i'm looking for someone who can really rip through this and junk. Tell me what's wrong with it and where I need to fix it not just conceptually but grammatical wise too. So if anyone out there is willing too please contact me!
Allen Gideon crouched before his son and with tender hands brushed the long dark hair out of his eyes. In normal circumstances he was a man who despite his age looked young and lively; but now, the crow’s feet he’d developed from years of smiling had deepened from worry, and his warm welcoming smile had turned into a thin lipped grimace, and his dirty blonde hair, once spotless, had developed notable streaks of white.
“Arthur,” he said “in the back of this closet there’s a secret door built for emergencies. As soon as I close this door, I want you and your brother to escape. Follow the passage and it’ll lead you to a street a couple of blocks from here; your suitcases are hidden by the exit. Go to the train station and take these Ids. You’re going to live with some relatives. Wait there a couple of years, and they can’t charge you with anything.”
While gripping the hand of his little brother Michael tightly, Arthur smiled bravely and nodded, in spite of the circumstances. Allen smiled and swooped both boys up in to a tight bear hug. Michael burst into tears and Allen calmed him with another smile.
“Don’t worry Michael, you’ve got a bright mind and a bright future ahead of you,” he said and wiped a tear from the young boy’s eyes. “And Arthur you’re the man now, I need you to take care of your brother. It’s a tough world out there and in order to survive you’ll need each other.” Arthur tried to keep a brave face but even he was having trouble keeping the tears at bay.
Allen gave his sons one last hug before he shut the door. The darkness drove into them, and all that remained was the fading footsteps of their father, and the rim of light drawing a box around the door frame. Michael tugged Arthur’s shirt towards the back of the closet where the secret door was but Arthur resisted. The closet was upstairs and they could hear everything going on below. There was a loud bang and a terrible wrenching noise as someone ripped open their front door. Raised voices, crashes, and footsteps echoed across the door. Arthur opened the door a crack and saw several soldiers surround his father holding machine guns. Allen Gideon didn’t budge or look scared; his expression was passive and even carried a confident smile as he stood casually with his hands in his pocket. The men with guns spread apart to make a path for a handsome man dressed impeccably in his military uniform with five gold stars on his chest that labeled his status as a General. The General resembled every opposite of Arthur’s father with his raven hair cut short and his serious demeanor. Though the man had a critical advantage on Allen, he did not smile.
Allen spoke first, “Sergeant Corbet you’re a General now, congratulations. How much butt kissing did you have to do to get there?” General Corbet’s face remained passive and Allen continued smiling.
“Everything’s a joke with you Gideon,” said Corbet “That’s why I’m standing here and you’re standing there.”
“I’m standing here because I have a spine,” Allen replied. For a second the General’s face flash with rage but it was only a ripple in a calm sea. The General’s demeanor demonstrated the quiet calm before a storm, and that alone said a lot about how dangerous he was. Allen clapped his hands and the earth beneath them turned to mush, in which all the surrounding soldiers sunk waist deep into the ground. Corbet responded quickly with a snap of his fingers and a torrent of water shut up from the earth drowning the trapped soldiers and would’ve done the same to Allen had he not summoned a pillar of earth to elevate him above the flood. Corbet rode a wave that lifted him up to Allen’s level, which put the two of them out of Arthur’s view. The wave caused by the General rose up to the top floor forcing Arthur to shut the door; yet, a trickle of water still managed to slip beneath the threshold.
Arthur wanted to step out and see more of his father’s epic battle with General Corbet but Michael was still persistently tugging at his shirt. Arthur took his brother’s hand and led him through the trap door and out into the tunnel beyond. The water had gotten worse by then and was waist deep by the time they left the tunnel, which led out into the sewer. Arthur took one final look back in the direction of his father before opening the sewer port hole and letting in the grim light of the day…
The Grand Central train pulled into the station its engine pumping huge clouds of steam onto the platform. The Steward coughed as he took the tickets from the two grim looking boys in front of him; the older boy held his brother’s hand tightly. He checked their Ids which read, Erick Woodman age 11 and Sean Woodman age 9. He asked “You boys going to,” he checked the tickets “Mill town?”
“Yes sir,” replied the older boy Erick. “We have family down there.”
