Emma-Claire

5 posts
User avatar
Gender Female
Points 4013
Reviews 201
I have been working on this piece for a long time. There are three more chapters so far. I hope its good. Please rip it to shreds.
~peanut~




Snow fell quietly, the New York sky began to light as I looked around. The flurries whirled around me; Josh circled the park bench behind me.
Looking for ammo, I thought, laughing to myself. I looked forward, staring at the concrete walkway, carefully not to look back at the bench; the beauty of the park captivating me. Standing there I began to think about Josh, Mom, and Dad; about everything.
I laughed as a snowball whizzed passed my head, nearly hitting my shoulder. Nearly. My light brown hair swirled around my head. I could still see the smile on Josh's face through the haze of brown; his blue eyes sparkling with excitement. I smiled and reached down, the icy snow chilling my ungloved fingers, making an imperfect snowball. Slowly, I raised my right arm, aimed and launched the white sphere at Josh. Shock filled his eyes as it hit him. Then the whining started, of course.
"I'm a girl. I'm sorry girls are just better than guys." I stated as we started down the pathway.
"That's so not true," Josh pouted, jogging to catch up with me (the faster one, obviously). I ignored him and turned the corner. He was annoyed, just the way it was supposed to be.
I stopped in front of our house, shivering as Josh walked slowly up the steps.
"Forget your key again?" He drew out the last word and dangled his key in front my face.
"Yeah, just open the door, I'm cold!" Josh may be younger, but he was a lot more responsible.
"What's the magic word?" He insisted. Yep, he was definitely younger and more immature.
"Please?" I chattered. I felt like a woodpecker was knocking on my freezing teeth.
I slipped off my socks; my bare feet chilled against the wood floor, and made my way down the hall to my room. My door shut as Josh trudged to his own room his wet boots squeaking on the dry – once dry- floor.
Wow, he’s quick today, I thought, his footfalls banging on the wood once more. I followed, pulling my robe closer to my body.
Water soaked through my socks and the farther back down the hall I walked the worse it got.
“You know, Josh, my socks are soaked because of you.” I said, the carpet in the living room squished under my feet the wooden threshold was hard in contrast to the carpet. He wasn’t paying attention to me, I could tell. His back was turned away from me toward the T.V. he was flipping channels, the blue bar flashing every few seconds telling him what was on each channel. He went through at least 100 channels and still couldn’t find anything. He didn’t move as I walked behind the couch and into the kitchen.
“Emma, you should make us some hot chocolate,” Josh requested from his spot on the couch.
“You should go clean up the water you tracked in before dad gets home.” I told him, walking through the dining room. “Oh, hey, what’s the magic word?” I teased, I heard him laugh softly.
“Please!” he called.
“Ummm... I’ll think about it, maybe.” I shot back at him, crossing into the kitchen. That’s what he gets for making me wait out in the cold, I thought laughing quietly.
I circled the island, making my way to the refrigerator. That’s when I noticed the orange post-it stuck in the middle of the counter. Wonderful, I thought in disgust, Josh will love this. I picked it up, even though it wasn’t hard to guess what it said.
“Josh,” I called, “Dad left us another note.” It took him a minute to get into the kitchen so I read the note silently and as usual I was right about what it said.
“So,” Josh said form the door separating the kitchen and dining room.
I sighed and began to read it aloud, “Sorry, guys, Melinda called last minute. Couldn’t say no. Hope you had fun at the park. Be home soon. Love you.” Before Josh could say anything I ripped the post-it and threw it into the trash can. I missed the can and it was if the ceiling was crying orange tears as the paper rained down.
“Typical!” Josh spat, kicking the confetti reduced post-it as he moved. “I’m surprised he even knew where we were. I can’t believe he’s going out with that witch tonight.” He fumed, and glanced at the calendar by the fridge.
Believe it, I thought but was careful to stay quiet as he continued.
