Warning: This work has been rated 16+ for language.
Three
After I finish eating, I go outside and I know that Ales would be at the nearby swimming pool. Knowing that she would probably beg me to swim with her, I stop by Carlyle and check the trunk. Turns out my pool bag was in there after all. I grab the bag and sling it over my shoulder as I begin my walk towards the swimming pool.
I watch the lake go by as I walk. Boats ranging from small motorboats to tall sailboats crisscross the glassy water in inconsistent harmony that is as nerve-wracking as it is calming. I love living near the water. It isn’t like living near Lake Erie, or along the Atlantic coast, or even on the Mediterranean, that Ales and her parents took my mother and I for a two-month-long cruise a few weeks ago, but it somehow brought a certain peace that I found oddly enjoyable. I see the occupants of the boats and I take in their body language with meticulous care. Some look relaxed, others are laughing and shouting incoherent messages that spell out fun, happiness, and joy. The water is where memories happen and it is where I’ve watched the world for the past eighteen years.
I arrive at the swimming pool and I see that business has picked up since I drove by it nearly an hour ago. To my displeasure, I see that a number of the girls from the cheerleading squad are present as well.
As I enter the swimming area, a few girls stop in mid-conversation and glance at me. I smile politely in return. They giggle. I don’t consider myself awkward around girls, but I am not the best at starting a conversation either. I was having enough trouble keeping my eyes to theirs instead of their revealing swimwear. I daresay Ales could tell which of them were aiming to get a few gawks out of their swimsuits.
The guys are a very different story. Some ignore me. Others try to engage in small talk. Times like those, I have trouble responding. That particular struggle mostly came from being unable to relate to what they were speaking of.
Somehow I spot Pauline Marek before I find Ales. Before I was gawking at her beauty, now I am intrigued by what she was doing. Rather than playing water polo in the pool with the other teenagers, she is sitting at a lounge chair reading. It’s not a magazine she is reading, but rather a large book. I look closely at the title, even though I am on the opposite side of the pool, and I see The Lord of the Rings.
“Ciao, il migliore amico!” I jump and yelp as I turn and see Ales already in her black two-piece swimsuit.
“Dammit, Ales, what are you trying to do? Make me fall into the pool before I even change into my swimwear?” I gesture with the pool bag under the crook of my arm.
“Potrei buttare in piscina, se non si cambia presto,” she says raising an eyebrow coyly.
I glare. “You better not throw me into the pool,” I warn, tapping her nose playfully. “Plus we’re with your friends; don’t you think that you can stick to English?”
Ales scoffs, waving her hand dismissively. “How will they know who my best friend is if I am always speaking English when I am around you?” she counters.
I squint sideways at her. Eventually, I raise my eyebrows and cock my head thoughtfully. “Well, I can think of another way.”
“Cosa intendi?”
Instead of giving her the satisfaction of a verbal answer, I smile broadly, set down my pool bag, and scoop her off her feet.
“Che cosa? No, non avete il coraggio!” Her protests are cut off as I throw her into the pool, followed by a chorus of laughter. When her head emerges from the water, her expression is lethal which I return with an open-mouthed smile.
“I’ll see you in a couple minutes, migliore amico,” I say waving my fingers as I pick my pool bag up. Her angry Italian remarks are drowned out as I head over to the men’s restroom. As I go, I steal another glance at Pauline. My throwing Ales into the pool must have severed her gaze from her book. Her eyes find me and I am caught off-guard. Being an artist has taught me a thing or two about the way a person looks at you and this was not just a stare. I think she is actually seeing me. And not that stupid brooding, mysterious teenager stare; it was more of an “I see you” stare. Her brown eyes meet mine like an icy grip that is as rapturous as it is terrifying. That feeling, however, is cut short as the wall cuts off my view of her.
As I change into my swimsuit and apply sunscreen, many thoughts run through my mind. I can’t let myself fall for this girl. I’m in high school for heaven’s sake! I need to focus on getting decent grades and avoiding situations that might otherwise land me in trouble. High school romances are nothing but flings doomed to end either by unfaithfulness, end of high school, inability to resolve issues regarding everything from public display of affection to differences in personality, and finally, a profusion of hormones outweighing chemistry and feelings.
