Hi! Cricket here for a review!
Guh, I just had this feeling that Joseph was going to find out! And I didn't think it would be pretty once he did. I just can't figure out Joseph right now though! He's acting sooo strange. Very different from his usual self. Like he all of a sudden just wanted to purposefully shove Asenath aside. Almost like he doesn't love her anymore, but I know that can't be the case.
What I really like in this chapter though, is how you portrayed Asenath. She doesn't seem quite as childish here, as she normally does. Like she grew and matured, over a very small period of time it seems. (Not how it's supposed to be like, but I think you know what I mean. She just sounds more mature in this chapter) I think the real reason why she sounds more mature, is because she is trying to help her husband out, while still trying to do the right thing in the process, which is very hard. As Joseph made quite clear in the end of this chapter, he didn't need her help in anything. Idk, I just hated that part. It was like Joseph didn't have control over his mouth when he was speaking. I know the Joseph from before, when they were newly married wouldn't have spoken that way to her, at any time, place, or circumstance. It just wasn't like him. And from the way Asenath reacted, it didn't do that well. Women are there to be the helpmates of their husbands, and being told by their husband that they aren't needed, isn't exactly good for their marriage. I'm kinda thinking that Joseph needs to be slapped right now, but that's not Asenath's place I believe. Although I'd do it any day.
What I really just don't understand is that Joseph seems to be treating this entire scheme like some way to get back at his brothers. I mean, I know the Bible story. But never while reading the Bible did I get the impression that Joseph was trying to get back at his brothers. I always just thought he was trying to see if they had changed at all, and if they were sorry for what they'd done. That was my general reaction when it came to the actual story. Here though, I keep getting the feeling that he is just doing all of this to get revenge. But I don't think that is his or yours intent. It really just doesn't seem like him at all. More like someone extremely foreign and new had taken his place, and the old Joseph was just pushed aside for a better time. Like he has two personalities! Don't think that's going to work though, cause right now I'm upset with Joseph.
A black scarf was wrapped around her head, andonly her eyes shone through.
Here I think you could help this sentence flow better if you added that article right there.
She clutched a bag of grain, a mortar and pestle, and a pomegranate close to her body
Hmm, would they have pomegranate's right then? With the famine going one and all I would think that there would be a shortage of such delicacies. Also, make sure you research if those type of fruits grow in Egypt.
Go away. I…I don’t believe in ghosts.”
Bleh, what is he? A baby? Sorry, but he now reminds me of a silly four year old boy. That would be something my little brother would say, and even then... he wouldn't do it quite like that. xD I'd suggest really mapping out each and every character as you write, as to make sure they all sound their age, and of course they sound unique.
Right now, Asenath and Oni are pretty similar in their ways of talking. There are several ways of defining someone's particular style of speaking, so many that it would take forever to tell you about them. But an example would be like, one person uses contractions a lot in speaking, while the other doesn't. Just a simple way of defining that one person's way of speaking is all. But there are many other ways. If you have time that is, it would be a good idea to research this when doing the final edit.
So like Joseph’s, but so different.
So twice in a row is sooo boring. xD How about entirely instead of the second so.
He hit the wall as hard as he could.
We only learn what he hit the wall with until two paragraphs later. How about you tell us right here, instead?
Nobody else knew.
Here's an example of telling and not showing. Show us that nobody else knew. Otherwise we don't have as clear of a picture as we could have, and just a little more info on that and you could be adding more meat to the story!
“I was picking up weaving!”
Instead of this, or only this... how about you have it to where she motions to the weaving in her hands and maybe make some helpless gestures, or just something like that. Would be a bit more realistic I think.
OK, as far as story line goes for this chapter, I'd say I'm absolutely in love with it. I knew that Joseph was going to find out sooner or later, and he did! She got caught red handed, right in the act. Which was what I was fairly sure would happen, but not entirely. From what I can see there's going to be a period of time that they don't talk to each other. How long that is going to be for I don't know. But I can just seeee it. xD
That's all for now I think. Keep writing!
~Cricket
Points: 1658
Reviews: 401
Donate