Hi, Jyva. Pan here to fry up a review.
Wow. It's a rare thing on this site for me to be so hooked in by a piece that I almost forget to read it critically, but you achieved that with this. I adore the voice of the narrator - you get such a strong sense of their personality within the first few lines, and you maintain that throughout with your coarse descriptions of characters and liberal use of swearing. The setting is incorporated effortlessly, too - people always go on about the necessity of showing in writing, but an even harder skill is being able to tell in a way that holds the reader's interest. A lot of what you do in this opening is exposition, but there's enough mystery to hook me in and it's so well handled that I want to know more.
A truly polished piece. And your opening and ending lines are killer.
There's not much for me to comment on, but I will give a few pointers:
1) As brilliant as the narrator's voice is, be careful that it doesn't intrude too much on active scenes. For instance, in this exchange:
“Because he fucks you in the ass every other weekend, dickweed,” Claire shoots back, showing absolutely no regard for Mallory’s dignity or reputation. Christopher – remember him? He’s the white guy. Christopher stifles a giggle. Amy’s face goes red. “Where’s Jackson?” Claire repeats.
It's not a huge issue, but having the narrator chip in with little comments can pull the reader out of the scene and distance them from the action. For the most part, you manage to do this effectively, but be careful that it doesn't happen too much. The narrator's voice is so distinctive that the reader will need the occasional breather.
2) Also, cutting out unnecessary telling. Sometimes you reinforce something to the reader that they can already infer from the text. An example in the quote above would be the clause 'showing absolutely no regard for Mallory's dignity or reputation'. You don't need it, because we can already glean from Claire's crass comment that she doesn't care about Mallory's dignity. It specifies something that we can tell for ourselves.
Another instance would be here:
Claire, being very tired of Mallory’s shit at this point, kicks the door open.
We can kind of guess from the fact that she's kicking the door down that she's tired of her shit. If you want to keep the same rhythm, maybe replace the line in bold with a clause that further highlights her exasperation - something about her huffing air through her nose or rolling her eyes or whatever she does in that hesitation before slamming her foot into the door.
If you give the piece another read through, just keep a keen eye out for anything that isn't necessary to the reader's understanding. It's only a minor issue, but it will tighten the piece up.
I don't really have much else to recommend. I was really impressed with this - it's the best piece I've read on YWS for a long time. My presence on this site is really irregular, but if you decide to continue this, could you please PM or tag me when you post the next part? I really want to know what happens next!
Hope this helped!
Keep writing!:D
~Pan
Points: 46598
Reviews: 641
Donate