I messed up the activation of something

Edit: The puzzle was solved by Omnom! It activated the YWS Holiday Theme.

Edit 2: Omnom has kindly posted the solutions (in a spoiler) here: I messed up the activation of something

So, I need some help.

Yesterday, I put in place the necessary updates for something, but I can't remember what it was. Worse, I hid it behind a series of clues. D'oh!

All I remember is the first clue, which had something to do with a tavern? On YWS? I don't know. It doesn't make sense to me either.

-.-

Hmm... there is a popular tavern located in the Warriors of the Iron Page club, however many others exist.

Tavern? Which one?

The Tavern [2]
Guys?

Fast forward another couple years...

Out of nowhere, Nate exclaimed, "This was the most liked work in December 2010!"

A weary bar patron looked up from his root beer float. "What is the Literary Spotlight?"

Nate shook his head, clearing the confusion from his mind. "Huh?"

"I thought we were playing Jeopardy."

"No, and that would still be wrong."

Anyone know where we could find the next one?

I do.

I found it.

Yeah, can you tell us? I thought I should keep the first clue a secret but I wanted everyone to chip in.

no mwuahaha >:3

Well, once you get stuck, come back.

I am stuck.

want to work together @Saruka?

I'm stuck too gaaahhh XD

I'M STUCK

I would think the next clue lies in the most liked work of 2010, but how might we find that exactly?

@KiraThePotatoChip I PMed you