12+

Fair-weather friend

PreviousNext

Eight-year-old Daniela stood and watched the rain. It was late at night and a summer storm was in full gear, pounding wind and rain on the window. Her mother approached her from behind, rubbing her head in a silent gesture of comfort. They watched the storm together.

There was an idiom that Daniela had heard the other day that she’d been thinking about since she heard it, trying to decipher what it could mean. She’d heard someone say

“-perfect storm. How could a storm be perfect?”

“Well, you can’t think about it literally.” Her mother said, staring out the window next to Daniela. “You have to realize that they don’t mean a real storm. They mean, maybe a person who’s really energetic.”

“Like Jen?” Daniela asked.

“Yeah, like Jen.” Her mother responded. “And you know, Jen has her flaws. But her energy means that she can do things better than the rest of us. Like, you’ve seen her soccer playing.” Jen was good at soccer, way better than Daniela. Daniela felt a pang of hurt with the indirect comparison, but nodded without a word.“You think Jen could do that if she wasn’t so wired? Some kids don’t have as much energy as Jen, which can be a good thing, but sometimes Jen storm is what makes what she does perfect.”

Daniela squinted her eyes and tilted her head as a gust of wind sent the trees outside her window leaning to the left.

Jen was the storm.

Ten candles blew out on Daniela’s birthday cake. On her right was her mother, and on her left was Jen. As Daniela beamed out at the table of people, Jen leaned down and whispered in Daniela’s ear.

“What’d you wish for?” Jen asked, grinning. Jen had outgrown her hyperactivity, and her energy was channeled now into being charismatic and keeping herself fit - she was still the star of the soccer team. Her perfectly curled blonde hair brushed against Daniela’s cheek. Daniela had recently started to develop acne on her cheeks and forehead. Secretly, she was worried about what Jen would think if she saw. Jen’s skin was perfect.

“I can’t tell you!” Daniela smiled back. “Then it won’t come true.” Jen laughed. Daniela’s mother pulled the cake away and began to cut it, resulting in screams of excitement from the group of kids.

Daniela had wished that she was as pretty as Jen.

Later, as Daniela and her friends ate, she overheard her mother talking to a friend.

“We better enjoy this while we can, Lily.” Said Daniela’s mom. “These years, right before they’re teenagers? This is the calm before the storm.”

Was Jen still the storm?

At fourteen, Jen and Daniela sat next to each other around a campfire surrounded by their friends.

“Let’s play a game.” Called Evelyn, the hostess. “Everyone go around the circle, say one thing you’re gonna miss about middle school, and then one thing you’re excited for in high school!” There were chimes of agreement, so the group of girls quieted down.

“Jen, let’s start with you.” Evelyn said. Jen stood up next to Daniela, and Daniela looked up at her. She had to look up at her now. Even when they were both standing, Jen towered over everyone, and her high ponytail, lean frame and strong presence only made those around her feel even smaller. When she stood up like that, it made Daniela feel like Jen was on top of the world. Too far up to look back down at her.

Jen smiled her perfect smile. “I’m gonna miss this group - I can’t believe some of you guys are leaving for other high schools! Hopefully we stay in touch.” A few people nodded. “But I mean, we get to start fresh. New friends, new teachers, new boys,” she emphasized, resulting in giggles from the group of girls. “and in the end, every cloud does have a silver lining.”

Were these the storm clouds mom said were coming?

At sixteen, Daniela and Jen sat together at a lunch table. Normally they were surrounded by their friends, but today they were alone. Their eyes were on another table, on one person. His name was Casey.

“Come on, you have to go talk to him! This is your chance!” Jen egged Daniela on. “Just go for it! I’ll go with you.”

Daniela agreed at the idea of company. She stood up cautiously, and Jen popped out of her seat excitedly. Daniela walked shyly with her shoulders tensed, Jen pranced with her head high.

The two walked to the table where Casey sat, sliding into the seats across from him. Before Daniela could open her mouth, Jen’s voice spoke, bright and eager. “Hey!”

Casey smiled at them. “Hey, who are you two?”

Daniela felt the brush on Jen’s ponytail on her neck as Jen flipped her hair. Daniela looked over at Jen. She had that smile again. The one that made her look like she was on top of the world all over again. “I’m Jen, this is Daniela.”

Casey was smiling too. Suddenly, the chime of the bell sent students scattering. “Well, you two seem great. Wanna talk tomorrow?” Casey’s eyes swept over the two of them. Daniela’s heart fluttered. Jen’s eyelashes did the same.

“Oh, Daniela, don’t you have to go to the library tomorrow? Some makeup test?” Jen asked sweetly, looking down at Daniela.

“Uh, that’s next week.”

“But you better get it done soon! There’s a bug going around.” Jen’s hair flipped back at Daniela as she turned back to Casey. “See you tomorrow!”

