*** This story is deleted -for the time being. Sorry.
Points:
Time spent:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
It's kinda a bit much. I think it could stand to be stretched out a bit; it's a little too much information for such a little amount of text and it gets kind of confusing.
Also, you manage to mix really choppy sentences with tons of run-ons, and you generally use too many commas. This is a run-on: "We were already poor, it had been a struggle to get bread onto the table." The comma should be changed for a semicolon, dash, or just a period. You should vary your sentence structure more.
It was interesting, though, and I do want to (so, plan to) read more.
Thanks for your reviews! Megsug - Thank you so much for pointing out the time period. I didn't realize I overlapped it too much. Oops. Anyway, I'll be sure to fix it. Also, thank you SO much for the part of Stanley and his Ma's jobs. I guess I didn't really think a lot on that.I'll do more research and fix on the mistakes.
And also, Megsug, please feel free to give me as much history lessons you want. It's very helpful.
~DeadEnds
Hey Deadends,
I didn't think you needed a preface, but this is cool, I suppose. There are a few things that don't match up historically.
If Stanely was five when the Depression, which was 1929, he wouldn't have been older than thirteen when the Dust Bowl ended. I can't remember how old he is in chapter one, but it's something like eighteen, right? Anyway, by 1941 the Depression was over. I would rethink his age at the time of the Depression. Even in a family hard pressed to find food, a thirteen year old wouldn't do much or feel like he had a lot of responsibility on shoulders. The Dust Bowl started in the early 30's. Most of my sources say 1931. It ended 1937. American troops weren't really sent over until after Pearl Harbor, which was 1942, but my history teachers say volunteers were sent over before that to help the Allies. I think, pilots especially, because of the Battle of Britian, which happened in 1940. Actual fighting between the Allies and the Axis Powers didn't start until 1939 where America was "neutral" during most of that time.
What I'm saying with all these dates is, you haven't really been matching up this whole time. Yes, the Depression and World War II are related and overlapped a bit, but not as much as you're saying.
Just try to use the dates I've given you and make a timeline. Your story is still possible. You're off to a great start. I would draw up a timeline with the main happenings of the Depression and WWII and what you're planning with the story. See if that helps.
I would give you a link, but I found the information from many sources, and they didn't all match up. The information I got is reliable though.
I don't want to push your story too much in one direction, so I'll let you figure out what age Stanley needs to be where.
It was fine. Compared to your first chapter it was... okay. PM me when you have a new part or seriously edit anything. I'll
be happy to review something or re-review it, if you need me to.
Megsug
Hey DeadEnds!I'm Hope, and I'll be reviewing you today!
Mehh this is kind of an info dump, and what I don't really like about it is the fact that we haven't really been introduced to the character before it.Adrenaline doesn't seem like the best word to describe what you're trying to convey, in my opinion. When you say adrenaline it brings to mind really high pressure situations, a lot of action and fear. Which doesn't really fit here does it?
Ehhhh I have a problem with this. Like really if you're "hoping to make it through the next day" and watching your younger siblings starving, you really wouldn't slack off all the time. I just find it a little unrealistic. Most kids back then weren't spoiled, especially if they had like you said, nothing.
But anyway, those are my nitpicks! Good luck and keep writing!
~Hope