I return outside and I see that Pauline has returned to her book. I also see Nigel Payson approach her and snatch her book away from her, to which she protests. I can’t hear over all the cacophony, but I can tell that they are arguing. I even see Nigel threaten to toss the book into the pool.
I want to storm over there and teach the punk a lesson, but I look away callously and claim an empty lounge chair next to one with Ales’ towel on it. Out of the corner of my eye, I see Ales rise out of the pool and walk over to me. She places her hands on her hips and stares down at me with an aggravated look. I say nothing.
“You’re gripping your paintbrush really hard,” she says finally.
I glance down at my hand and gaze at the old paintbrush thoughtfully. I have had that paintbrush for years. I have never used it, but I was always twiddling it in my fingers either to keep my hand busy or when I was lost in thought. I have even used it as a weapon once, which I do not like to think about. That was what earned me the nickname, “Paintbrush”. I loosen my grip on it and stare off into space.
“What has you so tense?” asks Ales, sitting down on the lounge next to me.
“Pauline’s eyes terrify me.”
“Terrify you?”
“They feel like an iceberg against bareness of my skin.”
“That could just be attraction, Kieran,” Ales points out.
“That’s the problem,” I snap.
“You need to let go of the past, amico,” I inhale as Ales places a comforting, but wet hand on my bare shoulder.
I decide to shift gears before the atmosphere turns disconsolate. “So how come I don’t recognize her? How come I’ve never seen her before?”
“She moved in last year,” Ales answers. “She is a skilled gymnast, multi-instrumentalist, bookish as you can see, and very, very reticent.”
“Is there anything that didn’t happen last year?” I wonder aloud.
“Sì, naturalmente.”
“Like what?”
“Non ho speso del tempo con il mio migliore amico perché era seimiladuecento chilometri di distanza appeso con i Vichinghi!” Ales pulls closer to her wraps her arms around me in a loving embrace.
I grip her wrists affectionately. “Mi dispiace, honey.” I raise an eyebrow questioningly as I twist around in her arms to face her. “Oh, and you’d be surprised by how keen some of those people were on tracing their genealogy all the way back to the Vikings. I daresay they were more dedicated than the Daughters of the American Revolution considering that they have way more generations to cover. Oh, and I thought I was doing a decent job of making up for our time apart.”
“What, you think going on a two-month long cruise through the Mediterranean was enough to ameliorate an entire school year where our only method of communication was hour-long Skype conversations?” Ales’ eyebrows come together in an angry frown.
I gape, hurt. “I thought I was doing a rather outstanding job making up for our time apart.” I smile deviously. “Shall I toss your pom-pom-brandishing ass into the pool again?”
There is so much fire in my Italian-American best friend’s eyes that I might run for my life was I another person. Then she breaks into a devious grin of her own, probably finding a sense of magnanimity, as she leans in to whisper in my ear. “Only if your paintbrush-brandishing culo follows.”
I’m left there staring as she gets up and dives into the pool. What the hell, I think. I take off my glasses and follow in after her. The cool water engulfs me like a gentle caress as I slowly skewer my way towards the surface. No sooner that my head emerges do I feel a bombardment of splashes descending upon my face like London being bombed all over again. I turn my face away as I send splashes of my own in the direction that I feel them. I take my best friend’s yelps as a sign that I am hitting my intended target. I submerge and plant my head between Ales’ legs and rise out of the water with her on my shoulders. She laughs and yelps as toss her in a direction where she wouldn’t hit anyone. When her face appears from the water, she shakes her head while trying without success to suppress her laughs. The reaction of the people around us is mixed—some, mostly the guys, steer clear of our silly water dual while others, mostly the girls take sides and it turns into one large battle of Team Kieran (or Paintbrush) versus Team Ales. The lifeguards, I guess they were just enjoying the show while making sure that everyone was being safe.
