Many people lose the color.
It's a precious thing, but sometimes it is lost. My second grade teacher had proposed to his girlfriend and was engaged, only seeing a colorful future, one that had blossomed into a symphony of hues the moment he'd fallen in love. But we had a minimum day Monday and he missed Tuesday. When he returned, the gray eyes we glanced at while turning in our homework, expecting to see them bright and big, newly introduced to the world of color, were cold and dark. And damp, after recess.
A kid's dad worked in the office, and discovered that the teacher's fiance had cheated on him and lost his love. His expression for a while after was one that had lost the light and was looking for it.
Many people lose the color.
I had crushes, but I understood it didn't equal the color. I would say you had to really KNOW you were in love to see the color, but I don't think that's true. I think everyone has a certain level of attraction. When you reach it, you gain the color.
And when I got my first boyfriend in high school, I was disappointed at the absence of color, but I stuck with him. Some people don't see color until a few months or even years with their boy or girlfriend. Maybe something clicks, maybe they realize it themselves, but just because the color doesn't come with your first kiss doesn't mean he's not your soul mate. But during college we drifted apart, and decided to break up for our own good.
I moved into a flat with a quiet male roommate who kept to himself, and I slowly but surely became infatuated with the colors.
I recall an early attempt to gain the colors. On Sunday, I'd bought a package of thread - six different colors. At least that's what the tag said. I had cut off sections of the five lightest colors and tied a loose, clumsy bow on each finger of my left hand. Every time i became aware of the strings, I'd looked at each bow carefully for a few seconds, trying to see something past the varied grays while thinking about all the secret crushes I was harboring at the moment.
I had failed. And I supposed I'd known that I would not succeed, but desire, a burning need, had pushed me to at least try and fail.
In the early days of living with a roommate, one of my best friends visited with her boyfriend, leaning against him and laughing. My lonely roommate greeted them shyly and talked to us for a while.
"How long have you been together?" he asked, less awkwardly than usual. The couple was pleasant and he responded in kind.
"Ten months," she replied, squeezing her boyfriend's hand and giggling. Her mouth fell open unexpectedly, and she let go and backed into the wall, shocked and confused.
"Are you OK?" her boyfriend gasped.
She looked up with widened eyes. "I think this is color! Like, I see so much!"
"This is amazing! I'll pull up the picture!" he offered.
When I was four, my favorite book was No, David! by David Shannon. I reread it again and again and I labeled each part of the drawing according to its color with my mom's help. In third grade, he visited our school. As if I was seeing the President, the entire assembly I sat with my mouth slightly open and focused on his face and the way he acted and the way he moved, so I could keep it all in my head like a mosquito in amber.
Her expression was similar to my childish one, her eyes bright as she picked through my roommate's desk decorum.
"Is is red? It is kind of warm, like they said!"
Her boyfriend had picked up her phone from where she had dropped it and scrolled excitedly through the gallery, obviously remembering her greatest wish.
My friend's father died from cancer when she was very young. She said her mother had always talked about how vivid and vigorous he was, the embodiment of color. When she gained color, she planned to look at the picture of him healthy, cancer-free, holding his newborn.
Shaking, her boyfriend held out the phone. She grabbed it and blinked several times. The blinking led way to crying, and the crying led to full on sobbing. Her boyfriend hugged her, and my roommate went to get a blanket she could wear, because that's the way he dealt with crying, apparently.
For months afterwards, she was ecstatic and stuck with her boyfriend through thick and thin. I listened to her descriptions of gaining a sense you never had. Of living with one leg but suddenly being able to stand on two.
But her boyfriend told her he couldn't take the commitment and left, and I never figured out if he saw the color or not. If he did, how could he keep himself from telling everyone he had gained something so incredible?
She was visiting me, and we were in the living room when she got the call, her annoying ringtone blaring through our conversation. I heard his tinny voice as he said he was sorry, and I watched her close her eyes, and I felt her tremble as I patted her back. My roommate dragged his soft blanket off his thin shoulders and dropped it on hers before leaving quietly.
"I don't want to open my eyes," she muttered, bringing the blanket around her face.
"I know," I said after a pause. She didn't want to lose the color, wanting to keep it like a mosquito in amber. But it doesn't work like that. I have forgotten David Shannon's face, and that moment I knew she would forget red and purple and everything in between.
There was silence. A gasp and sniffle under the blanket.
"I'm sorry," I said.
"Blue."
"What?" I recognized the word immediately. It was like lucid dreaming to a regular dreamer. Blue. I knew what it tasted like, what it smelled like, which of my belongings were blue, the names of what colors "looked nice" with blue - but I had never seen it.
