Warning: This work has been rated 16+.
The light was blinding when we got back outside, and I had noticed the breeze had picked up. “Scary as hell, that one.” I said, rubbing my arms.
“Eh, she warms up as you get to know her.” Mersh replied, starting the walk back to the house. I stood watching him for a second before I started following him, jogging a little to catch up.
“What’s her deal?” I asked, hoping to learn a little more. She was one of the only familiar faces in this town, I wanted to know more about her without Mersh getting on my case about it.
“She lived with her Mom, Dad, and her Grandparents. She was closer than anyone else to her Grandmother, and they spent all the time in the world together. She loved her parents and her Grandfather also, of course, but her Grandmother always seemed to be the best in her eyes. They would always spend time together and Audrey confided in her. Well, one year her whole family disappeared while she was at school, her house was left in ashes. She saved a lot from a bomb shelter that they had passed down for generations that apparently the law never knew about. Of course, this was five years ago, and records on people have improved greatly since then. It’s amazing that Audrey survived. But I think somedays she wishes that she died with her family.”
Mersh’s eyes were sad, his shoulders slumped from the heaviness of knowing and telling the story. I knew in this moment he was thinking about Aysia, what he would do if Aysia had to live through the same thing he had. I looked down, because I didn’t realize what kind of effect my job had on the friends of the families. But it was still the law, if someone murdered Aysia, he would want justice! That’s all we were doing, delivering justice. Audrey’s family must’ve been hiding illegal books, or some other crime. I still didn’t know if I would be able to look at her the same after hearing her story. I didn’t want to treat her differently because I knew.
My mind took me back to the day we first met, the way she acted when I said I was here a business and the fire that took place, it all made sense. It was a sensitive subject for her. I wonder if she couldn’t stand fire anymore, what if she fears it? I mean, most people fear it, but I don’t I crave it. I was itching to set another fire, to serve more justice. I knew I would have to be more careful now that some people knew me, especially because Mersh was living at my house, but I would find a way to do it. I’d be in a lot of shit if they found out about me, I’d probably get lynched or something. No knowing what people would do in a small town. Sacrifice me to a God?
I doubt it would be that extreme, but what if they started exposing me to the world? Maybe it would scare them into giving up those stupid books their hiding. What’s so special about these books anyway? What purpose do they give people? Why are they something something would even consider dying for? I just didn’t understand it. It didn’t seem like it was that significant to me, it’s just a bunch of fake stories, just a bunch of words, a bunch of paper.
We stayed pretty silent the rest of the way home, letting the other keep to their thoughts. Mersh raced to Aysia when we got home, picking her up and spinning her when he saw her. She giggled and laughed, and it made me smile-just a little bit-looking onto them. I went to the kitchen, grabbing a root beer and then going back to my room. I needed to check my laptop for emails such as updates from Jae. I took my shoes off, placing them by the edge of my door, and walked to my desk. The laptop glowed yellow when I opened it, the background brightness turned all the way up. I quickly turned it down, and my eyes relaxed a little bit. I pulled up my email, with five new emails. One was from Jae, the rest junk mail. I quickly deleted those and opened up Jae’s email. It read:
Mason
I need report by Monday. Report back every Monday. Have good time in Texas, work hard. I tell you if you have to burn house.
Jae
I rolled my eyes at his English, still needed work. I closed my laptop, sighing. I would start the report in an hour or so, I was just so tired for some reason. I walked over to my bed, plopping down on top of the covers. I was just gonna close my eyes for a second…
---
I gasped, clutching around me for a weapon to hit whoever was shaking me. “Mason! It’s me! Come on, it’s 7:30, we need to get going!” Mersh yelled in my ear. I sat up quickly, almost smacking my head on his. I rubbed my eyes, I couldn’t believe I slept for seven hours. I quickly changed into a black T-shirt and black jeans, trying to dress as fast as possible so I could leave for work.
Usually I wore suits to work, not clothing I would wear everyday. I guess all of this is just one big learning experience. Mersh watches me as I head out the door. He had offered to come along but I told him I would be able to find my way. I had Joshua drive me to the bar, and I arrived just on time. I looked at myself in the car mirror one time before going inside. The music wasn’t super loud but it was more turned up than it was earlier, and it was playing more club music rather than a radio station. The bass was turned up, making the floor vibrate. The DJ kept messing with the sound volume and different EQs, and I realized he was doing a soundcheck.
