Circle I (i-Luke)

7 posts
User avatar
Gender Female
Points 53415
Reviews 1125
Rated for gore.

AN:
Spoiler
So I'm mostly posting for the sheer thrill seeing as I haven't posted in a while. It's very rough. What I'm most looking to improve is a) introducing Luke's whole situation and b) trying to stop Finn coming off as a Sue, which I'm afraid that she might. Anything else, I'm always open to whatever advice you can give!


I. Luke


On the way to Maths class, I saw another body.

It was a girl this time, or maybe a young woman. It was hard to tell. Her body was crumpled up like nothing imaginable, face down, peroxide blonde hair trailing on the ground. I think her top had been white to start off with, but was so covered with blood and God-only-knew what else that it looked like some macabre version of tie-dye. I couldn’t even make out her legs, so mangled with so many parts missing, perhaps she was only left with one. I didn’t know. All I knew was that she was dead and I was going to be sick.

I shut my eyes hard because I didn’t believe what I was seeing. When I opened them, the vision or whatever the hell it was was gone. The gravel by the science block was empty and clean and pale in the winter light. But she was still there in my mind and I began to gag.

I never made it to Maths. I ran back to my room, pushed the stiff bolt on the bathroom door across and retched into the toilet, then just sat with my back against the wall trying in vain to get the image of her out of my mind.

That made four. Four bodies in ten days- the ten days that had passed since my roommate Barry went home with what was apparently glandular fever. The morning after he left, I saw the first one. An old man, homeless by the look of him, so viciously ripped apart it looked like he had been killed by a particularly ferocious bear.

Then, just like the others that followed, I blinked and he was gone.

At first I thought Barry had given me his illness and went up to the matron’s office. But she felt my glands and took my temperature and frowned and asked if I was really sick. She knew I wasn’t one to fake illness to get out of class. I shook my head, said I just wanted to make sure and went on my way. I figured I was imagining things.

It was only later, in the common room that lunchtime, that I began to get worried. The news reported that a homeless man had been killed in more-than-mysterious circumstances in Carrickdove, the village where our school was based. I tried to tell myself I must have already heard of the murder, that my subconscious was playing tricks on me.

Until it happened again.

And again.

And now I was sitting on mine and Barry’s bathroom floor thinking that no imagination could conjure up that girl.

But if I wasn’t imagining things, then what the hell was happening to me?

I figured I might get away with missing Maths, but even with my track record I was pretty sure I’d be in trouble if I skipped Irish as well. Ignoring the smell of vomit, I picked myself up, winced as I thought of the girl again and splashed my face with cold water. I put my glasses back on and told myself that it was nothing I couldn’t handle. I knew I was lying.

Irish was a chore. It always was. Poetry heavy, and the poetry was depression heavy, and somehow Finn Moloney and her gaggle of followers were there. I could hear a few of them giggling and Mary Shea shrieking as I pushed the blue swing door open. God, I hated that girl. She was so ordinary from her name to her hair to her talents, and that would have been fine if she simply accepted it like the rest of us had. But of course she couldn’t, she had to make noise and try and grab the attention of the room. All she was really doing was making my already pretty atrocious headache worse. She had only just been moved to our class- the Honours class. I may have hated Irish almost as much as I hated Mary Shea, but that didn’t mean I wasn’t good at it. All the time I spent studying paid off.

I moved in and took my usual seat, neither at the front or the back but quite comfortably in the middle. No one bothered you if you were in the middle and you kept your head down. I began rearranging my textbooks and waiting for Mr. O’Hara to come in when the girl’s body as I had seen it lying outside on the gravel came to me again. I flinched and held back the urge to throw up.

“Luke? Are you okay?”

Out of all the people to notice me, it was Finn Moloney. Dear Lord.

In every way that Mary Shea was dull, Finn was pretty extraordinary. She didn’t try to catch attention, she didn’t need to when she effortlessly drew every eye and ear in the room. She annoyed me with the way she knew she was gorgeous, she knew she was smart and sexy and funny. Girls like Mary Shea fawned over her, boys like me (but not me- that much) drooled over her.

