User avatar

Rei

  • Novel / Chapter » General, General Re: somewhere over the Rainbow:Part I

    Definitely continue. It's all right t leave certain stories unfinished, but only if you've given the reader enough so that s/he can piece together what might happen next. Here, you ...

    May 2, 2005
  • Novel / Chapter » Fantasy, General Re: Rain Before Dawn, Chapters 1-4 (all revised)

    Chapter one: You've still got some sentences that are way too long. Think of the shortest sentense you have have while still saying the same thing. I still don't get ...

    May 1, 2005
  • Novel / Chapter » General, General Re: Scarlet Begonias (Part II of the Lyric Trilogy)

    Once again, the voice is way to formal. This time it did take away from the believability of the character. And don't you think after fourteen years, they might have ...

    Apr 30, 2005
  • Novel / Chapter » General, General Re: Crimson and Clover (Part I of the Lyric Trilogy)

    Pretty good. A nice introduction to what promises to be a very interesting story. There are a couple of awkward sentences, though you can hardly notice them. I thought the ...

    Apr 30, 2005
  • Novel / Chapter » Fantasy, General Re: The Intruder

    Honestly, this is very dull. I can tell it was written very academically, and there was a lot of thought put into it, but it's very bland. The use of ...

    Apr 29, 2005
  • Novel / Chapter » Fantasy, General Re: untitled fantasy - chapter 1 (a novel in the works)

    I also didn't get into this. It was really lacking in several areas. Your opening paragraph were good, but once the dialogue began, the quality of the narrative dropped considerably. ...

    Apr 29, 2005
  • Novel / Chapter » Fantasy, General Re: Heroes of the Elven Lands:Chapter 1

    I think Griffinkeeper pretty much said most of what you need to know. I only read half of this because I couldn't follow what was happening. Your first few paragraphs ...

    Apr 27, 2005
  • Short Story » General, General Re: My angle in heaven

    Very nice. I loved your use of language in this. Very simple, yet very elegant. There are some really great images and ideas here. But I felt that there wasn't ...

    Apr 27, 2005
  • Short Story » General, General Re: Nothing

    Definitely not crap. However, did sound like you were trying too hard to sound poetic and vague. You know, being literary to the point where it no longer sounds like ...

    Apr 27, 2005
  • Short Story » General, General Re: i dont have a title(help me out)

    What you need to do is scrap this and start all over again. You're rushing into it. It's a fairly standard premis for a science fiction novel, but there's nothing ...

    Apr 25, 2005
  • Novel / Chapter » General, General Re: The Beach

    I'd say this is a pretty decent start. Definitely creates a lot of curiosity about what will happen next. However, I thought there were a few things you could have ...

    Apr 25, 2005
  • Short Story » General, General Re: sadness

    This is more of a piece of creative non-fiction rather than fiction. But it's a good start. I can tell you really understand what you're writing about. However, I would ...

    Apr 24, 2005
  • Short Story » General, General Re: Choiceless

    A decent beginning. All right ideas. However, you could be a little more concise in your use of language, especially during the dream, and sound less like you were using ...

    Apr 24, 2005
  • Poetry » Dramatic, General Re: A graveyard of sorrow and joy (Kind of graphic)

    Yes, indeed it was very graphic, but also very powerful. This really transported me into the place you're describing. I think it needs to be this graphic, or else it ...

    Apr 22, 2005
  • Short Story » Action / Adventure, General Re: Escape

    As was already said, what is needed is more background. I didn't really get who these characters were. I mean, I got the basics, but they didn't feel real to ...

    Apr 22, 2005


I think the more you understand myths, the more you understand the roots of our culture and the more things will resonate.
— Rick Riordan