By the time Finnley’s mom took him home from school, the official school day was nearly over. At first, his visit to the dean’s office had been utterly boring: he didn’t care what the dean had to say about the school rules, and the dean didn’t listen when Finnley explained that the students were verbally attacking Mia.
Sylvie’s parents were there when he got out, so they all trooped back into the dean’s office and he was left alone in the waiting room, still angry at the other students for saying such awful things about his best friend. Although his mother had argued his case when she got to the dean’s, getting him off with just a detention, she had turned to scold him as soon as they stepped outside of the school.
“You need to know that it’s never okay to resort to physical violence,” she said for the fifth time within two minutes. She kept her eyes fastened on the road, though there was hardly a car in sight. Finnley chose to ignore her.
“I’m being serious!” she insisted. “What is this? You’re safe from magic and monsters now so you want to find trouble at school? Is this how Mia has been influencing you?” Finnley could tell by the stricken look on his mother’s face that she regretted the words as soon as they were out of her mouth, but she had already said them. And it made him push away from her.
“I am not ‘safe from magic and monsters’. They’re still out there! And by preventing me from learning further magic, you’re keeping me from the one thing that could actually protect me. None of this is Mia’s fault, and I didn’t get into trouble because she likes trouble — I got into trouble because they were saying terrible things about her, things that aren’t true.” Under his breath, he added, “Like you just did.”
She was silent for a moment, then said: “I think you should really think about visiting Dr. Lark. She’s still here, and will be for maybe a week. I hope that I didn’t call her up for nothing.”
Finnley groaned and his head fell into his hands. He couldn’t believe his mother right now. “Mom! You did call her up for nothing. I don’t want to talk with her. Allie’s death is too… too personal. Besides, what would she even say? That I need friends? I finally have friends, and they’re a monster hunter and a ghost, and you’re going to have to deal with that.”
His mother pursed her lips, then said quietly, “I’m trying to deal with it — really, I am. But just because they’re your friends doesn’t mean you have to get involved with all the monster hunting and ghost and magic stuff.”
Finnley remained silent. Maybe he hadn’t had a lot of friends before, but this was one thing he understood. Having friends meant that what they did was something that he was inherently involved in. More than that, he hadn’t chosen to get involved in the monster hunting. He had chosen magic, or magic had chosen him, and it seemed as if the monsters and ghosts and everything was caught up in that one choice. It became such that there really wasn’t a choice anymore. Everything seemed to be impossibly connected.
When they pulled into the familiar, cracked driveway to their home, Finnley started to unbuckle his seatbelt and his mom put her hand over his. He looked at her, and she met his gaze with warm brown eyes so unlike the pale blue ones Finnley must have gotten from his father.
“I want to make a deal with you,” his mom said quietly, as if it was going against her very nature to compromise with him. “If you meet with Dr. Lark, just once, and have a legitimate conversation about Allie’s death and your feelings and friends, then I will let you go back to Mr. Vaughn’s and learn magic. Not every day, mind you, but maybe twice a week.”
“Deal,” Finnley said instantly, and he realized in that moment how important the study of magic had become to him. It wasn’t just the magic though — he was still worried about the possibility of another magician. He had little evidence, but the idea was growing and growing in the back of his mind, gradually taking hold. He had no leads other than Uncle Henry and Mr. Vaughn.
His mother, still holding eye contact as if to make sure that he would really do his part, slowly nodded. She didn’t smile, but Finnley got the odd sense that the meeting with Dr. Lark was her first priority, and that she could work on stopping him from learning magic later. And that she knew he would resist it with all the strange, hidden parts of him that had fallen in love with the idea of magic.
“Bye,” Finnley said casually, closing the car door. As if it had been a normal conversation. He heard the car start up and back out of the driveway, carrying his mom back to work, but he didn’t look back as he unlocked the door to the house and stepped inside.
The ability to learn magic again opened new possibilities, but first he had to prepare himself to meet with Dr. Lark. An honest meeting. He was fairly certain that Dr. Lark wouldn’t conceal anything from his mom, and if she didn’t think that their conversation had been open and fruitful, then his mother wouldn’t consider their deal fulfilled.
