Ali's Hot Dogs *Edited*

8 posts
User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1030
Reviews 1260
AN: This is an entry for Trident's Three Pronged Contest. We had to include various listed items in our story.

Ali zipped up her coat and huddled her arms close to her chest. She had been outside for nearly four hours in the freezing cold and had yet to sell a single hot dog. She had chosen a fairly busy corner of town, but everyone that walked by barely regarded her, with the occasional condescending glares from older men and women whom Ali guessed had hundreds of dollars in their wallets. The finished hot dogs that she had laid out on the table were beginning to get cold, and she did not want to place them on the grill` for fear of burning them. She would take another package out of the little icebox which she kept by her feet, but she was running low and wanted to conserve as much as possible, and besides, they would have to thaw out, which would take fifteen minutes, twenty at the most.
Sometimes Ali wondered if she should just pack up, forget the whole thing and go home. It would never work, running the hot stand. However, she knew that she could not. Ever since she had been laid off from her job at Macy's Department Store nearly three weeks ago, she had difficulty finding a sufficient job that would help her pay the rent. Since nothing had come up, she had resorted to this, figuring that because of the cold people would want something warm to eat. Besides, she only charged a dollar for the hot dogs. But somehow it had just not worked out. Ali was beginning to grow scared of what might happen. Soon, her monthly rent would be due, and she would not be able to pay it. She did not want to be evicted from her apartment; if so, where would she go? She did not doubt that Matt, her boyfriend, would let her move in with him, but he wasn't doing well at his job either and Ali doubted that he would be able to financially support them both.
Off in a daze, Ali suddenly heard deep breathing and became aware that someone was at the stand. Bewildered, she looked up and saw a little girl in a light blue coat, who was looking at her with beady eyes.
“I want a hot dog,” she said loudly, holding out a dollar, “with lots and lots of ketchup. No mustard, though. Mustard is icky.”
Ali was about to reach out and take the girl's cash when a voice boomed from behind.
“Marissa?” A tall man in a black trench coat came into view. He was carrying a white plastic bag, which he waved in the girl's face. “Marissa, we just came from the store with things to make bologna sandwiches at home. I told you we aren't stopping at any hot dog stands, and in the future, please don't run from me again, do you understand?
The girl nodded. She looked like she was about to cry. “I want a hot dog though,” she said. “Bologna is icky.”
“I don't care,” he said flatly.
“Daddy, I'm hungry now though! I don't want to wait until we get home!”
“Come on, you can wait.”
“Well, if I can't have a hot dog, can we make the bologna sandwich now?”
“Marissa...” He turned to Ali. “I'm so sorry about this. She's only seven--”
“Please, Daddy?”
“Alright,” he said. “Let's find a bench or something first though.”
As the two walked away, Ali found herself trying not to cry. She had been so close to finally selling a hot dog, finally getting a measly dollar, and that had to be taken away from her. “They're only a dollar,” she whispered.
Ali missed Matt and wanted more then anything to talk to him right now. He was still at work, but Ali still guessed that he would be able to answer a text. She took out her phone from her black bag which sitting next to the edge of the grill.

Hi. <3 Miss you, love you.

So maybe it was a little bit cheesy, but at least writing the words comforted her just a little. While she was waiting for a text back, Ali's eyes drifted to the contents of her bag and she found herself eying a thick and small little book near the bottom. Ali took it out and grasped it tightly, rubbing her hands against it. She had no gloves, as she had recently lost the ones that she had been using and she had no money to buy a new pair. After so long in the cold, her hands were becoming quite frigid and this was her feeble attempt to warm them up. Ali bit her lip and laid the book out on the front table so that she could clearly see it. English to Spanish and Spanish to English: The Beginner's Dictionary.
It was Matt's. About the same time she had gotten laid off, she'd asked to borrow his dictionary because she'd wanted to get better at Spanish. She'd taken four years of it in High School but was starting to forget most of it, and Ali had heard once that those who were bilingual had good job opportunities. So far she'd learned a little, but Ali had forgotten more that she had originally thought, and but it was hard to relearn and practice a language with a dictionary as her only resource.
It was funny, because the text she got from Matt referenced the exact thing.

Hi :) still at work, whats up? Do u still have my spanish english dictionary I let you borrow? lol the client i'm visiting right now just moved from mexico and their english is really bad. love you so much <3

She smiled and started to send a reply.