The two walked off, and Daniela watched Casey leave over her shoulder.

“Don’t worry, Dani. I’m just gonna get in there and break the ice, tell him all about you.”

Daniela went to the library at the next day’s lunch. She thought about Casey and Jen alone at a lunch table. She thought about the ice that Jen said she was trying to break.

There would have been no ice if the storm hadn’t frozen the lake.

Whack. Seventeen-year-old Dani winced as Jen’s hand hit the table, sending her blonde curls bouncing.

“Don’t you get it?! It’s not about you! It’s about him!” Jen yelled into Daniela’s face. The table and lunchroom all stared.

Jen and Casey had broken up. They’d almost been together a year, almost made it to junior prom. Whipping around, Jen angrily left the room.

Daniela and Jen’s other friends remained at the table in silence. Finally, a girl named Jackie moved down a few seats to put her arm around Daniela’s shoulder, comforting her. “You didn’t do anything wrong.” she reassured her. “She’s just having a bad day. First Casey, and I heard she got a pretty bad grade on that essay we turned in a month or so ago.”

“And you know Jen.” Said another friend, a boy named Brandon. “When it rains, it pours.”

Jen brought the rain.

Eighteen-year-old Daniela sat and watched the rain. She was in a cafe now, away from home.

Jen was away from home too. Jen was gone, but she wasn’t only gone in the way that Daniela no longer sat next to her. After high school ended, Daniela had been terrified. She’d stayed up at night, worrying about the next few years and her own future. But when she’d dialed Jen’s number on her phone, it always went to voicemail.

Instead of Jen, there was a boy named Kenneth sitting next to Daniela.

Kenneth had seen Daniela alone in the cafe, staring out the window at the threatening-looking storm clouds that were rolling in. He’d sat down next to her, handed her a coffee he’d claimed was supposed to be for a friend who’d “cancelled on him”, and struck up polite conversation. Daniela had been talking with him for hours now. Particularly, about high school. Particularly, about Jen.

“I knew a ton of girls like that in high school.” Kenneth said, shaking his head sadly. When he shook his head, his curls shook with it. Kenneth’s curls were like Jen’s, but they were real and they were brown. Big, loopy curls that spilled over his eyes in a way Jen would never let hers do. “They’re fake, completely toxic. I always call ‘em fair-weather friends. They’re around when they need you, but never when you need them. Only when the weather is good.” He turned his head to look out the window that Jen had been staring out of. The rain was harder now, and wind bent the big, evergreen trees to the left.

Jen brought the rain and the wind. She bent trees and buildings with force. But once she began the storm, she left. She didn’t return until her storm was over and the weather was good again.

The weather was stormy now, and Jen was gone.

Comments & reviews · 5
Note: You are not logged in, but you can still leave a comment or review. Before it shows up, a moderator will need to approve your comment (this is only a safeguard against spambots). Leave your email if you would like to be notified when your message is approved.

Random avatar
santiesther
Comment

General question for everyone who added to this thread - if I posted a second version of this story, would you critique it again? You've all been super helpful!

People don't get notified if you make a comment like this, so you might want to reply to their reviews or write on their walls. Anyway, I'd be happy to! Just let me know when it's up. :D

User avatar
alliyah
Comment

I really like this concept, and I think you did a good job in its execution too! Keep on writing! :)

~alliyah

User avatar
niteowl
Review

Hi there santiesher and welcome to YWS! Niteowl here to review this fine Review Day!

So I'm not sure if I'm reading too much into things or not, but I was definitely thinking that Daniela was falling in love with Jen rather than this being all about friendship. I don't think that's what you intended though.

Jen was away from home too. Jen was gone, but she wasn’t only gone in the way that Daniela no longer sat next to her.


This line really threw me for a loop. I found myself thinking that Jen was dead, but the last few paragraphs really didn't support that, so I was confused. I would consider reworking this paragraph to make it clear that she's still alive but has completely cut off Daniela. Unless she is indeed dead, then I would make that more clear.

Jen smiled her perfect smile. “I’m gonna miss this group - I can’t believe some of you guys are leaving for other high schools! Hopefully we stay in touch.” A few people nodded. “But I mean, we get to start fresh. New friends, new teachers, new boys,” she emphasized, resulting in giggles from the group of girls. “and in the end, every cloud does have a silver lining.”

Were these the storm clouds mom said were coming?


Overall, I agree with Bloodlord that the storm metaphor works pretty well, but this doesn't feel right to me. The paragraph I quoted seems rather benign to be the omen of storm clouds. Maybe this scene needs to be further developed to create the feeling that Jen and Daniela are drifting apart.

The sixteen-year-old scene with Jen stealing Casey is definitely interesting, but I feel like it could be developed better. It wasn't immediately clear to me that Daniela had particularly strong feelings for him, so I didn't feel the betrayal as strongly as I feel I could have. I would develop this scene a little better with an emphasis on Daniela having feelings for Casey, assuming that's what you intended.

