z
  • Home

Young Writers Society



The Rat

by Kafkaescence


At the grave a rat had made its way into my wife's skull and was now gnawing into her neck and her sunken chest, for I'd unearthed her in my misery and now sat on a nearby headstone, stiff with sleeplessness. I'd endeavored to wave it away but it wouldn't leave, and I couldn't stay standing long, for the night was cold; I could only muster a single wave at a time before retreating back to the headstone to sit, and shiver. As time dragged on the night's breaths grew only cooler, and my attempts to drive away the rat grew less and less frequent until eventually I couldn't even move from the headstone for want of warmth. Occasionally I'd shout some curse, but I knew the rat couldn't hear me, for I wasn't shouting but merely whispering, and they weren't curses but mere self-degrading entreaties.

After a time spent thus, I spotted the undertaker. "There's a rat in my wife's body," I told him. "It started in her head but it's made its way into her abdomen, and the cold is keeping me stuck on this headstone."

The undertaker, only now appearing to notice the lidless coffin, looked appalled. "Leave," he yelled, "vandal, what has come into you? Now I must rebury this coffin."

Oddly relieved, I slid off the headstone, careful not to step on any underfoot graves; the rat, concealed inside the coffin, had heard it all, and now fled away into the too-cold night.


Is this a review?


  

Comments



User avatar
1334 Reviews

Points: 25864
Reviews: 1334

Donate
Tue Jan 22, 2013 12:37 pm
View Likes
Hannah wrote a review...



Woah there~ First impression: way too long of a first sentence. Too many things thrown at me at once. My impression. The night is crisp. Why let us into it with a languorous sentence more suited for warm houses?

Also, does the headstone radiate some sort of warmth? If not, the movement would keep him warmer than standing still. Even just walking around keeps one warm, but when you sit and stare and don't move, you can feel the cold start to creep through the fabric of your clothes. So if that's what your story is kind of revolving around, it might -cringe- need a major face lift.

I think this was gunning for something and missed the mark. Like, in quick description, a man sitting in a grave and watching a rat eat through the body of his dead wife. That's powerful and disturbing. I feel like the distance of the man's processing of the scene is necessary and intentional, but rather than just distance and numb him, you've shrunken him down in his own words so we feel like this piece is hardly worth it. You use "mere" two times in a sentence, if that's not enough of an explanation. You're bringing him down with his own words, and though he'd degrade himself, I don't think it'd be as politely as "mere". Even were he so weak and hopeless, he had the fire in himself to make himself walk all the way out to the graveyard, so he can't be that weak yet.

[On a note slightly related because of the repetition, the first line is made more unpalatable by the repetition of "action" .. "now" , "action" .. "now" -- the repetition of the sentence structure with now.]

You also fall into the trap of wordiness a few times. You have a requirement to fit! Why would you waste words on "and less" when less on its own will do and "eventually" adds nothing to the sentence? Work through it carefully. Make words do double duty. Then you'll have room to fit more, like hints as to whether this is a regular thing or a first time thing and how long its been since death -- if this is a new widower or a man whose grief has caught up with him after ages and ages of pretending to live with it.

Furthermore, an undertaker usually hangs out in the funeral parlor doing embalming 'n' stuff. Why's he out in the cemetery?

Lastly, at the end the way you've structured the sentence makes it seems that the rat is concealed and "now flees" at the same time. You could say "who had been" or something to separate the times.

I guess I want more vividness, even though you're covering it with the numbness of the man. If this vague description is not, in fact, of characterization design, then definitely give me something: a texture of this night. the crunch of bone? or just scratching against it? does it sound like stone or china when scraped? Even one shivering detail would make this resonate much better.

PM me with questions or comments! c: Good luck~




User avatar
27 Reviews

Points: 941
Reviews: 27

Donate
Mon Jan 21, 2013 5:24 am
View Likes
KilljoyRetardedFish says...



Great capture of emotion! There is a lot said with few words, which is what hardly anyone can ever claim to do. Very well done, I see no constructive criticism I need to give here, its amazing is all I can say! :)




User avatar
8 Reviews

Points: 520
Reviews: 8

Donate
Sun Jan 20, 2013 9:38 pm
View Likes
reowine wrote a review...



wow, this is great, and leaves many questions for the reader:
-how long has he been there?
-is he insane? or does he just truly love his wife?

this story is great and it really has a deeper meaning to it then just "man tries to drive stubborn rat away from wife's dead body" but it really displays his love and affection for that woman because of what he's doing. he's out there suffering in the cold and trying to get that rat away, it shows an undying and amiable respect that he has for his wife, and it also gets him respect from the readers.

the story has an unsettling atmosphere, and makes one wonder if he's crazy to do what he's doing, and why this night of all other nights he's most likely been sad, to go dig up his wife. I want to know what triggered this. the story really makes the readers feel genuine sadness for this man because most of us have no idea of the pain he's experiencing, both inside and out, and it it makes us develop intense feelings of sympathy.

the ending was impressive too, with the rat having heard everything, like wow man, good touch. its also nice to know that rat left the coffin in the end, making it seem as if the mans efforts weren't for nothing.

the only real issue i have with this is that its just too short! I'm not saying to make it into a novel or anything, but you could really do more by explaining his emotions more, physically and mentally. like he did this because he felt this, or just he felt this. but emotions are a huge thing in my writing, so opinions will be opinions.

All in all, nice work man! this story is deep and shows a lot about the mans character, and even the rats. I'll be checking into your other stuff too cause this was just too good!!!




User avatar
20 Reviews

Points: 524
Reviews: 20

Donate
Sat Jan 19, 2013 6:23 am
View Likes
AntonioRivera wrote a review...



Jesus Christ. Listen, this isn't even a review. This story, or this piece is just amazing. I am a serious writer, so I appreciate great writing; and this is just that. The imagery was great. It's weird because I started reading Dickens today and your style is a lot like his. I wish there was more to this story, but I'm definitely going to read your other stuff. So yeah, this was just a blurt, but it's what I felt. This was truly talented.





The heavens laugh with you in your jubilee; my heart is at your festival.
— William Shakespeare