Yep :-) it's been nice to have. Love you <3

Ali didn't get a text back, but it didn't bother her because she assumed Matt was busy with work and didn't have the opportunity to take out his phone and text her. She slid the dictionary back into her bag, figuring she'd take it out later.
For another thirty minutes or so Ali sat in her chair, cold and bored. Almost all of her hot dogs were cold now, so she knew she would have to start grilling more. Looking at her phone, she saw that it was only four in the evening, so she wanted to wait for at least another hour before she packed up for the night.
The hot dogs grilled, and they were starting to smell really good. Ali, suddenly hungry, tried to resist temptation to take one and eat it. Soon they were done, and Ali took them off of the grill and flopped back down in her chair, trying to hope.

About twenty minutes later, it started to snow. Ali hugged her arms close to her chest, hoping it would not get too much colder. To try and amuse herself, she started singing “Let it Snow”.
She stopped a few seconds later when she saw a man in a plaid coat and jeans walk toward her. He was wearing a New York Yankees baseball cap over his hood.
Ali recognized him immediately. “Matt!” she screamed. It was so loud that nearly everyone on the block could hear. Ali didn't care. All that she knew was that she was very happy to see him.
He smiled, ran up to her and hugged her tightly. “Hey,” he said. “How are things going?”
“Not good,” she whispered, pointing to the old pencil case she had intended to keep her profits in, still empty.
“Well, tell you what,” said Matt, taking his sleek black wallet out of his coat pocket. “I am very hungry because I've spent a long while at work without anything to eat.” He pulled out a ten dollar bill and handed it to Ali.
“One hot dog, please.”
“Matt, they're only one dollar...”
“Come on,” he insisted. “You need the money more then I do.”
“I thought you weren't doing well at work?”
“My next paycheck comes tomorrow.”
Ali nodded, figuring to just go with it. She felt each of the hot dogs that had been made. One was still warm.

Draft 1
Spoiler
Ali sighed and threw her notebook and pen, which she was using to doodle, to the ground. She straightened up in her chair and looked out to the street and sidewalk where pedestrians walked along, barely paying her hot dog stand any mind. She'd been out in the freezing cold for nearly four hours and still had only made about ten dollars. The ones she had laid out were getting cold, but she didn't want to place them on the grill for fear of burning any, and she was running out of fresh ones to make.
It would never work, running this hot dog stand. Ali knew that she would be evicted from apartment unless she could find better work. But nearly two weeks had passed since Macy's had laid her off and she hadn't had any luck finding a new job, so why should she expect her luck to change now? Maybe Ali could move in with Matt, but he wasn't doing too well either with his job at the house cleaners either. Ali picked up her notebook and pen again and started to draw draw random little smiley faces. Some had arms and feet, some were happy, sad.
That was when Ali heard a voice and soon came to realize that someone had come to her stand. She nearly jumped, seeing a little girl in a pearl blue coat looking at her with beady eyes.
“I want a hot dog,” she said loudly, holding out a dollar, “with lots and lots of ketchup. No mustard, though. Mustard is icky.”
Ali was about to reach out and take the girl's cash when a voice boomed from behind.
“Marissa?” A tall man in a black trench coat came into view. He was carrying a white plastic bag, which he waved in the girl's face. “Marrisa, we just came from the store with things to make bologna sandwhiches at home. I told you we aren't stopping at any hot dog stands, and in the future, please don't run from me again, do you understand?”
The girl nodded. She looked like she was about to cry. “I want a hot dog though,” she said. “Bologna is icky.”
“I don't care,” he said flatly.
“Daddy, I'm hungry now though! I don't want to wait until we get home!”
“Come on, you can wait.”
“Well, if I can't have a hot dog, can we make the bologna sandwich now?”
“Marissa...” He turned to Ali. “I'm so sorry about this. She's only seven--”
“Please, Daddy?”
“Alright,” he said. “Let's find a bench or something first though.”
As the two walked away, Ali found herself sighing. “They're only a dollar,” she thought.
That was when she decided to take out her phone. She wanted just wanted to talk to Matt. He was probably still at work, but maybe he'd at least be able to answer a text.

[i]Miss you. Love you.

So maybe it was a little bit cheesy, but at least writing the words comforted her just a little. He had texted her back about a minute later.

