The Goat

by SubSubLibrarian

Published October 20, 2018

E - Everyone

In Miscellaneous Stories

Anna tossed a few more letters onto the bulging pile of mail and sat down at the other end of the table. The letters and bills at the bottom of the pile were already two weeks old and still unopened, despite her mother’s nagging. She sighed and let her head drop into her open hands. Someone knocked on the hardwood door. She groaned and hesitated for a moment before rising from the bench. It took her a minute to recognize the man standing before her. He was tall and thin, well-muscled, but scraggly too, and he had gray whiskers poking out across his jawline. His eyes were bright, blue, and kind of bloodshot and the skin around them was wrinkled and thin. His hair was thinning and gray and touched his eyebrows. If things had been different, she would have smiled at the old man, but as it was, she just stood in the doorway, staring.

“Sorry I couldn’t stop by sooner,” he said in a rasping voice. “I’ve been awful busy.”

Anna composed herself, stood up straight and took a step back into the house, motioning for him to come inside. “It’s fine. I haven’t really been in the mood for visitors anyway.”

The man looked around the kitchen. “So, you got everything, eh? Your grandma left it all to you?”

Anna nodded. “Yeah. The house, the farm, the business. I got the whole burden.”

The man looked at her intently. “How are you holding up? You’ve always been tough as nails. Just like your grandma.”

“It’s been hard. I have no idea how Grandma did all of this, took care of everything and still had time for life and children. I don’t think I can do it.”

“Do you want to do it?”

Anna frowned. “What do you mean?”

“I knew you when you were a little girl. You always had big dreams.”

“I don’t know. I never accounted for something like this when I was a child.”

“You know you don’t have to do it.”

“I know, but that doesn’t help me. It would feel so wrong to leave. But it wouldn’t feel right for me to stay here either, wishing I could be somewhere else. I don’t want to do something just because I feel like I owe it to Grandma. But I do owe it to her, and I can’t just let it go.”

“You need to choose soon. All those fancy colleges won’t wait forever. I expect that’s all from them?” He pointed to the pile of mail on the table.

“Most of it. My mom keeps telling me to decide, but she acts like it’s so easy, like it’s not the most important choice I’ve ever had to make.”

“You forget, your mother has had to make hard decisions too. Hard decisions need to be made even more than easy ones. And sometimes hard decisions aren’t as difficult as they seem.”

“I know, I just can’t yet.”

A quiet fell over them. The old man’s expression was curious as he looked at Anna. Anna stared at the ground. A shout and another knock on the door broke the silence. Anna opened the door and a young man in dirty jeans and a t-shirt stepped just inside the doorway.

“A goat’s missing,” he announced. “We need you Mr. Owen. I’m really sorry to interrupt, Miss Anna.”

“No, it’s fine, John,” Anna responded, crossing her arms. “What can I do?”

John paused. “We’re going out in pairs to find him. You can come, if you want. Mr. Owen will need a partner.”

“Okay,” she said. She took a deep breath.

Anna and Mr. Owen followed the young man into the yard and through the gate, into a green pasture where a group of Anna’s employees waited for them. Mr. Owen stepped took charge. “You all have your whistles? Good. Bill and Ashton, I want you in the East. Al and Larry, you take the West. Mikey and John can take the North and Anna and me will go South. If we don’t find this goat by sunset, everyone come back to the farm. Let’s go.”

The group broke up and Anna followed Mr. Owen into a forested area of the property. “Do you think we’ll find the goat?”

Mr. Owen shrugged and pushed through the brush. “There’s a fence in about half a mile that circles the property. The goat’s got to be somewhere on this side. I just hope we’ll find him alive. If a coyote got through the fence, he might have found dinner.”

“All this fuss over one goat. Why?”

Mr. Owen smiled. “It’s what your Grandma wanted. She ordered all of us to do this every time an animal went missing. She loved this farm and every creature who shared it with her. She was quite the lady.”

“I wish I could be like her,” Anna said.

Mr. Owen laughed. “Child, you already are like her. You can do anything. Do you think college is going to be easy? If that’s why you want to go, then you might want to rethink it.”

