"You said you wanted to talk?" Ingrid asked.
James nodded. There was a beat of awkward silence as she looked at him expectantly.
"...Do you want to do it here?" she finally asked.
James hadn't really thought through the where, but, out in the open like this was a much better option to going anywhere private. Out here, at least, there was the accountability of cameras to keep them in check.
He nodded again.
There was another tense silence as James tried to think of how to begin, but he could tell Ingrid was growing impatient.
"Why are you here?" James decided to ask.
Ingrid's eyes widened a bit, and she looked almost offended by the question. But it was a valid question.
"I... I thought you'd want to see me," Ingrid said quietly.
Ohhhhhhhkay. Wow. She was taking this route, huh? James had to keep his face from looking more pissed than he normally did.
"Just answer the question," James said.
"Fine," Ingrid said, frowning. "I wanted to see you. Is that not enough?"
James let out a loud exhale through his nose.
"Not when I haven't heard from you in three years and this is the first time I see you," James said. "What, you couldn't have waited two months until this show was over? Why come to me on a TV set? Why come during my DMV? Why now?"
Ingrid bristled, once again looking hurt at his tone, like maybe she'd expected him to be soft after all these years.
"You think I came here just to be on TV?" she asked. "Is that what you're accusing me of?"
"I'm not making any accusations," James said. "I'm asking questions."
"Yeah, but you already implied it," Ingrid retorted.
"Is it that hard to give a straight answer?" James shot back.
"God," Ingrid huffed. "It doesn't have to be this difficult. You're the one coming at this like it's an interrogation. Can't we just have a conversation?"
"What do you think we're doing right now?" James asked, lifting up his hands in exasperation. "Did you come here for your fifteen minutes of fame or not, Ingrid?"
"I could care less about he TV show!" Ingrid said curtly. "And it's insulting you would think so. Don't act like you didn't block me and change your number after we broke up. And then you went to prison, and no one was allowed to talk to you except your lawyer and your family. And then you went fucking off-grid. I didn't have any way to find you until now."
"I've had private investigators track me down," James scoffed. "What, you couldn't dig for my information online if you wanted to see me that bad?"
"I'm not a stalker, James," Ingrid argued, gesturing out towards where the goolf cart had disappeared, now. "Unlike some people on this island, apparently."
James rolled his eyes. That was besides the point.
"Why not just wait two months until this was all over, then?" James asked. "The whole world practically knows where I live, now."
"As if I could be assured you'd be going back home after this at the rate you're going," Ingrid shot out.
James opened his mouth with another scoff, but he didn't have a retort prepared for that.
"Wh--what's that supposed to mean?" he asked.
"Read between the lines," Ingrid said, frowning.
James stared at her, his brows furrowed deeply. Was she implying that she thought he was suicidal again?
"I'm not going off the rails," he said, lowering his voice.
"Hell of a lot you're doing to prove it," Ingrid said, frowning deeper. "You're not convincing me."
James pinched his eyes shut, rubbing his face for a moment before he let out a frustrated sigh.
"So what," he tried again, asking in mocking disbelief. "This is all to make sure I'm 'okay?'"
Ingrid didn't respond right away at that, and when he looked up at her again, she was looking at him with her brows knit together, and her eyes began to look misty.
God, not again.
"Take a good look at yourself in the mirror," Ingrid said.
"I already do that every day," James said flatly.
"Well, I'm sorry for caring that you don't end up in some sandy ditch somewhere," Ingrid said. "You might not want my help but I'll be damned if I don't at least try. I don't know why the DMV reached out to me instead of anyone else, but the reason I said yes to coming is because I've been following Island Magic ever since it started, and all I've seen these past three weeks is you repeatedly digging yourself several graves while the rest of you falls apart. Everyone can see that you're not doing well, James. I don't know what it's going to take for you to admit it for yourself--"
"I know I'm not okay!" James cut in, raising his voice and throwing his hands out in front of him. "I don't need another self-awareness lecture! This is about you--"
"No it's not--" Ingrid tried to interrupt.
"Yes it is!" James ran her over. "I don't know if you forgot this, Ingrid, but you're the one who ended it! Not! ME!"
And at hearing his own raised voice carry loud over the silence that fell between them, James suddenly felt like havin this conversation outside was a bad idea.
He felt himself shrink under Ingrid's stare as her expression only grew more heartbroken, and he wished he could just slink away and pretend he never tried to start this. But it was far, far too late for that now.