Hi :) still at work, whats up? Do u still have my spanish english dictionary I let you borrow? lol the client i'm visiting right now just moved from mexico and their english is really bad. love you so much <3

Ali laughed upon reading the text. About the same time she had gotten laid off, she'd asked to borrow his dictionary because she'd wanted to get better at Spanish. She'd taken four years of it in High School but was starting to forget most of it, and Ali had heard once that those who were bilingual had good job opportunities. That was when Ali took out her black handbag, which she carried everywhere, and saw the dictionary sitting in it. She smiled and started to send a text back to Matt.

Yep :-) it's been nice to have. Love you <3

Ali didn't get a text back, but it didn't bother her because she assumed Matt was busy with work and didn't have the opportunity to take out his phone and text her.
For another thirty minutes or so Ali sat in her chair, cold and bored. Almost all of her hot dogs were cold now, so she knew she would have to start grilling more. Looking at her phone, she saw that it was only 4 pm, so she wanted to wait for at least another hour before she packed up for the night.
When Ali bent down to take some out of the icebox she kept under the grill, she suddenly felt a tear, and looking up, realizing there was a small hole in her pant leg. Ali sighed and cursed under her breath. This was the last thing she needed right now. She had no idea how to sew; so maybe she could use duct tape. Maybe when she packed up she could go over the Walgreens across the street and buy some. Right now, Ali didn't want to leave her seat in case any customers came. A little while later, Ali got a text. It was from Matt.

I just got off of work. Hungry :-). Maybe I can see where they sell good hot dogs ;)

Ali texted back with a heart, sat back in her chair and smiled. Okay, so maybe it wasn't much. If Matt bought a hot dog it would increase her total to eleven dollars, out of thirty dollar expenses for the day. It was pathetic. She had barely any money and would probably be evicted soon. But she still had the ones that cared about her, and maybe she would have a better day tomorrow.
Last edited by Elinor on Fri Dec 03, 2010 11:21 pm, edited 9 times in total.

All our dreams can come true — if we have the courage to pursue them.

-- Walt Disney




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 4996
Reviews 107
Hey Elinor!
For being ''very rough'' this was ''very good''!
The idea of a young woman running a hotdog stand for money so she won't be evicted from her apartment is really original or to me at least. I liked the part with the little girl and her father. It was well described and I truly felt sad for the poor girl when the father refused to buy her a hotdog. The bolgna probably cost more than that hotdog anyways...what a jerk! :p

I also liked the relationship you managed to build between Ali and Matt in such a short amount of time, I really enjoyed the two of them together even though they were only talking via cell phone during this piece, and that closing text from him was so cute! It made me smile :)

Very well done!
*daydreamer
"A black cat crossing your path signifies that the animal is going somewhere." ~courtesy of one of history's funniest men, Groucho Marx. ^_^




Random avatar
Gender None specified
Points 1060
Reviews 3
This is an amazing story line I love it!
The only thing that I could see was that the end sentence wasn't to grabbing!
I think it should be more gripping so that the reader would want to read more!

hope this helps,
MADI




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 44360
Reviews 1087
Heya, Eli. :)

I always like reviewing contest entries... It makes me feel more pumped up. Weird, I know. Hey, I'm a creeper. I had a look at the contest, and it looks like an interesting one actually. Anyway, enough of my blabbering!

Okay, the first line... Hmmm... I'm not sure what I think. I may be a bit biased here because I've personally never liked stories that begin with the whole, my name is ___ and I am ___ years old kind of thing. This is just my opinion on the whole thing, but I would consider maybe changing it to something a little more gripping. One thing you could actually do is stick with the idea of what you already have, but end it with a fact that makes us readers have to look twice at. This isn't a very good one, but for example, My name is Jefferson Bloggs. I prefer Jeff. I am twenty-one years old. I killed my grandmother yesterday. Obviously, you wouldn't use that exactly, but do you see what I'm getting at?