He went upstairs to his room and closed the door, arming himself with a pen and paper. Slowly, heart thumping, he called up a single memory of Allie: there had been one day when she was playing basketball. She was younger then, and Finnley even younger than that. The ball had missed when she tried to shoot it, and Finnley had picked it up for her. She had enlisted him to rebound, but now she encouraged him to make a shot. Sloppily, with much arm flailing, he flung the ball into the air and missed the hoop by a mile. But Allie had just smiled at him, encouraged him to try a few more times, and told him that he had potential.
Finnley felt a little hurt in his heart thinking of that day. The memory was so old that it was fuzzy around the edges, but it was so strongly Allie. He wrote it down on the piece of paper as closely as he could remember it. Maybe if he did it slowly enough, he could have some honest things to tell Dr. Lark about Allie without it hurting so much.
Cautiously, he reached inside himself for another memory.
End of chapter
Continue to next chapter How Was Your Day? - Chapter 31.1Points:
Time spent:
IP address:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Hi, Querencia! Dropping in for another review.
This is a bit tell-y again. In what way is he angry? Find a way to show it through his actions.
Do you need the bold? Why not step deeper into the scene and just show her scolding him through the dialogue?
Hmm, Finnley seems so measured and reasonable here. It's a very formal response - I feel like he should be curter, snappier, maybe a bit meaner. It doesn't feel enough like a real argument.
This is why I wish Finnley's study of magic had been more integral to the plot. He says it's really important to him, but I don't really feel the importance because it's pretty much just been a hobby of his. It would be good if Mia's recovery, or maybe the tracking down of the magician who enchanted the horse, was key to Finnley using magic in some way. If that was the case, there would be a real and urgent reason for Finnley to want to be able to use it again. Just a thought.
Note: ah, I've just noticed that you mention the magician in the rest of the paragraph - good. Still, I would like the magician to feel a bit more like a concrete threat rather than just a suspicion.
If that's the case, she isn't a very good therapist. I've just had a brief scour of google to look at patient confidentiality laws and it does seem that they're variable across the US (especially where minors are concerned), but a therapist should offer discretion unless the parent absolutely needs to know what's going on with the child. Unless Finnley revealed that he was suicidal or hurting himself or otherwise in danger, Dr Lark would have very little reason to spill everything he said to his mother. Mrs Bale would probably have to ask her to, as well.
That's all for specifics. The very end of this chapter is nice, touching, but really quite sad as well - it makes for a good end. As far as the rest of the chapter goes, I think it's in the right ball park and more interesting than the previous one, but there are a few hiccups. I think the argument between Finnley and his mum could have more passion in it; it doesn't feel like a proper squabble at all, and once again your characters are erring on the side of being too reasonable. I'm also a little confused by this deal that they've made. The idea of Finnley finally unloading and talking about Allie to Dr Lark might sound grand and poetic, but I'm not convinced it's going to do him any good in the long run. Therapy isn't something that changes you overnight, even if you have a good session. Recovery takes a long time. It would be much more productive - and fair - if Finnley's mum asked him to return to weekly or fortnightly therapy sessions in exchange for him being permitted to learn magic again. It would require finding a new therapist, but given Dr Lark's track record with Finnley, that doesn't sound like such a bad idea...
That said, I don't know where you're planning to take the plot, so we'll see how it all pans out from here. This chapter was definitely an improvement, and I am keen to see how Finnley deals with talking properly about Allie to someone.
Keep writing!
~Pan
dang it I need to review this but I just don't have anything to sayomgosh is that a good thing or a bad thingI don't even knowPlease feel free to ignore my advice it is not meant to offend you hurt you or make your poem seem bad or demean it, however it is advised that you brace yourself for impact that said . . .
1.What I liked
Okay this somehow seemed deep to me. Was it because if that last sentence? I don't know either way I liked that about this. I think Finnly seems like a real character.
2. Flow & Style
It seems to me that you might want to consider redrafting this? It seems like there are alot of short paragraphs I found it hard to focus with so many short ones. Also the first time you use the word Dean to much. I think you should find a name for this dean so you aren't using the word to much.
3. Emotion and Characters
Other then those problems what this needs is more attention to your characters emotions. Okay you give us examples but it would help to bring it into the moment if you describe what he was feeling-for example his belly churned with nervousness etc. Also I think his mother could use some more character develoupment. She doesn't seem to have a personality or a character. Also please add Finnly's thoughts. Don't just tell us how he was feeling but what he was thinking when he felt that emotion.
4. Encouragment
This is pretty interesting. Nice story. Keep it up.
5. Overall
Overall I thought this was an interesting read.