Love's Last Wish

Heh. You know, you guys, this topic is three years old. I've since edited the poem and published it in the second literary journal. I appreciate your reviews, though! xD

My nameless beauty,
So polite so strong,
Some wish her grief,
I wish her love,
I tell her to tell me her wish,
Fore I shall grant it,
She whispers in my ear,
All that she can,
And says “I wish, we never meet again.”,
Although his heart weeps,
Her wish is not of hate,
Tis of love,
He is bound by his promise,
To grant her wish,
So he does,
And slowly walks away from her death bed.

So polite so strong,

Fore I shall grant it

Thanks Everyone! I'll make the changes ASAP, and maybe re-post it. ^_^


Flemzo: X_X Just try not to click on my first few stories.

Max:

I think you can make this into a story and maybe this could be a reviling peek into the future? I don't know just a thought, good poem, better story.

Hello FA like I said I was bored so I say this... hmm........ It's not that I don't like it for it's I like this very much but. I want to know more, why did she want to never see him again how did they fall in love, why did he grant her a wish? I think you can make this into a story and maybe this could be a reviling peek into the future? I don't know just a thought, good poem, better story.

-Max

Awww... sad poem. I kind of liked what was going on here. You have a great idea going on here, and that's great. For a couple of crits:

Firearris wrote:My nameless beauty,
So polite so strong,
Some wish her grief,
I wish her love,

I tell her to tell me her wish,
Fore I shall grant it,

She whispers in my ear,
All that she can,
And says “I wish, we never meet again.”,

Although his heart weeps,
Her wish is not of hate,
Tis of love,

He is bound by his promise,
To grant her wish,
So he does,
And slowly walks away from her death bed.

Thanks for letting me practise on your poem, Fire! ^_^

Not every line needs a comma at the end, deary. In fact in your... *counts* ninth line? The comma is unnecessary because you already have punctuation there.

Also, line 6 -- it should be "for." Fore is what you shout on a golf course. xD

I agree with Snoink -- the perspective kind of changes. Maybe break it up into stanzas where it does switch POV? Or choose different pronouns to work with.

Aw. And such a sad poem. Interesting, if you ask me. Then again, I know nothing of poetry. =D

Erm... I thought it was good? Lol. It was pretty. ^_^

-Saint Razorblade
The Official YWS Pirate

I liked this but the punctuation and wording need some work and there's always room to improve where imagery is concerned. Here's a quick line by line -

My nameless beauty, [Perhaps a semi colon here?]
So polite, so strong, [I'd end this line with a full stop.]
Some wish her grief, [Maybe a dash?]
I wish her love, [Full stop.]
I tell her to tell me her wish, [Maybe have a line of enjambement here.]
[s]Fore[/s] For I shall grant it, [Again, a full stop.]
She whispers in my ear,
All that she can,
And says “I wish, we never meet again.”, [Remove the comma at the end of this line.]
Although his heart weeps, [Don't switch tenses.]
Her wish is not of hate,
Tis of love, [Maybe 'But of love' would sound better and the line needs to end with a full stop.]
He is bound by his promise,
To grant her wish,
So he does,
And slowly walks away from her death bed.

In general, you have a nice theme here but the poem itself could be more... well poetic. I think a little more imagery would be nice, perhaps some brief descriptions of the characters and such. Good work though and let me know if you have any questions.

I am also a "liker" of this poem. I know that makes no sense, but it does to me.

Cruel to be kind and all that, as the girl is dying and doesn't want him to linger on her love forever? Am I right? If so, I loved this, because it is different to the usual romatic sob story.

Good work.

I also like this.... but the tense change makes me squeal in a bad way. You'll really want to fix this. Another thing that irked me was the fact that a lot, lot, lot of it was telling.

"Although his heart weeps,
Her wish is not of hate,
Tis of love,
He is bound by his promise,
To grant her wish,
So he does,
And slowly walks away from her death bed."

That whole thing is telling, but the like "So he does" really gets to me. It's nothing really amazing--it's just telling. Try going through the poem and finding a better way to explain what is happening, maybe add more action even because I was kind of confused about what is actually going on. Not to say I'm the most amazing poet or anything, but this reminded me of my poem Sade's Folly. It isn't the best, but it might give you an idea of how to keep away from all the telling.

Keep it up!

This is rather sweet! It is sparse, but I think it works. A few places I was a little confused about tense; "she whispers in my ear" and "I wish her love" sounds like the poem is from the point of view of the boy, but it changes to third person at "he is bound by his promise". I'd suggest making a new stanza when you intend to change points of view, or changing all to the same point of view. There were a few lines I was confused at, and I don't think they're quite necessary:

"All that she can" is a little awkward; it made me thinkall what that she can? and confused me for a bit.

"He is bound by his promise to grant her wish so he does": I think that the "he is bound by his promise" is a little unnecessary, and adds wordiness. I think that the "so he does" is nice because it slows everything down before the final line.

"Her wish is not of have, tis of love" sounds a bit wordy as well; see how you can say what you mean in fewer words in this case, maybe

Additionally, I think that you could rethink commas and capitalization. At the moment, it seems kind of automatic, as if it's a rule that commas go at the end of lines and capitals go at the beginning, when each are used for emphasis rather than as a straight rule. In general, I'd suggest using a capital when beginning a new thought, or to mark an important idea.

PM me if you have any questions!
-Melia

Aww... this is kind of sad.

The only thing that really bugs me is that it seems to go from first person to third. So... is the narrator of the poem "I" or "he?"

Just something to think about...