-
Re: Trapped - Chapter One
I laughed when I realized who the tall guy in the suit was, lol. Anyway: toss the dream. It's an overused and unideal opening, and fails to build the necessary ...
Mar 16, 2013 -
Re: Bitter
Karzkin, I hate reviewing pieces that I don't understand. Maybe that's why it took me two three days of rereading and researching and conceptualizing before I felt confident enough to ...
Mar 15, 2013 -
Re: "The Raven Called"
It's repetitive. Your pattern is so constricting that you end up repeating a lot of the same ideas (ie "prepare myself for life's game" = "don't cry when the going ...
Mar 10, 2013 -
Re: Ch 1 - No Time for Goodbyes
1. This does not feel like an alien world, at all. It might pass as a futuristic Earth, but really the only two differences setting it apart from the world ...
Mar 9, 2013 -
Re: Greener Grass on the Other Side
Ixnay on the storytelling thing. All it does is make an already unfocused piece seem even more pointless. This is a parable, but the story-within-a-story thing it's adopted here makes ...
Mar 8, 2013 -
Re: Familiarity
Cool beans, Kyll. I think I'm going to tackle this one stanza by stanza. The more I learn, the more I observe, the more that I realize why opposites attract. ...
Mar 6, 2013 -
Re: A Nation Grows Large and Still Collapses
I couldn't make sense of this. It verges on unreadable in places, laden with misplaced prepositions, fractured sentences, and unintuitive line break placement. There might be something, buried underne
Mar 5, 2013 -
Re: Mirrored
One thing I look for in a first chapter is a strong sense of place, and this chapter failed to deliver on that front. Before a reader can prepare to ...
Mar 4, 2013 -
Re: To Beat His Weary Drum Today
I saw little baby Jesus in the rearview. We both flicked our cigs at the same time. I actually really like this opening--the irony of Baby Jesus smoking is striking ...
Mar 3, 2013 -
Re: Snowlight - prologe (undecided title)
It's an intriguing premise, and definitely gives you foundation enough for the development of a story. I'd like to discuss with you how you could make this a stronger beginning. ...
Mar 3, 2013 -
Re: Into the Fire- 2
As the previous reviewer mentioned, this seems to be very emulative of Victorian-era writing, save for the magic bit, which I think gives it just enough originality to not feel ...
Feb 24, 2013 -
Re: Gorbak the Gobux Chapter 1
Your story is a bit bland and I'm not really drawn to it. I'd like more depth in your characters, something to distinguish them from the stereotypical couple in hard ...
Feb 24, 2013 -
Re: Obsidian
As the first two lines foretell, it's a repetitive poem that goes on for way too long saying way too little. You could cut out half the poem and it ...
Feb 24, 2013 -
Re: Burn
Proofread this, or have someone proofread it. It was verging on incoherent in places. And once you do that, reevaluate your plot. It was equally nonsensical. When does this take ...
Feb 21, 2013 -
Re: The Writer
Tigersprite, I don't think I've ever given you a full review. Overall, I enjoyed reading this. I enjoyed the diction. The second paragraph is by far the strongest and I ...
Feb 20, 2013
