-
Re: What I hate about myself
Lumme. Pity party in full swing here. Seriously, I don't know what to say about either of you. Isn't this kind of stuff supposed to be private? (If you both ...
May 17, 2007 -
Re: POD 30:1 -Helpless (Rewrite)
Oh man, the rewrites and the chapter numbers are making this all confusing. Have I said this before? Sorry, anyway, the courtroom scenes sound very prof. Already I dislike Ortega. ...
May 17, 2007 -
Re: A small excerpt from the novel I'm working on
Okay, the first lines set tiny little alarm bells ringng. This looks disturbingly like a LOTR-esque story. Wargs are direct from LOTR, dwarfs I suppose you can get away with ...
May 16, 2007 -
Re: The Bible is Full of Incest
Ugh, I don't get or like this at all. And the title is a factual error. A positive note is that the imagery is very strong, and the language evokes ...
May 15, 2007 -
Re: Dark Child
Um . . . isn't the point of a crit supposed to be constructive and helpful? Not crushing and biting. I accept that you people know a lot about how ...
May 15, 2007 -
Re: Geezer's Property #9
Way cool! Atlantis?? But the pegasi . . . *sulks* Rats. Still, the author knows best. No great errors in here - Sworddance has pointed them out, so once again, ...
May 15, 2007 -
Re: Geezer's Property #8
Hey, I like Mekare. Phlegmatic. In a nice way. And, oh the DRAMA!!! “Lockegeo Bethazel . ” rumbled Mekare, That should be a comma. The Geezer bowed as well as ...
May 15, 2007 -
Re: Geezer's Property #7
Pegasi? Oh good! If it's what I think it is: plural of pegasus and not something else. I like Pegasi. :D I must confess I'm getting a little confused with ...
May 15, 2007 -
Re: Geezer's Property - #6
Sworddance has dun most of the critiquing, so there's nothing left for me to do, 'cept say that this was another good chapter - with one exception. It's what Ofour ...
May 15, 2007 -
Re: Geezer's Property, #5
Third crit!..... ...Except that it isn't a very good crit. At this stage, all I want to do is read and not look out for mistakes. Sorry, but it does ...
May 15, 2007 -
Re: Geezer's Property (Part 4 Up)
Cool! :) I just started reading this, and it's great!! :D :D No criticism - there's hardly any to be made, and Ofour's dunnit all already. *scuttles off to read ...
May 15, 2007 -
Re: Cinderella Parody
Yeah, it's like a Jennifer Saunders Fairy Godmother! :D Really funny - I love parodies like this! Yep, poofy blue dress, wand, even the darned little wings were all in ...
May 14, 2007 -
Re: You Hide in the Shadow of a Dream
Good! Normally I don't like second person, but this was good, wasn't too patronizing. But ALL your stuff is so dark and distuuuuuuurbing ..... Getting murdered in second person, that's ...
May 12, 2007 -
Re: POD 31- The First Step -On Both Accounts (rewrite)
Eek, this is rather confusing. It was bad enough with you having two chapters numbered the same. Can't you make it a bit simpler? :wink: Hope you put the next ...
May 11, 2007 -
Re: The Dragon's Park
I liked it...:D It didn't seem to have a fixed structure, but perhaps that doesn't matter. I like the way you put the dragons in a contrast to the humans ...
May 8, 2007