“I mean,” he continued, “how bad can he get? Going out doing god knows what with some one else.” A tear trickled down my cheek as his voice cracked. “On Mom’s birthday.” He was whispering now. I couldn’t take it anymore. My heart was saying something my brain just couldn’t comprehend telling Josh. So I whispered, “Josh, she’s gone.” Tears erupted from my eyes, flowing like rain sown my porcelain skin. It had been two years, but Josh could still hardly stand it. I jumped as the refrigerator beside me kicked on and ice fell from the ice maker hidden in its icy depths.
Josh turned away and walked to his room, slamming the door. When the door slammed I sand, I felt like my heart had fallen onto the linoleum floor beneath me. Gently I collapsed and pulled my legs tight against my chest, and closed my eyes.
Memories came rushing back to me capturing the darkness. Replaying like an old movie. Nostalgic feelings took over as I watched. I could see the Maine coastline that I had walked down so many times with my family.
Suddenly the colors changed. Black began to take over everything. My family, my friends, thoughts, everything. The only colors were the blues of the hospital gowns and bright colors of the nurses’ scrubs. I wanted to scream, and open my eyes. I wanted to go to Josh and tell him none of it was real, that it was all a horrible dream. But I couldn’t open my eyes, my mind wouldn’t let me.
Memories of the funeral came too. Old people hugging what was left of our family. Whispers of how bad they all felt for Josh and I. They couldn’t possibly know what we were going through; I remember thinking as the whispers fluttered by, buzzing like annoying little bees.
The service was even worse than the visitation. All I could see as this part played was the closed casket. It wasn’t Mom’s casket just the casket. The thing inside was not my mother it was just her body not her soul. It wasn’t her. I couldn’t remember the preacher’s face only his nasally voice. As I stared at the dark wood of the casket I could hear the preacher preaching. That was his job after all. But what he said made no sense. How could God be so wonderful? I still ask myself this question, but that day it burned in my throat. It wanted so badly to be yelled. It wanted to be yelled at the preacher along with my other questions.
Why did wonderful God let that idiot into our house? Why didn’t her save her? Why didn’t he let her fight?
I still don’t go to church; I don’t see the point, even two years later.
I still couldn’t open my eyes. It was like my mother wanted me to remember, for her birthday. I waited for the memory to play, wondering what else there could be. Then it played.
I could see my dad and I knew what I was about the witness, again. It was the night Josh and I had walked in on them. They were kissing in the living room I could remember the look on Josh’s face. He was furious. Dad had already missed Josh’s football game. It was the one game Dad had promised to go to and it was the one and only game they had lost.
As Josh slammed the door in my memory, the fridge door beside me closed. Finally I could open my eyes. When I looked up I saw Josh staring down at me.
“Gosh, Emma, I thought you’d lost it. I could hear you crying from the living room. Thought you were gonna run out of air.” Josh explained, handing me the glass of water he had in his hand. He smiled as I gulped it down and grabbed my hand pulling me up. I could still see the puffy redness under his eyes from earlier but at least he was smiling now.
We watched T.V. and drank hot chocolate for the rest of the night, trying to forget about Dad and my episode. At eleven I forced Josh to go to bed. His light clicked off and I turned my bathroom light on. After brushing my teeth I slid into my bed and wished Mom a happy birthday, my once-a-year-prayer.
I woke to the sound of the front door hitting the wall. I checked my alarm clock 3:30. That’s definitely a new record, I thought pushing back my blankets and standing up. I walked out my open door and went into the kitchen where Dad was standing.
“You could have been a little quieter.” I said, leaning on the island.
“I know I’m sorry.” He said. “You know Melinda said she’d love to get to know you and Josh better.”
He’s not sorry, I thought, he’s talking about her. He doesn’t care that it’s 3:30.
“I don’t want to know her.” Josh’s voice spoke up from the doorway. He must have followed me when I got up, I thought, watching Dad’s reaction.
“Josh, go back to bed. You know what, both of you go to bed. It’s late.” It was like Josh had flipped a switch, Dad’s eyes went cold. There was something else in his eyes beside anger, he was hurt. Apparently he couldn’t see what he was doing to us.
There is a light in you, a Vision in the making with sorrow enough to extinguish the stars. I can help you.
~And The Light Fades


