I like to think of myself as an artist, but can’t yet confidently refer to myself as one.
I’ve tried a number of different mediums over the years, but I’ve never been able to capture what I’m really trying to depict, which is true human emotion, the actual experience of being alive, of being in love. It’s not an easy thing to do, it’s hard to get even a morsel of investment out of the reader or viewer, not to mention the same investment they have in their real life. As far as I know, nobody has perfected it.
I’ve tried painting portraits of all kinds, with pastels, acrylics, or watercolors, sometimes with the most realistic proportions I could manage, sometimes with abstracts and bright colors. I would paint only one person of course. But even if I painted the background with star studded night sky blues, I didn’t feel as if I was really standing with him in the cold November air. Even if I covered the canvas with angry crimson reds, golden streaks of hope, black blotches of despair, I couldn’t make the viewer feel the same way I did. Hazel eyes and a cocky grin seemed hollow in a painting, all their subtlety lost.
I’ve tried writing, but there aren’t the proper words to describe anything, or maybe I just haven’t discovered them yet. Poetry, dialogue, prose, nothing seemed effective. With static, unchanging words, there was no way to depict the flaws of human memory, how every moment you forget something and remember something else. Words on a page can’t make the reader feel every step in the grass, or a joyful leap of the heart. They can’t throw the reader into a fiery pit, make them feel as if they’re really crashing and burning, and put them through the painstaking process of getting back up again. A reader won’t see the word ‘whisper’ and look over their shoulder for the sound.
I’ve tried photography, but a single wordless snapshot was the least immersive of all. Even with the most expensive camera equipment, the image still seemed terribly blurry, its meaning unclear. My most recent photo shoot was of a man in black, standing in a doorway, his eyes vacant and pupil-less, avoiding the viewer’s gaze. I showed it to a friend and asked her if she was in love with him, and didn’t she want to be just like him? She said the man was ugly.
I’ve tried to film videos, short live action movies in my backyard, poor attempts at animation, dramatic covers of my favorite songs. Surely this should have been the most immersive medium of all, if still limited to sight and sound. Yet even the highest frame rate wasn’t enough to show them what I meant. It was as if reality was warped by his very presence, as if the very fabric of the universe was bending around him and
just for a moment
the rules didn't apply.
At least for me.
And there I was, sitting in my room, surrounded by unused equipment and unfinished paintings, thinking that everything I created seemed bland and lifeless, wondering if Dr. Frankenstein was onto something when-
Suddenly, it was all over. In a split second, it was as if I was never in love at all.
Points:
Time spent:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Hey there MPH!! I love your works, so I'm here once again for a review <3
First of all, this is so dramatic!! I love the violent imagery, it adds a sense of drama to the entire piece--which is awesome! It's also incredibly relatable, lol.
The first line definitely sets the stage for the entire piece, and it made me think: Are we only artists if we can capture human existence perfectly? This piece gave me the narrator's answer to the question, and it was definitely an interesting perspective. The narrator believes that you are only an artist if the observer of your work feels the exact things you do--and while I believe otherwise, you've described this feeling in such a beautiful way that I can imagine why the narrator believes these things.
Your final paragraphs are magnificent, by the way--I feel this way about a lot of your work. The last words elevate the piece amazingly. Here, your metaphor with Dr. Frankenstein doesn't feel out of place, it feels real. Because the tone of that paragraph fits perfectly with the bleakness of Frankenstein as a story.
Your tone throughout reads as regretful, like the narrator is looking back on their past failures and commiserating over them. It's a unique tone, and you've definitely captured it well.
The very last line was definitely a plot twist--you've always executed them well!--and this time, it truly left me wondering what happened. Did the narrator and their love break up? Did the narrator have a sudden realization? I find myself wanting more, but I know that that isn't what's right for the piece. Well done on that!!
Overall, I definitely enjoyed reading this! <3 Keep writing!
<3, daisy (formerly theromanticchemist)
Thank you so much for your review, and for continuing to read my work
Hello!
Iam new to this platform and your title immediately made me curious. I cannot help but relate to this piece. You did and amazing job in expressing how art and being an artist is subjective in nature. I do not know much about writing, but I can confidently say that this short story is indeed "A piece of art".
hello! I'm not great at writing reviews but I'm gonna try!
I really love this piece and the first part is really good (and real)
"I like to think of myself as an artist, but can’t yet confidently refer to myself as one."
That being the first thing I read immediately drew me in, just cutting straight to the point was a really good choice. All the things you listed that you said you wern't good enough for added this like rawness and realistic touch to it like woah. (Sorry about how crappy this was i tried but seriously I love this)
Thank you so much for your review! I%u2019m glad you enjoyed my story
*I%u2019m
Hi Milesperhour133, just stopping in to review your work!
The title instantly intrigued and captured my attention, as I find writing about art to be one of my favorite types of work. This short story is unique in the fact that not only does it write from a first person perspective, but reads like a journal/dairy entry. I find this fitting as the short story is about creating and art, and journaling is just another avenue of creating. Even if this wasn't intentional, it's a nice touch, as not all works can fit in this format.
I also want to comment that I really love the content and emotion behind this work. It feels personal, it feels like we are gazing into the heart and desires of an artist as they struggle and learn and feel. The repetition of "I've tried" beginning each paragraph gives off a feeling of giving up. Of reflecting on what has been done/attempted, and not knowing what's next. It's clear that the narrator is not satisfied, especially when trying to capture the essence of "him"
Love often is a big inspiration for art, and I love how love is used as a driving force for the narrator, even as they realize that no medium of art can satisfy the true essence of this person. This fits even more perfectly with the title! The ending of this poem sums up the feelings portrayed in the prior paragraphs.
This last line makes the emotions more clear as we can read it from a new perspective. Is the reason the narrator cannot capture this person, is because this person is distant? "He" was never meant to be theirs? "He" was hollow in a painting, ugly to a friend, and blurry in the photo because this love was also blurred and hollow?
This short story begs a lot of questions, but questions that do not need to be answered. I enjoy how this work can be perceived in different ways, as the emotions behind it are nothing short of complex. I really enjoyed this work and would love to know your thought process while writing it! Hope to read more works from you soon <3
Thank you so much for your kind words!!
I love your interpretation of this sm, I never thought of the reason the mc (I named them Paul lol) not being able to capture "him" in art being that they were never really meant to be with him in the first place, but looking back at what my inspirations were for this work at the time you may be right lol. Thank you again, I'll definitely have to read some of your work as well!