Players and Audiences *Edited*

9 posts
User avatar
Gender Other
Points 89625
Reviews 1272
Many are the princes acting
in roles either too small or
too large, never satisfied
that there is not a
monarch to behold their
toils and strife, that
we are not a captive audience
set to watch a swelling
scene that is not a
subplot of our own play—
where we are princes
vexed that we
are not the ones
being watched.

*

A/N- Multiple lines/phrases have been taken from one of Shakespeare's plays. This clip to be exact. But you don't need to watch the clip to understand the poem (at least I hope not!). As for needing to know the play, you shouldn't need to know about it either because I don't myself, lol

Edit notes- Grammar, line-breaks and one word change


Original:

Spoiler
Many are the princes acting
in roles either too small or
too large, never satisfied
that there is not a
monarch to behold their
toils and strife, that
we are not a captive audience
set to watch a swelling
scene that is not a
subplot of our own play,
where we are princes,
frustrated that we are
not the ones
being watched
Last edited by Rosendorn on Sat Aug 28, 2010 3:59 pm, edited 7 times in total.
A writer is a world trapped in a person— Victor Hugo

Ink is blood. Paper is bandages. The wounded press books to their heart to know they're not alone.




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 2702
Reviews 867
I rather like this. It is very much like Shakespeare. It is very efficient, no wasted lines. I wish I had more to say about it.
Moderator Emeritus (frozen in carbonite.)




User avatar
Gender None specified
Points 83309
Reviews 436
Mmkay. :D

So, as Grif said, this is good because it is efficient. It doesn't need the imagery, the description, that some poems do - by not using them you are detracting from your poem but rather creating something different that captures the theme better.

I read through the prologue to Henry V, as it's not one of Shakespeare's plays I'm familiar with (which is a shame, really, because I feel that knowing the play would give me a deeper understanding of your poem). Anyway, I read it through, and was half expecting to see lines from your poem easily recognisable and scattered liberally through the prologue. And I was happy: they weren't. You used the prologue in a subtle way - it influenced your poem, and was used in a your poem, but in a way that it also becomes your own in a way that it wouldn't if you simply copy and pasted.

Okay, so I'm sorry. You said rip it if I could, but I'm not sure I can. The way you've written it, in such a concise way, leaves little to change. It all fits in together and I don't want to be the one to attempt to change or unravel lines that work well together.

Apologies for the slight uselessness, but you did a lovely job with this. :)
"It is curious how often you humans manage to obtain that which you do not want."

-Spock.


Click if you love cookies




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 10087
Reviews 701
Hi Rosey Unicorn,

Here's the review you requested :)

To be honest, I saw this poem yesterday but didn't comment on it, mostly because there really isn't much I can say! Like Grif and AquaMarine, I think it's wonderfully concise and it conveys a single, central idea with economy of imagery and language. I love the way it kind of folds back on itself, so that the "princes" of the first line are themselves watched by other princes who are in turn similarly frustrated. It reminds me of a mirror poem; kind of mind-bending, but in a good way.

One thing you might think about is putting a full stop somewhere in there. I kind of got a sense as I was reading it that I needed to take a mental 'breath' somewhere, but I'm not entirely sure where and part of me thinks that's necessary for the theme, so. Your decision! Either way, I like this piece. Well done :smt023

Cheers,
~bubbles
Got a poem or short story you want me to critique?

There is only one success: to be able to spend your life in your own way, and not to give others absurd maddening claims upon it. (C D Morley)




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 12611
Reviews 321
Flower here, and I will be your review for today. Like everyone else I read this, but did not review it simply because I could find anything to talk about. I will try though haha.


Many are the princes acting
in roles either too small or
too large, never satisfied
that there is not a
monarch to behold their
toils and strife, that
we are not a captive audience I don't understand the use of captive. Shouldn't it be captivated, or are you sticking with the older language?
set to watch a swelling
scene that is not a
subplot of our own play,
where we are princes,
frustrated that we are This line seems rushed compared to the other lines.
not the ones
being watched. I love how you ended this!

*

Alright, as you can see I didn't really have any nitpics at all. I know you didn't need to use imagery in this poem, but I think it somewhat detracts from the beauty of the poem. I think some description would be nice to have, but that's really up to you.

I think you did a wonderful job on the flow in this poem. Besides the line I talked about above, it is not rushed at all. Your punctuation is also flawless.

Well dang Rosey! You left me nothing to review my friend. This was a really great poem.

Keep Writing

-Flower-
My reality comes to a close as I once again realize that you don't love me, and even if I love you with my everything you will never care.





User avatar
Gender None specified
Points 5715
Reviews 206
Hey there, Rosey!

To tell the truth, this does remind me of Shakespeare, at a first glance.

Anyway, this is quite short (for me =D), and I couldn't find any errors. The main thing that caught my attention was that the poem presented a subject that I could relate to, and it made me think about the truthfulness of the ideas and thoughts that were presented.

Overall, nice job. Keep it up! :D
Hope for the best, but prepare for the worst.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 9692
Reviews 3900
Hey Rosey!

I liked this... Shakespeare uses such beautiful language and you did a good job assembling his lines and putting it together as your own! My main problem with this poem is a very slight problem... I don't like the word "frustrated." Which is a kind of minor thing, but it just seems so weak with everything else.

Still, nice poem! :)
Ubi caritas est vera, Deus ibi est.

"The mark of your ignorance is the depth of your belief in injustice and tragedy. What the caterpillar calls the end of the world, the Master calls the butterfly." ~ Richard Bach

Moth and Myth <- My comic! :D




User avatar
Gender None specified
Points 37290
Reviews 367
Hi, Rosey!
I luffed this! Like everyone else said, this really reminds me of Shakespeare. I'd like to be able to give some constructive criticism here, but you've done wonderfully with this poem.
I think it has been mentioned above, though, that it ran on without ending for pretty much the whole stanza and I felt myself needing a mental breath. Maybe that's just me.
Smiles! Have a good day!
-Mizz
"Chase your dreams, and remember me, speak bravery,
Because after all, those wings will take you up so high."
-- Owl City, "To the Sky"
✯ ✯ ✯




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 28467
Reviews 675
Hey Rosey. I figured, to say thank you for your help yesterday, I would at least give you a review. It was the least I could do for you.

As far as the poem goes, I like this a lot, Rosey. There’s just one itty bitty thing that bothered me.
Many are the princes acting

The feels funny here. But it’s not wrong either. It’s just the one thing about this poem that kind of bothered me. Nothing major. :D

But you did a great job of writing in this sort of modern Shakespearean tone. Great job, Rosey. And thanks again!

~lilymoore
Never forget who you are, for surely the world will not. Make it your strength. Then it can never be your weakness. Armor yourself in it, and it will never be used to hurt you.



"You, who have all the passion for life that I have not? You, who can love and hate with a violence impossible to me? Why you are as elemental as fire and wind and wild things..."
— Gone With the Wind