I walked over to the counter where Audrey was wiping down the surface. WIthout looking up she sighed. I wondered why she hated me so much. Did I say something wrong? Did she know my secret? I sighed as well, it was too much energy to try and figure her out. I just wanted to know what her problem with me was. She looked at me, raising her eyebrow, “You gonna stand there and stare or learn how to bartend?”
“Oh, sorry,” I said, walking through the small door that separated the counter from the dance floor and the work floor. I slowly walked towards her as she gathered various drinks and set them on the counter.
“Okay, so I’m gonna show you what most people ask for.” She said, shaking some drinks and pouring them into a cup. She put a tiny umbrella in it and some shaved ice and powdered sugar in it. “Say hello to ‘Lucky’,” she laughed at the thought, and I wondered if there were some memories to go along with the drink. She quickly stopped when she remembered I was standing there. “You got it?” she asked.
“Yeah, thanks,” I said quickly. She nodded, trading spots with me. I watched her face carefully as she continued to wipe down counters, and she didn’t seem to notice.
“Obviously, the other drinks are one’s that are already mixed or just beer and whiskey, and so on,” she looked up to see me looking at her, and even though I knew I should take my eyes off her I couldn’t, and it almost seemed like for a second she couldn’t either. My stomach flipped and I could feel something that I couldn’t quite describe. I felt like I was going to throw up but I also felt perfectly alright in that instance. I looked down first, not wanting to make her feel uncomfortable. I needed to regain my cool, needed to slow my heartbeat. I didn’t know what just happened between us but it was something I never felt before.
“Work starts now,” she muttered before leaving the counter to go to the front door and collect money from the groups that were starting to filter in. She smiled at them, took their money, pointed to the bathrooms and the bar, and motioned to the dance floor. The music was deafening now, the bass making the glasses shake. My first few costumers were men buying drinks for their girlfriends or someone they met, and then there were so many I couldn’t really keep track. The club filled fast for such a small town. I knew I shouldn’t but I couldn’t stop looking for Audrey, wondering if she had felt the same thing I had felt earlier.
But soon I had to focus on mixing a “Lucky” and pouring this guy’s vodka, and getting this girl and her friends a wine cooler, and so on. It was hard for one guy to do. I wonder if this used to be Audrey’s shift. I wonder where she was. Was she out on the floor dancing with someone? She was wearing a dress; maybe she planned on partying while I worked. I was only mad because I couldn’t watch her dance, or dance with her even. Why was I thinking about her so much? Even with the girlfriends I had in school, they were merely a distraction from all the shit going on at home. I had never really thought so much about them unless they were right by my side.
“Excuse me? Hello?” someone was yelling, snapping his fingers. God, some people and their nerve. I wanted to yell at him to stop ordering me around like I’m some servant that’s lesser than him, but I just smiled and asked him what he needed.
“A beer for this lovely lady right here,” he winked at the young girl next to him that looked like she was 18 or 19. She smiled, nervous yet excited at the same time. I wonder if this was her first time at a club. I grabbed a beer quickly, and slid it over to him. He put a five-dollar bill on the counter, and I quickly scooped it up. He opened the beer and gave it to the girl, and as they turned around he reached down and grabbed her butt. I almost felt sympathetic for her, but It’s her own choice to get drunk with that guy.
The hours went on, and it seemed to take forever before pretty much everyone went home. I was giving my last drink to a man on his way out, and Audrey walked up to me. Her eyes were dazed, her curly hair messy, and her dress seemed shorter. “Fun night?” I asked her. She looked at me and rolled her eyes, still smiling. She honestly looked younger than me, but not by much, maybe a year or two. Her eyes were a little glassy, and she came behind the counter.
“Give me a beer? Grab yourself one too. Sit down, you’ve been on your feet all night.” She giggled, pulling out a chair. “And no, I’m not drunk, just a little buzzed. I honestly don’t know why I’ve been so serious and rude to you every time I see you. I haven’t even given you a chance really, I’m just not used to new people in this town.” She looked at me, her eyes wondering. I bet she was wondering if I was annoyed by how much she was talking, or amused. I was definitely amused. She scooted her chair closer to mine, taking a drink of her beer. “How old are you, Mason?”
“Twenty-three. How old are you?” I laughed. I liked this side of her. I hoped she didn’t have to be buzzed to bring out this side, because I wasn’t gonna depend on her getting drunk to talk to me.
