Knackered Bloodfists

by Pompadour

Published April 11, 2015

16+

In Contests, Events and other such randomness~

Warning: This work has been rated 16+.

A/N: Far from satisfied with this, but here it is. For the ToC competition. It might be littered with errors, because I haven't had the time to proofread, but I'd like to work on this--and maybe expand it--later. ~P




You are one of those pesky human beings that appreciate ‘living in the moment'. It's a strange philosophy, but it appears to work—most of the time.

Your eyes are refusing to stray anywhere this afternoon, although the manager has told you that the sky outside is a clear scarlet, bold and beautiful. It is the busiest time of day, however, and you do not wish to displease her, what with the steady influx of Strangers from all over the city, popping in to ‘catch a bite', but staying on for more. There will be time enough to 'look at the sky' after the shift, you tell yourself. Time enough to get out of this uniform and go for a walk and look at the bloody sky just as I please.

Which, in layman's tongue, means there probably won't. There won't be any time and there won't be any walks. You've given in to the reality, however, and you know well that your Function lies here. Wren, the café worker. Wren, the simple-minded. Wren.

Just Wren.

And you're fine with that, honestly. Or that's what you like telling yourself anyway—but then he strides into the café every single day, the goddamn idiot ... and really, you can't help but get distracted.

Ding.

He arrives at a quarter past one, clad in red—government colours—and takes a table by the window. Table 46, with the finest view in the café, overlooking a brick wall.

You scowl to yourself, because yes, this is completely normal, but it still doesn't explain why he distracts you so. Strangers come from all over to see the Wall, after all; it has collected graffiti over the years, poems and crude words that are photographed and sent to the museum, to be hailed as works of art. Obscene gestures and wills, calls for revenge against the government, all sorts of things that are now taboo—it intrigues people.

So you are not surprised that the man always sits there, although he remains silent and contemplative—which is odd. You settle your chin on your palm and scrutinise him carefully, face twisted into a frown. His face is intense, impassive.... Most people find it hard to contain themselves when they catch sight of Godzilla, as you have taken to calling the Wall—not out of fondness, or fear, but because the word has been scrawled in large, yellow letters across its greasy surface. You are often wondering what it means, what ‘abortion' means, what a ‘i heart jessica' is ... and you wonder sometimes if life will ever allow you to leave the café, and find out.

‘People were once like that, you know,' most strangers say, pushing their spectacles onto their foreheads and grinning widely. ‘People actually thought Thinking was right, and that Services were wrong. It's criminality, on these walls, but it's artistic, isn't it? Although I think...' here the speaker pauses—always pauses, because you have heard these words a thousand times—and continues, ‘I think the government has left these walls up as a reminder.'

‘What would you like to order?' you ask, tipping your neon hat over to the customer with a smile. It's become a ritual: the strangers ramble on about Godzilla and you listen, but never asking any questions; then, you're supposed to ask them to place their order. It never changes, the routine, and you've grown used to it. But sometimes you wonder what it would be like if it were to change. Would the universe collapse? Would the Manager fire you and send you back to the institution, where children are raised to Comply? Or would the world continue with its steady pace, unperturbed by a crick in the cosmos?

Then—you remind yourself. Slapstick, Wren! Thinking is not allowed.

The man at table 46 has never placed an order.

*

He frowns at you as you skid over the marble floor, mirroring the manager's exasperated expression,—‘Can't you see the “wet floor" sign, Wren? Bloody kid.'—and grab the table to keep from sprawling on top of it. You straighten up hastily. The man does not look amused.

‘Er, top of the morning to ya.' You don't know where the greeting comes from just then, but it seems to be the most appropriate thing to say.

He grunts. You clear your throat.

‘What would you like to order?'

His eyes remain fixated on Godzilla, at a small patch of wall. You're an idiot sometimes, but you can tell that the man is ignoring you. You crane your neck, trying to get a clearer view of what he's looking at, but there's nothing there that you haven't seen before. Peeling paint, rust red, graffiti, swollen oaths. The usual.

You tap your pencil against the spine of your notebook. Sir? you mean to say. Your order?

Instead, the connection between your tongue and your brain breaks loose. ‘What's your name?' you ask.

