A/N: For what it's worth, I'm going to tell you a bit about my intentions with this. I was experimenting with narrative voice, meaning that I had a sacrifice a bit of my usual style. If you--as a reader/reviewer--have a comment on how this affected my story, than definitely don't hesitate to point out my weaknesses. I'm expecting quite a bit of negative feedback because I tried a new thing, so whatever you have to say is appreciated. Thanks. :)
We are put in cages.
Usually, they are the kind with overlapping wire that fishnets over the ceiling. They are built from a stubborn alloy that refuses to bend--iron, maybe--and are stacked atop each other in a cubic array. But they reserve those for the smaller of us. I am big, so they have moved me to a vaster cell with three others like me. We are trapped behind thick metal rods that rust beyond a show of character, like we have committed a crime and are to be punished.
I am not sure if this is true. I have not broken any written law, but to my knowledge the rule now is that you are not allowed to be outside alone (as long as you are bare-necked) and, because of this discrepancy, I still do not know whether I was kidnapped or arrested.
I do not know much about the death penalty, or what they call euthanasia. I am bringing this up because everybody I have met in here is afraid to die. Their mouths clam up and their shoulders get cold at the mere mention. Maybe for good reason. One of my cellmates is called Jeffords, and he tells me that he has seen his friends dragged down the corridor and through the double doors. The double doors are two colossal slabs of scarlet-painted steel that are very heavy. I know they are heavy because the man in the overalls --he is called Doris by those of us who enjoy the use of names--has to haul open the left door with all of his might, muscles in his bicep contorting, nose wrinkling with the effort. When he gets it to swing on its hinges, he slips inside, and it slams shut behind him faster and louder than a mousetrap.
Jeffords has a theory that when they take you away like that, it is because your upkeep is no longer worth their time, and they put you down. He said it exactly like that--"put down" instead of "kill".
Nobody knows for certain what goes on behind the double doors, mostly because no one who goes there comes back.
Jeffords is very old and big, older and bigger than me, and he is compiling a whole list of theories. He claims that the other prisoners lost their families and were all stolen viciously from vacant alleyways. According to him, each and every one of them were deposited in these types of orphanage-prisons throughout the state. I do not believe him. This is a ridiculous theory, because the tyke who sleeps across the corridor has been yapping all week about the family he used to belong to.
The tyke who sleeps across the corridor is called Scoundrel, and he is much smaller than me. On bad days, he will slump into a fetal position, body seizing and clicking like a broken engine, quaking with spastic sobs. After some time of watching him, an untamable sound will escape his black lips; a screeching wail that scrapes inside my ears like a lion's claws against a chalkboard.
Many of the others who have been taken are like this. They suffer emotional instability. Jeffords thinks it is because the Keepers--that is what those of us who enjoy the use of names call the men who have taken us--have identified their breaking point. He calls them abusive. I asked him how he would expect a prisoner to be treated, and he did not answer for awhile. We both sat until the cement froze beneath our bottoms, and then he told me that he thinks different people have different ways of dealing with situations.
I have learned that this is what Jeffords says when he does not know what to say.
Today, the itching started.
First there is an uncomfortable tingling, like a cloud of bugs is gnawing at my skin. The itch creeps onto me like a spider perches on the wall. It hides peacefully on my blind side until its visage hits me suddenly and without preface. It puts me in a craze, and Fletch from down the corridor says that around lunchtime he can see my head start snapping back and forth in some possessed search for my conquerer. After that, I begin to tear at my own skin like I am trying to get underneath. I am scratching myself raw.
I have this feeling all the time now. It is an unsettling feeling that sinks like two stones in the pit of my gut, except that they are abrading against each other as they go down. My chest is weighted down like a barbell and my mind does not know what to do with itself.
I think this is how it feels to be afraid.
We call the people who have stolen us Keepers because of a saying that Boy used to use. I do not know much about Boy. I have only heard stories of him. Most of the stories are told to me by Cara. She is younger than me, but has been here for longer. She says that Boy was a sight to see, with eyes gray like heather and golden hair. There is a weak spot in the cement by the bars of his old cage, and he would wriggle out of his cell at night through a hole he'd dug out with his nails. He would run back and forth down the corridor, and with the fervor he ignited he might as well been a steamroller smoking and screaming. He went dancing and leaping about and causing a racket. It would worry the rest of them, Cara told me, because they were all afraid that he would get caught. But Boy was reckless and unafraid. When the Keepers would come in, he would scramble back through the gap and pretend to be asleep at the far end of his cell.