She smiled, raising her eyebrow, “I’m twenty one as of today,” she replied matter-of-factly, and it was my turn to raise my eyebrow.
“It’s your birthday today?” I asked, and she laughed some more, happy that I was amused and taken by surprised. She winked and nodded, looking at my lips then back into my eyes. I didn’t know what was about to happen, but her body language was giving off the impression that she wanted to kiss me. I suddenly felt very nervous.
“Wanna do something crazy?” She asked, looking at my lips again. I suddenly felt self-conscience, what did she think about my lips? My eyes? Was she looking at them because they looked weird? I chewed on the inside of my cheek, thinking. She lightly touched my cheek with her hand, “Don’t do that, you’ll hurt yourself.” She smiled and shook her head, her hand lingering. She slowly took it down, and sighed. “I should clean up and go home,” she looked at me one more time before setting her beer on the counter and hoping off the stool, walking away to clean the dance floor.
I wondered what she was talking about when she said ‘something crazy’; did she mean kiss? Or go somewhere? I took my mind off it, I was surprisingly wide awake as I cleaning the counter, throwing away empty beer cans and bottles that got left behind and washing shot glasses. My phone started buzzing, and I quickly pulled it out of my pocket to see Jae was calling. I slid open the lock screen and put the phone to my ear, wondering what he wanted at 3 am in the morning, but then I realized it would 5 am there, which was about the time he got to work.
Points:
Time spent:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Hello again!


I thought this was stronger than the last part. I agree with a lot of what Ark said and I'll try not to repeat too much of her advice
I think (and this is a theme of the other sections as well) that you tend to use a lot of extraneous detail. It's easy to do in a first draft as you're not entirely sure who the characters are and how the plot is going to unfold exactly, and that's fine. When you get ready to revise, I think it helps to keep the following in mind:
- what is the main focus of this chapter? In one sentence, what is the main thing you want to get across (if it's more than one sentence, it's probably too long).
- what critical things need to happen in order for that main focus to make sense?
- for each paragraph (or even each line if you have to) ask yourself what the purpose of it is. Does it move the plot forward? Does it illuminate a character? Does it show the world? Those are your three major categories. Anything outside of that, really think about if it's necessary to have at this point in story.
This should help you trim some fat and stay on point in the story. I feel like I'm getting a little distracted at times and I'm not sure what are important details and what are fillers.
Right now the voice and the tone is very reporter-esque. Like I feel like Martin is telling us the story and giving us the facts and there isn't a lot of feeling or emotion behind it. Ark mentioned that this feels like it should be in 3rd rather than 1st. I think putting it in third could be a good fix for you. First is really good for stories that are driven by the characters. First person needs lots and lots of voice and the personality of the narrating MC needs to jump off the page. It's totally fine if you want to keep this in first, but if you do, I'm going to need a lot more voice.
More info on POV can be found here. More info on bringing more emotion into your work can be found here. More info on avoiding unneeded information can be found here. And last but not least, more info on voice can be found here.
I'll leave things there for now, but please let me know if you have any questions or if anything I said was confusing!
thank you for all the really good points!

I don't know, like you said, first draft! second draft will hopefully be better
Hey, Lyl! I haven't actually read the rest of this, so I'll comment less on your overall plot and characterization and more on things that are pertinent to only this part.
All four of these sentences have the exact same syntax. Normally, this is something I might not comment on, but I have this problem in my own writing—it's so tempting to just write "Subject verbed, verbing something else too". It makes your descriptions of actions easier...but it gets really, really monotonous after a while. If you keep writing with sentences like these, a reader is liable to get bored because they all sound the same.So, let's start off.
Try altering your syntax a little—let me give it a shot. I'm going to change around sentence order a little bit in this "revision", as well as your dialogue tags—dialogue tags should always be connected to the dialogue by a comma, exclamation point, or question mark; periods are right out. That way, you don't have so much "Subject verbed, verbing something else", and you have a bit more personal narration from the first-person narrator. Obviously, you don't have to use my exact rewrite of the example, it's just something I pulled out to show you how you can change things around so they read more naturally.
You don't need to capitalize any of these—it's "her mom, dad, and grandparents". It's only Mom, Dad, Grandmother, or Grandfather when you're using it as a substitute for their name.
