I can't say that I enjoyed the narrative style in this. I felt that it was too tell-y, as if you're just giving us this information to do what we wish with it.
I think that, in order to make this poetic, you should focus on livening your words -- use words to describe this sole that you otherwise wouldn't. Use words in new contexts, incorporate poetic devices, and elaborate. Elaboration would help this poem, because right now, you're just telling us about a [seemingly] everyday object, and where's the interest in that? Step back, look at this, and make this interesting for us to read.
Not bad, it's a start. Keep writing, and PM me if you've any questions. =)
June
"I'd steal somebody's purse if I could google it and then download it." -- Firestarter
Thanks for the critisism. I was kind of going for a more stark image of the sole as a metaphorical represntation of the soul, so I think I'm gonna keep it as it is. But thank you for the input
I don't agree with you Juniper. It is quite blatent that KayDee had her own intentions and it is a shame that you did not pick up on her brilliantly crafted extended metaphor. any elaboration would cloud this otherwise simplistic and therefore perfectly woven collections of words.
Eek! I really liked this for the most part. It reminded me of William Carlos Williams's "Red Wheelbarrow", which is always a good thing! My main problem was it wasn't simplistic enough.
The sole A vital part. It bears the brunt, Of pounding footsteps <-- love the beginning! It takes the everyday wear and tear, <-- this seems unnecessary and it has too many words--play around with it! In its stride.
Sometimes it cracks, Holes appear <-- appear is such a weak verb!
But they can easily be covered up. <-- I don't like the italics... I think if you shorten the line (maybe "but those can be covered up") then it would have a punchier ending without having to resort to gimmicky writing.
Still, I liked this a lot! A gold star for you!
Ubi caritas est vera, Deus ibi est.
"The mark of your ignorance is the depth of your belief in injustice and tragedy. What the caterpillar calls the end of the world, the Master calls the butterfly." ~ Richard Bach
I agree wholeheartedly with Snoink. And unknown poet--- June is one of the most helpful poetry-critiquers on this site; and she didn't say anything to dismiss or discourage KayDee. A caustic remark was unneeded. And KayDee, I thought your poem brilliant. However, sometimes people, even smart, intuitive people, have different views on a work that what the author intended. (This happens with pretty much everything I write. ) So you must accept that, and move on. I, personally, looked at the title and thought- soles? She must mean both soles and souls, because no one writes about soles. other than that, do everything Snoink said and keep writing. empress
Naked I came from my mother's womb, and naked I will depart. *Le Bible Royal Reviews Here!