He looks around, eyebrows raised. They're very fine eyebrows, you notice, as if drawn on with a pencil and shaded to perfection. His eyes are strange, too—very dark, like a Native. You've never really taken note of their exact shade before, probably because he always has this fez/fedora-ish hat pulled low over his face. But they're a striking ochre, with lines of orange nearer the iris. Incredible.

‘Waow,' you say stupidly. ‘Are you a native? I didn't know we had Natives in Government!' And you grin widely, because you're thinking, This is so cool.

His thoughts don't appear to be much similar. He actually looks rather bored, although he does sit up a little now, and look at you thoughtfully.

‘Yeah,' he says, ‘I am a native.'

‘Cool,' you say. And because you've already lost your inhibitions out of excitement, you go on, ‘You're a little laconic, aren't you?'

You swear his face twitches into half a smile—although you think you might be kidding yourself just a tad—as he leans back and taps his wrist against the table.

‘I've been told,' he mutters. ‘I wasn't aware it was part of your Function to chat to Strangers.'

You're miffed, but you decide not to show it. ‘It's not my function to chat to Strangers, but I can talk to Natives however I like. Anyway,' you say savagely, ‘aren't Natives supposed to stay out of the city? What're you doing dressed all in government red?'

‘None of your business,' he says easily. ‘I could tell you if you were to sit down, though.'

He knows his cards well, you think, glaring at him. It's against your function to sit with a Stranger—the last time someone tried that, the manager had them sent to the Outskirts, where the natives work in the mills. Before being exiled, you were whipped publicly and branded on the back with a ‘N'—for nescient. You have been witness to enough episodes in the last year, along with the rest of the common workers, and you have no desire to experience the same.

But then again, you've never talked to a Native before, either.

‘I can't,' you hiss, ‘sit down with you.' Suddenly, you realise how tremendously suspicious this entire situation must seem; you can sense the Manager's eyes boring into the back of your skull and you feel hot all over. What excuse will you make for standing here this long? ‘So sorry, Manager, sir, customer couldn't decide if the beef was more tempting with cheese or with mustard. Then he invited me to sit down so we could go over the technicalities of the order.'

Crappity crap crap crap. You fiddle with your neon hat and pretend to scribble something on the notepad. ‘Anything else, sir?' you say loudly.

He laughs, then stops abruptly. His gaze slides over to the wall again. ‘Yeah, you stay in the Common Dorms, don't you? Above this building?'

‘Hm,' you say, nodding. His eyes flicker to your own.

‘Then, Worker, if you're really that keen to find out who I am, you'll drop by the Wall sometime.' He smirks.

‘Hell knows I'd never slip out of the dorms,' you mutter. But his gaze is electrifying and you've spent too many days staring at this stranger—too many days to count. Why weren't you ever stationed nearer his table before? you wonder. Why have you been watching him for the last six weeks, wondering who he is, why he sits there, and why he comes to see Godzilla every day? It puzzles you, because you cannot answer yourself, and for the second time today, your lips form an answer on their own.

‘I'll be needing a name. If you're not there?'

His stare is gravitatious, ochre eyes dark and unwavering. ‘Narth,' he says, finally. ‘You'll find me at East End.' Raising his voice slightly, he continues, ‘I'll have a salad with that, if you don't mind.'

Behind you, you can hear the sound of glass breaking; cocking your head to the left, you see that the Worker at table 37—Shed—has dropped the dishes he was carrying, and stares at you openmouthedly. No doubt he'll be telling the Manager later—that the government bozo finally cracked and ordered something. You smile to yourself as you scribble on the pad; ducking your head as you leave, you mutter, ‘I'm Wren.'

Narth leaves before the salad reaches his table; you see his hat disappear as he stomps out the door—red coat flashing in the dusk.

*

You've often thought about the Government—although, admittedly, you've never voiced your opinions regarding it to anyone—and you think the system is quite flawed. History isn't taught at schools, but you know enough to scrape by: a couple of decades ago, society was completely remodeled—what it was prior to the remodeling, you don't know—and everyone was given a Function. The Strangers are the aristocrats, the royals, the people who have half-days at their office jobs and roam the streets of the city with their bald pates glinting in the sun. Like coins, you've often thought. The Workers are the people who supply goods to the Strangers; the Managers keep them in check. Institutioners are the teachers of sorts, and the Children...