As for the dialogue itself—whoa, talk about block characterization infodump. If you have to explain this via another character, why include it at all? Characterization should show through the characters themselves; if she's regretting her life, then show it through her, don't tell us through Mersh.
Also, unless Mersh has this whole thing memorized, he probably shouldn't be able to just reel it off like this. In a normal guy's mouth, it would probably be more like "She used to live with her family, but their house burned down about five years ago." Then you can add something about her regret, but no normal guy is going to spout something like "her house was left in ashes" except to act as a bad title drop.
As for the rest of the chapter, your narration is extremely bland. Even when your viewpoint character is supposed to be feeling excited in some way, angry or defiant or anything, I feel...nothing. I'm not getting any kind of emotional response from the narration, and I honestly feel myself losing interest because of how emotionally distant it is.
Your punctuation is somewhat weak—I would recommend reviewing the rules of dialogue tags, as I mentioned above, and also how to use a semicolon. You're using commas where you should use semicolons or periods, and while that might work once in a while in first-person narration, it definitely doesn't work every few sentences.
You use five words to say things that only need two—"clothing I would wear everyday" can be shortened into "everyday clothes", or even "casual stuff" if your narrator is characteristically a little less uptight about their speech patterns. I think a lot of the emotional blandness comes from this, because it feels like you're padding out your wordcount by making the narration stilted. It feels like it should be third-person, not first-person, because the character isn't actually central to the narration.
To tell the truth, I'm not invested in this story, and it's not because I'm coming in three chapters late. The things I'm having trouble with are simple cadences and ways of speaking and narrating—it feels like you're shoving Shakespeare characters into teenage skins, and Shakespeare characters spoke like that because they had to keep to a certain rhythm, since it was all poetry. I feel no connection to your narrator or the other characters we see, and it feels like your dialogue serves as a way to exposit information onto your audience.
Keep writing!
wow, thank you, really.
I know I shouldn't make excuses, but I thought it was funny you mentioned that I was "just trying to make up the word count", because it's totally true xD Part of my nano, this is ;p
But seriously, thank you. I appreciate when people can tell me how it is and not dance around the serious critique! second draft will be 100x better, I promise.
thanks again!
Hey, Viv here to review.
It really does seem like Audrey hates him or is annoyed by his very presence. That's just wrong. But she probably has her reasons. Anyhow, onward to my 3 pieces of cool feedback.
1. "Sacrifice me to a God?" I don't think you need to make this a separate sentence seeing as it was part of the one before it. And since you are using the general term god and not the Abrahamic Faiths God you should lowercase the g.
2."Why are they something something would even consider dying for?" The second something is supposed to be someone. Poor Mason doesn't know the value of a word.
3."...setting her beer on the counter before hoping off the stool..." the hoping should be hopping.
This is probably the first time Mason has ever gotten in trouble for work, huh? He's new to this so Jae should really cut him some slack. If Audrey just turned 21 why was she working at a bar? I'm so curious to know who she was dancing with or for and what she meant by "something crazy". I'm happy Mason is developing a crush on her because he cannot go through life without developing a crush on somebody, that's cruel to the rest of the world that has suffered the heartache and heartbreak of crushes.
Still, this chapter was great, Mason's learning.
Hey, Viv here to review.
It really does seem like Audrey hates him or is annoyed by his very presence. That's just wrong. But she probably has her reasons. Anyhow, onward to my 3 pieces of cool feedback.
1. "Sacrifice me to a God?" I don't think you need to make this a separate sentence seeing as it was part of the one before it. And since you are using the general term god and not the Abrahamic Faiths God you should lowercase the g.
2."Why are they something something would even consider dying for?" The second something is supposed to be someone. Poor Mason doesn't know the value of a word.
3."...setting her beer on the counter before hoping off the stool..." the hoping should be hopping.
This is probably the first time Mason has ever gotten in trouble for work, huh? He's new to this so Jae should really cut him some slack. If Audrey just turned 21 why was she working at a bar? I'm so curious to know who she was dancing with or for and what she meant by "something crazy". I'm happy Mason is developing a crush on her because he cannot go through life without developing a crush on somebody, that's cruel to the rest of the world that has suffered the heartache and heartbreak of crushes.
Still, this chapter was great, Mason's learning.
so since this is set in the future, their age for drinking is 19, I guess I should probably mention that xD but thank you!