On good days, he would find trinkets on the table near the door. Ones the Keepers forgot to take with them on their way out. A ring of keys. A paperclip. He would sneak his loot back to the hole after he had picked the room clean. "Finders keepers, losers sweepers," was what he liked to chime. Cara says that overtime everyone took a liking to his rebellious activity. They cheered him on when he took the floor, rallying behind him in a staggered frenzy, voices echoing wildly throughout the chamber. One night they were heard, and Boy was not fast enough to get back into his cage. He was dragged by the neck to the doors, his own voice battling a chorus of furious shouts, and then he was gone.
It is a sad story, mostly because I would have loved to have met him.
Cara says that it is gloomier now because there is no one like him here anymore.
There are a few of us in the prison who like to keep things nameless. I am thinking it is because they like maintaining a certain degree of separation. I do not. I do not like the anonymity. When somebody has a name, it helps me to remember who they are and what they have told me, and the memories I have made with them. If there are no names, then there is nothing to grasp onto.
I do not know much about the Keepers themselves. All I know of them is what I have experienced firsthand. And that is only a fleeting memory. I recall standing in the center of the street, sunlight pulsing over the asphalt in waves. I was out for a jog alone. The village was empty-or so it looked--and people were packed up in their houses, because it was Christmastime and around Christmastime, everybody wants to be inside. But I liked the outside. I liked the chill that slapped between my eyes on a windy afternoon. There is also the fact that I could not have gone inside, even if I did want to.
A blue van climbed the shoulder of the road and rumbled to a halt. Two men in black caps got out, wielding ropes of various sizes. They were talking loudly, fog clouding from lips like breathed fire, which I remember. It was like they were speaking through microphones. They were laughing, and swinging the ropes in their hands. I thought nothing of them until I realized they were coming towards me. Then I ran. I reckon anyone would have if two strangers were coming towards them with a roll of twine.
After that, it is all a blur of hands and hair being yanked from my body, and the cries coming from my own mouth like those of a wounded animal.
I am told I am supposed to be best friends with these kinds of people. I do not have a clue as to why. I can not imagine any of the Keepers having any friends at all.
Today, Boy came back.
I knew it was him right away, mostly because he had eyes gray like heather and golden hair. There was an unruly grin on his black lips, and he was unbound by ropes. He bore a silver chain around his neck and an air of intrigue. All of us prisoners were drawn huddled right up to the bars, eyes magnetized. I heard questions about where he had been, and why he was here.
A whisper grew to a muddle of yells and shouts; contagious and uncontrollable, even as we tried to tame our own crescendo. The Keepers had brought Boy in; two of them were walking behind him.
And suddenly, in the climax of our excitement, the Keepers stopped walking. "This one's here to join us again, fellas," one of them said, though I am almost sure I am the only one who heard. The Keeper who had spoken thrust his key in the old lock and chinked it ajar, beckoning to Boy. Then he knelt down and made a sound between his teeth. Like the sound the wind makes before it slaps you between your nose on a windy afternoon. He said, "Here, Boy."
Boy's hair stood on end. His head jerked to the left. His grin morphed into a snarl, and a thunder came up from deep in his throat until his voice quaked. He begin sprinting back and forth down the corridor. A big ruckus. The Keepers tried to catch him, anger swelling in their chests. Everyone else was cheering him on, and I could feel myself joining them, as if it was something I had always done or wished to do.
Finally, the Keeper called Doris caught him around the neck. After that, it was all a blur of hands and hair being yanked from his body.
Boy did not give up like I had. His limbs flailed persistently, a guttural sound howling from deep in his chest like that of a wounded animal.
Then his voice died, as quickly as the breeze slaps you--a mistake, surely--neck snapping in the meaty fists of the Keeper.
Gone.
Doris was stunned. He let out a perturbed cry, face ghostly as he dropped Boy's limp body. Everyone was shocked. Doris fell back, cussing under his breath. The Keepers spoke quickly in hushed tones before retreating behind the double doors.
And then it was done.
