Hi there! And welcome to YWS, this was an interesting piece - I'm not sure if it would quite fit in the poetry section or if it leans more towards short story. I think it may be helpful (if you try to develop this piece further) to go either way decisively. I can easily see this being broken up into stanzas with the mysterious descriptive language, or being lengthened with more of a plot background to make it into a short-story.
There are a few areas where I'd like to share my comments and suggestions:
Grammar & Phrasing
The other reviewer sort of hit this already so I'm just going to put my critiques here under the "spoiler" for you to read if you so choose. I would suggest re-reading your work a couple times out-loud before posting just to get some of those easy to catch mistakes out. Although I can still understand the piece with a few typos and grammar mistakes, it generally makes me take a piece more seriously if it's polished and I don't have to pause at little mistakes.
Style & Word Choice
One area that you could work on towards improving (especially if you're not using a poetry format) is working on being less repetitive. For instance again and again you use the language "the demons have taken away my happiness, I'm tired, I'm sad". This in a nut-shell is your entire piece. While it's fine to say that once or twice - you aren't really adding anything to the message to say it so many times in a row to fill up half a page of text. There are a few sections where the plot sort of moves on and you're using more imagery to describe the demons' actions and I think these areas are stronger and less repetitive.
These couple of sentences were particularly repetitive
You are just saying the same thing again, and again, and again. And it can get boring for the reader."I won't say I'm sad, but I'm not happy either. And I'm tired, very tired of waking up to not being happy and falling asleep, not happy. I don't know why, I'm not sad, but not happy either"
I would suggest playing with your word choice and thinking about deeper more creative ways to describe the emotions that you want to describe.
For instance, rather than saying "I am tired, very tired" you change it up and say "my eyelids are heavy with sleep, and I lack enough energy to rise from the slumber that calls me to submit to a restful existence" <- while that may be a bit dramatic for your style, it does show that there are other ways to say very basic things, to make your piece more interesting.
There's some filler and unnecessary phrases that if removed or changed could make your piece more interesting for the reader.
Some words that are repeated a lot in you piece are "happy, sad, demon, But, and, emptiness" for these words especially I think you should look at ways to vary your sentence beginnings and find alternative way to express these somewhat generic words.
There are a few sections where I think you use particularly evocative and creative language choices: the first is this phrasing " the demons part their lips to kindle the fire"
and the second part I really thought was unique was this sentence "I've learned to shush the demons, but their whispers still slip right through my fingers." My only issue here is that it's sort of a mixed metaphor - you "shush" but the demon "slips through your fingers"? Why are they behind your fingers in the first place? If it was changed to include something about your hands initially I think it would be more powerful figurative language. Although I do really like that imagery and would like to see more of this style infused in the rest of your writing.
Content & Overall Impressions
For my first impressions, I think you need to vary your images and word choice a little and think about what message you are really trying to get across.
I think the strongest message or content line was this one: "I remember I have to be that fighter, I promised myself to be, before falling asleep.And though every new day feels like an eternity, I still carry on in this melancholy."
Sometimes when I read heavy or dark pieces like this one, I get weighed down with the negative emotion and don't really feel like I can take anything away from it besides a feeling of sympathy for the author or character in the piece. So I like that you left a bit of hope in the piece, something for the reader to grasp onto.
For me, the beginning and ending lines didn't pack as much of a punch as I was hoping. It's a bold move to begin your piece with the word "But..." ... but for me, it didn't really make sense. I think you could work on both those areas; and maybe remove the dash/hyphen in the very last line.
Overall, it wasn't quite as depressing to read as I thought it might be - which to me at least, is a good thing! And I think you've made a strong first piece to post on YWS. Good luck with all of your further writing and revisions!
~alliyah
Points: 144550
Reviews: 1227
Donate