"The blanket. It's blue." She let it fall from her eyes. She looked at me. "And you're peach with brown sprinkles." Something she had already told me, back when she had just gained the color.
I smelled peaches and the light taste whispered to me. Brown reminded me of purple because it was so dark, but seemed happier and kinder, a chocolatey touch.
"You...still have the colors?" I asked. She nodded.
"How do you feel?" I asked cautiously.
"Not so great. I lost something and didn't lose something, I guess," she said, tracing the blanket's fringe. "Maybe it's a failed signal. But I think I love someone still. It could be anyone,."
It was possible. Colors were generally gained when the cause was in view or nearby, but it wasn't always true.
She left without saying much except "Yeah", "I will", and "Thanks." A curious numbness seemed to have taken hold of her, a sudden change from hysteria to detachment.
I folded up the blanket and stared at its light gray static before leaving it in front of my roommate's door. I studied all the possible soul mates for my friend but didn't reach any conclusions. Who was I to say who loved who?
That night, I wandered about my room and repeated a ritual I had grown accustomed to. I picked up objects - a stapler, an action figure, a stuffed animal - and placed them in order of color. Red to orange and yellow to green and so on, trying desperately to understand how some could be warm and some cold, attempting to see if green went with orange or if yellow went with purple. I had labeled my belongings with their colors, sending pictures of them to my parents to get the colors. As far as I knew, no one else did this, but I couldn't understand how they would understand everything when they finally gained the final sense.
After leaving a pile of pennies near, but not in the brown pile (something I had decided long ago), I snatched up a plastic bracelet I had bought at a fair, having noticed the beads' spectrum from warped translucency to dark gray. I was sure that it held many colors but had forgotten to ask anyone. Then I decided to try a little experiment.
I placed it on the dark gray desk near my black laptop and a gray pen (labeled red) and a light gray action figure. Carefully, I focused on the bracelet, observing its every curve, noticing the plastic seam that circled the beads. Cheap, yes. But rich in something I longed for. I stared at it and I thought of every possible soul mate in my life. My brother's buddy, the guy at the bus stop every morning, the security guard I greeted every morning, the students that sat on either side of me during class, the bus driver I talked with every day. I even considered my own roommate, but only felt some pity and awe of his silence. People I liked. People I saw and had conversations with. But not people I loved.
And yet still I tried to bring out the color in the bracelet, turning it blurry and going cross-eyed and blinking and squinting and glaring -
Swallowing an achy lump in my throat, I turned away from the bracelet. My life was still in black and gray and white. I couldn't change that through willpower. It was a stupid thought. I picked up the worthless jewelry, putting it in my wallet, impatient to ask my friend what colors it kept from me as soon as possible.
The next day, I came home from class to find her at my front door. I greeted her, surprised, and opened the door. She headed for the living room and found my roommate reading a comic book as usual.
"Hey," she said, quieter than usual.
He looked up carefully, as if his fragile neck would snap from the weight. "Hi."
"How's that comic?" she asked.
"Colorless," he said.
I was taken aback. I didn't think she knew how to talk to someone like him, but here she was hitting his favorite topics on the head.
"I think I love you," she said in a rush.
Nope, she diidn't know how to talk to him.
He kissed her.
It was probably his first kiss, looking back.
They separated with smiles. He blinked, his mouth falling open to reveal ivory teeth, creamy sheets of paper from which braces had recently been erased.
"How's that comic?" she repeated.
He looked down at it and a tear marked the page. "Colorful."
I left the room, tasting green, bitter and rough.
They married in the next four years. I wasn't the maid of honor, because she was my best friend but I was not hers. I stood to the side and I clapped for her, the plastic bracelet hard in my pocket, as the painful green and the soft, gentle brown tickled my taste buds and left their scents and brushed my fingers and whispered in my ears. Teasing, just out of sight.
I met someone after college at a boring party. We dated and became officially "together." Six months ago, he proposed to me. I said yes before he finished the sentence.
"Red roses," he breathed as I hugged him, and I knew I had opened a new world for him.
I love him; I am certain. But I hide one thing from him. It is difficult to conceal, but I would do anything for his happiness. I love him. A mantra I have repeated for months, willing my secret to be made false by one single gain.
I had whispered the colors to myself every night. At the grocery store, I silently named each familiar item, like my mother had done for me when I was a child. Carrots are orange. Eggplants are purple. Bread is sort of brown. Pre-sliced apples are sold in green bags. I had gone "shopping" and went through each tag to read the color. Orange Heels. Pink Teddy Bear. Yellow Highlighter. Navy Blue Baseball Cap. I focused until my eyes blurred with frustration and desperation. It didn't work.