Eventually—I don’t even know how long we were all splashing each other to death—someone throws up a white flag. Well, a white bra anyway. After shouting at the girl to put her bra back on, Ales and I swim over to the middle of the pool and shake hands. Before we turn away from each other, she slaps me in the face and I flick her in the nose with a “Doyng” sound effect. We laugh and share a meaningful hug.
As we leave the pool everyone returns to their own water sports. We simultaneously groan in exhaustion as we sink into our respective lounge chairs.
“So, how do you feel about helping me set up for a party at my house this evening?” asks Ales after a few minutes.
“I feel that teenage parties are playground for condoms, beer kegs, awful music, and overall perfidy,” I state explicitly. “However, I can’t change the hormonal behaviors of the commonplace adolescent so I would be overjoyed to help my migliore amico set up for an end-of-summer party…after I’ve cleansed myself of this chlorine stench and napped.”
“How does a girl who maintains a dual-citizenship end up being friends with a guy as verbose as you?”
“How does a guy who most consider to be an abstruse person end up being best friends with a head cheerleader?” I counter.
“We were best friends before I even involved myself in that stupid cliché of clique,” she reminds me. “As I have told every cheerleader and jock that have approached me with a similar question, I will tell you that they can suck it up or go to hell with their inability towards someone breaking the social barriers of high school.”
“You make us sound like a living, breathing example of The Breakfast Club,” I joke.
“Sometimes I believe we are.”
“I’m sure that would make John Hughes very happy, God rest his soul.” I stretch, feeling some of the dryness of my skin crack as I do. I always hated how chlorine did that to my skin, and how I always seemed to forget to put a bottle of Vaseline in my pool bag. “Unless you want to find yourself another ride, I’m ready to go.”
I think Ales takes the silent message for what it is that it is time for me to tear myself away from this wildness as she gets up and heads over to the women’s locker room. I head over to the men’s locker room respectively and I step into one of the shower stalls. After rinsing all that chlorine from my body, I put my clothes back on and return outside. I catch myself scanning the area. I don’t even realize what I am looking for until my eyes land on Pauline. I don’t find her in that lounge chair with a book in her hands; I find her in one of the swimming lanes.
What impresses me is her swimsuit. It is a one-piece swimsuit and it is blue. Why did it have to be blue? And not just any blue; it is a deep shade of blue and as she rounds about to do a backstroke, a graphic streak of a much lighter blue starting from her hip and ending just above her breast on the opposite side is revealed. I avert my gaze, ashamed.
I leave the swimming pool area, quietly. I see Ales beat me to Carlyle, which is still parked in front of her mother’s restaurant. I get into the car without even saying a word to her. She follows suit.
“Qual è il problema?” she asks after a while.
The question catches me off-guard. “Nothing,” I answer almost too quickly.
“Kieran, sta in realtà cercando di mentire a me?” by her tone, I can tell that she already knows the answer.
“No, I am simply withholding the truth from you,” I answer stubbornly.
“Questo è mentire, genio.”
“It’s nice to know that you think I am a genius.”
Ales grumbles. “Look, if you don’t want to talk about it, that’s fine, but be truthful; you and I have come way too far to be doing that to each other.”
A few minutes go by where neither of us say anything, finally I exhale. “I just feel that I might be running the possibility of finding a certain girl to be extremely attractive.”
My best friend lets out a happy squeal that make me cringe. I think she sees my expression as her excitement soon dies down. She puts a comforting hand on my shoulder. “Oh, amore, non è niente di cui vergognarsi.”
“I’m well aware of that,” I say, but I know that my tone does not hide my shame. “I’m just—I’m just not ready.”
“Raramente siamo.”
“Isn’t that a fact?” I think I sound a little more impertinent than I mean to, but Ales doesn’t seem to take offense. Her comforting hand slithers across my shoulders and turns into an affectionate hug as she rests her head on my shoulder. I catch a whiff of her beautiful red hair that still smells a little like chlorine mixed with a more prevalent TRESemmé shampoo and conditioner.
