E - Everyone

The Scourge of a Sonneteer

PreviousNext

Fair muse, thou abandon me this hour…

My hand is lacking thine unrivalled grace.

The words, they elude, yet still I scour…

For cursed be prose I ooze at leaden pace.

Fair muse, why hast thee forsaken me so?

Thy songlike sleight I struggle to harness.

I plead, augur; sunder weal from wan woe

Ignite my soul and dispel this darkness…

.

Ere Lethe-lacéd ink doth choke mine art.

Tarry, why seems it like the worst is past?

Hast thee shattered the chains that bind this heart?

Thalia, sense I thy presence at last?

.

Patron poet and conduit of lore,

Seems thy sultry touch enchants me once more!

Comments & reviews · 2
Note: You are not logged in, but you can still leave a comment or review. Before it shows up, a moderator will need to approve your comment (this is only a safeguard against spambots). Leave your email if you would like to be notified when your message is approved.

User avatar
alliyah
Review
alliyah wrote a review · Sat Aug 09, 2014 2:23 am

Wow! Can I just say you have quite the mastery of old English word choice, I'm seriously impressed. Most of the time people attempt to do this they can't keep it up the whole time so there's a problem with consistency or it comes off really cliché or fake. You succeeded in really making this seem like an authentic good-old sonnet. Not very many people post sonnets on YWS, so I am probably not very adept at reviewing them, but I will give it a shot.

Wording & Grammar
I'm laughing at wisegirl's comment below about the words "being from the 1960's" .

Again let me just praise your word choice! You really must have worked very hard to not only have such controlled language but then also have the references to the "Lethe" river of Hades, and the Greek Muse of comedy "Thalia".
As far as grammar, I'm not familiar with sonnets enough to know whether the first line of every line must be capitalized, but if it isn't necessary I would suggest taking out some of the capitals that aren't necessary.

Really I only have two suggestions or differing opinions with your grammar choices.
1) I have an extreme dislike for the use of ellipses, in my opinion it makes lines seem unfinished and are distracting to the overall look of a poem what they add to the poem are a sort of feeling of longing or waiting for the next line. But in my opinion when you already have such a visually clean poem it's not worth it to have the ellipses. (Just my opinion!)

2)My second differing opinion is that ending with that exclamation mark seems a little premature and ill fitting to the rest of the sonnet. In the rest of the poem you are searching, pleading, questioning and then you are again enchanted by the "sultry touch" of the sonnet. It does end on a positive note but I'm not sure that it's quite excitement. The speaker doesn't suddenly feel the touch but they "seem" to feel it.

2.5) Another punctuation comment I have is that I'm not sure all three question marks are quite necessary, just something to consider as they are a little distracting and you really only need the 3rd one. They do help to separate each line though.

2.75)Just caught another punctuation comment: in line 7

"I plead, augur; sunder weal from wan woe"
this just seemed a little bit awkwardly punctuated, I would maybe suggest putting "augur" in quotes, or replacing the semi-colon with a comma.

This is definitely a poem that average reader will have to re-read a few times in order to grasp it's meaning, but after rereading it (and looking up a few unfamiliar spellings) there isn't anything that is really impossible to figure out. The only line that leaves me a little more confused is "Thalia, sense I thy presence at last?" If Thalia is the Greek Muse of Comedy then is this line just foreshadowing the positive ending? or is there something else humorous that I'm missing?

You even did a lot of good work with alliteration.

Form & Other Suggestions

So by the rhyme scheme I gather that this is an English/Shakespearean Sonnet, and you keep this rhyme scheme perfectly my favorite rhymes were "scour" & "hour" and "lore" & "more". None of your rhymes seem forced either.

Wonderful job keeping form! Really no complaints here. :)

Overall Impression
What an interesting subject for a sonnet! My favorite line was when you "cursed" prose writing, because of it's "oozing"! :) I hope to see more sonnets from you in the future, because it was something different to read than the normal casual free-verse. Good luck in future writing!

~alliyah

User avatar
erilea
Review
erilea wrote a review · Fri Aug 08, 2014 7:51 pm

XeNITe, hello, welcome to Young Writers Society, and thanks for following me! As soon as my number of followers and following are equal, I will follow you.

Thalia...muse...unrivaled grace...why did you leave me NOOOOOOO...well, that's about it! Byezeez!

Hehe, just kidding. Okay, I liked the vocabulary, but was the "thee" and "thine" and all that really necessary? Is this from the 1960s? Actually, I don't know when people said those old-timey words, just really. With those words, the whole thing seemed old, like it was written a hundred years ago. If you were going for that, okay, but that's not really my style. I had to define seventeen words to understand, and only then did I understand the slightest bit. Thalia. I know Percy Jackson isn't the best reference here, but were you going for Greek Mythology? Because it did say Muse, so I thought you meant the Ancient Greek one...

This was good, besides those totally unnecessary little nitpicks, and I think you have talent at sounding like a 98 year old man :D. Maybe try to sound younger? I think you might as well get the literary spotlight, you deserve it. Thanks for being online, have a wonderful time!

-wisegirl22

Okay, firstly, thanks for being the first to review! The archaisms were intentional, as it's the monologue of a poet who truly believes in the daughters of Apollo (which would be from further back than just the 60's :D) Another reason was that I needed to keep the meter (iambic pentameter, that is) watertight, and the occasional "thine" and "thee" did just that. Percy Jackson fan too, huh? :D I WAS actually referring to the mythological Thalia, the Muse of Comedy...the 'grace' bit was an unintentional inside joke! The spotlight would be cool, but hey, always room for improvement. Once again, thanks for the feedback, really appreciated...especially from a fellow demigod!

Hehe. I'm glad you appreciate it. I actually didn't notice the pun, but hey, awesome.



A true poet does not bother to be poetical. Nor does a nursery gardener scent his roses.
— Jean Cocteau