thing against Adjectives.

I like how the boy stumbled over the word affinity, it showed what level of education he had, but then he tried it again. it was a real 'moment' for me as a reader :-p I enjoy it a lot, It was very good. You set the plot up amazingly, and do well with characters and dialogue and the like. I'll get to rest when I can :-D I'm sort of jumping around and critiquing a lot of things.
“It's necessary to have wished for death in order to know how good it is to live.”
― Alexandre Dumas, The Count of Monte Cristo




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 5890
Reviews 440
yay! the editing of chapter 4 (according to aero's crits) is achomplished. let me know what you think, aero (I left the elephant/fox analogy, it makes me smile every time I read it, and Sage and Shafter get the joke and smile too, so I'm just going to be stubborn.) ;-) thanks so much! *gives cookies to all the loverly people who have crited/commented*
"In a sort of ghastly simplicity we remove the organ and demand the function...We laugh at honour and are shocked to find traitors in our midst. We castrate and bid the geldings be fruitful." ~C.S. Lewis




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 6517
Reviews 798
I havent got much to say on this one, other then for an 11year old giant who has lived for 34years, Boom sure cries a lot. Thing is, most 11 year olds I know of, especially boys, do everything they can to avoid crying, especially in public and especially in front of girls. I know your trying to make him seem all gentle and harmless, but lay off the crying thing, as I think you achieved that in the very first description of him.

As the candle illuminated its face, he saw that it was a boy, not much older than eleven. He stood no shorter than twelve feet tall with shoulders broader than a normal man’s arm-span, but there was no mistaking the child-like quality of that large, round face. His bright, innocent blue eyes were red-rimmed, as if he had been crying .....

“I’m sca-sca-scared of the dark,” whimpered the child."


One other thing:

He would follow her tomorrow, he decided. Something gave him the feeling that she would go somewhere worth following tomorrow.


Yuk. I didn't like that at all, I think it would be better if you changed all that to, 'he would follow her next time he decided.' There's no way he could know she would do anything tomorrow related to that particular excursion.

Apart from those two things: Excellent. I'm really enjoying it.


That was an awesome intro to Boom.
Mah name is jiggleh. And I like to jiggle.

"Indecision and terror, thy name is novel." - Chiko




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 32885
Reviews 2058
It was there, sure and solid. She resisted the urge to bring it out and open it; that would be foolishness supreme.
I don't like the word supreme here. it just seems really out of place. maybe if you said 'foolishness to a supreme." or something?

The handsome black coach, the one which had joined them that morning sat a good distance away, its occupant not deigning to join his fellows.
this sentence falters a bit, whether due to puntuation or the way its worded.

She held a wand.
this line made it a bit too harry potter for me. I don't really like stories like this. but yours may be good.

You're a good writer :-) I read the most of this earlier in the day and am just now finishing it, so I pretty much forget anything I was going to say..sorry...but, its good. I like your chacacters.
“It's necessary to have wished for death in order to know how good it is to live.”
― Alexandre Dumas, The Count of Monte Cristo




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 5890
Reviews 440
Thanks everyone!!!! Chapter 5 to come out soon--in the meantime I've tried to go back and change the things you mentioned. A lot of them really, REALLY needed changing ;-)
Thanks again, and Claudette, I agree with you about the black coach descript, I originally had it simpler, but changed it, and now I've gone back and changed it back to the way I like better! Ha. so there ;-)
*sets out Halloween candy for all the nice criters*
"In a sort of ghastly simplicity we remove the organ and demand the function...We laugh at honour and are shocked to find traitors in our midst. We castrate and bid the geldings be fruitful." ~C.S. Lewis




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 890
Reviews 85
Yea! I'm here Gyr, I will look over the changes.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

The campus was huge, even after years as its headmaster, Tavrinal was still constantly amazed by its size. The buildings were all at least two stories high, taller in some places, made from blocks of reddish sandstone. The three buildings in the middle of the property were the tallest, five stories, and housed the main classrooms. In the grassy fields closest to the Gypsie’s Forest the students practiced archery and horsemanship, in the main courtyard outside the mess hall they gathered to hear the speeches and exchange a few brief moments as simply children. Ashter had been to the palace, and he knew that his institution rivaled even it in size and sheer impressiveness. He glanced up at the full moon overhead, then around him for the origin of his telling shiver.