“If you don’t want to come to the party tonight, I won’t make you,” she says, tacitly giving me the “go” sign for letting me have my alone time for the evening.
I take one of my hands off the wheel to return her hug. “I told you I’d come and help you with the party so that’s what I am going to do.”
Instead of letting out any vivacious outburst of excitement, she just holds me tighter lets the silent affection engulf us both. She knows that I dislike parties and, up until now she has never gone to any length to talk me into attending one. It is the summer before our last year of high school and, I guess I feel that I could do with helping her finish this summer off with bang.
Let’s see how this turns out.
Points:
Time spent:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Hey Crystal!
~ You have a lot of "coincidences" in your story. Things just "happen to be" where they need to be, which is way too convenient. This one would be an easy fix-- have him wondering if he'd remembered to put his bag back in his trunk after he took it in to wash his stuff, or something. Then it being there. Or have a sentence or two explaining that he always kept his swim bag in his trunk, since Ales often wanted to swim without notice. Or something.Shady back with another review for your story. As always, I'll give my specific thoughts as I'm going, and try to give an overall comment at the end.
~ That's it. I officially dislike Nigel. I was trying to like him in chapter 2, but I mean, you don't mess with a girl's book... Especially if she's reading LOTR. <3
~ Ohhh, this is good. I like this. I'd assumed that the nickname came from the fact that he was a painter... this statement intrigues me. I really want to hear the story, and it has me hoping you're going to include it in a later chapter.
~ This... left me incredibly confused. I think it's that whole thing with her speaking Italian just about all the time. Generally his responses make it make sense, but right now I have absolutely no idea what she said, or what he's talking about with the Vikings or the American Revolution... or what time apart they're referring to. I'm tired, so I may be missing something, but right now I'm just really confused... maybe add a bit of explanation (like "I couldn't believe she was still upset about--" or something) or make him insist on her speaking English.
~ This is the second time you've mentioned the Vaseline for his skin. I'm quite interested to know why his skin is so sensitive and why it's important. I mean, if it's a quirk/weakness of your MC you want to center around, then by all means play it up. But a bit of explanation would be nice... and if it's not a significant part of the storyline, then maybe nix it here so you don't have distractable readers (ME!) going off on mental rabbit-trails as we try to figure it out.
~ This sentence is really complicated, and I think you could phrase it more clearly if you used more punctuation and maybe split it up into two sentences. Like so: "I think Ales hears my silent message -- that I need to get away from this wildness for a while. She got up and headed for the women's locker room to get changed." I know that's not the best example ever, but you get the idea.
~ The "respectively" in this sentence is out of place. Just nix it and your sentence should be fine.
~ ~ ~
Ooh, Keiran's emotions are attacking him. Wonderful. c:<
I really like the characters you have created in this story-- definitely the strongest point so far, in my opinion at least. They're just so adorable together, and obviously are both very intelligent and interesting people. Keiran is a bit pretentious and sometimes his dialogue seems a bit unrealistic-- but generally he just seems like an elitist that looks down his nose at his peers. Which I understand-- he's exactly the type of teenager I was when I was in highschool. I was well read and would purposefully use big words when I was insulting things that highschoolers are supposed to be all for-- the romances, parties, drinking, etc. So, his feelings resonate with me, and it makes me happy to see that he (and I'm assuming you as well, considering how well you're writing him) shares the same feelings.
Overall this was a good chapter. I'm still not sure how I feel about the cheerleader, but when you mentioned that she was reading LOTR, I decided she's got a chance at making me like her, too. xD It's good to see Keiran with a self-perceived "weakness" in his emotions. Another aspect that I (frustratingly) can relate to-- snarking so much about how illogical and idiotic relationships are, and then having someone gorgeous making me fall for them, regardless of how badly I hated that. And having the best friend not being helpful. xD
Let me know if anything I said was confusing or you want any further explanation. As always, keep writing!
~Shady
I know his speech seems awkward. It's intentional. Read on and you might understand why.
