In Which a Little Girl Dies. (Rated for Disturbingness)

13 posts
User avatar
Gender Female
Points 4300
Reviews 111
I wrote this for Amy's contest, with the prompt to write something centered on a dream I once had. It's safe to say I have strange dreams. I know it's not amazing, but it's a while since I've posted a work of my own other than the poetry puke I'm blaming on Snoink. So, here we go. Enjoy.

(EDIT: I should have made it clearer that the dream was very much expanded on. It wasn't anywhere near this detailed, so I had to expand quite a bit.)

(EDIT #2: Thanks everyone for your reviews. I hope this is better, and if there's anything else I haven't picked up on, I'd appreciate if you could let me know, if it's not too much trouble. Thanks!)

In Which a Little Girl Dies (Edited)

Carla laughed as she watched the game, just another game on the big school playground, but it was a fun game, and Carla liked it, even if Caroline was playing. Caroline saw her, and stuck her tongue out at her, and she turned away quickly. She felt Caroline's glare burning into her, and she shivered. She wasn’t allowed to watch Caroline, not if she wanted to be able to go home without any of the nasty blood on her clothes.

Caroline was playing with Rebecca. They weren't proper friends, not really, but that was Caroline. She had a scary daddy and a scary mummy, and they had taught Caroline to be scary. She'd been suspended four times for hurting Carla.

Carla didn't understand why Caroline hated her. She wasn't nasty to the other little girls, although they stayed away from her because of the warm red stain on Carla's white shirt last year in nursery class, but she wasn't nice to them, either, except to get them to play with her. Like Rebecca, right now, who thought Caroline was lonely. Rebecca was new, and she didn't know Caroline.

Caroline had a reason, she had a reason for everything. Carla's mind wandered back to the first time, when they'd played together in pre-school. Caroline hadn't played with her since then. Carla didn't understand, but Caroline had a reason. There was always a reason.

“Come and play, Carla,” Rebecca said, bouncing across the hop-scotch to fetch her stone. Carla shook her head shyly, and Caroline pushed Rebecca over onto the concrete.

"She's not allowed to play," she said, and when Rebecca didn't say anything, a frightening silence fell.

Nasty red blood stained Rebecca's pretty dress and the concrete ground around her, until Carla couldn't see the hop-scotch any more. She couldn't remember a time when she couldn't see the hop-scotch before now.

A piercing scream that sounded like Caroline carried itself across the playground, and three teachers and the whole school came running. Caroline ran away, crying, and an assistant teacher followed her indoors.

Carla wondered what was happening. How much trouble Caroline would be in, what was going to happen in the toilets with the assistant. She watched Rebecca, though, and sat on the floor, waiting from a distance for her... friend? She wasn’t used to the word, but she liked the taste of it on her lips when she whispered it aloud. Nobody noticed.

The stench of sickly-sweet, almost rusty blood filled the air. Carla didn’t cry, although everyone else did. She almost faded from view as one teacher sat with Rebecca and helped her, and the others kept everyone away. When the headteacher came out and told everyone to go in, Carla stayed.

Nobody saw Carla as she shivered in the sudden cold of July. She pulled her lightweight cardigan around her tightly, anad wondered why her mummy had said she wouldn't need her coat. It was really cold, and Carla tried not to let her teeth chatter together. It was about Rebecca now, and if she was noticed Rebecca might get hurt more. But she didn't cry. No, Carla didn't cry.

"I didn't! It wasn't me! I'm sorry!"

She could hear Caroline crying and shouting at the teacher, but she had been the same after she hurt Carla, although Carla had sat back up and Rebecca was silent. Caroline was clever like that, she was good at pretending, even though she had been suspended. Carla sat still now, but nobody noticed. She wondered if she was invisible, but she didn't move in case she wasn't.

The ambulance arrived, and it didn’t see her. It drove straight past her, parking so that Carla was right behind it. The big, scary men ran over to Rebecca and the teacher straight away, and they left the ambulance open. Carla stared at it with wide eyes, but didn’t move. She watched the scary men sit down next to Rebecca, and they were touching her, and sounded worried, like Carla’s daddy when her little sister had been born.

They picked her up and put her on a white sheet, and Carla remembered the white sheet they had put on her nana last year. She hadn’t seen her nana since, and she watched with wide eyes. Her mummy had cried when they put the white sheet on her nana. Carla didn’t cry.

The scary men put Rebecca into the back of the big ambulance. They still didn’t see Carla, even when she stood up to watch. They got into the front of the ambulance, and the teacher in the back with Rebecca started to pull the doors closed.