Well, they're Children. But they're not many of them now.

You've often thought about a society without Functions—you're thinking about it tonight, as you slip into your pyjamas and wait for the Manager to make the nightly rounds. Your head hits the pillow as the whistle blows for the Workers to get into bed—but you will stay awake tonight.

Here's your chance at learning more about your world, Wren. Here's your chance. You'll be breaking tons of Functions, the punishments will be awful if you get caught, but you can chalk it up to sleepwalking again. Maybe spend the night in a dumpster and pretend you don't know why you're there when they find you in the morning...

You wonder if the sky is red at night.

*

Narth meets you at the east end of the wall, the end nearest the cafe door. You don't go out much, so this is quite the experience, and you relish the feeling of cold night air striking skin. But you're careful, making sure to wrap your face up in a scarf, and pulling your trench coat over your pyjamas. No mistakes, Wren.

‘I'm shivering,' you say, surprised, when Narth walks up to you, as naturally as though it isn't past midnight and you're simply out for a stroll. ‘My feet are wet and I'm ... shivering.' You wrap your hands up in your scarf and peer at Narth closely. His eyes are laughing.

‘People do get cold at night, yes,' he says, and his voice is much freer than you've heard it in the café. He nods at the stretch of wall before him; in the darkness, it seems to loom above you, at least fifteen feet high. It is intimidating. You realise that the piece of Godzilla you can see from the café is just that—a part of the Wall, and Godzilla is like a country on it. Far above ... you crane your head back at stare at the red, peeling paint, like wisdom peeling to the ground.

‘It's like the wall is withering with age,' you whisper, ‘and falling to the ground in clumps.'

'A lot more falls to the ground than just that, in these parts,' Narth says, sounding distant. There is silence, during which you scan the wall up and down, and look ahead at the slim passage between that and the café; it looks ominous.

‘Follow me,' Narth says.

You comply.

The walk doesn't last for more than forty minutes. Several times you wish to ask a question, but then you don't, because you are suddenly terror-stricken and confused. Halfway along, Narth takes a bottle of water and hands it to you silently. From his eyes it's quite apparent that he's made the journey several times: a dark alley spiralling straight along the side of the wall, a cramped hide-hole where the peeling exteriors of old buildings, café-houses and restaurants leave their grimaces. The wall is red, red, red. Functions are functions, functions, functions. What is red but a name?

Your thoughts are very jumbled up tonight.

‘Narth,' you speak quickly, as if desiring escape from your thoughts, their prison. ‘Narth, what was the city like before remodeling? Before functions?'

He doesn't stop walking, nor does he glance at you as he answers, but walks along with his hands in his pockets, tall frame silhouetted in the flickering neon light. ‘Life was different, I guess,' he says. ‘I don't remember much of it, because I was six when the new Laws came in, and I was sent to the institution soon after that. But ... it was a good life, what I remember. I played outside all the time; we had a house, not these facilities that people are divided up into. And people mingled.' He pauses. ‘It was very different, I guess.'

You nod. ‘Sounds different.' You wait for a while, then ask, ‘You said you were going to tell me ... why's a Native part of the Government?'

‘You know the whole story behind Natives, kid?' Narth says. He slows down and falls into step beside you. ‘A decade ago, all the kids who were born to their parents—the second kids—were seen as a burden upon the economy. The second kids, the third kids, and if the unlucky parent had any kids after that, they'd soon follow. They were tossed into the Outskirts of the city, trained to run the textile mills and such. But after a while, when people began getting injections to stop pregnancy altogether, the government realised that they were running short of a workforce.' Narth hesitates slightly, and stuffs his hands deeper into his pockets. ‘Soon after that, the Natives were given a new Function.'

You're almost afraid to ask, but you do it anyway. ‘And that was?'

‘Reproduction.'

He takes you onwards until the wall ends; you expect something grand, but instead, it appears to be the entrance to a small, ratty house, with a sign hanging over the entrance. Geritz, it says. You ask Narth what it means and his reply is cryptic; he takes you inside.