Hello! Same drill - I'll focus on big picture things and if you want me to go back and do detail work, will do!


Let me know if you have any questions or if anything I said was confusing!
Plot thoughts.
So is going to this party?
Big picture wise - I'm assuming this is going to turn into a teen romance, right? You've put some feelers out for that, but I'm glad there is more to this plot than just that. You have a solid friendship, I feel like there's some backstory with his family, and I feel like there's some backstory with his issue with drinking. I still feel like in chapter three that we're still getting geared up for the plot. Not much plot plot has happened, just set up for the main plot (if that makes any sense :p). Sure, things have happened, but they feel like singular events that are setting us up for what's to come. I want to get to the what's to come.
Smaller picture wise - I feel like we're jumping around a lot. First we had Kieran waking up and painting a picture. Then he and Ales went to Ales's mom restaurant and he freaked out at a guy and saw a pretty girl. Now they're swimming. It just feels a little disjointed and jumpy to me. Like when I started reading this chapter I was like "wait, there's a pool? where's this pool? what day of the week is it? isn't it still early in the morning? they're swimming? they just happen to have pool stuff with them?"
Kieran thoughts. I have many
1. He describes himself as awkward. I don't really see him that way. His manner of speech is a little strange (more on that later), and he's an art kid surrounded by a bunch of jocks, but he seems rather assertive. I've seen more examples of his assertiveness (calling over a detective, confronting a jock, throwing his friend in the pool and starting a game of chicken) than of his awkwardness. The only awkward thing about him (that I see anyway) is...
2. His speech. He doesn't sound like a soon-to-be senior in high school. His manner of speaking is so formal and the way he thinks about things and describes things is so formal. Maybe you're writing him like that on purpose, I don't know. I'm just not digging his voice. It doesn't sound authentic to me. Kind of with that, he sounds judgey to me sometimes too. He lumps cheerleaders and jocks into bad except for Ales. He recognizes that's stereotypical and cliche, but I don't see his evidence for why he thinks of jocks and cheerleaders in this way. The only encounter he's had was with the one spiking his drink. Does he have a history with them or something? Also, a bunch of people from his school were at this pool party event - but it was only jocks and cheerleaders there? Aren't there other people at his school. Which sort of transitions us into...
3. This Pauline situation. I want to know why he's so opposed to a relationship in high school. His reasoning sounds like someone that's past high school looking back on stupid relationships. Does he have experience with failed love? Does this have to do with his family situation? This kind of goes back to my earlier point about him not sounding like a 16/17 year old guy. Most 16/17 year old guys I know and knew back in the day weren't thinking about falling in love - they were thinking about just having a girlfriend. Why is he jumping in so deep like - if I admit I'm interested I'm going to have to fall in love and that's just not okay? Also, by the end of this chapter he seems to be okay with accepting the possibility that he might be interested in Pauline. How did he make that jump - because at the beginning of the chapter he was not on board with that idea. And, what does he like about her? So far we only know that she's really pretty. I agree that this is what guys typically notice first and what's on the mind of boys this age, but the feminist in me needs her to have more redeeming qualities than just prettiness :p
Ales thoughts.
Well she's just cute and fun, isn't she?
The only thing that bugged me in this chapter was that she's continuously referred to as Italian American. At this point, I get it. She's Italian American. She speaks Italian a lot and she's Italian. I don't need anymore reminders.
And as for the actual Italian. I have two ideas. If you want to keep using the Italian, I would maybe include a translation in italics after so the non-bilingual reader understands. Like: (my example will be in Portuguese because I don't know any Italian :p) "Eu gosto gatos!" I like cats Ales said. If that feels too clumsy to you, I would say "The sun is so beautiful and bright today," Ales says in Italian. That way the reader knows that she's speaking Italian while still being able to understand.
Overall thoughts.
