This is the first story I have posted here! I thank everyone who takes time out for me to view and hopefully critique this... and I hope you like it! Italicized words are being thought.
Chapter 1
The village of Crysteria was nestled between the Icy Mountains to the north, the sprawling taiga to the south and the Northern Ocean to the west. It was a village that was completely dependent on the surrounding environment; its rich oceans and thick evergreen forests gave it the ability to trade for items that could not be found in the north, such as fruit.
Bayard Vischer was the son of Caddis Vischer, the most prominent fishermen in the village. Caddis held high standing in the village, representing the interests of the fishermen in the village council and holding a seat in the trade committee. Bayard was a tall and wiry youth of 14 with long auburn hair and had recently graduated top of his class in the village's school. His father had always hoped for his son to inherit the family business, but he had given up on that hope and was now encouraging his son to further his education. He would soon be traveling to the sprawling metropolis of Vandaer, considered a mecca for the well-informed, to attend a university.
Today Bayard was perusing along the beach looking for anything that might have washed up; a massive tempest had blown through a few days before and the village was still recovering. While practically all the buildings were left standing because of their robust brick design, some of the shipyards had been simply blown away as if they were twigs. Bayard had now started to return back along the beach, with a full net of fish over his shoulder; they had been out of the ocean for a while and where now beginning to reek, but they could be used as bait for the few intrepid fishermen that hunted the giant sharks of the northern seas.
As he made his way back across the stony beach, he heard a faint noise, barely audible over the crashing of the waves. It sounded like the chirping of a bird, but none were visible to him.
"Hm... the noise seems to be coming from the cliffs. It doesn't sound like any local sea bird's call." he muttered to himself as he made his way across the beach to the cliff face . When he got there, he followed the chirping for a few minutes until he came upon a small opening, that seemed to descend diagonally. As he got on his knees, however, he realized that the sand was damp around him; he knew the tide couldn't reach this far, even when high, so he made nothing of it.
"This shaft is way too slippery to crawl down," Bayard said, recoiling from the opening after having tried to go on his knees, "guess I'd have to slide down... but then how would I get back up?"
Bayard sat there for a moment, thinking what he could possibly do to get in the cave safely. Then he had a bright idea: he ran back to the ocean and found a long, sturdy strand of kelp that had dried enough to be used as a rope. When he returned he tied the kelp around a boulder sticking up out of the ground.
"This should hold." he remarked after having tugged it a few times, to check if it it would hold his weight. So, he held it under his arm and settled himself in a relaxed position, and pushed off. He rushed down the shaft and in a few seconds he was thrown flat onto the ground, his body aching.
"God, why'd I do that?" he asked himself bitterly as he stood up, stretching his body. As his eyes adapted to the lack of light he saw that he was in a cavity of the cliff. Along the sides of the cavern he saw that there were a few more vents and in the middle of it was a big pool of water, probably from the storm. In here, the chirping was quite loud, and as Bayard looked around he saw the source of it. He was star-struck for a moment, and then ran towards it to make sure he wasn't just hallucinating after his crash.
"Great Scott! It is a penguin!" Bayard cried with a mix of excitement and wonder, "Since when do they come this far south?". He had heard stories of penguins from sailors that braved to go into the high latitudes of them and read of them in school, but he had never seen one before. What surprised him the most, however, was its peculiar coloring; instead of the traditional suit of black and white, this one was covered in blazing red and translucent blue feathers! The poor thing was covered in cuts and bruises from head to toe, most likely given to it by the storm. "I think he sought refuge in here from the storm... yes, that must be why. But still, why has this little guy come so far south?" Bayard pondered to himself as he gently picked up the penguin and caressed it.
He was violently taken out of his world of though when a vent, right above him, started to gush water. It started out as a trickle first, but then soon grew to a healthy stream. Bayard knew just by smelling the water it came from the sea; the vent must lead out of the cliff somewhere and was now being submerged by the emergence of the high tide!
"Well, this explains the damp water in front of the opening; this cave must fill up during high tide, then flow into that pool of water!" He said despairingly. He quickly made his way back to the vent he came from quickly and grabbed onto the seaweed. He tucked the little penguin under his arm. While the oceanic rope of his held, he could not get up more than couple feet into the vent; even with the occasional hand hold here and there, it was just too slippery! How stupid am I to miss such a blatantly obvious feature? If it is too slippery to crawl down, it will be too slippery to crawl up!, he thought to himself, cursing his luck. The cavern was now filling up, and the water was now to his knees.
The penguin, which had been silent under his arm, now began to stir. He let go off the rope and held out the little guy, just to see the penguin open its eyes. They were like jade and pierced anything they looked at with a knife of keen inquiry. When he saw Bayard holding him and the rising water, it jumped out of his hands and hustled up through the vent without hassle. Bayard was amazed at this, and then saw that the vent had dried up completely. He quickly grabbed the rope submerged under the water, which had now gotten up to his waste and scampered up the vent.
Bayard flew out of the vent, ran for a while, and then collapsed. He heard the water starting to trickle, and then stream out of the vent, but didn't bother standing up. He was overwhelmed by a mix of adrenaline and exhaustion; it wasn't until the tide began lapping at his hair that he bother to stand up. As he looked around him, he saw the tide receding and then the vent's flow of water stopping. Beside the vent was the little penguin asleep and Bayard began to think about the events in the cavern.
