Hi papillote,
Mailice back with another review!
The presentation of John Graves is visibly successful. I liked how you started the chapter describing him as if Bitter was just picturing his appearance in her head and the story of the relationship as she then sets off to join him.
I liked that transition from her memory/thoughts in her head to fleeing her flat. Graves seems a bit stereotypical in terms of his character. He's neither this Good Cop or Bad Cop kind of guy, but this middle-of-the-road guy who does whatever comes to hand and also goes about it very calmly.
Unlike the other chapters, this one felt a bit bare. I think I once told you that I like the story because it reminds me of a series and jumps from chapter to chapter in such an episodic way. I didn't find that feeling again here because I missed the contrast. You were a bit too rushed in terms of pace and felt like there could have been more.
There were no conversations / dialogues and extended descriptions here, and I found that a pity. I would have expected Graves to bring Bitter to her senses a bit here, and maybe talk about good old times, or take time to eat his snack first, while Bitter then ponders why she bothered to seek him out in the first place, and maybe then splashes the coke in his face, etc....
I think you can definitely expand more here and give back that feeling I miss here, that typical way of your writing style.
Other points that caught my eye:
His square, cheap black suit, white shirt and reddish tie didn't really have a softening effect on his physiognomy.
I like how Bitter comes up with such "big" words now and then, and you have to think a bit about what exactly she has in mind. At the same time, it gives the reader this residual effect of having to think a bit about what he looks like.
Our relationship grew more sporadic as I learned to avoid reading or watching the news.
I like how you can interpret out here that Graves doesn't really care about anything except the news or generally has no interest that matches Bitter's.
I'd had to sneak out the backdoor of my building to avoid Mike Murphy, who was stationed out front. I tracked down the detective in the sandwich shop where he was having a late lunch.
I thought the transition here was a bit rushed and I think that just as vehemently as you portrayed Murphy in the previous chapters, this escape would not have been so easy. As desperate as he is, I would have thought he would have known about this back door and switched between the two doors every now and then. I also thought the way you got to the sandwich shop was a bit too rushed. It does show that Graves is predictable, and is probably always to be found there, on any given day, but there was also a lack of substance to me in how Bitter makes these conclusions.
"And so are you," I guessed. "Why?" My damn curiosity. "No, don't tell me. I don't care, it's none of my business."
Here I think you would have to restructure it a little bit because this change between dialogue - sentence - dialogue - thought - dialogue doesn't read well. I would extend it a bit, maybe insert that Bitter pauses before she asks and then gets a bit more lost in her thoughts and comes up with the answer while Graves is sitting there eating his fries with relish.
Have fun writing!
Mailice
Points: 0
Reviews: 1232
Donate