The walls slouch, the floor is covered with a tatty old carpet, and huddled in the corner are a bunch of women talking amongst themselves in hushed voices. There is a large stain in the middle of the room; it looks like blood. You retch as you back up against the wall, and Narth grabs your hand. He drags you inside, deeper, where the women glare at you accusingly, and you bewitch yourself into thinking, This is all my fault.

Deeper, deeper into the strange clinic, into a corridor that is dank and smells like rot. You hear the crying of a child from behind one of the blue doors. At least, they appear to be blue, in the dim fluorescent lighting, but it's hard to tell. On and on, for what seems like forever, until you're in an operation theatre of sorts. Then, at last, Narth turns to you, eyes burning with rage, and fear, and shame. ‘You asked me why a native is in the government,' he says. ‘Well, I work here.'

The world is spinning around you. You sit down on the floor. ‘You do this ... what they—what they do there?' you ask dumbly. The look on his face is answer enough—you understand.

‘I—I carry out the process,' he says. ‘Supplying the injections to the Strangers, impregnating the women with chemical sperms—the whole lot. Hell, some of them are cancerous when they're produced, the drugs. But we still do it anyway.' You can almost see the shame radiating off his body; you can see it in his eyes and his posture, the way he tosses his hat onto the counter and stares at the surgical instruments with despair. It's something akin to madness, you think to yourself.

Out loud, you say, ‘Why don't you just stop?'

His answer is simple. ‘It's against my Function.'




Later on, when you are outside again, and he's walking you home, you rub your hand against the wall and wonder if there is a world outside of the one you know. 

But even if there is, you are not supposed to know. 

The sky is so red tonight. His eyes are like knackered bloodfists.

Comments & reviews · 8
User avatar
Vervain
Review
Vervain wrote a review Review · Jul 17, 2015

Hey, Pomp! Here for the Big Review and all~

I'm disappointed with myself that I never got to sink my fangs into this one back while I was running the ToC; it's really a great story, and I honestly struggled to find things to critique. This reads extraordinarily well, considering how odd it can be to read and write in second person, and just wow.

I'd like to say that you did a superb job of the second person, too. A lot of people, when writing in second person, will try to leave details vague so the reader can identify with the character, but you quite literally molded the reader into the character—and I wasn't expecting it to work, but it did. Quite impressive.

I love the voice and style you've taken with this work, too. They work together to get the point across, and it makes it enjoyable, and brings out the details of your idea without forcing it into the reader's face. It's really wonderful!

However, however, however. There's always a "but", and mine comes when we cross the halfway point of this piece.

Once you get far enough in that you're no longer talking about things as normal, and Wren is actually doing things outside of the cafe, your storytelling gets a little more awkward. It's more difficult for me to follow, because the sentences become stilted, and it just doesn't match the beginning at all.

The beginning has a certain dreamlike quality to the narration, a little distant from the inside of the character, and the character is a little distant from the world. It makes it believable when you write things like "the connection between your tongue and your brain breaks loose", because there's a tangible sort of brokenness where the edges of the character and the world don't quite match up. The reader can tell that Wren doesn't fit perfectly, without emphasizing the somewhat formal syntax that Wren uses.

In the latter half, the formal syntax gets almost out of hand, especially when it delves into Wren's thoughts and feelings. There's one paragraph that made me stop altogether while I was reading, like a speedbump, because it was just a solid block of Wren's thoughts that I couldn't identify much with. And I'm pretty sure you don't want to include speedbumps of thought in your writing.

I'd definitely look at the half after Wren leaves their room at night and try to slim down some of the sentences. They can get very clunky, very quickly, and clunkiness combined with history and exposition is never a good thing.

On that note, I didn't really get a good idea of what Strangers were in the society until it was explained closer to the middle. I think it would be a good idea to include that description earlier in the passage, so we get more of an idea of how the society is structured; that way, we know what a Stranger is, and it can be fit seamlessly into the story. I also think that it might stand to be told nearer the beginning so we can get some idea of why it's significant that Narth is a Native instead.