“Don’t you get it?! It’s not about you! It’s about him!” Jen yelled into Daniela’s face. The table and lunchroom all stared.


This scene also feels weird and abrupt. Like Jen is upset because Casey broke up with her...why would Daniela think that's about her? I feel like this scene is supposed to be more important and dramatic and really showing how Jen is a fair weather friend, but it doesn't really. I'm not sure how to go about developing this scene, but maybe showing more of the fight? Another way to show that Jen is a fair weather friend might be to have Daniela be successful at something (school? love?) and have that be why Jen gets upset and cuts her off.

He turned his head to look out the window that Jen had been staring out of. The rain was harder now, and wind bent the big, evergreen trees to the left.


This scene is a little bit stronger, but shouldn't Daniela be staring out the window here and not Jen?

Overall, I think this starts out strong and I really like the storm metaphor and the evolution of the friendship over time. However, I feel like the high school scenes could be a little more developed to really show the cracks in their friendship. Welcome again and keep writing! :D

that last one was a typo, oh my god i can't believe I didnt' catch that haha. I meant to type casey, I must have been writing pretty late there. this was super helpful, thanks so much!

i'm going crazy that was still the wrong person. hopefully you understand it was a typo haha

User avatar
Mea
Review
Mea wrote a review · Sun Aug 26, 2018 11:59 pm

Hey there, santi! I thought this was a really good story, so I figured I'd come give it a quick review on this lovely Review Day!

I really like the central theme of this, the way you took the idea of a person being a storm and explored it throughout the stages of Daniela's life.

I think my main critique for you here is that at times, this doesn't quite feel cohesive, or it feels like you're pushing the reference to a storm a little too much so that sometimes it doesn't feel like it belongs. The way you used the metaphor of a storm seemed to change several times throughout the story, and the change didn't always feel natural.

For example, up until the scene with Caesy in the library, I had no idea Jen was kind of a jerk who'd blow over people to get her way. I just thought she was energetic, charismatic, and pretty, and that was how she was "a storm", but Daniela seemed to really look up to her (with the way she wanted her to think she was pretty), and so I thought she was actually a nice person, even if she wasn't very close to Daniela. So it came as a pretty big surprise and felt jarring when she was so blatantly a jerk to Daniela. I think if you foreshadowed her selfishness a bit in earlier scenes, maybe by having her say or do something to Daniela that readers would recognize as dismissive or mean, but Daniela wouldn't either because she's too young or she just thinks it's normal, that would really help.

That being said, I love the idea at the end, that the physical storm only comes when Jen is gone. I think you should emphasize more that Daniela is going through her own troubles that don't directly relate to Jen - with the phrase "fair-weather friend," usually the friend didn't create all the problems herself, just abandoned you when other problems came up, and right now it feels more like Jen is the creator of the problem. I think the metaphor would make more sense if you emphasized more that Daniela has always been wanting support from her sister, but has never received it.

One small thing - I'm guessing you probably had spaces in between the scene breaks here, but they seem to have gotten deleted (extra spaces tend to get deleted automatically). Instead, just put a small dash or a dot or something on a new line so we know where the scene breaks are. :)

And I think that's all I've got for you! Definitely keep writing - I hope to see more from you sometime, because I really enjoyed this!

i 100% agree, there were times that i struggled to fit the storm metaphor in with the story and i am still trying to work that out haha. thanks so much!

User avatar
Bloodlord
Review

Hi, Bloodlord here for a review!

This was a really well-written, touching piece! It reflects a very true aspect of friendship that is often hard to accept, and I can relate to this piece in many ways.

I really loved your extended metaphor with weather and storms - it made the story really cohesive without being contrived. The way you take Daniela and Jen through the years from age 8 to age 18 is really nice, and your transitions are pretty smooth. The friendship seems genuine and real, and you get a good feel for the characters.

I just wanted to say that I especially loved you translation with 'Ten candles...'. It was really smooth and so good!

Your grammar is pretty solid through the entire thing - I just have a few minor comments.

-------
She's heard someone say

'-perfect storm. How can a storm be perfect?'
--------

A comma after 'say' would be more correct.

-------
"Yeah, like Jen." Her mother responded. "And you know, ..."
--------

Replace the first period with a comma and I capitalize the Her. Also, when this quote continues later on, it would be helpful if you added something like, "Her mother continued, '...'". It is a little awkward the way you have it now.

In places with quotations, just remember the comma when your saying he/ she said / responded / etc.

This was such a nice piece and I can't wait to read more of your work!

Thank you so much! This was very helpful and I'm glad the metaphor was cohesive - I was worried it got a little too weird sometimes.



“I'm so glad I live in a world where there are Octobers.”
— L.M. Montgomery, Anne of Green Gables