One thing that I noticed a little bit of you doing here was telling instead of showing. It wasn't that bad, but I think it is worth bringing up. For example, how did Ali know that the man was the little girl's father? You wrote that she assumed he was her father. Why? Did he look like the stereotypical father? You didn't really need to mention him being a father though, to be honest because you had the girl call him daddy in the dialogue. Us readers are smart enough to figure out that he's the girls's dad. ;)

Something I'd like to see more of is the background of the whole thing. I'm not sure about the exact rules and regulations of the contest, so maybe you're supposed to be a little vague about that. If that is the case, then this critique won't be much use... Sorry! Anyway, yeah... I want to know more! How did Matt and Ali meet? She was about to write how... but we never found out in the end. I was hoping we would. xD I have other questions too, like how and why was she sacked from her job? What was her previous job? Did she like it? We didn't really get to know Ali's character much either, but I think that was due to the shortness of the piece.

The only other thing I have left to mention is about the plot. I mean, I can't really say what the plot is... A girl sells hot dogs because she's been sacked and her partner cheers her up by texting her nice messages? I think I got the impression you wanted to show that no matter how bad things may be, the right person is always there to cheer you up. It isn't an easy message to find though. For all I know, that might not even be what you were going for, but hey, that's what my simple mind came up with...

I want something cool to happen! Blow something up! Bring in some ginger ninjas! :P Not really... That would make me cry. I want you to make more out of this story though. Even if it means killing off someone... Mind you, that might just be my love of depressive writing kicking in. All of the short stories I've written (a grand total of two) have involved death... Seriously though, I would like to see you make something more exciting happen. In the end though, that's up to you. You might just want this to be a rather simple story, and that's cool. I think that you could make it a little more exciting though. Really make it pop!

Negatives aside, I did actually like the overall idea of this. It's quirky; I like quirky. The writing itself was good, and I liked the scene with the little girl and her father. I think that you showed the character of the little girl off nicely and effectively. Your grammar was wonderful, which is something I always love to see, and so was your grammar. With a little bit of editing, this could be even better. :)

Good luck with the contest and keep writing,

xoxo Skins

Spoiler
P.S You really like names like Alison, don't you? They're often in your writing. xD
I didn't know what to put here so I put this.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 3888
Reviews 763
Li!

So, I liked this quirky style and well, I know you can improve it, so here I go. (Shredding it, 'kay.)

So, first, hot dog vendor, Bologna sandwich - good connection. The dictionary bit was okay too. But the duct tape idea was meh for me. I didn't like it and seemed like it was forcibly put into this.

Ali and Matt - I don't really see the necessity for this connection. Good way of showing it to us. It's a good, fun relationship, but I totally think you can do so much better without him. I really enjoyed the daughter-father-vendor scene and I'd love for you dwell/develop on that. I think that would give this story more substance. (I can't find another word. >.<) Plus, it'll help you to develop Ali more. The only line I really enjoyed in the latter half was "If Matt bought a hot dog it would increase her total to eleven dollars, out of thirty dollar expenses for the day."

Also, I'd say, try out a different way to start. This is good, but maybe make it more like, "The lamp post she was doodling looked nothing like the one in front of her." (Heh, bad example, but you get the idea. Yeah, showing would be good here. )

Right now, this just seems like another normal day in the life of Ali, and for a short this needs more excitement, as Skinsy pointed out. It doesn't have to be over the top excitement, but something for the readers to hold onto and maybe feel the story.

SO, overall, it's a good start, but I want you to concentrate more on the girl and stuff. It doesn't have to be just under 1000 to be powerful.

Hope I helped. :)
EDIT- Do PM me if you put up a revised/new one.

~Lava. :)
~
Pretending in words was too tentative, too vulnerable, too embarrassing to let anyone know.
- Ian McEwan in Atonement

sachi: influencing others since GOD KNOWS WHEN.





User avatar
Gender Female
Points 7715
Reviews 522
Hi! I don't think I've reviewed anything of yours recently. Anyway, here goes!

I like this piece--your writing is pretty good, and I liked the cute relationship.

The biggest problem? Nothing happens. I think Skins and Lava have already gone over this a bit, and I agree with them. This is flash fiction. The object is to say as much as possible in as few words as possible. Descriptions and developed characters can only get you so far.

So, here's (basically) what happened: Ali is selling hotdogs because she lost her job. She has a boyfriend who cheers her up via text. A girl and her father walk past, arguing. The end.

You did do a good job incorporating the different objects (contests like this are always hard) but I feel like they could have had more significance to the plot--right now they're mostly just there because they have to be--they're just details, like gum on the sidewalk or trees. This wouldn't be a bad thing if they blended into the background, but often they seem stilted--forced into the scene (especially the duct tape).