The people down here are our zombies, who should be dead or not exist but do.
~Away From What We Started


P.S Got YWS?




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1422
Reviews 115
Hey, Peanut! I was genuinely excited because I wanted something to review and I came along this. So, here it goes:

Nitpicks

The flurries whirled around me; Josh circled the park bench behind me.

The 'me' sounds repetitive. Maybe you could change the second one to something else.

I looked forward, staring at the concrete walkway, [s]carefully[/s] careful not to look back at the bench; [the semi-colon should just be a comma] the beauty of the park captivating me.
Also, I'm not really sure why she didn't want to look at the bench.

Standing there [place comma here] I began to think about Josh, Mom, and Dad; [again, the semi-colon should just be a comma] about everything.


I could still see the smile on Josh's face through the haze of brown; [the semi-colon should be a comma] his blue eyes sparkling with excitement.


"I'm a girl. I'm sorry girls are just better than guys." I stated as we started down the pathway.
The punctuation is wrong here. Instead of a period after 'guys' it should be a comma.

He drew out the last word and dangled his key in front of my face.


Josh may be younger, but he was a lot more responsible.

You switched tenses in the first part of this sentence. It should be: Josh may have been younger. :)

I felt like a woodpecker was knocking on my freezing teeth.

It might just be me, but this sounds weird to me. Usually if your teeth are chattering, they are moving up and down at a fast pace. I don't really think it would feel like they were being hit with something.

I slipped off my socks; my bare feet chilled against the wood floor, and made my way down the hall to my room. My door shut as Josh trudged to his own room his wet boots squeaking on the dry – once dry- floor.
Wow, he’s quick today, I thought, his footfalls banging on the wood once more. I followed, pulling my robe closer to my body.

OK, I'm confused here. You didn't really say anything about Josh opening the door, and I don't know when she got a robe. It just sort of happened.

“You know, Josh, my socks are soaked because of you.” I said, the carpet in the living room squished under my feet the wooden threshold was hard in contrast to the carpet.

Before you said she took off her socks.

“You should go clean up the water you tracked in before dad gets home.” I told him, walking through the dining room. “Oh, hey, what’s the magic word?” I teased, I heard him laugh softly.

The dialogue punctuation is wrong here again. The same as I said above. The period after 'home' should be a comma.

Wonderful, I thought in disgust, Josh will love this.

You should put thoughts in italics. It's easier for the reader.

“So,” Josh said [s]form[/s] from the door separating the kitchen and dining room.
Just a typo. :)

I missed the can and it was as if the ceiling was crying orange tears as the paper rained down.


Going out doing god knows what with some one else.”

'god' should be capitalized.

My heart was saying something my brain just couldn’t comprehend telling Josh.

Huh?

So I whispered, “Josh, she’s gone.” Tears erupted from my eyes, flowing like rain sown my porcelain skin. It had been two years, but Josh could still hardly stand it. I jumped as the refrigerator beside me kicked on and ice fell from the ice maker hidden in its icy depths.

This should be it's own paragraph, because a new person, Emma, started talking.


So I whispered, “Josh, she’s gone.” Tears erupted from my eyes, flowing like rain sown my porcelain skin. It had been two years, but Josh could still hardly stand it.

Awww... :cry:

When the door slammed I sand,

I sand...?

They couldn’t possibly know what we were going through; I remember thinking as the whispers fluttered by, buzzing like annoying little bees.

The thought should be in italics, and it shouldn't be a semicolon, it should be a comma.

Overall:
Wow, that was long. Haha. But, I’m done with that, really. OK, a few things:

You had some problems with your dialogue punctuation. I tried to explain a little, but here’s an article that could really help out more: Punctuation Within Dialogue

Another thing you had problems with, commas and semi-colons. I can’t explain that very well, but this article will help: Commas vs. Semi-colons

I really enjoyed this piece! But, I must remind you of one thing. This isn’t cliché yet, but it could easily become cliché. I’ve read stories like this before. You know, the kids are upset about their mom dying and their dad moving on too soon…yada yada yada…put in a twist. Make this different. Your writing style is very nice and this has so much potential. Throw in a few surprises and twists.

Your characters are good. But, I’d like a little more on their ages. You say Josh is younger, I was thinking maybe fourteen or fifteen, because he seemed mature in some parts, but immature in others. Maybe you could clarify on the ages.

I don’t get much out of their father. I think we need a little more info on him.

