This user has been banned and her works removed from YWS.
Points:
Time spent:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
The language is amazing again Lhighton, you really have a way with words.
Really, I can do nothing but sing your praises
I loved it. The dialogue, the characters, everything. Everything was well developed. The dialogue was well thought out and I loved the accent. I don't know, again, everything just worked.
Hey, thanks for lending some time to critique, chocoholic!
I know. My Bad. Thing is, I didn't want it to go under that label because nobody critiques over there... hehe. Purely wrong of me, I know.
As for the Nell thing, it was quite common back then for the name Ellen to be shortened to Nell. It's a pet name, really, because the ripper and Ellen have a strange, morbid bond. I can see what you mean though, about it coming from nowhere.
For the lushington thing, it basically means 'drunkard'. I was trying to mingle old working-class words in with the modern ones. To be truthful, though, I merely typed 'Victorian slang' into Google!
Yeah and the ladybird was also slang. Prostitute, really, but on friendlier terms.
Thanks again.
PS Jodi Picoult is a genius. Love 'Change of Heart'...
I rally liked this, although I'm not really sure if this should be in Other Fiction? I got thefeeling that this was set in the past. Perhaps 1800's England? Forgive me if I'm wrong, my knowledge of those types of periods isn't very good, but either way it doesn't seem very modern.
I think you sould change this to something like,
He pulled nearer, his face centimetres away from Ellen's. He couldn't have missed if he spat at her.
Neel really doesn't sund anything like Ellen, and we've only just been introducted to this character. Pluss Ellen just sounds better than Nell. I'd make this Ellen.
Huh? Never sen this word before. Is it a period word or something?
Ladybird! That's brilliant! I don't know if it's actually ever been used, but it seems to work and it's really funny!
Overall, I quite like this. Is there more? Your characters seem interesting and I like the voices you use, especially for Ellen. And I didn't have any trouble figuring out what bit came first (I love Jodi Picoult!)
God job, and if there's more, can you PM me when you post it?
Thanks for the critique, Sam.
I understand I got a tad too carried away with the dialogue and left the setting and characters a bit on the threadbare side. It's a bit embarrassing now, in retrospect.
In regard to the master, he was the ripper, which I guess you know that. And indeed he was the man whom Ellen met outside the pub. See, the text in italics was meant to be before the the non-italic text. It is not what some would call a 'linear' story. I see I have a knack of confusing people on YWS with my set-outs. (Gah. Have they never read Jodi Picoults? Hehe.)
Well, thanks again. I'll try to change it a bit.
Hey, lhighton!
Oh my goodness, the character voices were beyond adorable. Doing a narrative--or even snippets of dialogue--is maddeningly difficult in thick slang like that, so I tip my hat to you.
I'll be relatively brief, just because my complaints are mostly plot-based:
- At the beginning, i have no idea of anything besides the fact that it's cold. The "master" never shows up again in the story; at least, not as far as I can tell. Is he the guy she tracks down in the pub? If so, why did you juxtapose the scenes like that? When you jump time and place, you need to be certain your readers know exactly where the characters from the first part are in the second. If the answer is 'they don't exist', we need to know that, too. Put collars on your characters, if you like--goodness knows they'll come in handy later.
- Hold up, partner--what, exactly, went on between Ellen and the man? And why does she think he needs an accomplice? He seemed to be doing just fine without her; in fact, he was trying to push her away. Sounds pretty self-supporting to me. In order for this "beautiful friendship" to be formed, we need to know what leads her to believe that he is in need of her services, and what will convince him that she is the girl. We'll also know that he's a human being and takes more than six seconds to make a decision. You can help pace by adding in explanation, though keep it sparse. You don't want to be going into info-dump territory, either. When you're done explaining, look through each bit of background information you've put in--is this essential?. If it's not, you can probably cut it.
__
Thanks for the read! PM me if you have any questions or want me to take a look at something else. ^_^
Thanks for the review, scasha. Thing is, with the whole 'what her master'd given her' and the like, it's meant to not sound proper-English. I thought that if I'd narrated in a proper voice, it would not have gne well with the setting and the class of the characters - so please don't think it was unintentional! However, clearly this doesn't show through and leaves me looking like a dodo-brain.
Finally, she corrected my 'coloured' to 'colored'. The 'u' is in the English spelling, and it's set in England. Just thought I'd say.
Thanks again for taking time to critique it!
Hey lhighton! Here's my review key:
Red = Comments
Bold = Words I've inserted that I think could work better.
Let's do this thing!
Loved it! Loved the language, I liked the characters, it was all very interesting. Some additional observations:
The ending of your chapter bothered me a bit. The beat change for the man not wanting to help Ellen then all of a sudden wanting to help her and almost needing to use her for something was a bit too fast. Show us how he thinks it over. Maybe his eyes light up. Maybe he looks around the corner. Looks her up and down, or have her say something more than don't you need a gal that makes it seem as though he needs to reconsider. Maybe have him say , "Well there is one thing" or Now that I think of it. Show us why he changes his mind. Don't tell us why, be subtle but at least try to be less abrupt.
Other than that, this looks like an interesting story you have in the works! If you have any questions, PM me! Keep up the good work!