Here's what I would do:

Decide on more conflict. Up the suspence by making her literally on the cusp of losing her apartment, or nervous about something else. Make things happen that aren't ideal--a vague notion of her financial difficulties is not enough. that At the moment Ali is very very passive--she's just watching things happen. What if she tries to get the girl to buy it, or gets in an argument with the Dad about something, or gives the girl a hotdog despite her not paying? Make something up, but have there be something uncomfortable for her or we get bored.

Decide how Ali is going to change. This is very short, so it won't be dramatic, but she should still be different at the end than she was in the beginning--otherwise there is no story. Right now you have her mention that "tomorrow might be a better day". What I would do is strengthen that a lot--have her on the brink of despair and then lighten up with the text messages and the girl, perhaps? I'm not looking for earth-shattering character changes (Christmas Carol, etc) but at least some change would be nice.

Give certain objects more significance. They could be the very points on which the story hinges--focus on them. Get rid of the ones that you had to force into the scene--they're distracting and take away from the story.


Lastly--more vivid, concise descriptions would be nice. For example, sentences like "sidewalk where pedestrians walked along," etc. Are not vivid. They don't give clear pictures. I'm not saying you should go over the top with purple prose, but some more unique words would be nice. :D

Good luck with the contest! As Skins said, this is quirky in a good way, and your writing really was good. I just feel like the plot could be strengthened. Hope I helped, and let me know if you ever need a review!

Lupis




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 49345
Reviews 547
Hey hun!

I love how you keep using Matty and Ali in your stories. It's like how I use Kisa in every story and every SB I join! XD

Anywho, this was cute. However it was a bit boring. If I had one suggestion, it would be to make something miraculous happen. You have the cutesy tootsy stuff down, with Matt and all that, however now you need to add a little zing. Might I suggest a car barreling into her hot dog stand? That way for a moment she would think that her life is over because she won't be able to make any money making hot dogs, but in the end she will realize that she can sue them and get money, yeah! Well that wasn't one of my best ideas, but you get the point.

Also, the end. The end was a bit boring and expected as well. I would, rather then you telling us, can you show us what you say in the end? Can you wait until Matt comes to her, then have her tell him that all she needs is him, and then end it that way? It's just a bit boring. Since we read this cute stuff all the way to the end, we are waiting for something create to happen, something to make us say "aww". Now you tell me your novel ideas, and I know you have it in you. So get to it girl! I don't care how you do it, add some sort of twist! Because the way it is now, I can basically play out the rest of their lives in my head, it's so expected.

I really like the texting. I think it's a great way to introduce the story into the modern world. So many novels and shorts nowadays seem to stray from the fact that we have cell phones and texting. It's like us writers don't like to admit that we have technology, because it's more boring, right? Your MC can't get lost anymore cause they can just find a GPS on their phone. Anywho, you added a nice touch to it through the texting. It made me happy. :D

Keep writing boo!

Classy




User avatar
Gender None specified
Points 83309
Reviews 436
Hi, El!

Ah, interesting. It's always nice to see what people do with these contest entries, especially when they aren't created to be funny.

Anyway, thoughts.

One of the first things I noticed was that I found it very easy to see which parts of your story came from the contest. The hot-dog vendor part I liked, because it created an interesting premise, but I thought that duct-taping the clothing was very obvious and, technically, unnecessary. I would have preferred it if you'd perhaps just focused on the Bologna, or even skipped the Bologna and spent more time trying to develop and incorporate the duct-taping. One or the other.

The story was very sweet, but in my opinion a little boring. Although there were many elements in it that added some emotion (the cold, the little girl, Matt ...) I didn't feel like any of them were sufficient enough to truly ground the story and give it spark. You tried to do that at the end, but it came off a little bit cliche, and I feel like perhaps you should spend more time developing the middle of your story so that you don't need to just rely on the end for some interest. I'm not sure quite what you could do - perhaps try to develop some element of the story more, or add in an entirely new and exciting one. It's up to you.

That said, it was a very nice story and an enjoyable read. I do think it needs some more work to make it fully live up to the potential, but there's still plenty of time before the deadline. ;)

Hope this helped!
"It is curious how often you humans manage to obtain that which you do not want."

-Spock.


Click if you love cookies



I didn't know beards could do that ;)
— ShadowVyper