You do a really good job of making things significant, but we're never really told or shown why, so they fall a little flat. Remember, as the writer, it's not your job to make the reader work for their answers (all the time)—don't hold their hands too much, but don't leave everything shrouded in shadows. Anything Wren knows about the situation, the reader should know, because Wren and the reader are one and the same.

I think you've got a really good, awesome story here, it could just use a bit more work, especially with the storytelling in the latter half. The concept is really strong; it's mostly the mechanics that need work, and figuring out where parts of information should go. Keep writing!

Thank youu! You hit the nail on exactly what I was struggling with; this is a great help. <33

User avatar
GoldFlame
Review
GoldFlame wrote a review Review · Apr 26, 2015

Heya!

This was amazing. No purple prose. No flowery description. No shifts in atmosphere. It was your style at its rawest, and I think it flows best when it's not weighed down by tons of imagery and metaphors; it gives you more room to focus on the mood and tone (can I just gush for a moment about this piece's mysteriousness? gah). And the symbolism was absolutely gorgeous as well.

Breaking down the piece, I'd say the theme and tone are reminiscent of Brave New World: this sort of detachedness that enables you to receive the story from different perspectives. I was opposed to the second person, initially, but it seemed to suit the story as you delved into the character descriptions.

Although I think you could utilize it to its full potential. Right now it's mostly just serving as a shortcut to developing the main character/introducing us to the setting; second person's supposed to engage in the reader's thoughts, twist their perceptions around, leave the ending lingering. Then all this time was dedicated into fleshing out the exposition, and the ending looks bare in contrast, the beginning like an excerpt from a novel.

Brave New World is centered on a society that's divided into faction-like thingies where humans are made through cloning and cell manipulation, as opposed to reproduction, and independence is discouraged. Each faction's distinguished by a particular trait. These traits are produced through the process of manipulating fetus growth and yeah, I'm really bad at explaining things, but that's sort-of-ish what the novel's about.

So this piece isn't original, and it was constructed so it depends on its plot to function, but you conveyed your ideas amazingly well. I think if you strayed from the worldbuilding a bit ... maybe that fistfight you had in mind. (I'd pay to read that. XD)

Onto the nitpicky stuff!

You are one of those pesky human beings that appreciate ‘living in the moment'. It's a strange philosophy, but it appears to work—most of the time.


I feel like this opening paragraph isn't serving a purpose, and it'd be so much more effective to start out with an action, to throw us right into the story and hit the ground running. An opening paragraph about the main character's personality implies the piece is going to be centered on the main character's personality. Plus, if you launch with the second paragraph, the second person POV feels smoother.

Your eyes are refusing to stray anywhere this afternoon, although the manager has told you that the sky outside is a clear scarlet, bold and beautiful.


Reading this individually, then in context, it's a bit of a clunky way to introduce the sky. There's also lots of contradiction occurring between these two sentences, if you check out the key words: although, however, and but (dat darn but); and the ideas are just very zigzaggy in general.

It is the busiest time of day, however, and you do not wish to displease her, what with the steady influx of Strangers from all over the city, popping in to ‘catch a bite', but staying on for more.


It'd be hypocritical to tell you to slim down on the commas in this sentence--because I'm far too comma-happy a writer--but the commas throw the illusion of a run-on. Try eliminating the commas before "but" and after "her," and cutting "what."

Also, the internal dialogue jars with the paragraph; it's bringing back that clunkiness from the second nitpick. (Didn't the narrator just state that their eyes were refusing to stray? Why do they suddenly have to make a conscious effort to not look out the window?)

The tone starts shifting a lot after the dialogue. The narrator's trying to establish a dramatic mood, but it ends up snagging instead of lending to the exposition. Things slip back into rhythm at the paragraph about the wall, though--so just keep a watch on this section.

You settle your chin on your palm and scrutinise him carefully, face twisted into a frown.


The "face twisted into a frown" is bordering a bit on purple prose, so I'd recommend clipping it.

And I'm going to go back to what I said about the clunkiness. The ideas aren't quite bridged, and the narrator's sacrificing tone as a result.

The consistency's also suffering. The first paragraphs say, yo, this is a person who ain't got time for sitting around and being idle (don't you dare look at the sky, Wren--don't you dare), and yet here Wren is leaning his chin on his palm to watch a person in the cafe.