"You want to know why I really broke up with you" Ingrid asked. "You really want to know?"
James didn't know what this was leading to. Was she just being dramatic? He thought she'd already told him. She'd already given him her piece.
"Alright, I'll tell you," Ingrid continued, even though James didn't give her an answer. "It was because I had to. You were already cutting off everyone close to you because you were so deep in your paranoia you wouldn't let yourself trust anyone. And at the same time, I knew you were worried to death that something would happen to me by being associated with you. I knew you'd never have the heart to fully push me away, but you were doing it anyway, and it hurt too much to watch. I thought that if I gave you distance you could at least be at peace knowing I'd be safe, and then maybe - just maybe - after the storm blew over, we could try this again."
Ingrid was on the verge of tears, but at her last words, her lips began to tremble, and tears started rolling down her cheeks.
"That might be too much to hope for," she said. "But I wanted to at least try. Because I--"
She got choked up on her own words and had to swallow the knot back down.
"I really wish I didn't have to do this with the whole world watching. And you don't know how humiliating this is for me, but I still love you, James," she said. "And I'm sorry that I had to push you away. I didn't know what else to do. You were self-destructing and you wouldn't let me in anymore."
She looked to the ground, tears plopping onto the sand at her feet.
"And you still won't," she muttered. "So... I guess it's pointless."
James stared at her.
He...
He let out a shaky breath.
This... no. No. This was too much. It wasn't real. It-- he didn't know what to believe. She hadn't said any of this three years ago. Where was this coming from? Why was she only saying this now?
He lifted his hands up to his face, steepling them around his nose and lower half of his face as he squinted at her - pained, and knowing that she was nonverbally asking for comfort. But he was not going to touch her. Not now, not ever. He still couldn't trust that she wouldn't alter his emotions, and he desperately didn't want that to happen.
Still, the very human part of him that still very much saw her as a person and still cared about her as a friend - former friend - hurt to see her like this.
How the hell was he supposed to respond to this in a way that didn't make him look like an asshole? Did she plan all of this to emotionally manipulate him, cornering him into crawling back to her again? Or was he actually in the wrong in all of this? He'd acknowledge his paranoia and trust issues, and he was trying to be better. But she wasn't telling the whole story. She was leaving out all of the parts where she made him feel small. Where she belittled him and cut him down. Where she didn't let him choose, and she pushed any boundaries he tried to set like they were merely suggestions. She was leaving out the part where she actually discouraged him from bringing the corruption to light, where she urged him to pursue comfort and safety instead of justice. She was leaving out the part where she was complicit, where he protected her when he shouldn't have, where he made it so the charges against her didn't send her to jail, and merely ruined her career. She was leaving out the part where she'd been resentful about it, and she didn't want to stick around with a partner who, at the time, could've potentially been in prison for the rest of his life.
But even if he explained all of that, there was always going to be someone who didn't believe him, and he knew that Ingrid was only going to deny it. She already had before - over and over again - and even in this, where she could've acknowledge it, she chose not to.
Instead she made it sound like he was the only one at fault, and she was just trying to "do the right thing."
She was making herself the hero of the story, like she always did.
"I can't do this again," he finally said after too long a silence of Ingrid standing there, crying to herself.
She sniffled.
"It's fine," Ingrid said with a croak.
But James shook his head.
"No. I don't just mean that," he said. "I... I don't think we should talk to one another while we're on the island. I think we need to leave this behind us. If you want to talk more about this, you can seek me after this DMV is over. I don't want to talk about this now. Not... not here."
And really, not at all. But he was giving her space for it, even if he didn't need it. Auslanii was just not the time and place.
Ingrid was silent for a moment, reaching up to wipe her eyes, patting her cheeks dry. She sniffed again, as if it were the last one.
"So you're just... going to pretend this never happened?" she asked sadly. "And we ignore it for the rest of the week?"
James clenched his jaw, letting out a sigh.
"I'm not going to ignore it. But I need there to be boundary lines between us. I won't control what you do, but I need you to know that there will be consequent actions I'll take if you cross them," he said, forcing his voice to be steady.
"You always had a way of reasoning away your emotions," Ingrid muttered.
And she knew that it would hurt. It was a weapon she used to use a lot in the past - one that hurt because it was true. But he was a different person now. He'd grown, and still had a long way to go, but he didn't keep it all inside. He was at least trying to invite people into it now. That's where he was starting, with some encouragement from his therapist.
