Colors

7 posts
User avatar
Gender None specified
Points 19207
Reviews 192
This story may seem a litte abstract. It is told through the perspective of a severely autistic person. Please enjoy.

All I see are colors. Dancing, vivid colors. They say I’ve got nothing to live for, that I shouldn’t even be living. But I live, because I live for the colors. Where I live, the colors are bleak and white. The ladies in white dresses and hats come to see me everyday. They have colors in their eyes. Eyes that look down on me with pity. Why do they pity me? I am content, the colors keep me happy. Sometimes, the man with black hair comes to see me. I do not like him. He stares at me from behind thick, colorless glasses. Then, he talks to the white ladies. His voice hurts my ears. There are two other people who visit me. They wear shirts with lots of colors, not like the men and women in blue and white. They look at me through a big glass window, their mouths move but I hear nothing. I think that they feel sorry for me, but I am happy with my colors.
There are other people like me here. They sit in big, wheeled chairs, just like me. Yellow tubes hang down from their mouths and noses, just like me. There are many people here, some old, some young, and they all stare hopelessly off into nothing. But not me. When I look at them I feel sad. So I close my eyes. There is a land there. It is a beautiful land. It is filled with colors. Here in my land, I play with the colors, I dance and run and laugh and sing. But my most favorite thing to do is to sit and listen to the most wonderful color of all. I know that there is someone behind the color, and I want to always go and see him. But I can’t, so I sit and listen to everything that he has to tell me. He tells me that he loves me. He tells me that I matter to him, and that I’m beautiful. Back in the white world, the ladies there tell me the same things. But they don’t mean them. They say them because they think I can’t tell. But I can. This man though, tells me the truth. He means what he says. I love that man.
Today, I sit in my chair in the white world. I can’t wait for the lady in white to leave, so that I can go to the color world. But when she leaves, I see the man with dark hair talking to the two other people behind the window. They look at me, and I want to cry because of the way their eyes are. Now they are coming into my room. They stare down at me. I can hear their words.
“Not worth it…” the woman says.
“Too much money.” The other man says. I look at each of their faces, cold and hard. The man with black hair is the worst of them all.
“The process is quick and painless…they don’t even realize what’s happening when they go.”
I feel a lump in my throat. Go? What does that mean? The people leave, and I am alone again. I close my eyes. Today, the color world is cold. The happy yellows don’t want to play. The deep greens stay far from me. The gentle purple doesn’t comfort me. I feel lost. I run through, searching for the beautiful color. I cannot find him. I sit down and begin to cry.
“Why are you sad child?” I hear the man in the colors say. I tell him everything, and this time he is the one who is listening. He comes to me and wraps me in a warm blanket of color. He tells me not to be afraid, that I will soon get to leave with him. I ask him where we are going, but he only says that it is a place more wonderful than my color world ever was. He says it is too wonderful to imagine. I am happy at these words. Then, I open my eyes and am no longer in the color world.
At once I realize that things here have changed, the white world seems more sad and dry. I look around and see that there are others in the room. Men in blue with masks that hide their faces. All I see is their hateful eyes. I shrink back from them. A lady in white touches my shoulder. She says that everything is going to be alright, that I’m going to take a nap now. I do not believe her. They are going to take me away from this place forever. The blue people start to push my chair down the hall. There is a door at the end. We go through the door into a room with the dark haired man. He is holding a needle, there is no color to whatever is inside of it. He tries to speak soft word to me, telling me that this will all soon be over. I shake my head. He comes closer with the needle. No! Don’t take me away from my colors! My pretty, wonderful colors! I want to scream. But all that comes out is a long moan. I am horrified at the sound of my own voice. The dark haired man pierces my skin with the needle, but I can’t feel it. He keeps talking to me, and I wish he would stop. The blue light of the room slowly start to fade into grey. It grows darker. Darker into black. I am scared. Soon, the entire world is blocked out, and I am left in darkness. I am very cold here, and very alone. There are no colors. Only blackness. Then, as I lie curled up, I hear his voice. And he comes to me with his beautiful colors. I am no longer afraid, for he takes my hand and leads me into his world. And his world is filled with the best colors of all.
No more countin' dollars... we'll be countin' stars.

Enter, if you dare.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 18529
Reviews 176
I'm rather confused about the ending... Did they kill him or something? I don't think they euthanize autistic people...

But, other than that, this was really beautiful and sad. Sometimes the abstract nature was confusing, but it was pretty entertaining to guess as to what was actually transpiring.

