To Be a Proton

5 posts
User avatar
Gender Female
Points 6396
Reviews 273
They live in a tiny world 
Of empty space and gravity, 
Of zip-zip motion and crazy eights. 
They come in huge numbers 
That we have no names for, 
And they live to break apart bonds. 
We’d keep them together,  
But when do they listen? 
It’s all a game of just the right time.  
 
There are those pesky electrons
That weigh next to nothing,
And we all want to be like them.
The smaller we are, the more we can keep;
But the polished ones just lose it.
They come and they go,
Like wayward children
Until all we can hear are goodbyes.
And even the ionic crystals will tell you:
You can’t hold on if they're not your own.
 
Neutrons are narcissists but
We once believed their lies.
They said we were equals,
And then brought home their isotopes –
Now what are we to do?
Those silly electrons are outsiders,
But still we’d like to get to know them.
But we’re blocked by our wardens,
Angry oafs that keep us from running.
So we’re a happy family: the Nucleons.
 
Then we’re all so alike,
Robots confined to the laboratories.
We’d run away from our monotony
Because no one wants an eternity
Of looking into the same old mirror.
But we keep in our corners,
And what’s the use of attracting
If we never meet our opposites?
That’s the trouble with not being seen –
We can’t even slip through the cracks.
atom.jpg
Last edited by Explosive_Pen on Mon Dec 07, 2009 12:57 am, edited 1 time in total.
"You can love someone so much...But you can never love people as much as you can miss them."




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1030
Reviews 1260
Hello there Ellie. Let's take a look at this poem, shall we? ^^
We're studying protons right now, so this should be interesting.

They live in a tiny world
Of empty space and gravity,

^
This seems a little redundant. Maybe you can try to make the hook a little more interesting. Right now it just seems as if you're giving a lecture in poetic form.

Of zip-zip motion and crazy eights.

^
"zip-zap" seems like it would flow a little better.

And they live to break apart bonds.

^
Isn't it the electrons that do that?

We’d keep them together,
But when do they listen?

^
This part is funny. I love it.

And we all want to be like them.

^
orly? Why? I never heard any of that in school.

I didn't really find many other problems with the poem, but it seemed to very inconsistent. First electrons are outcasts then we all want to be like them. The human characteristics that you give the protons, neutrons and electrons are never explained, leaving the reader confused.
Good start, and keep writing.

All our dreams can come true — if we have the courage to pursue them.

-- Walt Disney




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 9692
Reviews 3900
Hello!

Okay, so this may be geeky, but I totally read it for the title. Yep. Geeky. However, when you start with electrons, and when I was reading the first stanza, I kept thinking, "This isn't a proton!" So you may have to start with the protons first, or explicitly say "the electrons" first. Because, really, "they" is a weak word in poetry anyway, especially when you have to say, "That is, they is them!" Which is basically what you did.

Also, I am not quite sure of the lies that the neutrons give, or really much of the reasoning as to why the nucleons have the sort of behaviors you gave them. And maybe I am over-analyzing this too much (having taken quantum mechanics and all) but I do wonder! Maybe if you clarified what the lies are and why they are lies, that would be better.

I also don't understand... what cracks? :P

Still! I liked this! *stars*
Ubi caritas est vera, Deus ibi est.

"The mark of your ignorance is the depth of your belief in injustice and tragedy. What the caterpillar calls the end of the world, the Master calls the butterfly." ~ Richard Bach

Moth and Myth <- My comic! :D




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 15394
Reviews 1464
Ell!

I liked this! I do heavily agree with Snoinkarina that 'they' is a weak word in poetry. Kill the usage of it, and 'that' as much as you can throughout this - as well as any other trivial word with abstract meaning - they do nothing for you here. ;)

In fact, I would eliminate most of the narrative bits such as "and they" because they're not working. Once or twice is good! But after that, you can bridge these all with commas and such.


The end is just okay-- I don't like it because it's sort of like, "eek, how to close this poem?" Justice isn't totally served to the poem; I think it deserves a much better ending than this. But this is good; rather creative, and enjoyable. Two thumbs up and a gold star, El. Keep it up. :)

June
"I'd steal somebody's purse if I could google it and then download it." -- Firestarter




User avatar
Gender None specified
Points 1866
Reviews 9
Hello Explosive Pen (I see you're being called "El").
I've never had a physics brain and I don't take physics, so I believe every word of that poem because I don't know any better :smt003
It's a brilliant poem though, I must say, even if I don't understand the terminology.
Personifying the proton is definately unique and makes the reader sort of feel sorry for them in a way.
Two thumbs way up for "To Be a Proton" !
(No wonder it was featured :wink: )

-ElaBrave
Chase down your passion like it's the last bus of the night.



Twenty years from now you will be more disappointed by the things you didn't do than by the ones you did. So throw off the bowlines, sail away from the safe harbor. Catch the trade winds in your sails. Explore. Dream.
— Mark Twain