But he was letting people in that he trusted. And Ingrid just wasn't that. He didn't think she ever would be again.
He didn't address her comment.
"If you try to touch me," he said. "I reserve every right to walk away without explanation, and to do what is necessary to avoid it, no matter how awkward or bizarre."
Ingrid let out a pained scoff.
"You're seriously doing this right now? Giving me a list of ultimatums?" she asked.
"It's not an ultimatum," James corrected. "It's an if-then statement. If you don't try to touch me, then that won't happen."
"That's if you even let me talk to you," Ingrid said with a pout.
"Which brings me to what I wanted to say next. You can interact with others, and even me, but if you bring up our past relationship or try to engage me in restoring it in anything more than a surface level capacity - i.e. with romantic pursuit - I will also reserve the right to disengage from the conversation in any way I see fit. Be it ending the conversation altogether, changing the subject, or bringing someone else in to keep it from going that direction."
Ingrid's brows furrowed deeply.
"Why do I feel like you're going to interpret everything as an advance towards you?" she said quietly.
"You know, a great way to avoid that, then, is to not seek me out alone. Group interactions do a lot to mitigate those misinterpretations," James offered. "Which bring me to my last request: please do not seek me out alone. I think it's the wisest decision for this week for both our sakes'."
Ingrid stiffened, letting out a shaky huff through her nose.
"Now that sounds like an ultimatum," she murmured sadly.
"I'm just letting you know ahead of time," James said with a sigh. "Which I hope you will see as a kindness so you don't think I'm ignoring you outright when I don't seek you out alone either after this."
Ingrid took in a deep breath, shuffling in place for a moment as if she felt like she'd been backed into a corner. She'd probably been hoping to work him up emotionally so that the conversation would never reach this point, but James was determined to put his foot down.
This was a test of his mettle. If he couldn't do this, he wouldn't be able to stand up to Constantine.
Ingrid brushed a hair behind her ear, looking off to the side with a folorn look about her, as if he'd kicked her while she was down.
"You said... after all of this is over," Ingrid asked quietly. "And the DMV is over. That you're open to talking about it again?"
James took in a sharp inhale.
Give her an inch, she'll take it a million miles.
"I'm open to discussion," James said. "But not reconsideration."
Ingrid frowned, as if confused.
God, she knew what he meant. Did he have to spell it out for her? Fine.
Before she could speak - because he saw her opening her mouth - he spoke instead, with pain in his words: "Please just let me go."
Her face fell.
"I just want to move on," James said, softer.
And Ingrid would just have to accept that her future would not have him in it.
A tense silence followed, and Ingrid held her hands in front of her, staring at the sand at her feet as a few more tears escaped her eyes, adding the faint puddle of wet sand by her sandals. He wished he could understand her, and at the same time, he didn't know if he really wanted to. It wasn't that he didn't empathize with her. He knew her pain was real. But he didn't approve of the way she was going about this.
The worst thing he could possibly do right now in this stage of his life was rush into something. Especially if that something was letting Ingrid be involved again.
Ingrid would have to rebuild all of the bridges she'd burned. She'd have to regain his trust, because she didn't have it anymore. And all of that would take time, if it even happened at all.
"I guess I should go before I make myself look like more of a fool than I already have," Ingrid said, wiping her eyes once more.
James sighed. She was fishing for support again. To turn this all into something where he ended up comforting her, and she forgot about everything else he said.
"You still have to settle in," James said. "It's not a short walk to the mansion. I'd get going now."
And that was the softest way he could've told her to leave.
Flinching as if he'd yelled at her, Ingrid nodded, but didn't move.
James stared at her for a moment, feeling the weight of some kind of unspoken expectation without anything explicitly said. Not knowing what she wanted, nor wanting to give it, he decided if she wasn't going to leave, that he was.
Letting out a tense sigh, James shook his head when Ingrid glanced up at him. Alright. He'd go.
"Goodybe, Ingrid," he said, and finally stepped away.
He felt his hair raise on end when he saw her reach out for him, but she stopped herself short of doing so, and pulled her hand away, biting her lip. He glared at her hand for but a second before he sped up, pacing away quickly and leaving her behind.
He only glanced over his shoulder once to make sure she wasn't following. When he saw she had turned to start up the hill, he was relieved, and hoped that she stayed on that course and didn't change it once he wasn't looking.
He still had one more conversation he needed to get out of the way while he was out. He needed to do it before he forgot.
Gender:
Points: 3255
Reviews: 174