Lena
stay gold, ponyboy




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 13307
Reviews 350
Was this a submission to canislupis' contest? If so, you did an amazing job.
I won't go looking for nitpicks, but I did see a few things wrong with this story, one of which Lena.Wooldridge already found: it's probably illegal to kill people just because of their disabilities.
Maybe if he was violent and in severe pain, but not if he was quiet and content to sit still.
I thought the speaking voice of the autistic person was well done, but his perception of the world around him slightly skewed. Not because of his disability, but because of your own inconsistency.
When he mentions, "There are other people like me here. They sit in big, wheeled chairs, just like me. Yellow tubes hang down from their mouths and noses, just like me. There are many people here, some old, some young, and they all stare hopelessly off into nothing. But not me." you imply that he finds nothing wrong with himself. His understanding is incorrect.
However, when he hears three sentences and reads the expressions on the faces of his relatives (am I guessing that correctly?) he knows he's gonna die.
Is it just me, or is he extra-sensory about certain things and blind to others? Is it just because he's autistic?
Whatever, maybe it doesn't even matter. Great job!
Also, just as my trademark, I did find one nitpick:

“Why are you sad child?”


You need a comma after sad. Also, the dialogue should have had its own paragraph, like you did with the above dialogue between the doctor and the relatives.

Jenth
-ж-Ж-ж-




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 6748
Reviews 100
Did this take place in the past or does this take place in another country besides the U.S? I would like a little more detail about the background. I don't know much about autistic people, but I believe that they are smarter than the average person; they just have trouble showing it and surviving in a social context. So I believe your narrator might know what is happening to him. Otherwise this was very good. Good work. I'm sorry I can't really help you because I don't know much about the autistic mind.
Check these out please! :)
Alezrani
Will review for food thread




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 7241
Reviews 721
Hi, Dragon! I'm here from the contest. ^_^ If you haven't heard yet, you won second place. Congratulations! You can contact either Lupis or me about getting your prize reviews (though both of us are going to review this).

Where I live, the colors are bleak and white.
There's nothing really wrong with this sentence, but the first thing I thought of when I read it was "that's probably supposed to be 'black and white.'" Now, this misreading is completely my fault, but do avoid confusion you may want to consider changing the wording around just so that it doesn't parallel the common saying "black and white." Maybe try something like: "Where I live, the colors are white and bleak."

There are other people like me here. They sit in big, wheeled chairs, just like me. Yellow tubes hang down from their mouths and noses, just like me.
I like this bit. It's chilling.

He tries to speak soft word to me, telling me that this will all soon be over.
Words?
---------------------------------

Overall, this is very nice. I really love the way you have made your narrator both obviously retarded and obviously intelligent. This is actually a big thing we were looking for when judging the contest--you portray him as disabled without making him seem stupid or sub-human at all. In fact, he felt more human than the nurses and doctor and the other patients because of the way you wrote it. Nicely done. I also really enjoy all the descriptions of the colors. I think it's a beautiful idea and you executed it masterfully. Even though I know practically none of the normal things I would want to know about a character (I don't know even know his/her gender or name) but because you give such a good sense of the color world in which he/she lives, I feel like I have a really good sense of who he/she is.

I am also intrigued by the idea of the man in the colors. On the one hand, I feel like he could be just a person that the main character imagines to comfort him/her. He/she is obviously pretty much friendless, so the man in the colors is his/her only friend. And imaginary friend, really. But then there's also another idea I had when I got to the ending... what if that man is some representation of God? I'm not religious, but I am really intrigued by that idea. I know that autistic people think a lot more similarly to animals than "normal" people do, which does have a sort of noble air to it. But the concept that they have a private relationship with some God is really intriguing. I don't know if you had that in mind or not, but it's interesting to think about, anyway.

I really only have two issues with this piece.

The first one is one that other people have already brought up, so I'm going to try not to dwell on it to much: do they really euthanize severely autistic people just because there severely autistic? I just can't imagine that happening, unless his relatives were in extreme poverty, I suppose... I guess it is possible, but I just think we need more information in order to believe it. And that's a problem since, with your narrator, you can't really afford to give any more information.

My biggest issue with this piece was that it's a little inconsistent. Take the first paragraph, for example. You start out by describing the colors and how much he/she likes them. Then you say that he/she lives in a place without any colors. Then you say that the nurses are wearing white. Then you say that they have colors in their eyes. That detail made me think that the narrator would like the nurses, but he/she doesn't. The narrator obviously lives for colors. You describe the world he/she lives in as colorless, and the world in his/her mind as colorful... and you describe the man in the colors as saying that he/she will be taken to a more colorful place after he/she is killed. This excites the narrator, but yet she doesn't want to die and when she sees the needle she urges them not to take her away from her colors. But wouldn't they be taking her to the colors and away from the colorless hospital? It's just a little inconsistent and somewhat confusing since I don't really know how he/she feels about things. Colors are good and colorless things are bad, right? I thought so, but it's a little misleading at some places.