Rebecca sat up. “Come and play, Carla,” she said. The ambulance rolled backwards and bumped into Carla. She fell, and the heavy ambulance drove right over her. There was a long pause. Carla didn't get up.

The teacher in the ambulance screamed, and the scary men ran out to Carla. Everything went fuzzy, and the last thing she noticed before she closed her eyes was that Rebecca didn’t cry.
Last edited by Ruth on Thu Feb 04, 2010 9:09 am, edited 6 times in total.
"Ruth.
She's alive because she is not dead,
and junk."
~JoJo




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 6826
Reviews 34
Valentine

This dream seems to be a nightmare. The writing was as simple as could be. Not very much description at all, but it caught the perspective perfectly of a little girl. The words were childish, and everything was what it seemed. If I were to write down one of my dreams, it would be very blurry, and confusing. Yours are not like mine so, beyond that, the ending was great. It startled me, as I assumed this would be a harmless passage about a little girl. At the end of this, I have one thing to say: That girl should become an assassin.

Valentine
"You either die a hero, or live long enough to see yourself become a villain- TDK"

-My Bloody Valentine Reviews-




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 4013
Reviews 201
Hi Cheesy! Like I told you in chat this is sort of disturbing....But I have one thing to ask I don't really understand the purpose of the Caroline character. It seems like she would be the one to hurt Carla not Rebecca then she just disappears. Also the other girls, or at least Carla seem scared of her but it's never really explained why. That just bugged me a little because I wanted to know why she acted so strangely around her. I like the little twist at the end when Rebecca woke up and talked to Carla I thought an interesting thing to do instead of having Caroline come back to push her in front of the ambulance. Overall I think it's a good, creepy little story but maybe you could expand on it a little more just to make the beginning make a little more sense. I also agree with Valentine about the way you told the story the perspective was great.

Hope I helped.
~peanut~



EDIT: Cheese, adding to it really helped. I think you filled some of the gaps that I saw the first time reading it. And you sort of brought Caroline back. Good job.
There is a light in you, a Vision in the making with sorrow enough to extinguish the stars. I can help you.
~And The Light Fades


The people down here are our zombies, who should be dead or not exist but do.
~Away From What We Started


P.S Got YWS?




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 7979
Reviews 111
I: A Thought
Hmmm….an interesting story. Gore and surreal, I like the essence of mysteriousness in here especially the character of Carla or Caroline.

II: Characters
My first thought when I read is who is who? Honestly, I cannot separate who is Carla, Caroline or Rebecca? It almost feel that they are all the same. And what is the relationship between Carla and Caroline? Are they sisters? Okay, what is needed here is (1) description.
Describe the features of the characters and do this by not telling us but by showing them through events or through dialogue. This will help the reader imagine the character.
Here’s an example:
“Caroline’s hair seemed to converge with the blood”
(2) Personality
What I got from here is that the three girl’s personality seem the same except for Rebecca who is a bit kinder but in the surface, I cannot find a distinct trait that separates them. Who is Carla? What kind of girl is she? Is she reclusive? And what about Caroline…what kind of girl is she? I know she seems a bit mysterious and sadistic? You showed that sadistic at the first part but at the end, Caroline’s nature seemed to suppressed to more child-like.

III: Plot
Now I will explain, plot and description here. Firstly, the part of the “hop-scotch” that connects the story seemed confusing? What did happen? Did Caroline wound Rebecca or herself for there is blood? I think that you need to describe the setting here more elaborately because the reader can’t find a clue on what is going on. As well, the setting is a bit vague here. Where are we? Are we in school because the first part does not suggest so. Further, to show the setting with connection to the mood, try to show some objects in the setting that serve where to locate the place and to create a more mysterious atmosphere. For example, the empty road or the rectangular school with no windows can be used to both help the reader imagine and get the atmosphere going.

IV: Thought
Finally, this story has a great mystery to it but the characters and the plot seemed to add more mystery that what it suppose to give. Try to work more on elaborating the characters, the plot and the description while at all preserving the mood.
John McClane: Drop it. It's the police.
Tony: You won't hurt me.
John McClane: Oh, yeah? Why not?
Tony: Because you're a policeman. There are rules for policemen.
John McClane: Yeah. That's what my captain keeps telling me




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1030
Reviews 1260
Hi there Grin. No exclamation or smiley faces like in my usual reviews. I'm not in the mood for it all. This was your dream? I too have had very freaky dreams in the past. I'm just going to go over a few things about your characters okay?