A sharp whistle sounded twice. Mr. Owen stopped. “They found the goat and it’s okay. See, sometimes it’s not so hard as you think it is. It doesn’t usually take us long, but we still plan for the worst. And you’re never alone. If you were, it could take forever to find a goat.”

“You’re right, Owen,” Anna said. “The hard decisions do have to be made. I have always wanted to go to college, and who would I be if I gave up my dreams? I’m going to put you in charge of the farm. Grandma trusted you enough, and so will I. I can go to college and take care of the business. I don’t have to choose between them. I can be like Grandma.”

Comments & reviews · 2
User avatar
alliyah
Review
alliyah wrote a review Review · Oct 28, 2018

This story definitely reminded me of the story of Jack and the Beanstalk - where at the beginning Jack is forced to sell his beloved cow for his family, but instead trades it for beans. This story ended a bit more happily though.

Overall, you did a nice job editting the story, I could clearly follow what was going on as Anna goes through this decision making process. I wonder though if there could have been a bit more at the beginning to establish the main character. I didn't necessarally feel like I had too much sympathy for her situation just because I didn't know all that much about her you know? Mr. Owen's character could have had a bit more in terms of introduction and characterization as well.

Your dialogue lines seemed to be natural and easy to follow though and that was about the bulk of the story.

You might try incorporating more symbolism in the piece too if you go back for an edit; and don't be afraid to pull at the heartstrings by going in more depth about the emotional aspects of the plot too! :)

Good luck in your future writing!

~alliyah

Happy Review Day from Team Hocus!

User avatar
rosette
Review
rosette wrote a review Review · Oct 27, 2018

Hey there, SubSub! (Hope you don't mind if I call you that).

It looks like we've got a sweet and simple story here: Anna's grandma died, thus, Anna is left in charge of the farm - though she wants to go to college - and, after a talk with Mr. Owen and an experience with a goat, she comes to a decision.

So, it read a little bit like a fable to me, in that there's a moral-of-the-story sort of thing - with Anna, at least. I like that, and I like the setting of this. It felt a bit old, like it was set some years ago, due to the whole farm scenario and their names (Anna, John, Bill, Larry, etc.) I'm not sure if that's what you intended, but that's what it felt like.

Anyhow. This stands as a short story, which is great and all, but a few short story elements seemed to be missing from here. For example, we never get much of a connection with Anna. I just felt as if I was being told a story and I couldn't empathize much or relate because I didn't have sufficient details. I think it'd be great if you'd elaborate more on Anna's grandma and her death, and how much it affected Anna. She seems sad about it in the story, but not heartbroken, and considering her decision at the end deals with how she views her relationship with her grandma, I think more emphasis should be put on that part of the story. Since her decision also involves college, that whole problem should probably be amplified, too. It's totally okay to make this story longer, and I kind of think you should. This felt a bit too abrupt.

Oh, yes, and the goat!
The title of this story made me think it was going to be all about a goat, but that didn't end up being the case. The goat was barely mentioned, actually, and (oh boy, I'm about to say it again) I think you could have elaborated on that a bit more. It just all happened so... suddenly. The goat ran away, Anna and Mr. Owen walk out, Mr. Owen talks about, sharp whistle sounds, and boom. Lesson is learned.

Speaking of Mr. Owen... I'm still kind of confused about who he is. He seems like such a nice, sweet old man, but what's his connection to the family? That was my question in the beginning and it only heightened when Anna decided to leave him in charge of the farm at the end of the story. (That was a big decision to make after only a little talk with Mr. Owen - though, maybe if we knew him better it wouldn't be that weird??).

But it was a sweet moral of the story. I like happy endings. :]

Thanks for sharing this story, SubSub! Hope I didn't sound too criticizing, eek.
Have a great one. :D

~rosette <3

Thanks rosette! I'm glad you took the time to read and review my story! Have a great day!



Mr. Scorpio says productivity is up 2%, and it's all because of my motivational techniques -- like donuts and the possibility of more donuts to come.
— Homer Simpson