Congratulations again on second place--this is a lovely piece of writing. Please let me know if you have questions/comments concerning my review, the contest, or anything else you think I could answer. ^_^

I hope this helps!

a




User avatar
Gender None specified
Points 19207
Reviews 192
As an answer to all of your questions.
No, they don't euthanize autistic people. (At least not here in the U.S.). However, there are (many) politicians who do think that because a person doesn't think the way we do, or because they can't feed themselves, or because they're unborn that they should be eliminated from the course of society. They are trying to pass a bill that allows the relatives of a person like the character in my story the right to choose whether or not that person is worth keeping alive. They regard these persons as worthless, mindless, primal life forms and think that there is no reason what-so-ever to allow them to live. I hope that this story shows that that is NOT the case: Every human on this planet is worth something. They were meant to live. They have a purpose and a reason for life, and are entitled to give life a chance. It doesn't matter if they're disabled or even unborn, we shouldn't be killing them for the sake of convieneince.
Anyway, I wrote this just to show what could happen in the near future. Hopefully, it spoke to the human in us all
No more countin' dollars... we'll be countin' stars.

Enter, if you dare.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 7715
Reviews 522
Hello! Here to review, same as Azila. Congrats, BTW. I really love this piece.

First, I'll admit I was just as confused as everyone else when I read it:

No, they don't euthanize autistic people. (At least not here in the U.S.). However, there are (many) politicians who do think that because a person doesn't think the way we do, or because they can't feed themselves, or because they're unborn that they should be eliminated from the course of society. They are trying to pass a bill that allows the relatives of a person like the character in my story the right to choose whether or not that person is worth keeping alive. They regard these persons as worthless, mindless, primal life forms and think that there is no reason what-so-ever to allow them to live. I hope that this story shows that that is NOT the case: Every human on this planet is worth something. They were meant to live. They have a purpose and a reason for life, and are entitled to give life a chance. It doesn't matter if they're disabled or even unborn, we shouldn't be killing them for the sake of convieneince.


Ah, ok. So you meant this as an argument for what *could* happen, more than something actually happening? I haven't heard anything of this bill. Abortion, maybe (don't really think it's the same thing), but I'm pretty sure this won't happen. Still, I do understand what you were going for a lot more now.

But, with that in mind, I do think you should pull our heartstrings a little more. Your theme is one of outrage, and since you're also trying to convince people of your opinion, I'd go ahead and make us feel it. Given that everyone has reacted with confusion so far (since, obviously, this isn't happening now) I think you could make it more obvious/ironic when it happens, at least enough so that we can make the connection to the more hypothetical idea. Not that the theme would be more important than your character (I like how it's a theme more than a shouted message) but still.

For example, right now, we do feel for your MC. Obviously she/he is more than we know, and that she's being killed really made me feel desperate to save her. Which was great. But it could be better. For example, it's coming across as too black and white. I know that sounds odd, since you want us to agree with your side of the story, but it's coming across as almost melodramatic. Oh, poor me, this happens. I know, your story is supposed to be sad. But we can only take so much before it becomes a pity party/whiny rant. So add some depth. Make the parts when she's happy stronger--that way she has something to miss. I'm having a hard time explaining this, but for some reason, when everything is sad, we don't feel it as much.

I also want to see the other people as people, struggling with guilt or at least some emotion. You want people to see themselves as they don't want to become, in other words. ;) Of course, their casual callousness could work for you too, (in which case, exaggerate it) but in general I think you want this to be shocking rather than satirical, so I'd work on developing the "evil" characters a bit more.

Voice: Don't get me wrong, I think the character's voice is one of the best things about this piece. Like Azila said, you managed to portray him/her in a sensitive manner that really did make him seem more human than the others. At the same time, I wouldn't have guessed that she was autistic. I knew she was disabled from the tubes and stuff, but it seemed like she was thinking the same as us. This is going to sound like a no-win situation, but at the same time as you want to show her to be human, you also want to show us how different she is. Because your point is not that they are exactly the same as us; it's that they are different and that we should honor that difference. Make sense? I'm not saying she seemed entirely normal—what I mean is more that she needs to be obviously different in her thought process, and more than that, she needs to be consistent. I think Azila already went through that, so I won't add much more. :D

Finally, prose. Your grammar could use a little touch-up. It's ok right now, and I'm gonna try not to go grammar-nazi on you, but with this short a piece, there's no excuse. Watch out for comma misuse and dialogue especially. ;) I also want to mention the way you managed to infuse the entire piece with a dreamy feeling—it was perfect! The descriptions were occasionally brilliant as well.

Anyway, hope I helped at least a little. Let me know what you want your reviews on. ;) Good luck with revision/future writing!

Lupis



They laugh at me because I'm different; I laugh at them because they're all the same.
— Kurt Cobain