The steward nodded and permitted them entrance on to the train. Arthur accepted their fake ideas when the steward handed them back to him and he led Michael into one of the compartments. The steward was nice enough to load their suitcases into the item storage for them. Before he left the steward informed them that if they needed anything all they had to do was ring the bell and someone would be there to help them. Arthur thanked the man who then returned to his job.
When the compartment door shut, it was just Arthur, Michael and the huge elephant in the room. Arthur was staring out the window when Michael spoke.
“The way dad spoke,” Michael started picking his words carefully “it sounded as if we’d never see him again.”
Arthur nodded. The compartment shook as the train came to life and more steam poured onto the platform outside. Arthur watched as the city scenery faded to green beyond the window as the train left the father behind, and left their home behind. Michael started to cry and, seconds later Arthur was crying too as he hugged his brother.
“If we’re going to make our father’s death mean anything,” Arthur said through choked sobs “our lives have to be for the sake of killing the man who broke our family.”
Michael gasped, “But we’re not strong enough.” Then he looked into his brother’s eyes and saw a passion so fiery that it burned bright red in his eyes. “Then we’ll get stronger, Michael.”
Points:
Time spent:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
*moved to Fantasy Novels*
hey thanks naplemaster. YOu pointed out somethings that I didn't even noticed in the revision stage. Any way my novel is called The magician's War. It's in the fantasy section. So far I have two chapters up and i've revised the first one so please I'd really appreciate it if you took a look at it and tell me what you think. I don't care how hard anyone rips at it as long as I'm getting some feed back. The more red ink on the paper the better. I"m gonna finish this one.
True about the wrong section, but as it's here...
First, I have to say that the characterisation of dad was very well done - the elements of his former versus his current self. I was also taken off guard when the 'soldiers coming for arrest' bit suddenly exploded into magical action. If that isn't a grabber first chapter, I don't know what is. Now, I don't do grammar, plot and characters. "Then what the heck do you do Napalmerski?" Sentence structure and basic internal logic, and in this case, only the latter.
Three basic things I'd like to draw your attention to:
1)view from the door - as the kids watch through the crack in the door, they see too many details. Unless they use some kind of magical sight, and it looks like this is not the case, tone down the details. Let them not see five stars of the general, but a small glitter, and have them know, deduce that there are five stars there. They don't see everything (otherwise everyone sees them) they see tiny bits and pieces and their minds fill in the missing pieces.
2)epic battle - having said that, the epic battle is too rushed style-wise. You can't just start with a room and then have water flooding, earth erupting, presumably the ceiling exploding upwards and stuff, and not describe it at least with half a sentence. As it is now, the moment the magic starts the room sort of dissapears and a conceptual fog takes it place, in which the drama unfolds. As a writer you have to put some stuff into that fog. We the readers, just like the kids in the closet, will fill in the rest if you give us some details, but you can't leave us without any. So, triple the size of the epic battle, not what they do to each other, but where this takes place, and how it affects the elements of where this takes place.
3) tugging at his shirt - the smaller kid is tugging at his bro's shirt and this is the motivation for the bigger one to finally turn and lead the way to safety? Naah, I don't believe it. I think you should reword it as something along the lines, that at this point the bigger kid realizes that the smaller one is still tugging at him and remembers his responsibility as the new man of the family.
There are some basic grammar issues which you yourself will see on a second reading, stuff like ID turning into Idea, etc., and one final thing: they accept too easily that father is dead without having actually witnessed it. Let them try to comfort each other that maybe he isn't dead, but feel gnawing doubt that they are deluding themselves or something.
All in all, a pretty snappy opening chapter, with enough hints about a magical steam-punk society (alche-punk? Steam & Sorcery? heh), obvious political issues being played out, and a biblical/folk story style escape of kids from some big evil. Good luck with developing the story
oh no that's okay. I just really need someone who can read my stuff for me. I'm gonna finish this one.
Don't delete it. Just contact a mod to put this in the fantasy novel section. Do you want me to help you?
oh then could a monitor delete it for me? My bad.
I believe this is in the wrong place. Advanced critiques are for books, usually added as an attachment. This is probably better suited to the fantasy section.