I looked up, met her perfectly mascara-framed blue eyes and nodded. “Yeah. Fine.”

Finn turned her bright blonde head as Mr. O’Hara walked in and told everyone to suí síos. All her long, bleached hair suddenly reminded me of the girl lying face down on the gravel. I lurched in my seat but thankfully didn't throw up. Out of the corner of my eye I could see Finn glance toward me. The whole way through class that blonde head- still alive, at least- kept turning my way. I just stayed in my seat and tried not to think of anything to do with the bodies or what I would see on the news later or why Finn Moloney cared. I didn’t know what she would, didn’t know who the girl was or how she had died.

All I knew was that something was extremely wrong with me and I didn’t have a clue what it was.

--

edited 22/2/11
Last edited by StellaThomas on Tue Feb 22, 2011 11:04 pm, edited 3 times in total.
"Stella. You were in my dream the other night. And everyone called you Princess." -Lauren2010




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 4013
Reviews 201
I'm sad that I didn't see anything wrong with this...I want to be able to help you but I didn't catch anything that was obvious, so good job with that. I'm pretty interested in the story although I saw parts that you could use to your advantage. For example Finn had blonde hair like the dead girl, you could use that as something that bothers Luke. Like he could not be able to look at her or something. That would cause her to ask him what's wrong instead of him only being sick. It's not really a change but I think someone who doesn't normally notice Luke would be more offended and wonder more if it was he wasn't able to look at her. I'm interested to see where this is going and think you did a good job of giving out information but you could describe things a little bit more. I don't know what Luke looks like as of right now and I'm not that sure about his surroundings. Make him see his reflection in the mirror and say something about it? Have fun with the descriptions(: I hope this helps. I'd love to see where this goes so PM me when you post more(:

~peanut~
There is a light in you, a Vision in the making with sorrow enough to extinguish the stars. I can help you.
~And The Light Fades


The people down here are our zombies, who should be dead or not exist but do.
~Away From What We Started


P.S Got YWS?




Random avatar
Gender Female
Points 1493
Reviews 9
I really like this! Very unique! It draws readers in and makes you want to know more. I like the way things are described, but a few more details would be helpful. Maybe give some more background information, or something like that. Please continue, this is excellent!




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 28467
Reviews 675
Stellz, have I mentioned lately how much I luff you!
Well, I at least love when you bring up anything Irish because for some reason it just makes me all giddy for my Corkonian. *sighs*
Not even kidding, getting to Google translate “suí síos” made my day. Yeah, I’m crazy.

Anyways….

One little nitpick: (and it’s not even a real nitpick but it is me being picky and of the nit-like variety…so it may be a real nitpick. hmm)

boys like me (but not me- that much-) drooled over her.


The parenthesis and the dashes seem like too much, especially the one right after “much.” I don’t think you need it actually and it looks sort of lopsided, like a scowling yet smiling Cyclops is hanging out in the middle of your sentence.

As far s the characters go:

Luke I actually really like. You have the art of cause and effect down. He’s seeing flashes of dead people and he’s reacting. Some people forget to let their characters have a reaction as long as this remains consistent or evolves smoothly, then this particular aspect of him I like. Not only that but *looks back at the quoted bit overhead* I like that little bit of comedy in there. It’s cute and a little bit John Green.

As far as Finn goes, there’s not much to say yet because you’ve given us very little about her so far. But I like how she seems to notice Luke who would ordinarily be a “lesser creature” if you want to put it into my pal Zach’s terms. It takes away a lot of what could become a Mary Sue-like character.


Overall, I’m actually really curious to see where this goes, Stellz. And I’m hoping there’s some more Irishie things to keep me smiling! *crosses fingers*


~lils
Never forget who you are, for surely the world will not. Make it your strength. Then it can never be your weakness. Armor yourself in it, and it will never be used to hurt you.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 9692
Reviews 3900
Stella! And... Stella writing?! OMNOMNOM.