Sweet, I'm glad you added this. Now I have a better picture of the Academe than before.

Tavrinal barely needed to suppress the desire to run—all of his instincts told him this child was no threat.


Good.

He knocked softly on the door to her dormitory, praying she would be awake. She opened the door for him, and he saw that she was already dressed. So she had felt something.


Great changes, it doesn't seem so sudden anymore.

but he saw her calm as he had, the magic inside her connecting with the calm, steady, undamaging magic that pulsed ever-so-gently from his being.


Interesting...I like it!

She pressed her cheek to the hand, soft and solid


I realize what you're trying to do here. But just get rid of the soft and solid, it ruins the effect of the mood.

bracing himself for another long, boring, sleepless night.


lol, awesome, great characterization


-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Well I believe I caught all the changes; they were all done really well Gyr. Keep up the great work! I'm excited to see Chapter 5!

~Aero
They haven't invented the missile that can kill an ideal.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 820
Green = Comment/Correction
Blue = Suggestion
Black = Review

*

Headmaster Tavrinal sat bent over a few sheets of parchment, his feathered quill scratching as he wrote.


Gry, you know I love your work but I find ‘feathered quills’ annoying. People only use feathered quills for fancy stuff but in real life the feathers are stripped—I know this because OP is a lot like reality and I hated the idea of using quills with feathers as I didn’t want to go down the false direction. But if you feel you want to keep it I would suggest giving an explanation as to why the feathers were kept. Maybe it somehow helps the writer keep a grip on the quill or something else.

Ashter Tavrinal had managed to become Headmaster of the Dirantyr Training Academe by one simple technique: he knew exactly when not to use magic.


It is pretty obvious what school he was Headmaster of so you ought to take out the school’s name.

But still, it was nice that he looked like he looked like he belonged to the same generation he was born in.


Woah! Repetition of ‘he looked like he looked like’.

The campus was huge, even after years as its headmaster, Tavrinal was still constantly amazed by its size.


You capitalised ‘headmaster’ previously, you should continue or change it.

In the grassy fields closest to the Gypsie’s Forest the students practiced archery and horsemanship, in the main courtyard outside the mess hall they gathered to hear the speeches and exchange a few brief moments as simply children.


I assume there are a lot of Gypsies in the forest, having the apostrophe after the ‘e’ suggests there is only one. If there are more the apostrophe should be after the ‘s’.

By the way, use students and not children, you make out they're 11 or so XD


“Can I keep the candle?”


I don’t know if you intended to make this humorous but I did laugh at this point, also you have added the touch of ‘childish’ behaviour perfectly well.

By the way, how is it that the headmaster doesn’t know about this boy yet the archery teacher did? Wouldn’t the teacher have reported the presence of a giant just to keep on the safe side no matter how harmless Boom appeared?


He knocked softly on the door to her dormitory, praying she would be awake. She opened the door for him, and he saw that she was already dressed. So she had felt something.


Er... Who is she?

She stiffened when she saw him. “What is it, headmaster?”

“I need your help, Miss Morn,” he said. “Please come with me.”


Right, I see.

She started when she saw Boom standing in the moon-lit shadows, but he saw her calm as he had, the magic inside her connecting with the calm, steady, undamaging magic that pulsed ever-so-gently from his being.


This was awkward to read and a little confusing: 'She started when she saw Boom standing in the moon-lit shadows, but he saw her calm as he had,'
I thought the ‘he’ was Boom and then read the next part to find it was the headmaster.