This was my least favorite chapter so far, I think because it felt a little out of place compared to the other two. There was a natural progression with the first two and this one felt thrown in. I'm not sure how the plot advances in this chapter other than Kieran maybe thinking it's okay to maybe have a crush on Pauline? Or him agreeing to go to a party? And the prose was a little much for me at times. The descriptions got a little flowery and over the top and I felt distanced from the characters and actual plot at times.
I'll keep reading on because I want to see where you're going to take this!
I see what you're saying about Kieran. Maybe I am just trying to hard to make him a complex character, because he is. He reacts differently to different situations, which also means that he doesn't always react the same way to the same situation if you know what I mean.
The way you say that most guys in high school don't want to fall in love that they just want to have a girlfriend...sounds like most guys just want to have an attractive trophy to parade around with. I wasn't one of those guys, but I can tell you that there were plenty like that.
Hello.
The main thing that sticks out here is the syntax. You're very stiff with the present tense and don't have a lot of variety in your sentence structure. It feels like you're really not used to first person present tense and everything ends up stiff. You're using subject-verb-object almost exclusively, with a personal pronoun starting the vast majority. As demonstrated by this quote, repetitive syntax leads to boring writing. Try adjusting what you put first and how you build sentences to see how you can get a better flow.
You also don't really seem to have the individual character's voice down. Lines like "well, what do you know" seem like you're trying to add in humour without really considering the confines of prose and the flow. When it comes to adding in humour to prose, especially sarcasm, you have to keep in mind that not everything translates well. "Well what do you know" sounds like you've set up a situation for the sole purpose of using that line. Make sure the humour comes naturally instead of ending in an eye roll.
You've also got a habit of side-tracking the story for whole paragraphs of background information. Your third paragraph, for example, has two lines of present description then the rest is all stuff that's mostly irrelevant to the story's present moment. This is where the advice "show, don't tell" best applies: you're telling us that the cheerleaders dislike her, but it would be much more effective to have her sit next to the cheerleaders, they move with a sneer at her, and she wonders if it's because she doesn't have her jacket. Then her sister asks if they've made any bad comments about her art lately and we get the background information that way.
"Show don't tell" is best applies for the characters themselves. Don't tell us a person is angry, show them yelling. Don't say "she hates her", show the actions that let readers draw that conclusion on their own. Telling us about character relations doesn't actually prove anything, and readers need actions to truly believe what's being said.
Overall, this looks like an early draft. The prose is stiff and the character voice is revealed primarily through telling, without much actual interaction that could reveal so much more about the character. If you can't really show the character information, ask yourself why we need to know it at that moment. Readers don't actually need to know everything at once, and my rule of thumb is "only tell them what's going on when they question it". When I read that third paragraph, I don't question her relationship with the cheerleaders and why they dislike her. So the information is irrelevant. Irrelevant information has no place in writing.
Let me know if you have any questions or comments.
~Rosey
You right about the fact that I am not used to first person narratives. This is just an experiment.
Experimenting is good! I'm glad you're doing it. Keep practicing and the flow things I pointed out will come on their own. You'll get better with time
If you're interested, I have another story called Blood and Silver. I have been blocked from that story lately (as in writer's block) but feel free to check it out. That story is completely different from this one in terms of both narrative and genre.
Sounds cool! I'll check it out ^^ (eventually. I'm notoriously slow!)
We have that in common. LOL Though I am a notoriously slow writer. I will write for three hours straight and sometimes a week will pass before I pick it up again.
Shadowolf here

I must say. I have absolutely nothing to critique! This story was well written from beginning to end. It held just enough interest to keep me reading, and enough playful fun to have a small smile by the end. I have to say I haven't read your previous chapters, but I don't doubt they would be just as fun to read. If i had anything to say on it, it would be the Italian. I do not speak it, and I see you trying to use the mc's dialogue to possibly express or explain a bit of what she is saying. But I was curious as to if there may be another way to do this. I wouldn't know as I don't write in other languages, but maybe mix enough English into her sentences that when coupled with the mc's dialogue, we might be able to figure it out. Although its not a huge problem and something that isn't really need to be considered, its just more of an opinion than anything. Awesome story and great read! Keep on Keeping on