Anyway! I'm not sure if this is me misreading things due to sleep deprivation or whatever, but... are these people she's seeing not real? Because at first I thought they were real and then it seemed like she was imagining them and it was rather confusing! So I would definitely clear that up.

BUT. That doesn't stop the fact that I WANT MOAR. So please, more? :D
Ubi caritas est vera, Deus ibi est.

"The mark of your ignorance is the depth of your belief in injustice and tragedy. What the caterpillar calls the end of the world, the Master calls the butterfly." ~ Richard Bach

Moth and Myth <- My comic! :D




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 8009
Reviews 93
Hey Stella! I really liked this. People are always writing about characters who can see ghosts/dead people/various frightening things, but you made it seem fresh and not at all like a cliche. I didn't really notice anything that you could improve on, except for one minor thing:

I couldn’t even make out her legs, so mangled with so many parts missing, perhaps she was only left with one or maybe both were gone.


This sentence confused me. Does she have legs or not?

And like Snoink, I was really confused at first as to whether or not the body was actually there or not. At first I thought that the story was taking place in a world where finding bodies was supposed to be commonplace or something, but I quickly figured out that Luke was the only person who could see it. I would try to clarify this a little more in the beginning, though.

Other than that, I loved this! Finn doesn't seem like a Mary Sue, and she'll seem like even less of one if Luke gradually begins to notice some of her flaws and realize that she isn't as perfect as he originally thought he was.

Let me know if you post anymore! :)

Magnus
“Don't tell me the moon is shining; show me the glint of light on broken glass.” Anton Chekhov




User avatar
Gender None specified
Points 72525
Reviews 1220
You requested that I review this in Chat a while ago. Me, being the forgetful person I am, forgot to review and Like. This grievous injustice will now be corrected.

On the way to Maths class, I saw another body.

I adore this line. Not like; not love; adore. It is the perfect opening line: attention-grabbing, and it hints at more that went in addition to the more that is to come. And you don't disappoint with the to come, either, with how you explain the "again" straightaway instead of leaving us hanging. Omnomnom.

Her body was crumpled up like nothing imaginable, face down, peroxide blonde hair trailing on the ground

Nitpick! "Nothing imaginable" is a bit hard to imagine since it's so vague and counter-intuitive being a description that doesn't really describe. I suggest a more concrete description, else nixing the phrase.

but was so covered with blood

Missing an "it" in there.

parts missing, perhaps she

Semicolon would be more appropriate, methinks.

I shut my eyes hard because I didn’t believe what I was seeing.

Considering that this isn't the first time he's seen a body like that, and that the other sightings corresponded with reality, "I didn't want to believe" makes more sense.

I was sitting on mine and Barry’s bathroom floor

Grammatically, should be "Barry's and my", though you could probably chalk it up to the character's voice and get away with it. It does seem a bit at odds with the model student image presented thus far, though.

she couldn’t, she had to

catch attention, she didn’t need

fawned over her, boys

Semicolons needed: please apply within.

gorgeous, she knew she

I think that flows a bit better. Otherwise, semicolon, though there are already more than enough semicolon-needy sentences in that paragraph.

I didn’t know what she would

The "what " throws me off; I'm not sure it's the best word to use?

Overall, though, I had to look really, really hard to find anything that could use improving. This was just lovely and nom-worthy.

I don't think you have to worry at all about Finn being a Mary Sue. She's just been introduced, and since this is first-person, while Luke may view her as perfect, we readers aren't as ready to conclude such as we know this is only Luke's perception. I would mention that this isn't a problem unless Luke's perception = reality, but I know you know better than to write like that. :P

And now I am wishing there was a Love/Adore button instead of just a Like. You'll just have to be satisfied with netting my 550th review. :P
Secretly a Kyllorac, sometimes a Murtle.
There are no chickens in Hyrule.
Princessence: A LMS Project
WRFF | KotGR



Reading is one form of escape. Running for your life is another.
— Lemony Snicket