Hello, My Friend!
First, I notice you're new, so welcome to YWS!
Second, it's a pleasure to meet you! I am Raven, and I’d like to review this short story using my Familiar method today! ...This pretty much just means I use a fancy format covering first impressions, corrections and recommendations, and highlights and reactions. So, let’s dive in, shall we? Heh heh heh…
What The Black Eyes See...
Ah, a grim yet explorative story. A callous and abusive narrator discovers a mysterious system of channels deep underground, exploring eagerly only to sink into fathomless depths with a tortured conscious, a broken body, and a glorious find just out of his reach. Let's get into the details though.
Where The Dagger Points...
I don't have much to put here! There are just a few things that I wanted to mention in good faith, absolutely free to take or leave.
As Keeper also mentioned, I think your paragraphs do run a bit long. Now there's nothing inherently wrong with that at all, but generally speaking, readers do get intimidated by huge chunks of text and it can be hard to pick out details when a lot is going on in one body. So for example, perhaps where the paragraph in the beginning starts talking about the change in the tunnel, then again where it talks about the effort that's gone into digging it, these could become separate paragraphs. That way it's set up in a way that will have your reader going "and then what? and then what? and then what?" with each break, constantly drawing curiosity and excitement about what happens next, rather than forming one big picture from a big chunk.
You do certainly use an expansive vocabulary with rare words. Honestly, you won't find me complaining; I love works where words like this are still used, like older literature. I think it gave the narrator a noble tone, which was very fitting, and it also gave the whole piece a very classy feeling, like a piece from Poe or Lovecraft. I would just say that you should be aware of your audience, especially on a platform for predominantly young writers. These terms may not be quite as engaging to people who are 13 to 25 (there are outliers on either end but that is the generalized average as far as I know). So if you're aiming to entertain a younger fanbase, you may want to use more casual speech, something that fits the character while still being easier to understand. But if you're looking for readers who like things old-school, then I don't see a problem with that at all ~
The second is a little more technical:
my body was pact tightly between the adjacent walls and my arms forced to my sides as my shoulders scraped the boundaries.
Possibly a typo, I feel like "pact" was an odd word here. Maybe you meant "packed" by chance?
But of course, this is just my opinion and I am not a professional, so please always take my advice with a grain of salt. Your story was lovely regardless!
Why The Grin Widened...
I like how right off the bat, with that opening scene, you are able to give us a clear and vivid idea of what our cast of characters will be like, particularly the narrator/main character:
After an especially lengthy lapsation of time digging in those tight corridors, the labourers had finally reached what I expected they would. I spent my time down there with them and watched them, observing with overbearing torchlight and a gathering impatience.
Standing there while others work, especially with details like how long and hard these people are working, and he can only be impatient about it. It's clear that greed is going to be a prominent and consistent trait for him. Especially when you read on and he goes into detail about the abuses he's resorted to.
But finally, the dirt and stone was parted to reveal exactly what that man had prognosticated, a sodden and stygian tunnel created of heavy grey bricks and slabs boasting all sorts of cracks and leaks.
The damp air and the unilluminated abyss accommodated kindly for all sorts of strange fungi, arrays of moss-riddled surfaces, and coatings of slime, and supplemented by sundry things that crawl.
I loved your descriptions! Not only do these lines create a rich and finely detailed visual, but sensory notes like "damp air" and the prior mention of vapor in the tunnels also give it an immersive feeling. I would even say, for a place like this, you could have probably amplified the sensory notes with mentions like bringing up the smell of moss, damp stone, and leaf mold (fungus), maybe earthy minerals so dense that you can taste them in the air. It's something that I think would be nice, but not necessary enough to put in the recommendations section, haha. You did a great job already.
As you narrate this man navigating his way through these complex tunnels, I find myself absolutely engrossed; each new detail around every corner. Some ways looking more dilapidated than others, some more inviting than others, some threatening his torchlight or pinching him with their small space; it constantly leaves you wondering what's next and if he'll find himself stuck (oof, claustrophobia-inducing!)
I peered down into the chasm, a shoot so lavishly denying all geological precedent. The conclusion of a structure carved and shaped intellectually over geographical errancy was becoming all too clear, the blooming channel of thought twisting amongst my psyche, searching for recognition and consolidation, but being inanely rebuffed and rejected with confusion, madness, and fear; all in approximate measure.
Ooo, I loved this moment! The manifestation of a deep pit usually doesn't end well in these eerie stories already, but the way you describe it so finely here, like just looking at it seems to warp his senses and instill those sense of confusion and madness. Again, a very Poe-esque or Lovecraftian element that I really enjoyed!
I liked you repeated use of "falling" when he inevitably goes down, I felt like it put a lot of emphasis on that feeling and raised the tensions.
The impact shot through the entirety of my body. First breaking the legs, then the cascading shock bolted up my vertebrae and ricocheted through every bone, muscle, and ligament.
Incredible job describing what that would feel like! Ouch!
Perhaps that was my punishment for all my misdeeds. Yet as only my own foolishness? Willed by something maybe.
I loved this character moment, like this near-death experience forced him to reflect, and he knows his actions have been terrible but a mixture of greed and overzealousness just took control and couldn't let him stop. It's a very interesting point to think about.
The way you narrate him crawling in the dark with broken bones and bloody fingernails -oof! Brutal! (but I freaking love "brutal" in these stories! >:D ) And the mysterious pull of a "divine force" gives such a sense of hope and mystery, like an angel in the dark -or a trick of this place and the narrator's fading strength and consciousness. And of course...
Yet, to my dismay, it faded with the littlest haste, the essence of boundless holiness slowly fading and seething away from me.
And so I was left there, in silence and nothing, sitting on that icy pavement, dying.
The sense of hopelessness in that ending is glorious, a brutal yet poetic sense of justice. He abused his power and influence to find something amazing, and just as he found it, it fades away, leaving him to contemplate his mistakes as he suffers a slow and miserable demise.
Our
Overall, that story was absolutely AWESOME! I loved the genre and the themes you chose, and you nailed every moment just beautifully. I would love to read more from you! Nicely done!
Points: 84109
Reviews: 407
Donate