We all stared at Boy for a long time. None of us could speak. We waited for the Keepers to return, because they were the ones who told us what to do, and for once we could not remember how to act of our own accord. We waited for longer than I have ever waited, until two Keepers I have never seen before bustled into the room like there was something they were keeping secret. One of them was holding a trash bag. The other one picked up the body and put it inside. The first of them walked over to my cage, abandoning the bag on the floor. He reached his hand through the bars and brushed my head with his fingers, chin clenched tight. His face was stony. I was still. I could not remember what to do.
"Good Boy," he murmured, and then I knew.
Points:
Time spent:
IP address:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
First of all, to my understanding, iron is not an alloy. Iron has several alloys.
Secondly, it was superbly written. The narration was simply brilliant and I think I even learned a few things. I think your experiment with the narrative voice is a success.
Now let's get to the plot and characters.
You gave the plot a thin veil of mystery, which I consider a smart move. You started building a dark theme with a solemn-toned narration. But I have to say it didn't blow me away. I am a huge fan of dystopian civilizations and this didn't promise anything original. That's my thing; I want original.
The plot felt lacking. The characters seemed eggshell thin. There was a very clinical and plastic feeling about the whole experience. And not in a good way.
But, again, it's a personal prefernce thing.
what is the story about
How is it even possible to have -2 reviews?
idk
A worthwhile experiment, no doubt--one I'm a little iffy about.
On the one hand, it's definitely ambitious, much more ambitious than anything I've read in the past week. While the message sent isn't necessarily clear, it is telling the reader something, and I think that's what elevates a work from just ambitious to actually good; it informs the reader in some way. At the very least, it definitely informed me in a way. Especially considering the prevalence of animal-perspective stories with dark undertones (*ahem* Animal Farm *ahem*), I think this actually makes a good effort in separating itself from the genre, making itself more unique by showing new perspectives, leaving lots of gray areas for the reader to explore. Are the Keepers cruel psychopaths, or are they just doing their jobs? Was Boy a model for his friends and species, or was he another charming slave to the humans? And probably the best and most subtle message sent out: what's in a name?
But on the other hand, it's also very flawed. The pacing is iffy, there's not much introduction to characters, things happen without much warning, and the story doesn't feel like a story as much as it feels like a summary of a story. Events don't happen, as much as the main character tells us they happen--you get me?
So let me start with,
Style and Depth
I mean, look at this:
This is from your story, and there's nothing wrong with the style. However, look at this:
In the completely crazy part I've made, the reader feels more a part of the story than the above, because there's no medium between the reader and the story. The reader is hearing Jeffords words directly, and they're confident that Jefford is a real character with real feelings, because they're reading from him with their own two eyes. When it comes to the main character just telling us about a character, we have a harder time believing that Jeffords is a real character with real feelings, because there's more mediums separating Jeffords and the audience. Same goes for the rest of the story. For a good portion of the story, we don't see events happen, the character recounts events to us.
I'm actually iffy on this point, because while I prefer the latter, I know that in a way your own style has its purpose for being more The Narrator Tells Us What Other People Say--because the narrator is a dog, and all the other characters are also dogs. Only humans get to have English dialogue, and that actually makes sense. But the problem arises when it comes to humanizing these creatures, because, let's face it, dialogue is a great humanizing factor; losing it means that one has to support it with other factors.
So no, you don't have to take my route of writing if you don't like. But you have to make a way so that the audience feels closer to the story, regardless.
For example, the description of Scoundrel. You mention how the Scoundrel had a family before falling into the Pound, which immediately set off bells in my head, because it shows me something that the Narrator Tells Us What Other People Say usually doesn't have--depth. The feeling that there's much more going on beneath the surface of the story than what's actually there. Where did Jeffords come from? Did Jeffords have a family of his own beforehand? Why does he like conspiring theories? How long has he been in the pound? And on the topic of Scoundrel, what was his family like? Why does he miss them so much? How long has he been in the Pound? The Keepers, do they have their own little habits that seem weird to the narrator? Do they eat on the job? Do they talk about ludicrous things? Do they enjoy playing cards in their leisurely hours? Things like that that would suggest that the people/dogs of the drama are more than just characters from a story, words on a piece of paper. The Narrator already tells us a lot of cool little details (which I'll get to in a minute), so I thought it'd be great if you actually had details that built characters and the setting itself. I want to be able to reach my hand into the story and feel the depth.