It never would, and never will.
I know they are waiting in the church.
I sit on the chair in the dressing room in my wedding dress and my pink heels. "The splash of pink is perfect with your skin," the fitter had assured me when I bought them. Smiling, I had looked right at him. I had said, "Thank you."
Then I had gone to the car and cried, alone.
And again the tears fell, leaving the fabric a bit darker. I resist raising the "gorgeous" roses that I cannot appreciate to sniff their scent. I hide my feet under my gown, for I cannot smile when I see how the pink shoes flatter my skin. I do not lift my left hand to wipe away the tears, because my eyes will not be caught by the warm gold that "glows" from my engagement ring. I refuse to take the plastic bracelet out of my wallet, for I cannot smile at my former ignorance. I prefer to focus on the wedding dress.
At least I know it's supposed to be white.
Points:
Time spent:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Okay, review time. I'm really new to this, so my review will be short. I'm sorry...
I absolutely love the premise. The fact that people can only see characters after they find true love is quite creative, and the whole story seems to be one big metaphor.
This is beautiful. It reminds me of "The Giver," how everything is black, white, and grey until certain things (I don't want to give it away if you haven't read the book) happen. It's a lovely short story. Very well written. Good Job!
Oh my god. I don't know how to react. This was stunningly beautiful. A poetic perception of love. This was amazing I cannot think of a single thing you should change or fix. I am going to read more of your stories now because of this. It was magnificent! I love your writing style! Amazing job!
Hi there! In fifteen minutes, review day will end and I lose the competition with my friend (boo). Let's see if I can get this review written, then!
Okay, so I only noticed one nitpick in this entire thing, which is great! It is:
I'm guessing you meant "Her expression was similar to my childish one.
I'm reminded vaguely of the Giver, since they live their entire lives seeing no color. I wonder what your prompt is. It sounds interesting. I love how they only get to see colors when they feel like they are in love. Too bad for the main character, though. She won't be able to hide it for long. Maybe she will see as she says, "I do." Who knows!
The idea is very interesting. I'm guessing their parents teach them which color is which and they identify each color with the hue of darkness they see.
I guess peach is a skin color. The brown sprinkles must be freckles. It must be weird, suddenly seeing everything in color. It's like a blind man being able to see or a deaf woman being able to hear- it'd be overwhelming and a tad bit scary.
Well, keep writing X
~lost
Thank you! I fixed the mistake and now, that I think of it, it is like The Giver!
So, Hi, first off.
Secondly, happy review day.
Third, this made me smile. Even though the end was rather gloomy, just the premise and use of description and full out exploration of an abstract concept in this form with this tone and perspective created a feeling of appreciation for the writing that don't get often. Well done.
Back to the explanation of abstract concepts. Recently (just kidding, it was like two months ago, but it's the most recent piece I've written) I wrote a short little thing on impulse for an online contest that I never entered. It was about a boy who spent his childhood with a makeshift paintbrush and grew into his own world where he owned plenty of real ones, and spent his adulthood experimenting with colors. I illustrated the emotions he felt through the experimentation, although I did not associate colors with the emotions. I feel like here, you have done just that, but you've gone miles deeper into some place far under the surface of this topic to show the audience something we've never seen before and to let us feel something we've never felt. You managed to do all this while staying within the confines that your character presented, which I find very impressive.
Here I'd like to move on to technical aspects including grammar and sentence structure and such, but I was so engrossed in the content of the writing that it shut off my nit-picky sense. So now I have to go back and look again.
Okay. Back.
"My second grade teacher had proposed to his girlfriend and was now engaged, only seeing a colorful future, one that had blossomed into a symphony of hues the moment she said yes."
This sentence is beautiful. But I paused a little when I registered that you had said 'was now engaged.' I may be wrong. But I feel like that's a bit of a tense contradiction. Maybe, 'was then'...? Just a little something that stopped me.
"...so I could keep it all in my head like a mosquito in amber."
Great comparison. Wasn't expecting it.
"Her expression was similar my childish one, her eyes bright as she picked through my roommate's desk decorum."
Her expression was similar 'to' my childish one?
In the few sentences just after that, I love the jerking back-and-forth you have going on with the emotions and opposites of colors dealing with this girl and her boyfriend. Also loving the subtle repetition you have going on in just the right places, such as the mosquito in amber to allude to the previous little story from the narrators youth. Nicely done.