His face is intense, impassive....


I usually regard "intense" and "impassive" as antonyms, although maybe I'm just being ignorant here--but can they be used adjacent to each other?

a ‘i heart jessica'


Should be "an" (you basically use "an" whenever the following word is pronounced with a vowel sound--hour, heir, and acronyms like S.P.E.W.).

(Story gaining a Fahrenheit 451 aspect here. Gah, I love how you talk about the absence of culture. Amazingness. :D And when Wren wonders if life will ever let them leave the cafe--that actually reminded me of another short story someone wrote, where this guy was trapped in a coma and constructed this whole world inside his head, and it all pivoted on a coffee shop.)

I think...' here the speaker


"Here" should be capitalized--it's separate from the dialogue, even though it's cutting through it.

I'm also unsure how hearing the words a thousand times contributes to the pause; the way it's phrased, it's stating the pause is directly affected by Wren's expectation of it occurring.

you listen, but never asking any questions; then, you're


The commas are looking frequent here as well; I get that they exist for effect, but the semicolon slashes things by connecting the ideas together.

expression,—‘Can't you see the “wet floor" sign, Wren? Bloody kid.'—and


I love this part. The humor's great and the sentences flow so well, it's wonderful. There's just some grammar issues to fix up: clip the comma after "expression" and the period after "kid," and the quotation marks around "wet floor" are unnecessary.

‘Er, top of the morning to ya.'
‘Waow,' you say stupidly.


But this is where the humor really starts becoming stilted. It'd sound cleaner cut, smooth out the tone a bit.

Peeling paint, rust red, graffiti, swollen oaths.


I think you might've meant "red rust" here or "rust-red graffiti"--also, "swollen oaths" stands out a little.

fez/fedora-ish hat


Fezzes and fedoras look different from each other. Fezzes are red cylinders and fedoras are 1900s detective hats. Maybe "stetson/fedora-ish"? Considering this guy in a fez, he's much less mysterious.

No doubt he'll be telling the Manager later—that the government bozo finally cracked and ordered something.


The dialogue between Narth and Wren bears a really impressive fluency--you can definitely distinguish who is who. And Wren's idiocy is endearing. XD

(Just the M-dash here is unnecessary.)

‘Hell knows I'd never slip out of the dorms,'


Saying "hell knows" here clashes with the rest of the sentence. You'd use "hell knows" as in "hell knows she's lied to me countless times before."

You've often thought about the Government—although, admittedly, you've never voiced your opinions regarding it to anyone—and you think the system is quite flawed.


Going back to the clunkiness. Before, you were explaining the setting and world really subtly, really well, and then it cuts into this part where our idiotic simpleminded Wren reflects on a serious issue ... yet before, he reprimanded himself for thinking. It's jumped from Hazel Bergeron in Kurt Vonnegut's "Harrison Bergeron" to Bernard in Brave New World.

And too much backstoryyy.

The consistency is probably the primary issue; it erodes from the realisticness. Not that the piece was intended to be fully realistic, but Wren's views tend to jump around. And once that's smoothed out, this piece is going to be amazing, with Wren and the dialogue and the description and the nuggets of humor.

(Grammar: When ideas following colons span across multiple expressions, they're supposed to capitalized, as in: "... to scrape by: A couple of decades ago....")

But they're not many of them now.


It might flow a little better as "there isn't many."

Here's your chance


This section uses a lot of contractions, in vivid contrast to the previous dialogue and the narrative paragraphs where "I am"s and words like "however" dominated. It isn't like it's awkward or anything, but it's a shift in style.

‘I'm shivering,' you say, surprised, when Narth walks up to you, as naturally as though


It's unclear whether the "surprised" is referring to Wren shivering or Narth walking up to them.

at the red, peeling paint, like wisdom peeling to the ground.


Again things are unclear here, with the metaphor; it requires a little elaboration.

‘It's like the wall is withering with age,' you whisper, ‘and falling to the ground in clumps.'


"Clumps" is associated with words like "clods" and "glop"--mushy. I guess the narrator's trying to underline the bricks' friable-ness, but "clumps" doesn't register as right. (Thesaurus.com is handy in times like this.)

