-
Re: Luminous (old version)
I finally got myself here and finished reading! I'll start with my overall impressions and then go back to specifics. Firstly, I'd like to say that your writing is stellar. ...
Feb 8, 2017 -
Re: Glorious Fantasy Ch.4: Out of the Forest
This is an excellent next step for the story: it's much more human and personal than running from monsters and fighting with fantasy-world powers. It gets back to the elephant ...
Jan 16, 2017 -
Re: Glorious Fantasy Ch.3: Maeve
Onward we go! I don't have a whole ton to say about this chapter in particular. I liked the new characters a lot so I was rather less interested when ...
Jan 16, 2017 -
Re: Glorious Fantasy Ch.2: Death Kittens
Typing as I read again, so you'll notice a disconnect between my paragraphs ^^ I love the thoughts toward agility vs wishing she put points in endurance, etc. Fun way ...
Jan 16, 2017 -
Re: Glorious Fantasy Ch.1: A New world
Hi! Here to review as requested. Going to type my thoughts as I read. For starters, the tense is a little shifty. Past tense and present tense both make appearances ...
Jan 16, 2017 -
Re: Prince, Spy, Priest
Ok so! Rought draft with requested attention on pacing! Therefore, no prose comments. I'll type my thoughts as I read and avoid anything narrower than paragraph-level. The introduction is kind ...
Jan 12, 2017 -
Re: The Carpenter - Exordium of Shattered Crowns
Hey there, dropping by for a review as requested. I saw your comment that this meant to be like a prologue, so taking that into account, I think you have ...
Jan 12, 2017 -
Re: Atana: Chapter 1
Hi there! Finally back to catch up on my YWS reviews... sorry I left this request sitting around so long. This is a very cool start, with lots of mystery ...
Jan 12, 2017 -
Re: Shadowsong: Chapter 5- Yes, Master
Alrighty, last chapter for now! I don't think I have too much different to add that I haven't already said. As far as critique, I notice mostly the same issues--would ...
Dec 16, 2016 -
Re: Shadowsong: Chapter 4- Harbinger of Death
Back for more, and this time I'll try typing as I read. Ok I think I'm finally getting a handle on the conflict between light and darkness. These angels are ...
Dec 16, 2016 -
Re: Shadowsong: Chapter 3- Those Echoing Cries of Pain
Onto chapter 3, and this one's a long one! I like how we're getting some progression of the story; things are happening, characters are developing, more of the backstory is ...
Dec 14, 2016 -
Re: I'd Only Wanted A Tissue
Hi! Here to review as requested. This was a very emotional piece, and I really felt for the MC and their anxiety and self-doubt. Seems like this is a lot ...
Dec 12, 2016 -
Re: Shadowsong: Chapter 2- This World of Light
Hi! Moving onward. I secretly was already planning to crit the rest of it if I got the chance before you even asked ;) So here I am. Since this ...
Dec 9, 2016 -
Re: Return to Oblivion Draft
Hello there, Megrim here to review as requested, and what a fun story you have here. I looove the imagery of blasting through PLANETS as they fight. I got the ...
Dec 8, 2016 -
Re: A Writer's Wish
Hi! Here to try and review some poetry. I don't have a clue about poetry technique so we're going to go with reader reaction instead. Stanza 1: Ok I lied, ...
Dec 8, 2016