"She headed for the living room and found the my roommate reading a comic book as usual."
Cut out 'the' after 'found'.
"How''s that comic?" she questioned."
'How's' doesn't need two apostrophes.
"i was taken aback."
Capitalize 'I'. Small typo.
"Teasing, just out of sight,"
Period, not a comma. After 'sight'.
"...and I knew I had opened a new world for him. ."
One too many periods there.
"It was difficult to hide..."
Is? Be careful with tenses. That's an either or, but it is still a present action...
'Thank you."
Probably the pickiest thing I've said yet, but that first quotation mark isn't a quotation mark.
"...the pink shoes flatters my skin."
Flatter. Not flatters.
Alright. Nit-picks done.
This is great, captivating writing and I cannot wait to read more. I think you did what you meant to do with this.
Keep writing.
Thank you for all the grammar corrections. I always have trouble catching them!
I love the way you wrote this! I was so fresh and creative! Well done.
This is a really tiny thing, but I would change the fiance to his fiance so it feels more personal.But I do have nitpicks.
Grammatically speaking the title of a book should be italicized, No, David
This confused me, recalled, implies that something happened the past, while, in a moment, implies that something happened int he future. So it happened in the past, and in the future, at the same time *Mind explodes*
....Sorry...I've been reviewing for too long...anyway, it's an easy fix. Just changed "reacalled" to "I will recall" so it's all in the future.
I would advise you to play with your formating a little. Sometimes I lose track of when your narrator's talking about the same people and when the narrator's talking about a different group of people. Every time you switch to a new group, put in an extra space, otherwise just have one line of space.
Don't be so afraid of the word asked. readers automatically skip over it, which actually makes your writing smooth. it flows better. Same goes for when you wrote "I wondered" earlier, just write asked. Trust me. You only want to use something other than said or asked if you really need to emphasize how it was said.
That i needs to be I.
You switch between past and present tense a lot. If you did this on purpose, then don't change it. If you did not do it on purpose, I would advise making it all the same tense.
What a cool concept! And you explored it so creatively and masterfully. And the simple, yet provocative voice you used to tell the story was amazing. I wish I could write something like this...
I'm going to disagree with the reviewer below, kind of. I found a very clear conflict in this. Your character wants to find love, but since she see's the world as codified colors, she wants to find the color of love. I like that this conflict is subtle, but I think what the other reviewer is saying is that it's too subtle. The protagonist doesn't fight for it enough. And yes, there aren't really moments where the protagonist tries and fails to get what she(she?) wants. Consider this as you go into rewrites.
One more thing. The ending was absolutely perfect. it took my breath away.
Thank you.
-Art
Thanks so much for the nitpicking, actually! I'm always happy to fix up my grammar mistakes. I'm really happy you liked it, and have made some changes and added some tries/fails.
I thought this story was adorable, frankly.
There were a few grammatical errors, but if you read over the whole thing just once, that can be corrected, no big deal. I truthfully didn't understand what this was supposed to be about until I got to the "blue blanket" part, and then it hit me like a brick wall. But in a good way; I felt like I made a gigantic, important discovery or something. I agree that there could have been a better conflict, but I also liked, primarily, the wording at the end. I felt the emotion in it.
All in all, this story really made me think, and I liked it. Good job, and see you around.
Thank you for reviewing! I'm not sure if you read it before or after my edit, but I added some paragraphs that outline the conflict right before "I know they are waiting in the church." If that isn't enough conflict I will add in more.
Thanks!
Pretty well written, just a few things.
I was disappointedat the absence of color
I think you meant 'I was disappointed at the absence of color". You just forgot the space between disappointed and at.
I moved into a flatwith a quiet male roommate and slowlybut surely became infatuated with the colors.
(I'm not quite sure what you mean by flatwith, never heard of it and I don't see what you're saying.) But I saw that you forgot the space between slowly and surely.
I listened to her descriptionsof gaining a sense you never had. Of livingwith one leg but suddenly being able to standon two. I waited for the day I saw color.
Again missing a lot of spacing between words.
I found many things like this and you should fix it. It seems to me like this was written quickly, you need to slow down. But over all pretty good story.
Bye!
~BookWolf
Thanks! What happened was that I copied and pasted it into an email and the formatting got screwed up. I fixed it now. I meant to put "flat with" but that got messed up too. Thank you again!
Thank you! I am glad to get a review on anything, especially a helpful one like yours. I added two paragraphs right before "I know they are waiting in the church" that I hope adds in a try/fail cycle. If it doesn't answer your advice let me know. Thanks again!