I’m so excited to read more of this. You had me feeling bad for the characters, and that's really good because you want that. You want me to feel sympathy for your characters. Please, PM me if you add more. I’d be happy to review.

-Colleen

p.s: Put your MC's thoughts in italics. :)
"Can't stop, won't stop. I must be dreaming."




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1203
Reviews 228
Sarah sarah sarah...how many times have I read this story? Too many. Anyway...


Snow fell quietly, the New York sky began to light as I looked around.

Because I'm a loserbuttface, is this New York or New York City? Because when I read New York and I read the park , I thought of Central Park. Can you just tell me? kthxbai.


Standing there I began to think about Josh, Mom, and Dad; about everything.

It's kind of negative to put that in the story. I mean, okay she starts to think about it but you didn't say what she was thinking. You kinda just put it to the side, forgot about it, then finally told us later. Why not just take this out?


My light brown hair swirled around my head. I could still see the smile on Josh's face through the haze of brown; his blue eyes sparkling with excitement.

It doesn't really sound good that you repeated brown there. So don't repeat brown there.


"That's so not true," Josh pouted, jogging to catch up with me (the faster one, obviously).

ick. Please do not use parenthesis in a story that's not a journal. kthxbai.


"Yeah, just open the door, I'm cold!" Josh may be younger, but he was a lot more responsible.
"What's the magic word?" He insisted. Yep, he was definitely younger and more immature.

These two lines completely confuse me. You say he is younger and more responsible, but then you say he's younger and more immature. It totally threw me off and it might have thrown off the readers.


"Please?" I chattered. I felt like a woodpecker was knocking on my freezing teeth.

Do you mean that it sounded like a woodpecker was knocking on her freezing teeth? I think sounded would work better here.

Also, I didn't know that your teeth can feel cold. The only time that my teeth have gotten cold is when I was at the dentist, my mouth was numb, and he was drilling on them.


My door shut as Josh trudged to his own room his wet boots squeaking on the dry – once dry- floor.

Her door shut or did she shut the door? I think it makes more sense if she shut the door, because doors don't usually shut themselves. :P


“You know, Josh, my socks are soaked because of you.”

First reason why I don't like this: you repeat for the third time that her socks are wet. We understand. Her socks are wet.
Second reason: You repeated it again in the dialouge, which really annoys me. Only say it once please, in the dialouge if you have to.
Third reason: You repeated it.

Overall statement: Please stop repeating the fact her socks are wet.


“So,” Josh said form the door separating the kitchen and dining room.

form the door, I love it.


I missed the can and it was if the ceiling was crying orange tears as the paper rained down.

The trash can is as tall as the ceiling? Because that's what it sounds like here. Usually, trash cans are not taller than you are, so it's hard to get the picture of the ceiling crying tears of paper whenever it's not as tall as you. Just saying.


It wasn’t Mom’s casket just the casket.

That is a very confusing line. A very confusing line indeed. Did you forget a comma or something? It just doesn't make sense.


It wanted so badly to be yelled. It wanted to be yelled at the preacher along with my other questions.

To be yelled? Or just, to yell? To be yelled sounds weird, it really does.


I still don’t go to church; I don’t see the point, even two years later.
I still couldn’t open my eyes.

The repetition of still is getting on my nerves there. Can you please change it? kthxbai.


M'kay, I'm done with all the lines. Aren't you happy? :D


Characters :arrow: M'kay, m'kay, it's a pretty good start to it all. We know that Emma is the older sister to Josh, even though Josh is more responsible. I guess the characters are okay right now, but we could use some more description about Josh and Dad. And definitely Melissa.


Here's a tip :arrow: Put thoughts into italics please. Kthxbai.


Story idea :arrow: Stop rewriting and start writing the rest of this story before I smack you. Now.


Keep writing! Feel free to bother me if you have any questions or comments.

*Lin
"A journey of a thousand miles must begin with a single step." ~ Lao-tzu

Attack, IM, or PM me at any time. I will respond. ;)




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 2999
Reviews 438
It's late and I'm probably way too tired to be critiquing, but I'm doing it anyway. So there. =]

First, I'd like to see the ages defined a little more carefully. The writing at the beginning was slightly childish, so while I knew who was older, I couldn't get a grasp for either of their ages. 10? 15? 18? I hardly knew.

