The Sun Prophet

27 posts1, 2
User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 72
Two picky little things:
A tall man


If you've already introduced his character, then "THE tall man" would work better, because it indicates that this is a specific tall man, one we are farmiliar with, whereas "A" indicates ambiguity, and is non-specific.

I'm just a smuggler, not a General of men."


I'd change it to leader of men, because "a General of men" doesn't make much sense to me... unless you're phrasing this LOTR style ("King of men").

One more little discrepancy that's bothering me... Celareena thinks about how she's sure she's going to die, and then about how adventagous their position is. It just doesn't transition well for me. Maybe you could state that something about them being lucky enough to at least get a good position, since so little else was going their way.

I'm enjoying it. I'd love to read the beginning.
"El sueño de la razon produce monstrisos"
--Fransisco de Goya




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 18178
Reviews 1259
If you've already introduced his character, then "THE tall man" would work better, because it indicates that this is a specific tall man, one we are farmiliar with, whereas "A" indicates ambiguity, and is non-specific.


Ooh it sure would. That was a bit indefinitive. Thanks for spotting it.

I'd change it to leader of men, because "a General of men" doesn't make much sense to me... unless you're phrasing this LOTR style ("King of men").


Ahh thanks for that! That sentence was really annoying me, but I didn't know what to change it too! It does sound a bit silly. Thanks for the suggestion.

One more little discrepancy that's bothering me... Celareena thinks about how she's sure she's going to die, and then about how adventagous their position is. It just doesn't transition well for me. Maybe you could state that something about them being lucky enough to at least get a good position, since so little else was going their way.


Good point. That does seem a little silly really. That paragraph was only supposed to suggest what they had on their side, not make it clear that they had a chance of winning. I'll have a look at it.

Thanks for the critique, I'll save your comments somwhere. I'd edit it now but I really just want to get the whole thing finished then do the whole editing afterwards!

Ta, FS.

PS, the beginning (Chapter 1, surprisingly) is in this forum too!
Nate wrote:And if YWS ever does become a company, Jack will be the President of European Operations. In fact, I'm just going to call him that anyways.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 324
sorry but i gotta ask & it looks like
this thread is the place 2 do it...

is it true that in america, the letter 'Z'
is pronounced 'zee' & not 'zed'?
"There you go - sausages à la bread!" - Blue.




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 18178
Reviews 1259
Well, that is a litte off-topic though...

You could always start a new topic in the Lounge about english language differences in America and England. That would be interesting.

Don't want this thread being taken over by it, please!
Nate wrote:And if YWS ever does become a company, Jack will be the President of European Operations. In fact, I'm just going to call him that anyways.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 72
lol, yes i found the first chapter, fire. (me unobservant? noooo never.)

Yes, Kay, in America we say "zee" and not "zed". Differences like those are why it drives me nuts to hear our politicians saying that America's national language should be English. We don't speak English, we speak America, which is similar but very much it's own language.
"El sueño de la razon produce monstrisos"
--Fransisco de Goya




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 64
I think its smart to get everything done first, then go back and edit things.
(Not intending to get off-topic, Go Avalon! We practically do speak America. When my relatives from Norway came over, Maria was spelling something and she kept saying 'Double-Vee'. Double-Vee? EH? Oh. W. I feel silly.)
AHEM.
Back to what was previously written, I sure wish I had some former knowledge, but I enjoyed it nonetheless. If only I had a lesser sense of curiousity. I want to know when you write more.
Feeling stupid? Follow me!




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 72
er, that should be "AmericaN" however, i think i've proved over and over again that proof reading isn't exactly my forte.

Fire, have you tried sending this to any publishers? Fantasy is very marketable right now.
"El sueño de la razon produce monstrisos"
--Fransisco de Goya




Random avatar
Gender None specified
Points 890
Reviews 11
I really enjoyed reading that. It was like I could picture myself in the same place. You wrote the story well, as if it actually happened to you. I really really liked it.
Samantha Wallace
-Just a dreamer with a dream to dream of




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 18178
Reviews 1259
Fire, have you tried sending this to any publishers? Fantasy is very marketable right now.


You're joking right? I don't think any of my stuff will ever be published, but I can always dream. I was thinking of sending it to publisher after I've finished it, but I don't hold any hope of anything happening.

I really enjoyed reading that. It was like I could picture myself in the same place. You wrote the story well, as if it actually happened to you. I really really liked it.


Thank you. Comments like that are really encouraging.
Nate wrote:And if YWS ever does become a company, Jack will be the President of European Operations. In fact, I'm just going to call him that anyways.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 64
Fire, I don't think that AOA was joking. I agree with her. The biggest problem would be finding the right one. A lot of good books had been turned down a number of times. Whoever eventually published Dr. Sues made a fortune.
Feeling stupid? Follow me!




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 72
AOA was not joking, and she apologizes for being so slow about it, but she's been busy.

I think every writer who truly loves their art tries to become published. If nothing else, it's a good learning experience.
"El sueño de la razon produce monstrisos"
--Fransisco de Goya




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 890
Reviews 26
.
Then I find,
I feel this passion grow,
To face all that's been lost,
It's not too late to give control now.
Got YWS?



Those are my principles. If you don't like them I have others.
— Groucho Marx