With that said, you don't have to use this method on every single character. Especially in this story, that could actually be counterproductive. The story of Boy, for example. I don't need to hear about Boy's past or what he's like or how long he's been in the Pound--because Boy isn't supposed to be your average, three-dimensional character. He's a symbol. He's a position. He's the rare instance of an interesting one-dimensional character, the character with no name. The symbol.
Which brings me to my favorite part,
Theme
The theme is simply smart. The delivery is actually genius.
I'm not even exaggerating on this point, this is one of the rare YWS stories where I had to sit down for a minute and actually think about what the author is saying. And I may have gotten it wrong, for all I know I'm overthinking this, but if I'm not then you've just become one of my favorite writers on YWS.
So to sum up the theme in one sentence: What's in a name?
More specifically, what's the power of a name? What worth does it give a creature, a person, an inanimate object? Why is a name so important? I say this is the main theme of the entire story because of one thing that I ignored on the first few paragraphs that finally appeared in the ending, and hit hard--the fact that neither Boy nor the Protagonist has an actual name. Jeffords name defines him as old and wise, Scoundrel defines him as rowdy and troublesome, but what does Boy and the Protagonist have designated for them? Loyalty. Trust. A certain type of slavery.
When the story starts with the description of cages, it takes on a different meaning after the second readthrough--no longer is it a physical cage we're talking about, but a mental one. The cage of identity, designated by the same people who've put these creatures in their physical cages. Really, the entirety of the story communicates this one idea, revolves around it, but the reader never figures it out until the end.
The Protagonist has trouble grasping onto anything in the Pound. He starts scratching himself raw, he's paranoid that someone might come for him, he's desperately picking apart stories told by other dogs in order to make sense of his situation. And it's telling that he has no name. That doesn't mean the rest of the characters are well-off because they have names, but they at the very least have some sort of identity, something to hold onto. Scoundrel has the memory of his family. Jeffords has his conspiracies. Cara has the story of Boy, but the protagonist doesn't have anything clear to hold onto, he just tells whatever is on his mind, hoping it makes sense. And when he's finally designated a name in the ending, he suddenly understands why all those other dogs don't like the names. They're an entirely separate cage.
And none of this is said explicitly. That's what I loved so much about this work, it was all done with incredibly subtlety, the sort of subtlety you don't see nowadays. All of the ideas are planted and allowed to grow, but the reader doesn't notice, they can't notice, and that's why it's so shocking and eloquent by the end of it. It's actually quite refreshing to see a work that doesn't need to hammer it's message in.
So yes, if it stood solely on that message, I feel like the story would've been all well and good. But it didn't. It does not. It also relies on,
The Characters
This is relatively short as I touched on this in the depth section, but I'm still pressing it; while your concept is interesting, your characters are lacking. I'm interested in seeing how you could write Jeffords personality, I'm interested in seeing more of Cara's perspective, I'm interested in seeing the gloom and doom of Scoundrel, but that just didn't show up here. While the message was delivered, we don't really feel for that message because we don't know anything about these other characters or how they relate to the story. I feel as if the only other important character was Jeffords, and the story could've circled entirely around Boy and the Protagonist and it would actually be sharper and more concentrated than it is now. But as it is, the other two characters don't do much or say much, they just feel like a burden in the story--something I feel like they don't deserve to be. They could easily play roles in the story, build on the message and make more sense, but I felt like you missed an opportunity on that regard.
The Voice
Finally, there's the voice of the entire thing. I think this is what you wanted to talk about the most, because you said you intended to change up the perspective. I can tell you that the perspective is changed up quite a bit in all the good ways, though I feel like the voice could've been better executed. There are grammatical errors, of course, and I think you should run this through a proofreader to check that out, but besides that the work feels too robotic for its own good. The tone and voice feels hollow, empty, and maybe that's intentional. Maybe it speaks abut how the Protagonist is a hollow and empty vessel. But personally I don't like it, it doesn't easily convey the desperation the story has.
That's all I have for this work. Sorry if I couldn't help, but I mostly thought this story was cool. Expecting much from you later on.
Humbly,
--Elliot.
You're amazing. Thank you so much.
I love it! The ending is so good. "'Good Boy,' he murmured, and then I knew." It just made me want to know more. Even the format added to the story. The way there would be a paragraph and then that short line just made it so professional. Great job!