What is red but a name?

Your thoughts are very jumbled up tonight.


Two words serving as a singular adjective, should be hyphenated: "jumbled-up."

I love that question--what is red but a name? It's asking the same question of, is my red your red? Words are just labels we place to objects. Colors are abstract. But it feels irrelevant and out of place, and I hate to say it, but I'd recommend cutting this part.

asked me why a native is in the government


Forgot to capitalize native here. (Agh I love this twist with the Native working in the government and supplying the injections and it's just so awesome and well-executed)

His eyes are like knackered bloodfists.


"Knackered bloodfists" is a really amazing and unique description, but it serves as the basis of your conclusion without any elaboration, and in addition, your title. It might be more effective if it was more common: "knackered-bloody flesh," yet even then it's still ... stilted.

Overall, I think some of the humor could be cut (as Merkava said, it erodes from the enigmatic tone), but it was a really well-written piece. You should write more dystopian stuff. ;)

Looking forward to reading more from you!

I didn't get a notif for this. DX Thank youu, Flamey! I can't believe I didn't see this sooner

User avatar
StellaThomas
Review
StellaThomas wrote a review Review · Apr 15, 2015

Hey Pomp! So originally, the reason I clicked on this was because of the title. 'Knacker' here is a slang/semi-offensive word for a traveller -- who are famous for their fist-fighting. So it was a really interesting choice of title for me that drew me in. That said, I didn't really get why you chose that title. You describe his eyes as ochre, but here you're implying they're red. So I was just a bit puzzled by all of that.

I really enjoy the second person narrative. Usually I think that it can come off as pretentious, but you pull it off so nicely and naturally, so excellent job. One place I felt it didn't work as well was where you were talking about people who were exiled and branded - I couldn't tell if you meant that had happened to Wren, or that that was something that happened to abstract other people. So I'd just clarify on that.

Other than that, I think my main issue with this was that I felt there was no real... ending. There was a lot of world building and you did a great job of making the world so clear in such a short space of time. But at the end, I felt that that was all that had happened. Wren's ideas and thoughts hadn't really changed - because you had implied that they were already, you know, having thoughts and breaking rules throughout the story. So there wasn't a huge change in opinion. It was just like they learnt about the world and then went back to their life. I think that for the story to work there has to be something different at the end than there was at the start. For me, that would be Wren's independent thought or questioning of the world around them. As it stands, the story just kind of fades into non-existence.

I really liked Narth and the explanation of 'that's against my Function' - it was really cutting and cool the way it wove into the rest of the story and the world :)

Hope I helped, drop me a note if you need anything!

-Stella x

Thank you so much for this! I intended for the story to include quite a bit of fist-fighting, initially, but I wrapped it up quickly due to time-constraints. XD I'll definitely be working on this one and try to give the story Wren's state of mind a bigger shift!

And it did help~ ^^

User avatar
Nica
Comment
Nica commented Comment · Apr 12, 2015

Wow! Great story! Can't wait to read more. Tag me when you write the next chapter. :)

User avatar
Merkava120
Review
Merkava120 wrote a review Review · Apr 11, 2015

This is a great story! There are a few things I'd like to mention here.

First, I love how you wrote the story in second person. Few authors could do that successfully, but you've managed it here. You don't cause your readers to stumble on the "you"s after the first paragraph or so, and that's very good writing.

Second, I really like the tone and the mood of the story--it's very serious and sort of enchanting. However, somewhere around the "crappity crap crap crap" bit, the mysterious tone seems to slip away. It comes back by the end, but it would really help the middle of the story if you could make it a bit less casual.

Lastly, for most of the story, you have a very good "show-not-tell" way of writing. The only place this slips away is when you explain how the government works. Is there a way you could spread this out over the whole story?

All in all, great story, with impressive depth and generally good writing.

User avatar
GoldFlame
Comment
GoldFlame commented Comment · Apr 11, 2015

Oh my goodness this is my favorite work of yours yet.

I shall be back.



In a world too often governed by corruption and arrogance, it can be difficult to stay true to one's literary and philosophical principles.
— Lemony Snicket