Boom shrugged. “A doctor, a Normal doctor, not a Healer, said my brain and my body won’t grow anymore. He said I’m stuck at eleven, but I know more things than most kids do. I know about…” he paused again, and Karenna could have sworn he blushed, “about where babies come from, and I know about Gypsies and Werebeasts, and I know about Werenna and Scharon. I know how to live on my own and take care of myself.” He hung his head sheepishly. “I’m not stupid.”


The ‘I know’ was a little annoying after a while. To me I think Boom needs something in his speech to make him speak like a child. Do you notice how children usually would say ‘and’ a lot or stumble over their words, especially when they are the centre of attention—unless Boom is confident with Karenna and the headmaster.

“Are you alright?” asked Boom.

“I’m fine,” she said automatically.

“Can I pick you up?”

“What?”


That needs a little emption, perhaps: “What?” she ejaculated. Or something similar.

He sighed and rolled over, pressing his face to his pillow. Oddly enough, the thing he was glad about was not that she had returned safely from whatever errand she had been on—it was the knowledge that Obern had not gone on that errand with her. Still puzzling about why this made him happy, he closed his eyes and rolled over, bracing himself for another long, boring, sleepless night.


Ach! Why doesn’t he sleep! Tell me, please! *bats her eyelids*

Again, Karenna had to restrain the desire to let her anger lose.


Did you mean ‘loose’?

“Well, if Tavrinal couldn’t see through her, what could? An Elementar?” Obern’s tone was a half disapproving, half mocking. “Anyway, she hasn’t even shown enough magical potential to rate even a PW Class 1, and you’re a Class 2 yourself.”


PW what? A little information on the class/level of power would be a whole lot better as I’m not sure I can get my head around all these classes and such.

And you should have seen the weather that sprang up; it was almost like those stories about the air/water Elementars and the storms they could conjure on cue.”


What’s the forward slash doing? If the two are combined it ought to be a dash.

I love how her power ‘drains’ her energy, I did the same with OP. But this would mean she’ll have to eat quite a bit and stay healthy in order for her power to always be available to her. Which reminds me, after the Werebeast incident she should have eaten something, she was shattered right?

Gry, keep up the great work. I want to see more from Tannar’s point of view, he, in my opinion, is one of the main characters yet he is always in the background reflecting on what has already happened. It appears you only include him for that purpose and nothing else, no wonder he rebels against you.

I agree with Aero about the forest frightening Karenna, I suggest adding it in during the archery class.

-- Myth
Last edited by Myth on Thu Oct 26, 2006 9:46 am, edited 2 times in total.
.: ₪ :.

'...'




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 5890
Reviews 440
agian, thanks so much to everyone who took the time to crit my stuff! myth, as usual, you are your annoyingly eagle-eyed self ;-) I have saved your catches to a word document and will be working on them just as soon as Latin decides to leave me alone. chapter five is coming soon people, I promise!
"In a sort of ghastly simplicity we remove the organ and demand the function...We laugh at honour and are shocked to find traitors in our midst. We castrate and bid the geldings be fruitful." ~C.S. Lewis




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 790
Reviews 2
A few notes on peripheral stuff from chap. 4:

It's good that you've been able to use the school environment to slip some new characters into the story. Make sure, though, that Karenna doesn't integrate too quickly; she's a strange girl in prejudiced surroundings.

Boom was a great touch, not so much because of what he is doing right now, but rather because thus far, your secondary sympathetic characters have been consistenly cunning, subtle, and shrewd people in one way or another. Boom breaks the mold.

Tannar is delightfully confusing. He rocks.

Chapter four is a perfect introduction to Headmaster Tavrinal. In rapid sequence, we see some of his life story and we see him under a variety of circumstances; being meditative, having a conversation, in his element (school business and school politics), out of his element (with a child), and then he caps it all by realizing so quickly that Karenna is the person he needs.

This is fun. Keep it coming!
"Me fail English? That's unpossible!"
-??



It's all a matter of perspective. Everyone is the hero of their own story, and the villain of another's.
— James