Second, I'd like to feel more anger. You described it to us, but you forgot the physical part. How's it feel to cry that hard? How's it feel to be forced to remember, to not be able to stop, to be drowning in your own tears? Your heart squeezes - your blood rushes from fear of lack of control.

Third, work on all 5 senses. You have some of them, but add more. Let us smell the soothing smell of hot chocolate when things calm down, and hear the tension in the air when the father comes home. All emotions and moods come with certain sounds or smells - even if they're always there, they're heightened at certain points.

PM me for anything.

~JFW1415




User avatar
Gender Other
Points 89625
Reviews 1272
Hi Peanut!

You requested a review from me awhile ago on this, and I'm really sorry I'm just getting around to it now. You also said I could be harsh, so here I go!

Grammar: This is what is stopping me from doing a nit-pick review. You've got a lot of run-on sentences, comma splices (using a comma in place of a period) misplaced commas, not enough commas, and a few too many semicolons. I would check out this punctuation guide to brush up on grammar. Also, you can check out this article on how to punctuate dialogue.

Also, make sure that all dialogue is on different lines. Like here:

“I mean,” he continued, “how bad can he get? Going out doing god knows what with some one else.” A tear trickled down my cheek as his voice cracked. “On Mom’s birthday.” He was whispering now. I couldn’t take it anymore. My heart was saying something my brain just couldn’t comprehend telling Josh./ So I whispered, “Josh, she’s gone.” Tears erupted from my eyes, flowing like rain sown my porcelain skin. It had been two years, but Josh could still hardly stand it. I jumped as the refrigerator beside me kicked on and ice fell from the ice maker hidden in its icy depths.


This paragraph should be broken in two somehow. I put a slash (one of / <- those) where it would be better. Also, delete the "so" from that line and put "I whispered" after. It would make more sense.

First person: Outside the grammar, my big issue was your use of first person. This goes beyond putting thoughts in italics (which you really should do, btw) but just the fact that you used so many thoughts. In first person, you are 100% inside your characters head. You see what they see. Your prose should be in their voice. Ie- All those thoughts should be the whole tone of the work. If you're only trying to give us the information, with no worry about being distant (you really want to avoid distance in first person. The reason you use first person is to be very, very close to the MC's thoughts and voice) then switch to third person and keep her thoughts in first.

To take the example above,

Tears erupted from my eyes, flowing like rain down my porcelain skin.


It's down, for one.

Second, the metaphor you use, although beautiful, is not very realistic in a first person story. Would you really think of your own skin as "porcelain"? Not really. So metaphors like that are much better suited to a third person story.

Description: In some locations, you were missing paragraphs. Take here:

"Please?" I chattered. I felt like a woodpecker was knocking on my freezing teeth.
I slipped off my socks; my bare feet chilled against the wood floor, and made my way down the hall to my room.


I thought she was taking her boots off outside.

There are several other locations where this is a problem. Read this over and check for any places where you don't tell readers an action has happened.

Another thing about your description is how repetiitve they can be. Repetitiveness can work in some cases (Stairs, by anti pop is a horror that does repetition really well) but in this case it looks like you're trying too hard to do something. Like here, for instance:

I jumped as the refrigerator beside me kicked on and ice fell from the ice maker hidden in its icy depths.


The use of "icy" to describe the ice maker really feels like too much.

On a related note, what I just quoted never really shows up again. Who turned on the ice maker? Who stopped it? Did any fall on the floor? You don't tell use what happened after.

To expand on that, what you need to make sure in your description is you tell us what happens around every event. Although I believe I'm now just restating the first point I made on description.

I agree with JFW on the age thing. It's hard to know how old they are but it's the key to the whole work.

Overall: I felt really, really detached from this, and the grammar really detracted it for me. There's so much to the story, like the plot, the characters, and the MC's voice, but none of it shows up on the prose.

It has promise, though. PM me when the edited version is up. (Also, PM me if you want all the grammar errors pointed out. I'd be more than happy to do that for you. ^^)

~Rosey
A writer is a world trapped in a person— Victor Hugo

Ink is blood. Paper is bandages. The wounded press books to their heart to know they're not alone.



Mudwesterner
— BlueAfrica