Your characters were kind of blah and seemed to fit generic descriptions. Caroline is a brat, Carla is an outcast, and Rebbecca is the one who is shunned for speaking out. I know this was a dream, so the characters aren't going to be extremely fleshed out or three dimensional.

However, despite what you may think, you aren't limited only to what you experienced in a dream. You can take your dream as a basis for a story and adapt it to text. Caroline has no known motives for hating Carla, and it seems just wierd. Give her something. Also, right now, Carla seems a bit stupid. Why didn't she move? Was she too scared? Maybe you could input a few of her thoughts as the ambulance is coming toward her.

Otherwise, it was flawless, creepy,seeming like it could be an episode of The Twilight Zone. Thumbs up for you, and I wish best of luck in the contest!

All our dreams can come true — if we have the courage to pursue them.

-- Walt Disney




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 4013
Reviews 201
Cheese :) Much better. You explained a reason for most of the stuff and I'm glad you did that with out going into too much detail. I'm beginning to think this story is supposed to be a little vague and you aren't supposed to know everything. But that's just me. There is one sentence that really bugs me, I should have said something in the other review. You don't have to change it but it's just repetitive and I've noticed it every time I've read this piece.

Rebecca sat up. “Come and play, Carla,” she said. The ambulance started moving. Carla fell over, and the ambulance rolled over her.


You can always take out that first over. Then it would just be she fell. Or you could reword the sentence. Like I said it's just a small nitpick :)
Good luck with the contest.

~peanut~
There is a light in you, a Vision in the making with sorrow enough to extinguish the stars. I can help you.
~And The Light Fades


The people down here are our zombies, who should be dead or not exist but do.
~Away From What We Started


P.S Got YWS?




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 4300
Reviews 111
peanut19 wrote:I'm beginning to think this story is supposed to be a little vague and you aren't supposed to know everything.


Give her a hamburger! Since the story is being told from the perspective of a little girl about six years old, she's not going to understand what exactly is going on. And Caroline is sort-of based on a gil I knew at that age - when I asked why she didn't like me, her honest-to-goodness answer was, after a pause, "Because you fidget."

So, yes, thanks for all the lovely reviews, you've all been very helpful. I hope I've improved enough for this to be a lot better, and I think I have because of the reviews, so thank you. I really appreciate it.

~Grin
"Ruth.
She's alive because she is not dead,
and junk."
~JoJo




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 8230
Reviews 102
Dear Cheesy,
interesting.... though I think you should expand on it a bit. Is Caroline the assassin? Why is she crying? Is Carla dead? Overall I believe you have an interesting and thought provoking story. I love psychological stories!
"You may not be educated well in the areas of etiquette and the like as a princess, but you do throw some bashing good parties!"
Not all princesses are pink sparkles.
Exhibit A




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 1091
Reviews 3
I am emotionally scarred. I loved it. You are a great writer.
Live and don't learn, thats us - Calvin

Alas, poor Yorick - wait, why the heck am I holding this skull? - Me

I can count to potato - The guy who lives next door




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1957
Reviews 3
Personally I think this is great and I also understand it should be a bit vague since it's in a six-year-old's POV but maybe expand a little more but other than that great!!!
TaeKwonDo is For the Strong
The Violin is for the Artsy
Lastly, Writing is for the GREAT!!!




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 4300
Reviews 111
Aristotle wrote:I am emotionally scarred. I loved it. You are a great writer.


I love it! Such an oxymoronic speech!

*Exploits self to be a geek*
"Ruth.
She's alive because she is not dead,
and junk."
~JoJo




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1671
Reviews 6
Wow. Creepy... really gave me the shivers for a second.

Now, to the review!

1) I would make your characters a little more... individual. They all seem to bled together into one mega-kid. Not good. =S. It makes it really confusing to keep track of who is who. Google "character development worksheets" and see what helps you out. One I suggest is at http://www.pameladowd.com/Adobe/Charact ... tChart.PDF. It's a PDF, so you'll need Adobe Reader. =)

2) It needs a little more, what I like to call, substance. In other words, description. I understand it's supposed to be vauge due to the age of your POV character, but it seems to be lacking in the details department.

Other than those two things, I really enjoyed reading this. Keep it up!

Peace!
"Art saves / Make the pain / A weapon you can use"

- OTEP, Serv Asat




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 289
Reviews 11
wow that was breathtaking



I'm officially making it my goal in life to become a roomba. I want to be little robot. I want knives taped to me. I want to be free.
— TheMulticoloredCyr