What just happened? Was it magic? How could such a beat-up little penguin regain its strength and jump out of a hole? Could this perhaps be some special creature? Bayard's mind was racing with thoughts, until he decided to just give it a rest and think about it later. He went and got the net of rotten fish and hauled it over his shoulder and returned to the vent to check out the penguin; it was sound asleep. I owe my life to this little guy; best should take him home and give him a nice infirmary to recover. So, he picked him up with his free hand and trudged home, unaware of the sheer wonder he was carrying along with him.
Points:
Time spent:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Hey there Penguin. I am back as requested.
You are still telling here. Exactly how is this done? Use descriptions to show this. Describe farmers fishing or people picking fruits off the trees and exporting them.
Again, you are telling. Show it. Use descriptions to help create a picture in the reader's mind. If Bayard is the most prominent fishermen in the village, then give examples of when he was praised or admired. If his father wanted him to inherit the business, then describe the scene where they were discussing negotiations and talking it over with his parents.
Would anyone in real life talk to themselves outloud? Talking to themselves in their minds yes, but not outloud. That will just seem awkward.
Overall impressions:
It is better, but not by much. The only suggestion that I have for you now is to slow down the pace of what's happening. Take some time to show more of the character's feelings as well as the surrounding itself. Action itself isn't enough to tell a story as it will seem more like a sports play by play. That isn't what we want.
Sit down and read a fantasy novel. Learn how actions and descriptions are integrated together. Your homework now is to slow down the pace of this (as well as taking the rest of what I've said into consideration). When you're done, I'll have a look at it again for one last time.
Andy.
Okay everyone, I revised the chapter.
I made it longer, put in more action that I hope reveals Bayard's personality to all of you, and put less monotonous details.
Enjoy!
Hey there Penguin, are you one of PenguinAttack's troops?
Action! Give an example of it! Show how it is done.
When you are giving the history of someone/ some place at great speeds, it isn't a story, it's just text out of a history book.
Isn't he suprised to see the Penguin?
Overall impressions:
I'm aware you have heard of "show, don't tell" correct? This is what a majority of this piece is. You tell us about all these exciting aspects of your society, but the problem is that there is nothing in the writing for us to search or feel for. Think of it this way: It's like reading a guide tour of the place but not actually being there.
Ditch the history lesson of the place and just get on with the story as what you have right now only annoys the audience. Your society seems rather nifty and fun, but why can't we experience it ourselves? Start where the fishermen finds the penguin and work your way from there. I assure you, you will get more of an audience for that.
The concept and ideas to it are nice, but you need to learn what show and tell is. Do some homework and learn this very important term. If you keep telling the audience of information, then how are we as the audience be able to connect with the piece so that we can truly understand what's happening and be able to critique it?
Good luck.
Andy.
Hi there, EP! Here by request
I told myself I shouldn't read any possible, already given reviews of this story before I'd made mine. You see, I can't really focus on the story and my review if I already know what others have thought about it. It makes it more difficult for me to be objective. But so it happened that I read Snoink's review and kind of knew what to expect.
I think that because this is the first part of the story, it's okay for it to be kind of slow motion, so the reader isn't blown off from the beginning. However, this reminded me of a nice languid August day spent in a hammock, and I, too, felt like it could've been spaced up with a little personalization of Bayard (cool name, by the way), like his thoughts. Don't forget to use your senses.
Okay, that was the overall section. Let's move to nit-picks.
No need for "of the".
Good for his hair to be graduated, but what about Bayard?
That "there" in the end makes the sentence awkward, change it to "a university in Vandaer".
Ditch the H, it's "were".
Remember to hit space after the comma
There's something wrong with this sentence, and it has something to do with the word "thankful". You can't really leave that word alone. Maybe you could divide this part into two: "He got on his knees and crawled inside. Luckily, it opened up and allowed him to stand." Or something like that.
What's with the "the"?
Only one eye? Surely you mean "its eyes"?
Well. I'm sure this turns out to be actually quite actiony, now that he found the enigmatic penguin.
Thanks for the read!
Demeter xxx
Thanks Snoink. I do see what you mean by it being sort of drab, and I realize that the cave situation isn't very realistic >.<
I'll see to fixing it tomorrow; really tired now.
BTW, how is my grammar? I have a tendency to use lots of commas and semi-colons.
Hello Penguin!
The thing that I noticed about this work was the slow pace. It took several paragraphs for you to tell us the background of your story. Which is what Dostoevsky did, but you're not Dostoevsky. What you basically told us that it was a town that fished and that your main character was educated and that he was the son of a fisherman. But it was done in such a style that it was way to info-dumpy. That is, you thought, "Oh noes, I must describe every single bit about my society before I start the story!!!" Trust me... you don't.
As always, if you have any questions, feel free to PM me.
This is going to be a shortish critique because I'm tired.
I would probably scrap this beginning if I were you and start where he finds the penguin, making it action-packed. This place that you're describing reminds me of the ocean around San Francisco, so I have a clear picture of what's going on in my head, and your character is being awfully stupid around the ocean. By doing what he is doing, he is endangering his life by even trying to go in that cavity of the cliff. The ocean kills people who do that. I have no idea why he doesn't think of this danger. If his father is that good of a fisherman and he's that educated, then he should know better, or at least be slightly worried. So! Why isn't he worried? This is a wonderful way to build up suspense and connect us with your character, so you should definitely take advantage of it.
Right now, this story is flat and we don't care because we can't connect to the character. He seems flat. So give him some feelings, put a little more sense into this story, and it should be fine.
Hope this helps!