-
Re: Brown Eyes
A very demure portrayal of adolescent navel-gazing. Self-referential language rarely works in poetry, unless you have some pretty strong images and ideas to back it up. Nevertheless, just because you ...
Sep 18, 2005 -
Re: A Paradox
This was a bunch of interrogative nonsense. Perhaps if you would drop the questions and start using [original] imagery to explain your ideas, the poem would be better. For instance: ...
Sep 18, 2005 -
Re: Blinded by Darkness
Who cares? Not only was this piece devoid of all emotional sympathy, but it also lacked any kind of coherent synthesis of ideas. Your images and metaphors were weak, if ...
Sep 18, 2005 -
Re: a poem (warning, this piece has a lot of adult language)
Two fundamental definitions: 1. Journal entry--Writing in which the writer tells the reader what emotions the writer is experiencing about something. 2. Poem--Writing in which the writer causes the re
Sep 9, 2005 -
Re: reflection in the calm waters of a bathtub
Which, in essence, is the very point of this piece. It was written for my Postmodernism class; hence, fragmentation and (dis)connects are rampant. Allow me to paraphrase T.S. Eliot for ...
Sep 8, 2005 -
Re: As Silent Tears Dance
I don't have a critique -- there's nothing there worth critiquing. Some poets make the mistake of opening up too large an issue, others focus on microcosmic spectacles. You achieved ...
Sep 5, 2005 -
Re: Falling into new depths
Jack, First Stanza: This is chopped up, mediocre prose with just about every beginner's mistake in the book - a feeble attempt to draw a grand moral from a weak ...
Sep 5, 2005 -
Re: Autumn Winds
Some small crits: Ghostly hands caress your face Okay... Loving you isn't enough anymore Very unconnected to the first line. Also, you need to answer what is enough, now? Miles ...
Sep 4, 2005 -
Re: Title pending poll. Wow, this was cathartic.
This made me shake my head, not a good thing. Vague, self-conscious language leading me nowhere. Practically speaking, the word "'Cuz" is repulsive in a poem. There's some odd punctuation, ...
Aug 21, 2005 -
Re: Pitiless Prophecy
A peace in irony: The poem decries the philosophy of science as an evil, dehumanization posing as 'anatomical art'; the irony lies thus: the poem itself is structured 'scientifically' and ...
Aug 20, 2005 -
Re: my sushi blueboy
I didn't like it. The smooth-flowing sentences lulled me to sleep, so I have no idea what I read. You need sonorization (creation of noise in silence), you need to ...
Aug 12, 2005 -
Re: Lettin' Go
Interesting. I'm not fond of the one-word lines: it isn't effective and you want your stanzas to taper down near the end. Why? It's visually appealing. I think I saw ...
Aug 10, 2005 -
Re: Ryan Gary Joel's EXCERPT!: The Contract
I then got a shock as Anthony Swanson’s voice began to talk ‘Are you ready?' Unintentional rhyme you may wish to remove. Also, I find that fact that his voice ...
Jul 28, 2005 -
Re: i know a girl
Jack-- It's too long. You lost momentum after the third stanza and concluded by succumbing to repetitive images and meaningless phraseology. That is not to say, however, that there are ...
Jul 27, 2005 -
Re: Dirty Poem
I was in Russia but after meeting with Dr. Lukva or something I was shipped into a psychiatric ward, which my parents refused to pay for, which brought me back ...
Jul 27, 2005
