nothing else will do

by sealegs

Published April 10, 2010

In Poetry

PreviousNext

Deleted for editing. Thanks again for the reviews!

Comments & reviews · 7
User avatar
perdido
Review
perdido wrote a review Review · Apr 12, 2010

Sealegs, again, you nailed it. Short poems like this are tricky because EVERY word has to be perfect, and so does the title. And actually, I once published a poem about having difficulty writing poems, so don't be so hard on yourself. This short form allows you to have colossal strength... you just have to find it, and in this one I feel it, the sea legs and coals are a perfect pair in the first stanza.

keep it up girl

User avatar
antimelrose
Review
antimelrose wrote a review Review · Apr 11, 2010

Your imagery is effective and surprising, but why write a poem about not wanting to? You have such excellent potential for this poem, but it ends up being a waste of time to read when we find out that the author isn't really interested in the subject matter. Now, you may personally feel differently, but if you wanted the reader to walk away thinking otherwise, I suggest you change the wording in order to make your feelings more clear. Also, the title of the poem seems disconnected with the actual poem; but then again, leave it to me with my eyes blind to abstract connections. :D

Really, I think you should change the ending, but all of this is subjective. Only the artist can make that decision. Regardless, best wishes and keep writing!

–antimelrose

User avatar
LastPaladin
Review
LastPaladin wrote a review Review · Apr 10, 2010

Greetings I'm LastPaladin, I'm sorry to say I didn't like this, but why you ask. Well it tries to be witty and it's not. It's not creative it's being navelgazing. Sure there is some lovely images. But nothing caught me about this, nothing really made me feel. And if laughter is what you wished then you didn't get that. You can elaborate on each of these images and maybe it could be strengthened but right now this is just a few lines that does nothing for readers. Believe it or not there is a thing called being too subtle and you are definitly to subtle.

So, cut comedy, quit being cheeky and expecting laugh, and do more to this. It's saving grace is this, the lines are pretty original. Which shows you have skill, trust me you can do great if you put your mind to it.

Hope this helps.

User avatar
Jasmine Hart
Review
Jasmine Hart wrote a review Review · Apr 10, 2010

Hi,

Welcome to Yws! I hope you like it here.

I really love "with sea legs" and I think the last two lines are very effective. The way in which you've laid them out is very effective.

The only thing I'd change is "to walk on hot coals" because I think it's a bit cliche.

Hope this helps,

Jas

User avatar
sealegs
Comment
sealegs commented Comment · Apr 10, 2010

Why? Because writing is habitual and if you want to get good at it, you must do it even when you don't particularly want to.

In my opinion, it's more important to try writing and to fail than to not try and never know. Think of all of the things that wouldn't be published today if the author had never just sat down and wrote. Yes? No? Maybe so?

Also, I never said I didn't like poetry. You made that impression. Which is okay because poetry is always open for interpretation.

User avatar
dasiamari
Comment
dasiamari commented Comment · Apr 10, 2010

why write a poem about not liking writing poems there is no point



You have been de-shenaniganed.
— WaffleCat